Do you have adblock enabled?
 
If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Fanbolt)   Aaron Sorkin wants to say he's sorry for HBO's 'The Newsroom' and he wants a do-over   (fanbolt.com ) divider line
    More: Amusing, Aaron Sorkin, HBO, Tribeca Film Festival, West Wing  
•       •       •

3597 clicks; posted to Entertainment » on 23 Apr 2014 at 1:22 PM (2 years ago)   |   Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»



84 Comments   (+0 »)
View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest

Archived thread
 
2014-04-23 11:45:38 AM  
You can't have one.

Although as bad as The Newsroom became after its first season, it still never got as bad as Silicon Valley. Holy Christ, that's a terrible show.
 
2014-04-23 11:51:36 AM  
Well, that's embarrassing.
 
2014-04-23 12:05:07 PM  

Pocket Ninja: You can't have one.

Although as bad as The Newsroom became after its first season, it still never got as bad as Silicon Valley. Holy Christ, that's a terrible show.


You know, I haven't seen much of The Newsroom, since I don't get HBO.  But the little bit I have seen looked to me like it was all the annoying parts of West Wing, and none of the good.  Seriously - we all liked Toby on some level, and he did provide a certain well-meaning-asshole vibe... But all Toby all the time was a bit much for me.

There are no Mulligans in television, Aaron.  You're going to have to take your lumps.
 
2014-04-23 12:06:43 PM  

Benevolent Misanthrope: But the little bit I have seen looked to me like it was all the annoying parts of West Wing, and none of the good.


That is an exactly correct assessment of The Newsroom.
 
2014-04-23 12:11:43 PM  
The last time I complained about the Newsroom on here (comparing it to Arli$$) the show's fans accused me of not liking it because I was some closet fascist.

So what's more annoying than a bad show are it's fans.
 
2014-04-23 12:17:12 PM  
He must have sobered up.
 
2014-04-23 12:19:56 PM  
I liked the first season, the 2nd season was OK. I like the quick dialog stuff, I liked studio 60 also. I get annoyed by how polarizing the characters are, but that usually doesn't bother me, if the delivery is interesting.
 
2014-04-23 12:34:40 PM  
I liked the first season quite a bit.  The second season took steps forwards in some ways, backwards in others.  I'll watch the third happily.  Hopefully Sorkin gets another project on TV soon after, he's one of the best television writers in the business.
 
2014-04-23 12:42:21 PM  
I'll watch the third season.

I'll tell ya, though. That season 2 finale made me gag a little.
 
2014-04-23 01:22:17 PM  

HawgWild: That season 2 finale made me gag a little.


I think he watched one or two million too many British rom-coms when writing that ending

The show gave me diabetes with how saccharin it was
 
2014-04-23 01:22:48 PM  
Meh. I liked it.
 
2014-04-23 01:28:11 PM  

Pocket Ninja: You can't have one.

Although as bad as The Newsroom became after its first season, it still never got as bad as Silicon Valley. Holy Christ, that's a terrible show.


We like Newsroom and Silicon Valley.
 
2014-04-23 01:32:04 PM  

Pocket Ninja: You can't have one.

Although as bad as The Newsroom became after its first season, it still never got as bad as Silicon Valley. Holy Christ, that's a terrible show.



I've only seen the first season and have heard this quite a bit. I got the feeling that as the characters were fleshed out the show, was straying from what initially attracted me to it. I've been hesitant to even bother watching more just to avoid the disappointment, lol

Because People in power are Stupid: The last time I complained about the Newsroom on here (comparing it to Arli$$) the show's fans accused me of not liking it because I was some closet fascist.

So what's more annoying than a bad show are it's fans.


I'm sorry you had to suffer the slings and arrows of strangers over the internet. Need a tissue?
 
2014-04-23 01:33:58 PM  
His coke stash must be low.
 
2014-04-23 01:38:06 PM  
"I wasn't trying to and I'm not capable of teaching a professional journalist a lesson. That wasn't my intent and it's never my intent to teach you a lesson or try to persuade you or anything."

I didn't watch The Newsroom but am I right in assuming the Jeff Daniels character was closer to Cronkite than "Let's look at what's trending on Twitter"? Considering how bad TV news is these days would showing a better way be so bad?
 
