If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Guardian)   An insightful, thoughtful and very personal remembrance of Margaret Thatcher and "Thatcherism." The reason for the "unlikely" tag? It's written by Russell Brand   (guardian.co.uk) divider line 37
    More: Unlikely, Iron Lady, welfare fraud, social context  
•       •       •

1710 clicks; posted to Main » on 10 Apr 2013 at 11:13 AM   |  Favorite   |  Watch    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»   |    Get this fabulous T-Shirt and impress the methane out of your friends! shirt it!



37 Comments   (+0 »)
   
Log in (at the top of the page) to enable voting.
View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest
 
  2013-04-10 09:42:38 AM
that was a good read. though i find him annoying, i've always thought that brand was quite brilliant.
 
  2013-04-10 10:02:17 AM
I read this yesterday and found it to be the best article on her death thus far. Shocking given that he seems like such a crass jackass whenever you see him.
 
  2013-04-10 10:51:09 AM
Irving Maimway: I read this yesterday and found it to be the best article on her death thus far. Shocking given that he seems like such a crass jackass whenever you see him.

It's just that: he's not actually that much of a jackass.  He's brilliant.  He's just chosen a different way to entertain himself (first drugs and sex, then just sex, now apparently a bit of both) that shapes his expression towards the comical instead of straightforward.  His success as a writer and comedian - and don't forget how successful his books are - has enabled him to embrace that entertainment without reserve.

Yet he's still brilliant.

Comedians, at their best, are insightful.  Sometimes it's situational ("Whats the deal with...") and other times it's just wonderful absurdism ("I know what you're thinking, 'Steve, when do YOU find time to juggle?'") but it's always about seeing something just outside the normal field of view.
 
  2013-04-10 10:54:18 AM
mattharvest:

Comedians, at their best, are insightful.  Sometimes it's situational ("Whats the deal with...") and other times it's just wonderful absurdism ("I know what you're thinking, 'Steve, when do YOU find time to juggle?'") but it's always about seeing something just outside the normal field of view.

This is totally true. Bill Murray and Adam Sandler come to mind as comedians or comedic actors who have done their best work in dramatic parts.

I've never read any of Brand's books, but I'll put him on my list.
 
  2013-04-10 11:11:06 AM
He does repeat the myth that Margaret Thatcher "declared war on the unions".  In the UK in the seventies and early eighties the unions were open about them using their power to bring down governments or force them to do their bidding no matter what the country at large wanted. They declared war first, and openly. Maggie was the first leader to have the balls to stand up to them.
She didn't declare war. It was self defence, and the UK benefited hugely from her time.
From being totally written off as a country in the seventies to having an economy so strong that when Blair came to power he kept to the spending plans of Major and coasted on the economic success of the Conservatives.
 
  2013-04-10 11:25:21 AM
He admits he has made bad decisions all his life, but he is better now and he is telling us the only reason he didn't go on a killing spree is because he didn't play video games.

Well I'm convinced.
 
  2013-04-10 11:25:35 AM
Flint Ironstag: He does repeat the myth that Margaret Thatcher "declared war on the unions".  In the UK in the seventies and early eighties the unions were open about them using their power to bring down governments or force them to do their bidding no matter what the country at large wanted. They declared war first, and openly. Maggie was the first leader to have the balls to stand up to them.
She didn't declare war. It was self defence, and the UK benefited hugely from her time.
From being totally written off as a country in the seventies to having an economy so strong that when Blair came to power he kept to the spending plans of Major and coasted on the economic success of the Conservatives.


This

When she took office unemployment was 17%. When she left office 5%. This pissed off the Unions.

Unions. Another way of saying thug.
 
  2013-04-10 11:26:40 AM
And, I should attempt to post in the correct comment thread.
 
  2013-04-10 11:29:30 AM
Flint Ironstag: He does repeat the myth that Margaret Thatcher "declared war on the unions".  In the UK in the seventies and early eighties the unions were open about them using their power to bring down governments or force them to do their bidding no matter what the country at large wanted. They declared war first, and openly. Maggie was the first leader to have the balls to stand up to them.
She didn't declare war. It was self defence, and the UK benefited hugely from her time.
From being totally written off as a country in the seventies to having an economy so strong that when Blair came to power he kept to the spending plans of Major and coasted on the economic success of the Conservatives.



What many don't seem to remeber was that the UK was well on its way toward being a 3rd world economy before Thatcher became Prime Minister (they needed an IMF bailout).  Unions were part of the problem-not the whole problem but a large part of it.  Inefficient state owned busnesses like the coal mines (there was a world-wide coal glut) were another part.
 
