Skip to content
Do you have adblock enabled?
 
If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Tasting Table)   Politics is a guaranteed way to get people to fight on the internet. This is the other way   (tastingtable.com) divider line
    More: Amusing, Pizza, Cheese, Tomato sauce, Baking, Tomato, Dough, Onion, Mozzarella  
•       •       •

930 clicks; posted to Food » on 07 Feb 2023 at 1:17 AM (6 weeks ago)   |   Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook



48 Comments     (+0 »)
View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest
 
2023-02-06 8:14:03 PM  
I've always thought standard Tombstone is prerty decent for a frozen pie. Get the Five Cheese then add toppings and more cheese halfway thru the cooking time.
 
2023-02-06 8:21:14 PM  
There is tolerable frozen pizza because it is inexpensive and easy not because any are actually good pizza. There is a take and bake pizza sold out of a food truck I get that is good. Making dough at altitude is tricky.
 
2023-02-06 8:26:25 PM  
30) Simple Truth Organic Goat Cheese & Beet Sauce Ultra-Thin Crust Pizza

I don't need to read any further than this. Beet sauce? If that's not a crime against humanity, I don't know what is.
 
2023-02-06 8:40:02 PM  

Pocket Ninja: 30) Simple Truth Organic Goat Cheese & Beet Sauce Ultra-Thin Crust Pizza

I don't need to read any further than this. Beet sauce? If that's not a crime against humanity, I don't know what is.


But the worst part is they pretend like it's not bad. It's literally 30th out of 30, and yet this is how it ends

Overall, this pizza had decent taste but did not climb to the top of our list.

Like, WTF is this? I quit after that.
 
2023-02-06 8:42:52 PM  
I don't do pizza anymore, I stuff pizza ingredients like cod and Velveeta into a pineapple and bake it.
 
2023-02-06 8:49:54 PM  
Look, if you have to do foreplay on a goat, you aren't making pizza. You're molesting goats. And if you're molesting goats, what is next, kids?
 
2023-02-06 9:00:50 PM  
Screamin' Sicilian is my go-to frozen pie. It''s horribly overpriced though, so I only buy it when it's on sale.

Basically $10 at my local store. They go on BOGO often though.
 
2023-02-06 9:04:18 PM  
It's pronounced "jif"
 
2023-02-06 9:07:42 PM  
Huh. Guess I'll have to try some of these sometime.
 
2023-02-06 9:32:56 PM  
They picked the wrong tombstone! (Rip)
ipcdn.freshop.comView Full Size
 
2023-02-06 9:48:43 PM  
I feel like the rising crust pizzas were a bad move. Whatever chemical trickery they use to make a shelf-stable rising crust does not yield a pleasant flavor. And as an added bonus, you get a lot of it.

Nah, thin crust frozen is the way to go.
 
2023-02-06 10:04:06 PM  
What!? Totinos Party Pizza at 28?!!

I'm gonna have to cut someone.
 
2023-02-06 10:08:32 PM  
I just love how Totino's is nestled in there with all kinds of "organic" "cauliflower" "vegan" etc pizzas near the bottom of the list.
 
2023-02-06 11:15:32 PM  
Hell yeah, I usually have a Tony's Pepperoni in the freezer.   Especially can't beat it at ~$2.70 a pizza
 
2023-02-06 11:24:04 PM  
Personally, I am a fan of Red Baron. That being said, so long as it tastes like tomato sauce on some kind of crust with some cheese substance, and assorted toppings? I'll give it a shot. The beet sauce... Concerns me. But I'd try it.

And if someone likes something I don't? Good on them; I will leave more if it so they can enjoy.
 
2023-02-06 11:37:58 PM  

johnny_vegas: Hell yeah, I usually have a Tony's Pepperoni in the freezer.   Especially can't beat it at ~$2.70 a pizza


I got caught up in that rising crust craze. In the last couple years I'm starting to prefer stuff like Tony's or Red Baron's simple pizza. I'm liking the thing crust and sodium.
 
