Do you have adblock enabled?
 
If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(The Roosevelts)   The top five comic books you should be reading, written by a woman who knows these things   (rsvlts.com ) divider line
    More: Cool, comics, Garth Ennis, IDW  
•       •       •

5200 clicks; posted to Geek » on 30 Mar 2013 at 12:30 AM (3 years ago)   |   Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»



89 Comments     (+0 »)
 
View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest
 
2013-03-30 12:42:53 AM  
"Five Comics My Boyfriend Told Me Were Good"
 
2013-03-30 12:44:11 AM  

Nina_Hartley's_Ass: "Five Comics My Boyfriend Told Me Were Good"


Done in one.
 
2013-03-30 12:59:17 AM  
Old news is so exciting said no one ever.
 
2013-03-30 12:59:56 AM  
What's the deal with 5?
The list has Superheroes/supernatural stuff and then something about "two women experiencing life" or some crap.
What did they pay for this greenlight?  (and they definitely paid to even have their own icon suddenly)

Lord of the Rings
X-Men
Star Wars
The Golden Girls
Alien
 
2013-03-30 01:11:46 AM  
Someone recommended Preacher to me, so I gave it a chance.  This is what I remember of it:  a guy getting his dick chopped off, someone getting shiat smeared on his face, vomit, a disgustingly obese man, that obese man getting shiat smeared on his face, someone else getting their dick ripped off, vomit, disembowelment, a guy getting his jaw blown off, a guy being forced to wipe another man's ass, homosexual rape and another guy getting his dick ripped off and having it replaced with a spigot for comedic effect.

No other comic I've read comes anywhere close to being so vile.  Preacher is a disgustingly irredeemable comic book, and Warren Ellis has issues.
 
2013-03-30 01:15:49 AM  
upload.wikimedia.org
 
2013-03-30 01:23:24 AM  
east of west is off to a great first ish, ill pick up a second
helheim as well, but ive yet to see issue 2 and i think its been over a month

marvels age of ultron falls completely flat imho, im pretty pissed.  virtually nothing has happened in the first 3 issues, how much longer can they stretch no story out?
 
2013-03-30 01:25:03 AM  

http://24.media.tumblr.com/0beae860c94aed59f79e6ee59f8fab64/tumblr_m j 0 hz98ZOK1rkxcqho1_500.jpg

24.media.tumblr.com

Knows of one graphic novel you should NOT be reading...

 
2013-03-30 01:29:52 AM  
Wow.
You mean "Five comics you should've read."

Y'know. When they were new.
 
2013-03-30 01:32:38 AM  
What is this, 1995?  Yes, they were all great series, but it's 2013 and pretty damn awesome here.

Saga
Walking Dead
DMZ
Hawkeye (Matt Fraction's series)
Shanower/Young's Oz adaptations
Witch Doctor

And on like that for a while.
 
2013-03-30 01:35:53 AM  
List is not complete without Transmetropolitan and The Boys
 
2013-03-30 01:40:17 AM  
that list was so cliche im surprised there wasn't Dark Knight Returns
 
2013-03-30 01:48:38 AM  

Baron Harkonnen: Preacher is a disgustingly irredeemable comic book


If that's all you remember, then, uh yeah, good luck with that.

\needs more gun
\\BURN YOU farkERS
\\\why don't you bastards ever write?
 
2013-03-30 01:58:22 AM  
Worst "Paid for" Fark link ever? No, not in a world whereWampler exists.
 
2013-03-30 02:17:14 AM  

Baron Harkonnen: Someone recommended Preacher to me, so I gave it a chance.  This is what I remember of it:  a guy getting his dick chopped off, someone getting shiat smeared on his face, vomit, a disgustingly obese man, that obese man getting shiat smeared on his face, someone else getting their dick ripped off, vomit, disembowelment, a guy getting his jaw blown off, a guy being forced to wipe another man's ass, homosexual rape and another guy getting his dick ripped off and having it replaced with a spigot for comedic effect.

