If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(YouTube)   Breaking news alert, Benjen Stark might be dead   (youtube.com) divider line 28
    More: Obvious, Benjen Stark, director of photography, narratives  
•       •       •

5067 clicks; posted to Video » on 19 Jun 2013 at 11:22 AM (1 year ago)   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»



28 Comments   (+0 »)
   
View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest

Archived thread
 
2013-06-19 10:24:19 AM  
What this is I don't even

Will it be in French?

Looks cool...
 
2013-06-19 10:29:51 AM  
SPOILER ALERT


I suspect Benjen is Coldhands.
 
2013-06-19 10:39:41 AM  
It's probably too late for Benjen to reappear in the books, unless there is some tie-in with Ricken
 
2013-06-19 10:46:43 AM  
RIP Iron Man
 
2013-06-19 11:14:18 AM  

StrikitRich: It's probably too late for Benjen to reappear in the books, unless there is some tie-in with Ricken


Benjen is the only one left who could tell Jon that his mother was Lyanna; that's why his body was never found.
 
2013-06-19 12:30:29 PM  

Because People in power are Stupid: StrikitRich: It's probably too late for Benjen to reappear in the books, unless there is some tie-in with Ricken

Benjen is the only one left who could tell Jon that his mother was Lyanna; that's why his body was never found.


Unless Howland Reed made his way to the Wall for some reason.
 
2013-06-19 12:52:31 PM  

Actual Farking: SPOILER ALERT


I suspect Benjen is Coldhands.


THIS
 
2013-06-19 12:54:59 PM  
This is fan fiction, in case people missed the caption.
 
2013-06-19 12:58:09 PM  

WI241TH: Unless Howland Reed made his way to the Wall for some reason.


Or told his kids.
 
2013-06-19 01:38:23 PM  

Steebin: Actual Farking: SPOILER ALERT


I suspect Benjen is Coldhands.

THIS


We have a winner!
/Strongly suspect this as well.
//and Lyanna is Jons mom
///and Rhaegar is his father
////FINISH THE DAMNED BOOKS ALREADY
 
2013-06-19 01:46:24 PM  

Wicked Chinchilla: ////FINISH THE DAMNED BOOKS ALREADY


SHHH! DANGIT!

Haven't you heard the Martin quote? "Every time someone asks me when the next book is coming, I kill a Stark."
 
2013-06-19 01:58:19 PM  
This thread is a minefield; I'm reading the books for the first time right now.
 
2013-06-19 02:15:41 PM  
Wicked Chinchilla:
//and Lyanna is Jons mom
///and Rhaegar is his father
////FINISH THE DAMNED BOOKS ALREADY


Pretty much the universal thought.
 
2013-06-19 02:16:41 PM  

unlikely: Wicked Chinchilla: ////FINISH THE DAMNED BOOKS ALREADY

SHHH! DANGIT!

Haven't you heard the Martin quote? "Every time someone asks me when the next book is coming, I kill a Stark."


That can't be true because there would be no trace of Stark left in the world. He'd have to resurrect and kill them all multiple times.
 
2013-06-19 02:21:37 PM  

Because People in power are Stupid: StrikitRich: It's probably too late for Benjen to reappear in the books, unless there is some tie-in with Ricken

Benjen is the only one left who could tell Jon that his mother was Lyanna; that's why his body was never found.


Ah Coldhands!! Why didn't I remember him?


Anyone wonder about the old black glass communication device Sam was shown at The Citadel?  If there is old technology still lying about, what other devices might show up?
 
2013-06-19 03:39:37 PM  

StrikitRich: Because People in power are Stupid: StrikitRich: It's probably too late for Benjen to reappear in the books, unless there is some tie-in with Ricken

Benjen is the only one left who could tell Jon that his mother was Lyanna; that's why his body was never found.

Ah Coldhands!! Why didn't I remember him?


Anyone wonder about the old black glass communication device Sam was shown at The Citadel?  If there is old technology still lying about, what other devices might show up?


www.johnbiver.com
 
2013-06-19 04:17:08 PM  

Actual Farking: SPOILER ALERT


I suspect Benjen is Coldhands.


When Coldhands first showed up, after the description of him my mind immediately went to Benjen.

I'm not so sure if it will turn out to be him now though.  I heard that he isn't in the series at all.  I would have thought the producers would have put him in if it was going to turn out to be Benjen.  But that's just my theory and I could easily be wrong.
 
2013-06-19 04:30:34 PM  
If Benjen was coldhands, wouldnt Bran know him? Then again that would explain the reason why he trusts him?
 