  2013-04-10 11:30:01 AM
Clemkadidlefark: Flint Ironstag: He does repeat the myth that Margaret Thatcher "declared war on the unions".  In the UK in the seventies and early eighties the unions were open about them using their power to bring down governments or force them to do their bidding no matter what the country at large wanted. They declared war first, and openly. Maggie was the first leader to have the balls to stand up to them.
She didn't declare war. It was self defence, and the UK benefited hugely from her time.
From being totally written off as a country in the seventies to having an economy so strong that when Blair came to power he kept to the spending plans of Major and coasted on the economic success of the Conservatives.

This

When she took office unemployment was 17%. When she left office 5%. This pissed off the Unions.

Unions. Another way of saying thug.


And I'm sure you give President Obama credit for bringing down our unemployment rate, right?

...Right?
 
  2013-04-10 11:32:05 AM
Clemkadidlefark: Flint Ironstag: He does repeat the myth that Margaret Thatcher "declared war on the unions".  In the UK in the seventies and early eighties the unions were open about them using their power to bring down governments or force them to do their bidding no matter what the country at large wanted. They declared war first, and openly. Maggie was the first leader to have the balls to stand up to them.
She didn't declare war. It was self defence, and the UK benefited hugely from her time.
From being totally written off as a country in the seventies to having an economy so strong that when Blair came to power he kept to the spending plans of Major and coasted on the economic success of the Conservatives.

This

When she took office unemployment was 17%. When she left office 5%. This pissed off the Unions.

Unions. Another way of saying thug.


You know she jiggered that number by moving a large chunk of the "unemployed" to "disabled" right?
 
  2013-04-10 11:32:57 AM
That was indeed surprisingly eloquent, and an excellent read.  Thanks, Subby.
 
  2013-04-10 11:33:04 AM
Wendy's Chili: Clemkadidlefark: Flint Ironstag: He does repeat the myth that Margaret Thatcher "declared war on the unions".  In the UK in the seventies and early eighties the unions were open about them using their power to bring down governments or force them to do their bidding no matter what the country at large wanted. They declared war first, and openly. Maggie was the first leader to have the balls to stand up to them.
She didn't declare war. It was self defence, and the UK benefited hugely from her time.
From being totally written off as a country in the seventies to having an economy so strong that when Blair came to power he kept to the spending plans of Major and coasted on the economic success of the Conservatives.

This

When she took office unemployment was 17%. When she left office 5%. This pissed off the Unions.

Unions. Another way of saying thug.

And I'm sure you give President Obama credit for bringing down our unemployment rate, right?

...Right?


Also, somebody is going to have to explain to me how full employment is bad for union power?
 
  2013-04-10 11:38:16 AM
Clemkadidlefark: Flint Ironstag: He does repeat the myth that Margaret Thatcher "declared war on the unions".  In the UK in the seventies and early eighties the unions were open about them using their power to bring down governments or force them to do their bidding no matter what the country at large wanted. They declared war first, and openly. Maggie was the first leader to have the balls to stand up to them.
She didn't declare war. It was self defence, and the UK benefited hugely from her time.
From being totally written off as a country in the seventies to having an economy so strong that when Blair came to power he kept to the spending plans of Major and coasted on the economic success of the Conservatives.

This

When she took office unemployment was 17%. When she left office 5%. This pissed off the Unions.

Unions. Another way of saying thug.


I'm pretty sure this is an out and out lie (or misunderstanding). The rate was like 6% when she came to power, soared during her early premiership (peaking at 13.5% in 1983) and then fell back to close to what it had been at the beginning. Source:http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=5 &ved=0CE wQFjAE&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ons.gov.uk%2Fons%2Frel%2Flms%2Flabour-mark et-trends--discontinued-%2Fjanuary-1996%2Funemployment-since-1881.pdf& ei=3oVlUeTDPJGe8QSNvoC4Dw&usg=AFQjCNE9YcBw-O9uJCCTR2rrQre5Vg1hZw

So... yeah.
 
  2013-04-10 11:38:48 AM
Irving Maimway: Clemkadidlefark: Flint Ironstag: He does repeat the myth that Margaret Thatcher "declared war on the unions".  In the UK in the seventies and early eighties the unions were open about them using their power to bring down governments or force them to do their bidding no matter what the country at large wanted. They declared war first, and openly. Maggie was the first leader to have the balls to stand up to them.
She didn't declare war. It was self defence, and the UK benefited hugely from her time.
From being totally written off as a country in the seventies to having an economy so strong that when Blair came to power he kept to the spending plans of Major and coasted on the economic success of the Conservatives.