No other comic I've read comes anywhere close to being so vile.  Preacher is a disgustingly irredeemable comic book, and Warren Ellis has issues.


I liked it too! Isn't it great?!
 
2013-03-30 02:23:13 AM  

Baron Harkonnen: Someone recommended Preacher to me, so I gave it a chance.  This is what I remember of it:  a guy getting his dick chopped off, someone getting shiat smeared on his face, vomit, a disgustingly obese man, that obese man getting shiat smeared on his face, someone else getting their dick ripped off, vomit, disembowelment, a guy getting his jaw blown off, a guy being forced to wipe another man's ass, homosexual rape and another guy getting his dick ripped off and having it replaced with a spigot for comedic effect.

No other comic I've read comes anywhere close to being so vile.  Preacher is a disgustingly irredeemable comic book, and Warren Ellis has issues.


Warren Ellis didn't do Preacher.
 
2013-03-30 02:26:44 AM  
All of the comics in TFA are 10 years old or older. If you want something current, Saga is freakin' amazing.

ifanboy.com

Albeit pretty farking weird.

Baron Harkonnen: Preacher is a disgustingly irredeemable comic book, and Warren Ellis has issues


You mean Garth Ennis. Warren Ellis wrote other, even more wonderfully vile comic books.
 
2013-03-30 02:28:57 AM  

Baron Harkonnen: Warren Ellis


Almost got me.
 
2013-03-30 02:34:34 AM  
No Cerebus, or at least Jaka's story or High Society. What a surprise.
 
2013-03-30 02:51:07 AM  
Baron Harkonnen: Preacher is a disgustingly irredeemable comic book, and Warren Ellis Garth Ennis has issues.
FTFY

Hitman was pretty fun
 
2013-03-30 02:56:06 AM  
should be looking at, reading is something a bit different.
 
2013-03-30 02:56:19 AM  
With a name like that, I thought this would be all indie stuff I've never heard of. A try to initiate us to some lesser known stuff. I haven't purchased a comic in over a decade and I've at least heard of all of those.

If you're doing a list like that, where the hell is Sandman? WHAR????!
 
2013-03-30 03:01:37 AM  
upload.wikimedia.org

/always lots to love when it comes to comics!
 
2013-03-30 03:12:48 AM  
I never understood the love for "Preacher". It tries to hard to be "edgy". And I mean that in the most obnoxious, marketing-driven sense of the word.

Warren Ellis is the best, though. It's too bad he never properly finishes anything.

/really wish "Desolation Jones" had kept going
 
2013-03-30 03:27:07 AM  

Bamboozler: List is not complete without Transmetropolitan and The Boys


Agreed.

Baron Harkonnen: Someone recommended Preacher to me, so I gave it a chance.  This is what I remember of it:  a guy getting his dick chopped off, someone getting shiat smeared on his face, vomit, a disgustingly obese man, that obese man getting shiat smeared on his face, someone else getting their dick ripped off, vomit, disembowelment, a guy getting his jaw blown off, a guy being forced to wipe another man's ass, homosexual rape and another guy getting his dick ripped off and having it replaced with a spigot for comedic effect.

No other comic I've read comes anywhere close to being so vile.  Preacher is a disgustingly irredeemable comic book, and Warren Ellis has issues.


Well, probably, but what does he have to do with Preacher?
 
2013-03-30 03:29:11 AM  
Also, list fails without Sandman.
 
2013-03-30 03:40:58 AM  

realmolo: I never understood the love for "Preacher". It tries to hard to be "edgy". And I mean that in the most obnoxious, marketing-driven sense of the word.

Warren Ellis is the best, though. It's too bad he never properly finishes anything.

/really wish "Desolation Jones" had kept going


At least Fell is starting up again.
 
2013-03-30 03:51:20 AM  
Crap, I know who both of them are, and had a brain fart moment.  I meant to say Garth Ennis.  I screwed that up, and it kind of ruined my point for me.