2014-04-23 01:38:20 PM  
Silicon Valley is great. What's not to love about it?
 
2014-04-23 01:39:40 PM  
The show lost me at the Osama Bin Laden episode.

Dumbass reporter to United Airlines pilot:  "We got Osama Bin Laden for you, sir."

Ugh, that was so sanctimonious and cloying it was reprehensible.  Who's "we", kimosabe?  What the fark did you do to "get" him?  Just horrible, regrettable writing.
 
2014-04-23 01:42:26 PM  
Have Olivia Munn appear totally nude. Full frontal, not covered up by scenery or costume. And not just once, but every second she is on the screen.

Do this and we'll consider your apology.
 
2014-04-23 01:43:53 PM  

Benevolent Misanthrope: Pocket Ninja: You can't have one.

Although as bad as The Newsroom became after its first season, it still never got as bad as Silicon Valley. Holy Christ, that's a terrible show.

You know, I haven't seen much of The Newsroom, since I don't get HBO.  But the little bit I have seen looked to me like it was all the annoying parts of West Wing, and none of the good.  Seriously - we all liked Toby on some level, and he did provide a certain well-meaning-asshole vibe... But all Toby all the time was a bit much for me.

There are no Mulligans in television, Aaron.  You're going to have to take your lumps.


Toby at the beginning? Great.

Toby at the end? Insufferable, unreasonable, sadsack jerkwad.
 
2014-04-23 01:45:29 PM  

Wadded Beef: "I wasn't trying to and I'm not capable of teaching a professional journalist a lesson. That wasn't my intent and it's never my intent to teach you a lesson or try to persuade you or anything."

I didn't watch The Newsroom but am I right in assuming the Jeff Daniels character was closer to Cronkite than "Let's look at what's trending on Twitter"? Considering how bad TV news is these days would showing a better way be so bad?


I agree.  I think he was trying to teach a lesson and that's fine and now for some reason is trying to backpedal.  Maybe because he thinks that his show being preachy is what turned people off which I don't necessarily think is true.
 
2014-04-23 01:45:36 PM  
I'll watch season 3 of Newsroom. It's been good. I care about plot and dialogue and overall the show has met that need. I mean what else is there to watch this summer?
 
2014-04-23 01:47:02 PM  
Wadded Beef:
I didn't watch The Newsroom but am I right in assuming the Jeff Daniels character was closer to Cronkite than "Let's look at what's trending on Twitter"? Considering how bad TV news is these days would showing a better way be so bad?

To be honest, he's closest to Dan Rydell, who was Aaron Sorkin's Olbermann figure.
 
2014-04-23 01:49:16 PM  

Benevolent Misanthrope: There are no Mulligans in television


images.wjla.com
 
2014-04-23 01:50:34 PM  

Dangl1ng: I'll watch season 3 of Newsroom. It's been good. I care about plot and dialogue and overall the show has met that need. I mean what else is there to watch this summer?


The Wire.
THe Sopranos.
Alot of other HBO shows you can get through HBO GO?
 
2014-04-23 01:53:36 PM  
I really enjoyed the first season. The second season, not so much. I'll watch the third and hope it's at least better than season two.
 
2014-04-23 01:53:53 PM  
Family Guy had it right... it's a comedy that's too good to be funny.
 
2014-04-23 01:54:13 PM  
Oh fark y'all it's still a great show. So it changed a little, go back to watching shows that never change for eight seasons
 
2014-04-23 01:54:46 PM  

Pocket Ninja: You can't have one.

Although as bad as The Newsroom became after its first season, it still never got as bad as Silicon Valley. Holy Christ, that's a terrible show.


That's disappointing to hear. I had high hopes for that show. Fan of Judge, and the kid from Freaks and Geeks.
 
2014-04-23 01:55:33 PM  
I wish he would just apologize for writing his characters like total idiots to advance romance plots.

As far as self-indulgent Sorkin TV shows go, Studio 60 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> The Newsroom.

It will be unpopular to say, but I haven't liked anything Sorkin has worked on since Studio 60 whether in TV or film. I'm very wary of this new Steve Jobs movie he's working on.
 
2014-04-23 01:56:17 PM  
It's no Sports Night...
 