This

When she took office unemployment was 17%. When she left office 5%. This pissed off the Unions.

Unions. Another way of saying thug.

You know she jiggered that number by moving a large chunk of the "unemployed" to "disabled" right?


CBO: Record Number of Workers on Disability to Increase

Social Security Disability Increased by 5.4 Million Under Obama

A White House study found that more and more people have lost jobs, received unemployment benefits for as long as possible, and then received disability.
 
  2013-04-10 11:40:42 AM
Maggie Thatcher should have gone to Washington and given Congress some backbone lessons.

They could use it. . . . .
 
  2013-04-10 11:42:07 AM
Oh Russell, still seeing things with "a kid's memory" and living life carefree as if still a child you have no clue what it is like in the "real world."Russell has no clue as he has never had to want for anything EVER in his life. Even now he is where he is because of his mother make no mistake.

 Mrs. Thatcher increased spending on Law & Order, Employment & Training services, Health services and Social Security.

What pissed people off is she demanded able bodied people take advantage of the job training and get off the dole.

Someone has to work to keep things moving wake up Mr. Brand as you are nothing but the weight of a rock on society.
Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher was a rock star who will be remembered fondly way after you are returned to dust.
 
  2013-04-10 11:46:10 AM

czetie


Also, somebody is going to have to explain to me how full employment is bad for union power?


If unemployment is near-zero, the job applicants have some leverage as the employers will probably have difficulty filling open positions (since almost everyone will already be employed elsewhere). Applicants can then negotiate better deals and as a result have much less use for a union.

If unemployment is high, the employers hold the upper hand and can be very selective and force lower salaries. The union, through the leverage of collective bargaining, can still negotiate higher salaries with the employers when individuals cannot.

When unemployment is high people tend to seek union jobs because of this, and also because of the damn-near-impossible-to-get-fired nature of a union job.
 
  2013-04-10 11:49:52 AM
FlashHarry: that was a good read. though i find him annoying, i've always thought that brand was quite brilliant.

I don't think it was a good read at all his dissed her then just in-case there is back lash makes up for it at the end. It reads like the writing of a bipolar manic.
 
  2013-04-10 11:51:02 AM
"a voice-both boring and boring" describes both Thatcher and Brand perfectly.
 
  2013-04-10 12:00:21 PM
Dispelling the Thatcher myths

 And when the economy did pick up speed in the late 80s, it was because of a credit bubble that promptly burst and threw Britain back into recession.

It's said that Thatcher was a tax-cutter. She wasn't. The overall tax burden (all taxes as a percentage of GDP) rose from 39 percent in 1979 to 43 percent in 1989. It's true that Thatcher cut taxes massively for the rich - the top rate of tax was 83 percent when Thatcher came to power, and it was 40 percent when she left. But VAT, which hits the poor harder than the rich, was just 8 percent before Thatcher, and was put up to 15 percent as soon as she gained power.
 
  2013-04-10 12:10:08 PM
I can't articulate with the skill of either of "the Marks" - Steel or Thomas - why Thatcher and Thatcherism were so bad for Britain but I do recall that even to a child her demeanour and every discernible action seemed to be to the detriment of our national spirit and identity. Her refusal to stand against apartheid, her civil war against the unions, her aggression towards our neighbours in Ireland and a taxation system that was devised in the dark ages, the bombing of a retreating ship - it's just not British.

No Russel, it's very British. Read up on your own country's history.
 
  2013-04-10 12:10:09 PM
Neither liberalism nor conservatism left to their own devices are great for an economy.

State-owned businesses and over-staffed government enterprises are proven time and time again in pure economic math to be more inefficient than private-sector businesses.  The role of government is to provide services and complete projects that cannot be done in the private sector--NOT to be an employment agency.

At the same time decreasing income tax too low for the rich, while increasing VAT or sales taxes too high does hurt the poor and lower-middle classes disproportionately.

In these threads can we all admit some from one a some from the other is probably the best way to go?
 
  2013-04-10 12:12:53 PM
Just remember, if you danced and celebrated when Thatcher died you have proved that she was right about there being no compasionate society.

/Like most things in life the truth about her legacy is some where between the two ends of the debate.
 
