If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(The Atlantic)   "Processed food is slowly poisoning everyone," claims heart doctor with sinister agenda   (theatlantic.com) divider line 28
    More: Unlikely, raw foods, processed food, political agenda, Cardiologist, omega-3 fatty acids  
•       •       •

6233 clicks; posted to Main » on 29 Jan 2014 at 2:22 AM (32 weeks ago)   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»



Voting Results (Smartest)
View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest

2014-01-29 01:55:40 AM
10 votes:
"We physicians with all our experience and authority" he writes, "often acquire a rather large selfishness that tends to make it hard to accept we are wrong. So, here it is. I openly admit to being mistaken. As a heart surgeon with 25 years experience, having done more than 5,000 open-heart surgeries, today is my day to right the wrong with medical and scientific proof."

Between 2000 and 2008, Lundell was subjected to five regulatory actions by the Arizona Medical Board:

In 2000, the board concluded that his postoperative management of a patient who had died following carotid artery surgery was substandard and insufficiently documented. He was censured for unprofessional conduct, assessed a $2,500 civil penalty, and placed on probation during which he was required to take continuing medical education courses in carotid artery surgery and medical recordkeeping. He was also required to submit to monitoring of his patient records [4].

In 2003, the board noted that 13 out of 20 charts reviewed by the consultant were deficient because they did not include adequate initial evaluations of the patients. Lundell was censured again and was placed on probation that included quarterly chart reviews [5].

In 2004, the board found fault with his management of two patients and concluded that his records for these patients were inadequate. He was reprimanded and ordered to serve two more years of probation, during which he was required to undergo an extensive evaluation of his fitness to continue practicing medicine [6].

In 2006, the board sent him an advisory letter for failure to maintain adequate records and for a technical surgical error [7].

In 2008, the board reviewed Lundell's management of several more patients and revoked his medical license. The board's order mentioned that the board was investigating his care of seven patients because the Banner Desert Medical Hospital had suspended Lundell's surgical privileges [7].


Financial and Legal Trouble

Lundell also ran into considerable difficulty in his nonmedical affairs. Although the full records are not readily available, documents I found on the Internet indicate the following:
In 1990 Lundell filed for bankruptcy. At that time, there were several lawsuits pending in state court on the theory that he was a partner in a construction business called West Coast Construction in which he had invested. I don't know the outcome of these suits, but he ultimately wound up owing at least $20 million dollars.

In 2005, he again filed for bankruptcy, claiming to have assets of $12,990 and liabilities of $20,185,769.60. The liabilities included $74,264.77 in credit card debts, $78,932.48 for accounting services, the $20 million debt related to the previous bankruptcy, and "unknown amounts" of state and federal taxes owed. The financial statement also listed his earnings as $0 for 2005, $0 for $2004, and $288,436 for 2003 [8].

In 2004, Lundell pleaded guilty in federal court to three counts of willful failure to file income tax returns. A newspaper report indicates that he had become a client of "tax protester" Wayne C. Bentson after a long-running dispute with the IRS and that rather than filing tax returns from 1992 to 1996, Lundell had filed affidavits contesting the government's right to levy taxes [9].

In 2005, Lundell was sentenced to three years' probation, but the probation was terminated after 16 months. Bentson was ordered to pay $1,129,937 to the Internal Revenue Service and was sentenced to four years in prison, to be followed by three years of supervised release [10].

link
2014-01-29 05:15:20 AM
3 votes:

hardinparamedic: Boloxor the Insipid:Who's the asshole, Soutare?

It's just a travesty that he did so much good and yet he lost his license for complete incompetence, and still won't sleep with you.

If it quacks like a quack...


Deepak Chopra was a medical doctor who saved lives, then became an asshole quack.

You can be both a doctor *and* and asshole.
2014-01-29 02:59:33 AM
3 votes:

Lenny_da_Hog: Now people think doctors are there to do what you tell them, instead of being highly educated and trained people who take care of problems the vast majority of people can't begin to understand.


Americans tend to believe that their opinion is just as valuable as the opinion of an expert in their field.

It's why we have anti vaccers and a global warming "debate". I even recall a guy on here who said that any scientific theory he read about that didn't make sense to him couldn't be true, since he's a really smart guy and all. therefore if he didn't understand it, it was a lie to deceive the public.
2014-01-29 07:08:09 AM
2 votes:

bunner: So, anecdotes are like "feels likes"?


