Ricardo Klement: Debeo Summa Credo: Assume the treasury has to issue $60b per month to fund the deficit.If all $60b of that comes from investors, there is no money created. Every dollar that went to buy treasuries already existed and was held by investors prior to buying treasuries.If the fed is buying $40b of those treasuries (these numbers are realistic in today's environment), only $20b comes from outside. The other $40b was created by the fed to buy treasuries. The fed basically says to the treasury: here's $40b of crisp new dillar bills to buy stuff with, pay us back later. Yes, interest rates are affected by this, because the newly created dollar bills are a supply of capital that drives down equilibrium interest rates. But new money is created. If and when the fed shrinks it's balance sheet, money supply is reduced.But there's no difference between having a bond that says $1 on it than having a piece of cotton paper that says $1 on it. Not while interest rates are effectively 0. Trading one for the other isn't creating anything, just changing the name. In both cases, there's $1 in your hands, and $1 in that of the feds. You can trade those two all year long, and both sides will still only have one thing with $1 on it. Nothing is made. No money is printed.
Stile4aly: Debeo Summa Credo: Ricardo Klement: Debeo Summa Credo: Ricardo Klement: QE is not printing money.People should stop getting their economics information from the Pauls.What is it then when the fed buys mortgages and treasuries each month? It isnt literally printing cash, but it is crediting the reserve accounts of banks for the securities they sold to the fed. The $85b per month or whatever it is is being conjured out of thin air. If a bank or other counterparty wanted cash, it could convert it's reserve account balance into literal cash.This isn't printing money because the short-term interest rates are basically zero, money and short-term bonds are the same thing. Exchanging money for short-term debt has no effect, and giving banks more money is exactly the same as giving them short-term debt.That's not to say that QE is harmless. Long-term debt has its uses, especially putting off inflation. So buying it back means that you undo that putting-off of inflation. But it is still not the same as CREATING the inflation in the first place. It already exists, we just sold it to the future.Huh? I don't understand. When the fed buys treasuries, which it is doing to a significant extent, it is trading newly created cash, more or less, for govt debt. The govt uses the cash to fund food stamps or aircraft carriers or whatever. So all the money used to buy those food stamps and aircraft carriers was just conjured from nothing, increasing the money supply, essentially printing money.The fact the treasuries the fed has purchased will eventually mature has no bearing on the fact that they printed money to buy them now. If the govt does eventually pay off the notes, without just refinancing themwith the fed (ie the fed shrinks it's balance sheet) then the fed will be reducing the money supply. But while it continues to expand its balance sheet it is in fact "printing money".I'm no paullist and I understand why they've needed to take the steps they have, but I think the phrase "printing ...The US budget operates independently of treasury sales. Though the debt limit sets a maximum to the amount of treasuries which can be sold, the spending is authorized regardless of whether those treasuries actually sell or not. As such, the Fed purchases of treasuries do not inject money into economic circulation, they only serve to restrain interest rates.
Ricardo Klement: QE is not printing money.People should stop getting their economics information from the Pauls.
If you like these links, you'll love
The next best thing to UltraFark
Sign up for the Fark NotNewsletter!
Links are submitted by members of the Fark community.
When community members submit a link, they also write a custom headline for the story.
Other Farkers comment on the links. This is the number of comments. Click here to read them.
You need to create an account to submit links or post comments.
Click here to submit a link.
Also on Fark
Submit a Link »
Copyright © 1999 - 2017 Fark, Inc | Last updated: Nov 20 2017 10:44:42
Runtime: 0.153 sec (153 ms)