2014-04-23 01:56:38 PM  

DontMakeMeComeBackThere: The show lost me at the Osama Bin Laden episode.

Dumbass reporter to United Airlines pilot:  "We got Osama Bin Laden for you, sir."

Ugh, that was so sanctimonious and cloying it was reprehensible.  Who's "we", kimosabe?  What the fark did you do to "get" him?  Just horrible, regrettable writing.


I don't know. When it was announced that Bin Laden was killed there was a lot of "We got him!" going around by everybody.
 
2014-04-23 02:01:03 PM  

Wellon Dowd: Have Olivia Munn appear totally nude. Full frontal, not covered up by scenery or costume. And not just once, but every second she is on the screen.

Do this and we'll consider your apology.


I like it.
 
2014-04-23 02:02:44 PM  

Pocket Ninja: Although as bad as The Newsroom became after its first season, it still never got as bad as Silicon Valley. Holy Christ, that's a terrible show.


the newsroom is appallingly written, directed and acted... i agree. but i kind of like silicon valley.
 
2014-04-23 02:03:10 PM  
We watched the first two episodes, and were like "Wow, this is shiat."

It was typical Sorkin drama with a ridiculous heavy-handed liberal agenda (and I say that as a liberal).  The amount of smugness when filming must have fogged up the camera lenses.
 
2014-04-23 02:06:16 PM  

Pocket Ninja: Benevolent Misanthrope: But the little bit I have seen looked to me like it was all the annoying parts of West Wing, and none of the good.

That is an exactly correct assessment of The Newsroom.


Watched a few episodes of Newsroom, ^^^ was my view as well.
 
2014-04-23 02:12:19 PM  
You think he could just follow the template.

img.fark.net
 
2014-04-23 02:15:39 PM  
Aaron Sorkin wants to say he's sorry.........

America says, "yes you are".
 
2014-04-23 02:15:50 PM  
DontMakeMeComeBackThereJust horrible, regrettable writing.

They're filming their Boston Bombing episode this week, so unless Jeff Daniels is sucked into a Time Warp & emerges in 1916, you can expect a lot of "Boston, we DIDN'T get rid of terrorists. Sorry"
 
2014-04-23 02:27:28 PM  
He should have casted this guy as the lead...

img0105.popscreencdn.com
 
2014-04-23 02:28:23 PM  
For tv, Sorkin peaked with West Wing. Still an amazing movie writer.

When he is allowed have total control he just goes crazy. Also, why is that when I watch every episode I can see where he wrote it for 42 minutes, and then had to pad it out to 55ish for HBO. If you put in one more piece of irredeemable like the Sex and the City tourbus and then chasing down the twitter person.

You know what, screw it. Cocaine, hookers, blackjack
 
2014-04-23 02:29:26 PM  

FlashHarry: Pocket Ninja: Although as bad as The Newsroom became after its first season, it still never got as bad as Silicon Valley. Holy Christ, that's a terrible show.

the newsroom is appallingly written, directed and acted... i agree. but i kind of like silicon valley.


It's written like everything else Sorkin has ever written, which is that the characters all sound exactly the same. It's as if he writes everything as a monologue but breaks it up among the characters in the scene to give the illusion of dialogue.
 
2014-04-23 02:30:31 PM  
This is the show were its just a liberal cricle-jerk right?  Mebbe it could be that?
 
2014-04-23 02:43:17 PM  
The best part of the second season wasn't in the second season.  It was what happened after.  Following the finale, parts of the press whined and complained that the "fake news story that makes it to air" was far fetched and overdone.  Then the Laura Logan Benghazi scandal happened plot point by plot point.  It was as if Sorkin had found a crystal ball and had written a TV show using it.  It was, hilarious.

/Benghazi itself, not so much.
 
2014-04-23 02:46:08 PM  

ongbok: DontMakeMeComeBackThere: The show lost me at the Osama Bin Laden episode.

Dumbass reporter to United Airlines pilot:  "We got Osama Bin Laden for you, sir."

Ugh, that was so sanctimonious and cloying it was reprehensible.  Who's "we", kimosabe?  What the fark did you do to "get" him?  Just horrible, regrettable writing.