I guess you missed the link showing the mean income as 73K a year.

here. let me post it again so you can ignore it again.

http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes119013.htm

also you seem unaware of crop insurance, and government guaranteed agriculture loans.
2014-01-29 05:02:48 AM
2 votes:
Boloxor the Insipid:Who's the asshole, Soutare?

It's just a travesty that he did so much good and yet he lost his license for complete incompetence, and still won't sleep with you.

If it quacks like a quack...
2014-01-29 05:01:39 AM
2 votes:
his ideas are sound but not practical for the most part.

Yes, companies often put in too much substances that can, over certain quantities per day, become harmful. Yes, they will use certain fats and additives to enhance flavor that, below a certain level, are harmless, but by heavily advertising their foods and convincing the sheeple to consume them to make major profits, they can do more harm than good.

Then there are the companies who cheat on healthy foods, like Olive Oil. Many popular brands are cut with vegetable oil to (A) lighten the taste (B) extend the supply (C) make a bigger profit. So, folks who consume the adulterated oils are basically wasting their money and some of the vegetable oils can be high in undesirable saturated fats.

Consider also the companies who target their food products for the poor, like 'spiced chicken patties' which, when cooked, extrude a yellow grease. They use parts of the chicken usually sent to dog food companies, toss in fats and spices to enhance the flavors, along with sugars and salts. It's food to keep you from starving and it will taste fairly good but, it is not that good for you.

Especially since someone discovered you can add inert cellulose to a food product as a filler. It has no taste. Causes no harm. Provides no nutritional or caloric value. So, you get less 'real food' for your dollar.

From when I was a kid back in the 50's to now, we've discovered over 500 different things previously affecting food that were harmful, but no one realized this. The most known is the lead solder used in cans. Now, we use aluminum cans mostly. No one knew that corn syrup in place of granulated sugar was going to prove more harmful than real sugar, but it was introduced when the cost of sugar, due to political actions, was rising.

I've seen, since back then, people no longer coming down with many illnesses that used to be quite common. I've watched the life span of the average person increase and noticed that age related senile dementia has decreased in severity.

Since our population has more than doubled since then, we need to provide ample food, able to be processed and stored for months, if not years, without loosing much of the nutritional value. And a lot of it.

We've changed our society so people don't have much time to stand around fixing healthy, organic meals like grandma used to, so they grab canned goods and quickly make what they want. When they took out saturated fats from various processed meats, it changed the flavor. Companies had to regain it in order to keep sales up so most added in corn sugar -- (not the syrup) -- which promptly went up in price.

Over the decades, companies have worked hard to enhance the taste of their foods to appeal to folks. Ever had basic, home made tomato sauce without salt or a touch of sugar? It's bland as hell.

'Fresh' orange juice is usually gathered the year before being processed and shipped to stores. To preserve the millions of gallons, it's sealed in tanks filled with nitrogen. That robs it of much of it's flavor, so even most of the 'right-off-the-tree-fresh' flavor comes in a bag of additives dumped into the tanks prior to processing.

The ability to store food for long periods of time has been a boon to mankind.

I rarely see a can of food forgotten on the back of a pantry shelf, puffed up, lid ready to pop from the pressure of spoiled food inside but I used to see them in the late 50's.

A combination of fresh foods as well as processed is fine. Read the labels to decrease sugars and fats. Our society is no longer as physically active as back in the 60's, which means certain energy providing fats in foods now no longer are needed to provide power, but can cause weight gain and harm.

As a kid because I was very active, I ate ravenously and remained as skinny as a rail. In my 20s, the same thing. When I took jobs requiring less physical activity, I gained weight because I was conditioned to eat like a horse. Plus, by then fast food places had exploded onto the scene and were advertising like mad to get your money. So long as the food didn't outright kill you, people started swarming to the places because the stuff tasted good and they didn't have to make their own lunches anymore.

So, the Dr is partially right, but neglected to figure in the booming population, economical constraints, the rising costs of fresh foods and the diminish amount of good farm land.

I used to love Georgia Peaches bought off a truck from a farm. They were the size of soft balls, smelled heavenly, were soft and so juicy you had to eat them outside. Today, the trucks no longer come to sell the surplus and Georgia Peaches in the grocery stores are small, hard as rocks, not very juicy and nowhere as tasty.