2013-06-19 04:34:24 PM  
Benjen Stark and Syrio Forel are currently in hiding in a two-man horse costume, masquerading as Sandor Clegane's steed.
 
2013-06-19 04:47:24 PM  
RIP BENJY BRONK!
cdn2-b.examiner.com
 
2013-06-19 05:29:18 PM  

Cagey B: Benjen Stark and Syrio Forel are currently in hiding in a two-man horse costume, masquerading as Sandor Clegane's steed.


lolol
 
2013-06-19 05:35:28 PM  

The sound of one hand clapping: Actual Farking: SPOILER ALERT


I suspect Benjen is Coldhands.

When Coldhands first showed up, after the description of him my mind immediately went to Benjen.

I'm not so sure if it will turn out to be him now though.  I heard that he isn't in the series at all.  I would have thought the producers would have put him in if it was going to turn out to be Benjen.  But that's just my theory and I could easily be wrong.


Doesn't Coldhands always keep his face covered? And Benjen was definitely in the first few episodes of the tv series. As you said, we could both be wrong, but I had your exact reaction when I read the books.
 
2013-06-19 05:41:32 PM  

Actual Farking: The sound of one hand clapping: Actual Farking: SPOILER ALERT


I suspect Benjen is Coldhands.

When Coldhands first showed up, after the description of him my mind immediately went to Benjen.

I'm not so sure if it will turn out to be him now though.  I heard that he isn't in the series at all.  I would have thought the producers would have put him in if it was going to turn out to be Benjen.  But that's just my theory and I could easily be wrong.

Doesn't Coldhands always keep his face covered? And Benjen was definitely in the first few episodes of the tv series. As you said, we could both be wrong, but I had your exact reaction when I read the books.


Sorry, I worded that really badly.  I meant that Coldhands is apparently not in the series (can't vouch for this 100% as I've only seen the first 2 seasons).  Indeed Benjen was in the first few eps.  And yes, I believe that Coldhands does keep his face covered.  My reaction just came from knowing that he most likely was a crow (black clothes, black cloak) and a gut feeling that he was helping/protecting Bran due to a connection to him.

But now with no Coldhands in the series I'm not so sure.
 
2013-06-19 05:50:10 PM  

The sound of one hand clapping: Actual Farking: The sound of one hand clapping: Actual Farking: SPOILER ALERT


I suspect Benjen is Coldhands.

When Coldhands first showed up, after the description of him my mind immediately went to Benjen.

I'm not so sure if it will turn out to be him now though.  I heard that he isn't in the series at all.  I would have thought the producers would have put him in if it was going to turn out to be Benjen.  But that's just my theory and I could easily be wrong.

Doesn't Coldhands always keep his face covered? And Benjen was definitely in the first few episodes of the tv series. As you said, we could both be wrong, but I had your exact reaction when I read the books.

Sorry, I worded that really badly.  I meant that Coldhands is apparently not in the series (can't vouch for this 100% as I've only seen the first 2 seasons).  Indeed Benjen was in the first few eps.  And yes, I believe that Coldhands does keep his face covered.  My reaction just came from knowing that he most likely was a crow (black clothes, black cloak) and a gut feeling that he was helping/protecting Bran due to a connection to him.

But now with no Coldhands in the series I'm not so sure.


I see what you mean. I hope you're wrong because I would love to see how they make him look on the show.
 
2013-06-20 08:16:56 AM  

LavenderWolf: This thread is a minefield; I'm reading the books for the first time right now.


It's people. Soylent Green is made out of people!
 
2013-06-20 12:55:25 PM  
Coldhands is supposed to very old, as if dead for a long time. So...not Benjen.
 
2013-06-20 05:51:06 PM  

Mateorocks: Coldhands is supposed to very old, as if dead for a long time. So...not Benjen.


But how long is a long time?  By the time Bran meets Coldhands, hasn't it been like 2 years since Benjen disappeared?  I think Coldhands is Benjen Stark myself, but I also admit I base that on nothing more than my gut instinct.
 
2013-06-20 06:57:37 PM  

Actual Farking: SPOILER ALERT


I suspect Benjen is Coldhands.


That is exactly what I think as well. Just makes sense.
 
Displayed 28 of 28 comments

View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest


This thread is archived, and closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »
On Twitter





In Other Media


  1. Links are submitted by members of the Fark community.

  2. When community members submit a link, they also write a custom headline for the story.

  3. Other Farkers comment on the links. This is the number of comments. Click here to read them.

  4. Click here to submit a link.

Report