I don't know. When it was announced that Bin Laden was killed there was a lot of "We got him!" going around by everybody.


Did you see the episode?  It was not a "We got him!!!" moment.  The dude was about to go off on the pilot of the plane he was stuck on (landed, on the ground) about the stupid rule of not being able to stand up because they were not at the gate yet (he had been giving the stewardess a hard time earlier).  When he noticed that the pilot was a United pilot (didn't he know what flight he was on?), he suddenly got practically genuflecting and said in the most somber "I present you my first born son, your holiness" voice "I just wanted to tell you: we got Bin Laden for you." (with emphasis on the "for you" part too)  It was  truly cringe-worthy.
 
2014-04-23 02:46:30 PM  

Smelly McUgly: As far as self-indulgent Sorkin TV shows go, Studio 60 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> The Newsroom.


This. I really wanted to like Studio 60. And I watched the entire season, even the final six episodes, the final 5 being a 5-part episode. I watched because I kept hoping it would get better, and let's be honest, it was just as much fun to hate-watch when it wasn't good. That show was incredibly self-indulgent. He'd write 2-part and 3-part episodes that only needed 1 part. He'd have characters break into West Wing style monologues, channeling their inner Bartlet. It was painful and hilarious to watch a show supposedly about SNL in the style of West Wing. It would make for a great SNL parody if it wasn't a thing that actually happened.

The worst part, though, was how much the show insisted that it's main character was the greatest writer in a generation. That his writing was so powerful that it would shake the nation to its core. The major powers that be were on notice that this sketch-comedy show (don't call them skits) was going to take them down. And with such powerful sketches as "pimp my trike" and "Santa meets Chris Hanson" and an epic parody of "Modern Major General" who wouldn't be quaking in their boots. Such powerful, amazing writing. To echo Peter Griffin, the show "insists upon itself."

But in the end, I really can't hate the show. Even now, I can't. I am, however, very, very disappointed in it.
 
2014-04-23 02:49:27 PM  

FlyingJ: DontMakeMeComeBackThereJust horrible, regrettable writing.

They're filming their Boston Bombing episode this week, so unless Jeff Daniels is sucked into a Time Warp & emerges in 1916, you can expect a lot of "Boston, we DIDN'T get rid of terrorists. Sorry"


Awesome...so, five minutes after they hear about the bombing, we can expect one of the producers to announce that a friend of theirs at the State Department called and told him that he knew about a couple brothers from (whereverthefark-istan) who might be involved?  AND, the government could have stopped this bombing if not for the actions of Republicans?
 
2014-04-23 03:03:56 PM  

DontMakeMeComeBackThere: Awesome...so, five minutes after they hear about the bombing, we can expect one of the producers to announce that a friend of theirs at the State Department called and told him that he knew about a couple brothers from (whereverthefark-istan) who might be involved?  AND, the government could have stopped this bombing if not for the actions of Republicans?


either that or they'll wrongly identify the bombers (a la the NY post) and catch hell for it. or, better yet, they'll nearly wrongly identify the bombers and then do the right thing at the last moment and sit on their scoop.
 
2014-04-23 03:15:03 PM  

FlashHarry: better yet, they'll nearly wrongly identify the bombers and then do the right thing at the last moment and sit on their scoop.


I've seen that movie.

static.rogerebert.com

It was ok.
 
2014-04-23 03:21:17 PM  

DontMakeMeComeBackThere: ongbok: DontMakeMeComeBackThere: The show lost me at the Osama Bin Laden episode.

Dumbass reporter to United Airlines pilot:  "We got Osama Bin Laden for you, sir."

Ugh, that was so sanctimonious and cloying it was reprehensible.  Who's "we", kimosabe?  What the fark did you do to "get" him?  Just horrible, regrettable writing.

I don't know. When it was announced that Bin Laden was killed there was a lot of "We got him!" going around by everybody.

Did you see the episode?  It was not a "We got him!!!" moment.  The dude was about to go off on the pilot of the plane he was stuck on (landed, on the ground) about the stupid rule of not being able to stand up because they were not at the gate yet (he had been giving the stewardess a hard time earlier).  When he noticed that the pilot was a United pilot (didn't he know what flight he was on?), he suddenly got practically genuflecting and said in the most somber "I present you my first born son, your holiness" voice "I just wanted to tell you: we got Bin Laden for you." (with emphasis on the "for you" part too)  It was  truly cringe-worthy.