2023-02-06 11:51:23 PM  

jaylectricity: johnny_vegas: Hell yeah, I usually have a Tony's Pepperoni in the freezer.   Especially can't beat it at ~$2.70 a pizza

I got caught up in that rising crust craze. In the last couple years I'm starting to prefer stuff like Tony's or Red Baron's simple pizza. I'm liking the thing crust and sodium.


Never tried the rising crust pizzas.  Which would you recommend?
 
2023-02-07 2:39:34 AM  
A couple of decades ago, before I started doing any real cooking, my wife was out of town and I was tasked with feeding our kids.  I thought sure, I'll just get one of those frozen pizzas.  It was a Tombstone pizza of some kind, and it was pretty bad.  I haven't bought frozen pizza since, but the freezer section at the market sure is full of them so someone must like that stuff.  I find it's really very little work to start some no-knead pizza dough in the morning and have cast iron pan pizza that evening.  Heck, some jarred pasta sauce, pre-shredded mozzarella, and pre-sliced pepperoni still makes a better and cheaper pizza than the frozen ones.
 
2023-02-07 3:15:31 AM  
Motor City Pizza Company is quite good and available nationwide.

However I'm actually a fan of fridge section dough and Del Grosso NY Style pizza sauce with Bel Gioioso fresh mozz, just don't get the pepperoni flavored sauce as that put the gross in Del Grosso.
 
2023-02-07 3:16:21 AM  

Sexy Jesus: I don't do pizza anymore, I stuff pizza ingredients like cod and Velveeta into a pineapple and bake it.


(I can only give one Funny, but I have to tell you that your post left me laughing so hard that, with my whole body shaking, it took several tries to get my mouse pointer on the Funny button.)
 
2023-02-07 3:25:44 AM  
THIS IS THE WAY

Lucius - Next to Normal (Official Music Video)
Youtube CteTC6zIlIw
 
2023-02-07 3:38:43 AM  
My first guess was over chili.
Pizza was my second guess.
Third guess would have been the definition of a sandwich.
 
2023-02-07 3:44:11 AM  

johnny_vegas: jaylectricity: johnny_vegas: Hell yeah, I usually have a Tony's Pepperoni in the freezer.   Especially can't beat it at ~$2.70 a pizza

I got caught up in that rising crust craze. In the last couple years I'm starting to prefer stuff like Tony's or Red Baron's simple pizza. I'm liking the thing crust and sodium.

Never tried the rising crust pizzas.  Which would you recommend?


You didn't ask me, but I prefer Digiorno to Freshetta.  Digiorno is zesty and Freshetta is kinda sweet.
 
2023-02-07 4:23:34 AM  
I've kept a couple Tony's pepperoni in the freezer for years. No way is it the best pizza in the world, but man does come in handy when nobody feels like cooking. Tried a Tombstone a few months back and I thought it was too saucy. Tony's seem to have a better sauce / cheese / pepperoni ratio, and the crust isn't too thick and chewy. I cook it for a couple extra minutes though.
 
2023-02-07 4:39:27 AM  
Duh subby. And the NYThas it down to a science, with how often they fark with italians by modifying carbonara
 
2023-02-07 6:40:35 AM  
"While you certainly could make a pizza from scratch, the preparation time of making a pizza isn't always in the cards."

No.  If you have a jar of sauce, some bread-like substance, and cheese on hand you can make a pizza:

Preheat oven.  If you like a crispy crust, put a sheet pan in while it heats.  Top your bread item (English muffin, bagel, hoagie roll, flour tortilla if you like a thin crust), smear some sauce on it, add some cheese and other toppings, slide onto a (possibly preheated) sheet pan, and bake.  If it's not browned enough to your taste after 5 minutes, switch your oven to broil.

Toaster ovens excel at this, and may not require preheating.  Just hit toast a couple of times.

If all you have is sliced sandwich bread, toast it first.

No sauce on hand?  Toast a slice of bread, add salami or similar, some cheese and toast again (or under the broiler if not a toaster oven)


"When the hunger for pizza hits you may not necessarily feel like heading to your local pizza joint or calling in for delivery."