They have to be picked green to have a shelf life. So, folks will turn to canned peaches. Good apples have exploded in cost, but here again, they tend to be hard, not as sweet as I recall and not as tasty.
We're still learning. It's going to take some time to clean up the food industry because much of what we thought was harmless that we added to preserve color and taste, 25 years down the road is turning out to be not so good.

Besides. Go to Whole Foods and pay two or three times the price of Organic food. Public will sell you healthy, high quality lettuce for a lot less that is not Organic and just as good for you.

There's a whole lot of factors that go into this thing that he hasn't fully considered. Yet, he is on the right track.
2014-01-29 04:36:06 AM
2 votes:

Solutare: Wow, I can't believe assholes are defending this asshole.

Oh... wait. I guess I'm not surprised at all, actually.


Why is he ans 'asshole' Solutare?  He saved 5000 lives doing heart surgeries in his career.  How many lives have you saved Solutare?   Then, he wrote a book that says you should eat healthy food.
Here you are,Solutare, calling a total stranger an asshole on the basis of some crap you read on the internet.

Who's the asshole, Soutare?
2014-01-29 03:37:07 AM
2 votes:

Boloxor the Insipid: Not filing your tax returns is a misdemeanor civil charge (http://www.irs.gov/irm/part25/irm_25-001-007.html ), which can escalate to felony, however it is still a civil, not criminal, matter.

In 2005, Lundell was sentenced to three years' probation, but the probation was terminated after 16 months. Bentson was ordered to pay $1,129,937 to the Internal Revenue Service and was sentenced to four years in prison, to be followed by three years of supervised release


try again.
2014-01-29 03:00:42 AM
2 votes:

mr0x: Umm, please provide citation.


I did. the link also has citations to the individual claims it makes.
2014-01-29 02:52:43 AM
2 votes:
I think a lot of this sentiment has come since the advent of prescription advertising. TV ads for prescription drugs all basically say, "Don't trust what your doctor has told you, but don't get a second opinion, either. Listen to us, the marketers, and tell your doctor you want our drug instead."

Now people think doctors are there to do what you tell them, instead of being highly educated and trained people who take care of problems the vast majority of people can't begin to understand.
2014-01-29 09:20:03 AM
1 votes:
In California you would be amazed what it takes to get an irritated letter from the medical board. A ludicrous misdiagnosis or negligent treatment protocol resulting in death usually lands a doctor on probation (if the entire affair is well documented). The vast majority of negligent deaths go unreported.
Any person who is repeatedly under fire from the medical board is most assuredly NOT somebody to be trusted, professionally or otherwise.
2014-01-29 08:46:26 AM
1 votes:
Meanwhile in reality, life expectancy continues to rise, disease continues its decline.
2014-01-29 08:28:54 AM
1 votes:
You have 2 options:
1) eat healthy, and die alone of old age, wheelchair bound due to a broken hip at 95, having your butt wiped by brown people who talk about you in their own language and steal your pills
2) go out in a bacon-fueled blaze of heart attack glory at 60 while nailing your 20-something mistress
2014-01-29 08:18:56 AM
1 votes:
Sinister?
It's not like his ideas are out of left field
2014-01-29 07:14:32 AM
1 votes:

log_jammin: bunner: So, anecdotes are like "feels likes"?

I guess you missed the link showing the mean income as 73K a year.

here. let me post it again so you can ignore it again.

http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes119013.htm

also you seem unaware of crop insurance, and government guaranteed agriculture loans.

I'm gonna save everybody some trouble.  The nanosecond you get all "Nuh uh, no, see it's like this, like this, stupid, because it is and I know because..." and start peacocking for your invisible fan base in the peanut gallery, you  have blown it.  Sh*t the bedding, screwed the schnauzer.  Finis.  Über mit.  Because it becomes very obvious that it's the reason you use this website.  Which means you have no views, per se, you're just here to tell everybody how clueless they are compared to you.  And then you get a "hit" and you bite down on that like a dog on a rag.  And there you are, calling people stupid and uninformed from the bus stop you got off at in '02 that says "AOL".  Cause that's how clapped out trolling, waxing superior and generally trying to piss from a great height on a web forum is.  It's that last decade.  And it makes the people who endlessly flog it the pile of dog crap you have to walk around in the park.  Ha ha.
2014-01-29 06:39:32 AM
1 votes:

mr0x: The average wage of a farmer is $24,000 and  there are about half a million farmers in the US. That is about 1%-2% of the population.