Wasn't the whole point was that they didn't know for sure if it was Bin Laden and they were trying to get off of the plane to get confirmation? The stewardess got tired of the one guy complaining and arguing with her so she got the pilot, and at that moment they got confirmation that it was Bin Laden. So it was a "we got him" moment like most of the press in the country had that night when Obama called the press conference and had the country speculating and wanting to say Bin Laden but were waiting for confirmation.
 
2014-04-23 03:32:12 PM  

DontMakeMeComeBackThere: "I just wanted to tell you: we got Bin Laden for you." (with emphasis on the "for you" part too) It was truly cringe-worthy.


What was really said: "And we wanted you and your first officer and Flight Attendant Crazy Lady to be the first ones on this plane to know that our armed forces killed Osama bin Laden for you tonight."

At least be outraged by what was said, not what you imagined :-)

/Yes, I'm a fan
 
2014-04-23 03:34:26 PM  
If I want to see liberals whining, I can get it for free on the internet.  Why would I pay HBO for it?
 
2014-04-23 03:37:56 PM  
your problem was you turned on the sound

img835.imageshack.us
 
2014-04-23 03:39:00 PM  

Handsome B. Wonderful: If I want to see liberals whining, I can get it for free on the internet.  Why would I pay HBO for it?


img.fark.net
 
2014-04-23 03:41:23 PM  

DontMakeMeComeBackThere: FlyingJ: DontMakeMeComeBackThereJust horrible, regrettable writing.

They're filming their Boston Bombing episode this week, so unless Jeff Daniels is sucked into a Time Warp & emerges in 1916, you can expect a lot of "Boston, we DIDN'T get rid of terrorists. Sorry"

Awesome...so, five minutes after they hear about the bombing, we can expect one of the producers to announce that a friend of theirs at the State Department called and told him that he knew about a couple brothers from (whereverthefark-Kochistan) who might be involved?  AND, the government could have stopped this bombing if not for the actions of Republicans?


FTFY.  Yeah, the show is about that subtle.
 
2014-04-23 03:46:14 PM  
Normally I'm not a fan of reboots, but I'd really love a new West Wing.

Start it up after the Santos presidency, all new players (with the option for cameos from the original cast), etc...
 
2014-04-23 03:48:12 PM  

cannibalparrot: Benevolent Misanthrope: Pocket Ninja: You can't have one.

Although as bad as The Newsroom became after its first season, it still never got as bad as Silicon Valley. Holy Christ, that's a terrible show.

You know, I haven't seen much of The Newsroom, since I don't get HBO.  But the little bit I have seen looked to me like it was all the annoying parts of West Wing, and none of the good.  Seriously - we all liked Toby on some level, and he did provide a certain well-meaning-asshole vibe... But all Toby all the time was a bit much for me.

There are no Mulligans in television, Aaron.  You're going to have to take your lumps.

Toby at the beginning? Great.

Toby at the end? Insufferable, unreasonable, sadsack jerkwad.



Which is exactly what would happen to an idealist like Toby who thought he had finally reached a place where he could make real, positive change, only to find it was Politics in America.   One of the best characters ever on television, in one of the best shows ever on television.

Also I loved the Newsroom, except for that stupid forehead woman, who should have been Mandied after the first episode.

Don't bother trying to argue either point, because you would be wrong and therefore should keep quite.
 
2014-04-23 03:50:13 PM  

The Stealth Hippopotamus: your problem was you turned on the sound

[img835.imageshack.us image 249x203]


Ah yes. The "Charmed" effect.
 
2014-04-23 03:59:21 PM  

John the Magnificent: Don't bother trying to argue either point, because you would be wrong and therefore should keep quiet.


Just sit there in their wrongness being wrong?
 
2014-04-23 04:10:47 PM  
They gave him a longer corridor.
 