Um.  This seems questionable.  I mean, I could see not wanting to go to a place with plague rats if there's a COVID surge in your area.  And I have social anxiety regarding making phone calls, but even I can call for pizza if I have to. How about "but what if you get the munchies at 2am and no one is open?" Or "how can you prepare in case you have to quarantine with Covid?"  Or even "but what if you live in a sketchy neighborhood or in the middle of nowhere and no one will deliver to you?"


"We ranked the 20 best frozen pizzas to help you on your next trip down the frozen foods aisle."

How the fark are there 30 in your list, then? This isn't some random blog, you have a damned magazine.  How do you not have editors?

/knows someone who can only order pizza delivery on certain days of the week at ~8pm
//because they're in the middle of nowhere but one of the delivery guys will bring them pizza at the end of the night as he lives in that direction
 
2023-02-07 6:41:05 AM  
Man I like that list just for the diversity.  All the way from college dorm stunners to Amy's.
 
2023-02-07 6:48:32 AM  

hlehmann: A couple of decades ago, before I started doing any real cooking, my wife was out of town and I was tasked with feeding our kids.  I thought sure, I'll just get one of those frozen pizzas.  It was a Tombstone pizza of some kind, and it was pretty bad.  I haven't bought frozen pizza since, but the freezer section at the market sure is full of them so someone must like that stuff.  I find it's really very little work to start some no-knead pizza dough in the morning and have cast iron pan pizza that evening.  Heck, some jarred pasta sauce, pre-shredded mozzarella, and pre-sliced pepperoni still makes a better and cheaper pizza than the frozen ones.


The no-knead dough in "Artisan Bread in 5 Minutes a Day" can hang out in the fridge for more than a week (it starts looking a bit grey by two weeks and has a vague sourdough taste, but still works)

If you have fridge space and suitable container, you can mix it up and have it on hand.  And it's usable in about 45mins if you use warm water, it's just loose so you might not be able to transfer after assembling unless you have experience
 
2023-02-07 7:21:51 AM  

beerrun: What!? Totinos Party Pizza at 28?!!

I'm gonna have to cut someone.


List fails if Totino's Party Pizza isn't at #1.  Not even gonna read the article due to that blatant insult to the best pizza on the whole damn planet.
 
2023-02-07 7:28:52 AM  

Pocket Ninja: 30) Simple Truth Organic Goat Cheese & Beet Sauce Ultra-Thin Crust Pizza

I don't need to read any further than this. Beet sauce? If that's not a crime against humanity, I don't know what is.


Still better than NY taco greaseboard.
 
2023-02-07 8:25:37 AM  

johnny_vegas: jaylectricity: johnny_vegas: Hell yeah, I usually have a Tony's Pepperoni in the freezer.   Especially can't beat it at ~$2.70 a pizza

I got caught up in that rising crust craze. In the last couple years I'm starting to prefer stuff like Tony's or Red Baron's simple pizza. I'm liking the thing crust and sodium.

Never tried the rising crust pizzas.  Which would you recommend?


A 12" riding crust pizza is an 8" pizza surrounded by a wad of crappy subway-quality bread.
 
2023-02-07 8:28:23 AM  

assjuice: johnny_vegas: jaylectricity: johnny_vegas: Hell yeah, I usually have a Tony's Pepperoni in the freezer.   Especially can't beat it at ~$2.70 a pizza

I got caught up in that rising crust craze. In the last couple years I'm starting to prefer stuff like Tony's or Red Baron's simple pizza. I'm liking the thing crust and sodium.

Never tried the rising crust pizzas.  Which would you recommend?

A 12" riding crust pizza is an 8" pizza surrounded by a wad of crappy subway-quality bread.


*shrug* I've been assured by many girlfriends that 8" is the perfect size
 
2023-02-07 8:51:20 AM  

robodog: Motor City Pizza Company is quite good and available nationwide.


Our current goto - double pepperoni.
 
2023-02-07 8:53:43 AM  
The best, and if you go to the OG spot 90 times better
Fark user imageView Full Size
 
2023-02-07 9:53:29 AM  

drjekel_mrhyde: The best, and if you go to the OG spot 90 times better
[Fark user image 850x883]


thread over!