I think you read your chart wrong


http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes119013.htm

"Farmers, Ranchers, and Other Agricultural Managers" showed a mean annual income of $73,000.

I grew up, and live in, rural Kansas, and I've never met a poor farmer.
2014-01-29 06:36:14 AM
1 votes:

mr0x: bunner: Like, eat food that like, just grows and stuff and not crap and it's better?

Goollll lee!

Whodathunk?

The average wage of a farmer is $24,000 and  there are about half a million farmers in the US. That is about 1%-2% of the population.

There are more jailers than farmers. There are more financial managers than farmers. There are more lawyers than farmers. There are more police officers than ... you get the idea.

Growing stuff is a low paying job done by a very small portion of the population.

http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes_nat.htm#00-0000


I have little doubt that the average farmer, when not trying to wriggle Monsanto's weenie out of his behind is struggling for the privilege of producing food.  They need a bail out.
2014-01-29 04:43:06 AM
1 votes:

Boloxor the Insipid: He saved 5000 lives doing heart surgeries in his career.


how do you know?
2014-01-29 04:29:48 AM
1 votes:
Like, eat food that like, just grows and stuff and not crap and it's better?

Goollll lee!

Whodathunk?

Soon, we will look back at the post WWII era between 45 and 70 when there was a brief epoch of industry based prosperity for people who worked for a living.  then, we will look back on this era as the time when "we had everything totally figured out, because computers."  With any luck, this will lead us to the era of "Wow, everything pretty much already works and, oddly, the less we mess with it; the better it works."  We can only hope.
2014-01-29 04:20:59 AM
1 votes:
Wow, I can't believe assholes are defending this asshole.

Oh... wait. I guess I'm not surprised at all, actually.
2014-01-29 03:58:24 AM
1 votes:

Boloxor the Insipid: The footnote for the second 'probation' mention isn't even about Lundell.


Yes I was wrong on that part.

Boloxor the Insipid: The previous mention of probation is about his medical licence.


the previous mention of probation was   In 2005, Lundell was sentenced to three years' probation, but the probation was terminated after 16 months.

the three mention of probation before that was for his medical license.

Boloxor the Insipid: I see no evidence that Lundell was ever convicted of a crime..

"In 2004, Lundell pleaded guilty in federal court to three counts of willful failure to file income tax returns. "


and was later..."sentenced to three years' probation, but the probation was terminated after 16 months. "
2014-01-29 03:36:09 AM
1 votes:

Boloxor the Insipid: It seems to me that the Atlantic article might be committing libel when it say 'Also, his invocation of moral defensibly loses gravitas in light of his criminal history.'

Even if you accept the accusations posted on the website 'Quackwatch' as truth, there doesn't appear to be any 'criminal' history.  Most of the 'charges' are about his medical license, not criminal wrong-doing. Not filing your tax returns is a misdemeanor civil charge (http://www.irs.gov/irm/part25/irm_25-001-007.html ), which can escalate to felony, however it is still a civil, not criminal, matter.

What is his crime?


Tax evasion...  it's a crime.
2014-01-29 03:33:32 AM
1 votes:
Has there ever been a health related issue taken up by the Facebook gossip crowd that wasn't in the end at least 50% bullshiat?

Health advice from Facebook is literally folk medicine. You're likely to get the same results by burying half a potato under a full moon while wearing a bra on your head.
2014-01-29 03:27:02 AM
1 votes:
I thought cooking was processing. All foods are processed, otherwise it's just raw. Macaroni and cheese is still organic because of the butter and milk and salt.
2014-01-29 03:23:29 AM
1 votes:
FTFA: "Diet advice, in particular, is in even more places than everywhere."

Incorrect by far;this guy reads like he's a valley girl.
2014-01-29 03:16:33 AM
1 votes:

log_jammin: mr0x: Umm, please provide citation.

I did. the link also has citations to the individual claims it makes.


>
>
>

Oh yeah, you did. Sorry. Great link.

He also has MLM supplement thing going on and membership based website.

He's obviously piggbacking on the paleo ideas and using his former heart surgeon credentials to make money.
2014-01-29 02:25:19 AM
1 votes:
hotmessmartha.com
2014-01-29 01:18:17 AM
1 votes:
Sinister?

Hawking your goods and services in exchange for something, in this case oodles and oodles of money, is as old a phenomenon as man himself, probably older.
 
Displayed 28 of 28 comments

View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest


This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »






Report