2014-04-23 04:13:00 PM  
Liked Sportsnight, AFGM, and the first season and a half of West Wing.  Early on in season 2 of West Wing, every character's lines could have been swapped with any other character and no one would have noticed. Every single one became interchangeable.  Could have retitled the series "When Liberals Attack Windmills."  (and I'm the libbiest lib who ever libbed) Here is how the dialog began to sound:

CAMERA PANS LEFT AND PICKS UP GROUP AND THEY ENTER THE HALLWAY.

FEMALE: Wenna?
MALE: No!.  Wenna wenna,
FEMALE: I thought, well, we, wenna wenna wenna.
MALE: Wenna.  WENNA!  Wenna wenna.  wenna
FEMALE: I said wenna.  Tampon!  Wenna.
MALE: (laughs) Okay. I wen--
FEMALE: Wenna wenna wenna, wenna, wenna wenna, wen--wenna wenna wenna wenna, wenn--a, wenna wenna wennna.....
MALE: Wenna Wenna.  Wenna?
FEMALE: Wennawennawennaaaaaawennawenna...wennawennawennawennawenna...wenna..aa a.wen...wenna wenna wenna....

Newsroom was an interesting idea.  But, please do not devolve into a giant glass of whine.
 
2014-04-23 04:13:24 PM  

John the Magnificent: cannibalparrot: Benevolent Misanthrope: Pocket Ninja: You can't have one.

Although as bad as The Newsroom became after its first season, it still never got as bad as Silicon Valley. Holy Christ, that's a terrible show.

You know, I haven't seen much of The Newsroom, since I don't get HBO.  But the little bit I have seen looked to me like it was all the annoying parts of West Wing, and none of the good.  Seriously - we all liked Toby on some level, and he did provide a certain well-meaning-asshole vibe... But all Toby all the time was a bit much for me.

There are no Mulligans in television, Aaron.  You're going to have to take your lumps.

Toby at the beginning? Great.

Toby at the end? Insufferable, unreasonable, sadsack jerkwad.


Which is exactly what would happen to an idealist like Toby who thought he had finally reached a place where he could make real, positive change, only to find it was Politics in America.   One of the best characters ever on television, in one of the best shows ever on television.

Also I loved the Newsroom, except for that stupid forehead woman, who should have been Mandied after the first episode.

Don't bother trying to argue either point, because you would be wrong and therefore should keep quite.


nail/head/etc.  but I would add that Toby eventually got tired of Toby too at the end.  I think a good point of showing this is when Toby talked about needing a dictator-like style of gov't to make the world the way he wanted it (season 3 maybe after the shooting).  Although, I still don't know exactly how he ended up under house arrest.  Seems like every time my wife and I re-watch the show, she watches those episodes when I am not around.  something with a secret spaceship.

and I hate the forehead girl on Newsroom.  Her face is too distracting and her characters actions are annoying.
 
2014-04-23 04:17:09 PM  

Gubbo: For tv, Sorkin peaked with West Wing. Still an amazing movie writer.

When he is allowed have total control he just goes crazy. Also, why is that when I watch every episode I can see where he wrote it for 42 minutes, and then had to pad it out to 55ish for HBO. If you put in one more piece of irredeemable like the Sex and the City tourbus and then chasing down the twitter person.

You know what, screw it. Cocaine, hookers, blackjack


The West Wing is one of the best shows in the history of television. Is it really a huge shock that other things don't measure up to it? Expecting Sorkin to match the achievement of West Wing on any project he does is kind of an absurdly high standard, isn't it?
 
2014-04-23 04:37:09 PM  
I like the Newsroom.

Just like The West Wing, it's pure wish fulfillment TV. Sort of like how 24 is for those who fap to fantasies of torture.
 
2014-04-23 04:42:31 PM  

Smelly McUgly: I wish he would just apologize for writing his characters like total idiots to advance romance plots.

As far as self-indulgent Sorkin TV shows go, Studio 60 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> The Newsroom.

It will be unpopular to say, but I haven't liked anything Sorkin has worked on since Studio 60 whether in TV or film. I'm very wary of this new Steve Jobs movie he's working on.


Needs more >>>>>>
 
2014-04-23 04:47:51 PM  
Daniels' character was beyond unlikeable. He was a snarling, angry, bitter douche. Having an anchor like that on TV would last about one broadcast. Other than that, the show was like like Think Progress envisioning it's perfect TV news broadcast. Ugh.
 