  2013-04-10 12:13:22 PM
Flint Ironstag: He does repeat the myth that Margaret Thatcher "declared war on the unions".  In the UK in the seventies and early eighties the unions were open about them using their power to bring down governments or force them to do their bidding no matter what the country at large wanted. They declared war first, and openly. Maggie was the first leader to have the balls to stand up to them.
She didn't declare war. It was self defence, and the UK benefited hugely from her time.
From being totally written off as a country in the seventies to having an economy so strong that when Blair came to power he kept to the spending plans of Major and coasted on the economic success of the Conservatives.


All that North Sea oil had nothing to do with it then?
 
  2013-04-10 12:19:28 PM
The article was boring and boring.  I ignored the content. The intent was clear.
 
  2013-04-10 12:26:36 PM
Clemkadidlefark:
Unions. Another way of saying thug.


No.

Unfettered union power, like unfettered capitolism, is where the thugishness comes from.

We're seeing the latter currently in the US.

Was Thatcher correct in standing up to the unions the way she did?  Yes and no.  Yes, in standing up to the unions, but that doesn't mean that all the methods she used were sound.

Nor were all her other methods of dealing with groups she was opposed to all that spectacular.

Yes, it gave her a legacy, but it's not the kind of legacy that successors would want to be associated with, at least not and have a chance of success.   In much the same way that Republicans in the US don't strongly reference the policies of Bush II; they have to go back to Reagan for "good feelings / buy-in".
 
  2013-04-10 12:35:58 PM
czetie: Wendy's Chili: Clemkadidlefark: Flint Ironstag: He does repeat the myth that Margaret Thatcher "declared war on the unions".  In the UK in the seventies and early eighties the unions were open about them using their power to bring down governments or force them to do their bidding no matter what the country at large wanted. They declared war first, and openly. Maggie was the first leader to have the balls to stand up to them.
She didn't declare war. It was self defence, and the UK benefited hugely from her time.
From being totally written off as a country in the seventies to having an economy so strong that when Blair came to power he kept to the spending plans of Major and coasted on the economic success of the Conservatives.

This

When she took office unemployment was 17%. When she left office 5%. This pissed off the Unions.

Unions. Another way of saying thug.

And I'm sure you give President Obama credit for bringing down our unemployment rate, right?

...Right?

Also, somebody is going to have to explain to me how full employment is bad for union power?


Because unions can use the threat of unemployement, and the lack of any alternative jobs, to boost their own power. If there are plenty of jobs then people can just walk away from a union they don't like and go work elsewhere. And the unions don't have any "threat" to scare their members with to support taking action.
 
  2013-04-10 12:59:00 PM
Well, THAT was.... boring.
 
  2013-04-10 01:03:45 PM
I thought the necrology by Ian McEwan was much better. Russell Brand IMHO uses too many multi-syllable words for the very sake of it, and McEwan puts some finer opposite viewpoints in there as well.
 
  2013-04-10 01:10:52 PM
That was intelligent and well written. Brand is a smart guy. The link below is him riffing, off the top of his head, about his character in The Tempest:

http://youtu.be/aBOMSzhIfjk
 
  2013-04-10 01:19:23 PM
tl;dr version:  I was too young to follow politics, but she seemed very stern.
 
  2013-04-10 01:50:11 PM
Perhaps the most insightful part of the article "I know from my own indulgence in selfish behaviour that it's much easier to get what you want if you remove from consideration the effect your actions will have on others."
 
  2013-04-10 02:41:00 PM
Thatcher's dead.  Good riddance.

http://www.anphoblacht.com/contents/22919
 
  2013-04-10 02:51:36 PM
KimNorth:  Mrs. Thatcher increased spending on Law & Order,


Awesome! I LOVE those shows!
 
  2013-04-10 02:54:21 PM
Hey now, I guess Russell's ok with me then. He's a good writer at any rate. Sure as hell better than the link below this one.
 
  2013-04-10 02:58:49 PM
RIP Margaret Thatcher.

She was real and spectacular.
 
Displayed 37 of 37 comments

Log in (at the top of the page) to enable voting.
View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest

 
   Forgot password? Create an account to make comments
  Remember me Use HTML Buttons
If you can see this, something's wrong with your browser's CSS support.
 
Before posting, please take a minute to review our posting rules and our legal/privacy policy.
By posting, you agree to these terms.
Got questions about Fark? See our FAQ.
Notify moderators about this thread
(comment-related issues: posting rule violations, etc.)
...or Notify admins about this link
(link/headline related issues: bad link, bad headline, repeats, etc.)
If you are about to post a question that requires an answer from us, use Farkback instead.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »





Report