Fark user imageView Full Size
 
2023-02-07 9:56:31 AM  

luna1580: drjekel_mrhyde: The best, and if you go to the OG spot 90 times better
[Fark user image 850x883]

thread over!

[Fark user image 400x491]


That one is the King of Kings. I'm in Chicago and those sell out fast
 
2023-02-07 9:56:32 AM  

johnny_vegas: assjuice: johnny_vegas: jaylectricity: johnny_vegas: Hell yeah, I usually have a Tony's Pepperoni in the freezer.   Especially can't beat it at ~$2.70 a pizza

I got caught up in that rising crust craze. In the last couple years I'm starting to prefer stuff like Tony's or Red Baron's simple pizza. I'm liking the thing crust and sodium.

Never tried the rising crust pizzas.  Which would you recommend?

A 12" riding crust pizza is an 8" pizza surrounded by a wad of crappy subway-quality bread.

*shrug* I've been assured by many girlfriends that 8" is the perfect size


So what do they say after they stop staring at your shoes?

/I KEED! I keed
 
2023-02-07 11:49:10 AM  

hlehmann: A couple of decades ago, before I started doing any real cooking, my wife was out of town and I was tasked with feeding our kids.  I thought sure, I'll just get one of those frozen pizzas.  It was a Tombstone pizza of some kind, and it was pretty bad.  I haven't bought frozen pizza since, but the freezer section at the market sure is full of them so someone must like that stuff.  I find it's really very little work to start some no-knead pizza dough in the morning and have cast iron pan pizza that evening.  Heck, some jarred pasta sauce, pre-shredded mozzarella, and pre-sliced pepperoni still makes a better and cheaper pizza than the frozen ones.


It's not the work. Frozen pizza is for when you want food without having thought ahead or putting in any effort at all. Sure, I can make dough ahead. But if I had the forethought to plan in the morning for pizza for dinner and make the dough, I wouldn't be buying frozen pizza.
 
2023-02-07 12:10:05 PM  

Lish: hlehmann: A couple of decades ago, before I started doing any real cooking, my wife was out of town and I was tasked with feeding our kids.  I thought sure, I'll just get one of those frozen pizzas.  It was a Tombstone pizza of some kind, and it was pretty bad.  I haven't bought frozen pizza since, but the freezer section at the market sure is full of them so someone must like that stuff.  I find it's really very little work to start some no-knead pizza dough in the morning and have cast iron pan pizza that evening.  Heck, some jarred pasta sauce, pre-shredded mozzarella, and pre-sliced pepperoni still makes a better and cheaper pizza than the frozen ones.

It's not the work. Frozen pizza is for when you want food without having thought ahead or putting in any effort at all. Sure, I can make dough ahead. But if I had the forethought to plan in the morning for pizza for dinner and make the dough, I wouldn't be buying frozen pizza.



I am literally sitting here trying to decide if I want to make some dough for pizza tonight, its already a bit late in the day
 
2023-02-07 12:23:40 PM  

drjekel_mrhyde: luna1580: drjekel_mrhyde: The best, and if you go to the OG spot 90 times better
[Fark user image 850x883]

thread over!

[Fark user image 400x491]

That one is the King of Kings. I'm in Chicago and those sell out fast


iTs A cAsSeRoLe hUrR d ... HaY wAiT a MiNut
 
2023-02-07 1:19:36 PM  
MrsGriffin and I set out to try as many brands of frozen pizza as possible and make notes on each. Both Newman's Own and Whole Foods 365 made it into the top tier. Some others worth mentioning include Bellatoria Breadcrumb Artisan Supreme, Freschetta Brick Oven Crust, California Pizza Kitchen Margherita Crispy Thin Crust.