2014-04-23 04:51:46 PM  
A do-over? No

A pass? Yes, based on previous work
 
2014-04-23 04:55:28 PM  
Sports night was good for a first-time TV show, except of course the terrible laugh track.
The West Wing is a high water mark.
Studio 60 was fun, about mid-range for a Sorkin show.
The Newsroom was preachy as hell (at least in season 1) and I'd say it was better that way. Will still enjoy it.

/Quo Vadimus?
 
2014-04-23 04:58:36 PM  
I like The Newsroom....mostly.

The love triangle is annoying. Couldn't care less about it, but for the most part, I enjoyed the show.

I liked Studio 60 as well, but my real issue with it was that the sketch comedy that was supposed to be great was terrible.

I enjoyed Sportsnight as well.  I think faking a sports highlights show is a lot easier than a late-night sketch comedy.
 
2014-04-23 05:01:43 PM  

Jeteupthemiddle: I like The Newsroom....mostly.

The love triangle is annoying. Couldn't care less about it, but for the most part, I enjoyed the show.

I liked Studio 60 as well, but my real issue with it was that the sketch comedy that was supposed to be great was terrible.

I enjoyed Sportsnight as well.  I think faking a sports highlights show is a lot easier than a late-night sketch comedy.


Sports Night worked because they admitted that they were only 3rd best in the ratings, so when things went wrong on air or behind the scenes, it made sense. Studio 60 was terrible because, as you said, it was supposed to be a great show but everyone was terrible at their job.
 
2014-04-23 05:08:37 PM  

Coder: Sports night was good for a first-time TV show, except of course the terrible laugh track.
The West Wing is a high water mark.
Studio 60 was fun, about mid-range for a Sorkin show.
The Newsroom was preachy as hell (at least in season 1) and I'd say it was better that way. Will still enjoy it.

/Quo Vadimus?


I can't see or hear those two words now without thinking of the "Deus Ex Machina" treasure chest at the end of Dodgeball.
 
2014-04-23 05:15:10 PM  

DontMakeMeComeBackThere: The show lost me at the Osama Bin Laden episode.

Dumbass reporter to United Airlines pilot:  "We got Osama Bin Laden for you, sir."

Ugh, that was so sanctimonious and cloying it was reprehensible.  Who's "we", kimosabe?  What the fark did you do to "get" him?  Just horrible, regrettable writing.


I rewatched that not long ago. He said "Tonight the United States military killed Osama Bin Laden for you. We got him."

Not saying that episode wasn't over the top, but I heard it as "We, the United States of America, got him."

I like the show.
 
2014-04-23 05:20:11 PM  

Jeteupthemiddle: I like The Newsroom....mostly.

The love triangle is annoying. Couldn't care less about it, but for the most part, I enjoyed the show.

I liked Studio 60 as well, but my real issue with it was that the sketch comedy that was supposed to be great was terrible.

I enjoyed Sportsnight as well.  I think faking a sports highlights show is a lot easier than a late-night sketch comedy.


I liked Sportsnight also.

The romantic subplots are the worst thing about The Newsroom.  Every time the show goes down that road it starts to suck a bit.

I liked season 1 more than 2.  I think Sorkin tried to tone down the idealism going into the second season, but the idealism is what made it work. Will McAvoy is a fun character, and I want to see more of his mission to civilize.
 
2014-04-23 05:32:57 PM  

TrainingWheelsNeeded: That's disappointing to hear. I had high hopes for that show. Fan of Judge, and the kid from Freaks and Geeks.


Don't not watch Silicon Valley because someone on Fark said it's bad. I think it's a fun show, and being someone who works in tech and who lived in the Bay Area during the dot-com boom, it's fairly damned accurate in the ways it needs to be. If you like Mike Judge and the kid from Freaks and Geeks (who plays a Satanic illegal immigrant from Canada on the show), I think you'll be fine.

Besides, you were quoting Pocket Ninja, King of Irony. So go ahead and feel free to watch Silicon Valley.
 