I went back to our notes for the biggest losers:
Screamin' Sicilian Supremus Maximus "Cooking time estimate per directions was way off!"
Conni's Special "Toppings slid off the crust way too easily and nothing was particularly noteworthy except the number of veggies was more than usual"
Brew Pub Pizza Lotza Motza "This was an almost complete disaster. All the toppings were buried beneath a flavorless covering of mozzarella cheese."
Green Mill Thin 'n' Crispy Primo (Green Mill is a Twin Cities pizza restaurant chain)
"Easily the worst pizza we have tried so far. Crust was thin but not crisp and flavorless. Sausage and pepperoni were likewise unremarkable if not downright bad. There seemed to be a powdery taste to the cheese, as if some parmesan had been sprinkled on after cooking."
Red Baron Brick Oven Crust Supreme "When the best thing you can say about a pizza is the crust quality, you have a pizza with issues. All the toppings were not just lacking in taste but lacking, period. To say the box's picture didn't match reality is a severe understatement, and nothing tasted particularly good."
 
2023-02-07 1:28:37 PM  
Missed my guilty pleasure. However, I also buy Digiorno's crispy crust and it is the best frozen I've tried so far.

Fark user imageView Full Size
 
2023-02-07 1:36:54 PM  
Mike's Wild is probably the my fave, but the local doesn't carry them anymore.
 
2023-02-07 2:42:31 PM  

Boudyro: Screamin' Sicilian is my go-to frozen pie. It''s horribly overpriced though, so I only buy it when it's on sale.

Basically $10 at my local store. They go on BOGO often though.


I get them regular priced at $7.50 or $6 on sale, and I'm in the Bay Area.  Ever since we tried one, the varieties we can get have been a staple.  I wish we could get the cheese one just to try it, but we can get the pepperoni, meat, and supreme pizzas.  What I love is the amount of toppings.  They certainly don't skimp on any of them.  To make up for the lack of the cheesy pizza, we go with the Red Baron cheese trio.
 
2023-02-07 3:00:42 PM  
Screamin' Sicilian's product is pretty good. I've eaten it when it's been put in front of me. But I don't buy it, because the company that makes it, Palermo, has a pretty bad reputation for being unkind to its employees.
 
2023-02-07 6:39:51 PM  

knbwhite: johnny_vegas: jaylectricity: johnny_vegas: Hell yeah, I usually have a Tony's Pepperoni in the freezer.   Especially can't beat it at ~$2.70 a pizza

I got caught up in that rising crust craze. In the last couple years I'm starting to prefer stuff like Tony's or Red Baron's simple pizza. I'm liking the thing crust and sodium.

Never tried the rising crust pizzas.  Which would you recommend?

You didn't ask me, but I prefer Digiorno to Freshetta.  Digiorno is zesty and Freshetta is kinda sweet.


I don't know if I ever found a preference. Whatever was on sale. If not on sale, the store-brand.
 
2023-02-07 9:05:34 PM  

hlehmann: A couple of decades ago, before I started doing any real cooking, my wife was out of town and I was tasked with feeding our kids.  I thought sure, I'll just get one of those frozen pizzas.  It was a Tombstone pizza of some kind, and it was pretty bad.  I haven't bought frozen pizza since, but the freezer section at the market sure is full of them so someone must like that stuff.  I find it's really very little work to start some no-knead pizza dough in the morning and have cast iron pan pizza that evening.  Heck, some jarred pasta sauce, pre-shredded mozzarella, and pre-sliced pepperoni still makes a better and cheaper pizza than the frozen ones.


Agreed. When I mix up a kilo of 00 flour to make dough, there's enough for four or five pies. Yes there is an ~2 hour wait for the first one, but then I can make the rest for another couple weeks whenever I want, after subdividing and refrigerating the additional dough.  Add sauce, cheese(s) and optional other toppings. With minimal extra thought/shopping effort you'll have the ingredients on hand compared to finding a frozen slab (plus transporting, storing and etc). Even using top shelf input, the cost per large pie is around $6.50 - 8.00, and (with a little practice) easily compares to better Philly area "gourmet" pies going for $25 and more.
 
2023-02-07 9:50:53 PM  
Another way is to mention pineapple on pizza
:)
 
Displayed 48 of 48 comments

View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest

This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking




On Twitter


  1. Links are submitted by members of the Fark community.

  2. When community members submit a link, they also write a custom headline for the story.

  3. Other Farkers comment on the links. This is the number of comments. Click here to read them.

  4. Click here to submit a link.