2014-04-23 05:36:46 PM  

ExcedrinHeadache: the kid from Freaks and Geeks (who plays a Satanic illegal immigrant from Canada on the show


He was also brilliant in Party Down:

prestigiousblogsir.files.wordpress.com
uproxx.files.wordpress.com
 
2014-04-23 05:37:23 PM  
A sports night remake with nudity and sex?

please!
 
2014-04-23 05:45:36 PM  
For the most part, I like The Newsroom. But that's not to say it's not a very flawed program.

As many have said, the romantic subplots are terrible. At times, the show is painfully bad because of them, and I don't understand why Sorkin insists on trying to force them on the audience. The finale of season 2 just completely fell apart at the end because it was "OK, jam all the romantic crap we ignored for a few weeks into this episode."

There are plot threads that go nowhere, like the online commenter threatening McAvoy in season 1. That built the entire season, then just disappeared in season 2. I'm assuming by dialogue that we are to infer the dead son of Skinner's DC source was the one doing it, but it was never really stated as such. Don't be "Heroes," Sorkin. Resolve your plots.

The character development is iffy (I still don't buy Mack as the badass journalist she's supposed to be, Maggie just sucks as a character) or flat-out ridiculous (Don is either a douchebag or he isn't. Pick one. Jane Fonda's Leona either hates the show or she doesn't. Pick one). Really, the best character development has been for Olivia Munn.

There are elements of a really fantastic show in The Newsroom. They too often are obscured by the crap Sorkin shoves into it, and that's a shame.
 
2014-04-23 06:32:15 PM  

someonelse: John the Magnificent: Don't bother trying to argue either point, because you would be wrong and therefore should keep quiet.

Just sit there in their wrongness being wrong?


Exactly!
 
2014-04-23 07:19:01 PM  
Olivia Munn in sexy business attire? You have nothing to apologize for, Aaron.
 
2014-04-23 08:35:01 PM  

Benevolent Misanthrope: Pocket Ninja: You can't have one.

Although as bad as The Newsroom became after its first season, it still never got as bad as Silicon Valley. Holy Christ, that's a terrible show.

You know, I haven't seen much of The Newsroom, since I don't get HBO.  But the little bit I have seen looked to me like it was all the annoying parts of West Wing, and none of the good.  Seriously - we all liked Toby on some level, and he did provide a certain well-meaning-asshole vibe... But all Toby all the time was a bit much for me.

There are no Mulligans in television, Aaron.  You're going to have to take your lumps.


Horseshiat. He's on his third mulligan. Been writing the same show with the same character (yes, they're all the same character) since Sports Night.
 
2014-04-23 09:00:57 PM  

Pocket Ninja: You can't have one.

Although as bad as The Newsroom became after its first season, it still never got as bad as Silicon Valley. Holy Christ, that's a terrible show.


Yeah, you're pretty wrong about Silicon Valley.
 
2014-04-23 09:56:10 PM  

The_Gallant_Gallstone: Family Guy had it right... it's a comedy that's too good to be funny.


It insists on itself.
 
2014-04-24 01:07:14 AM  

Coder: Sports night was good for a first-time TV show, except of course the terrible laugh track.
The West Wing is a high water mark.
Studio 60 was fun, about mid-range for a Sorkin show.
The Newsroom was preachy as hell (at least in season 1) and I'd say it was better that way. Will still enjoy it.

/Quo Vadimus?


They dumped the laugh track after the first few episodes.
 
2014-04-24 08:55:20 AM  

Nogale: Coder: Sports night was good for a first-time TV show, except of course the terrible laugh track.
The West Wing is a high water mark.
Studio 60 was fun, about mid-range for a Sorkin show.
The Newsroom was preachy as hell (at least in season 1) and I'd say it was better that way. Will still enjoy it.

/Quo Vadimus?

They dumped the laugh track after the first few episodes.


I remember them toning it down, but don't remember it being removed completely. *shrug*
 
2014-04-24 07:22:05 PM  
I gave up after 4 or 5 episodes.  Sorkin just isn't for me.
 
Displayed 84 of 84 comments

View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest


This thread is archived, and closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »
On Twitter






In Other Media


  1. Links are submitted by members of the Fark community.

  2. When community members submit a link, they also write a custom headline for the story.

  3. Other Farkers comment on the links. This is the number of comments. Click here to read them.

  4. Click here to submit a link.

Report