I wasn't trolling.  That's really my opinion.  I know that a lot of people like Preacher.  I don't know how they can stomach that kind of stuff.  I know there's an adventure story going on there, and some cool and interesting characters at the heart of it, but they're at the bottom of a huge pile of shiat, blood, vomit, pus, severed penises and ripped intestines.  I'm not digging thru that.  I don't think it's sanctimonious to point out that Ennis made the whole comic as gross and disgusting as he possibly could, and did a damned fine job of it.  Now, if you're into that sort of thing, fine, I, but what really bugs me about Preacher is that it somehow has this fantastic reputation when it's nothing more than an extended geek show designed to gross out the reader.  A well-written geek show, true, but a geek show.
 
2013-03-30 04:07:58 AM  
Count me amongst the people who couldn't get into Preacher. After hearing so much about it over the years I gave it a shot, but lost all interest around issue 25 or so, having gotten increasingly bored with it. It just seemed hokey. A combination of it possibly being dated badly and Ennis trying too hard to be shocking.

So then I tried The Boys, with major reservations. I liked that much better, even though it also has pĺenty of over-the-top Ennis. It wasn't some vital piece of literature told with pictures, but it was entertaining enough, despite the fact that I never liked the protagonist at all.
 
2013-03-30 04:08:05 AM  

Knobbs: If you're doing a list like that, where the hell is Sandman? WHAR????!

 
2013-03-30 04:22:22 AM  

realmolo: Warren Ellis is the best, though. It's too bad he never properly finishes anything.

/really wish "Desolation Jones" had kept going


Ditto for "Fell".
 
2013-03-30 04:40:21 AM  

Knobbs: With a name like that, I thought this would be all indie stuff I've never heard of. A try to initiate us to some lesser known stuff. I haven't purchased a comic in over a decade and I've at least heard of all of those.

If you're doing a list like that, where the hell is Sandman? WHAR????!


It's over in the corner listening to My Chemical Romance and cutting itself because it wasn't on the list.
 
2013-03-30 04:47:28 AM  
3.bp.blogspot.com

Just sayin'.
 
2013-03-30 04:49:41 AM  

Baron Harkonnen: Crap, I know who both of them are, and had a brain fart moment.  I meant to say Garth Ennis.  I screwed that up, and it kind of ruined my point for me.

I wasn't trolling.  That's really my opinion.  I know that a lot of people like Preacher.  I don't know how they can stomach that kind of stuff.  I know there's an adventure story going on there, and some cool and interesting characters at the heart of it, but they're at the bottom of a huge pile of shiat, blood, vomit, pus, severed penises and ripped intestines.  I'm not digging thru that.  I don't think it's sanctimonious to point out that Ennis made the whole comic as gross and disgusting as he possibly could, and did a damned fine job of it.  Now, if you're into that sort of thing, fine, I, but what really bugs me about Preacher is that it somehow has this fantastic reputation when it's nothing more than an extended geek show designed to gross out the reader.  A well-written geek show, true, but a geek show.


Television's going down the same road. I can't watch most of it anymore, not while wincing.
 
2013-03-30 07:05:31 AM  
As others have said, that list is pretty much 1995 all over again.

Want some modern stuff?

Saga
The Massive
Hawkeye
Deadpool Killistrated
Batman (yes, it's been good)
Adventure Time
The new relaunch of the Valiant books (Shadowman, Archer & Armstrong, Bloodshot, X-O Manowar and Harbinger are all solid)
 
2013-03-30 07:21:33 AM  

Dog Welder: As others have said, that list is pretty much 1995 all over again.

Want some modern stuff?

Saga
The Massive
Hawkeye
Deadpool Killistrated
Batman (yes, it's been good)
Adventure Time
The new relaunch of the Valiant books (Shadowman, Archer & Armstrong, Bloodshot, X-O Manowar and Harbinger are all solid)


Oh no, fark NuValiant.

Any company planning on rebooting Quantum and Woody without Christopher Priest and MD Bright, and rastifying the characters for the new millennium and making them brothers can go straight to hell.
 
2013-03-30 07:34:19 AM  

FirstNationalBastard: Any company planning on rebooting Quantum and Woody without Christopher Priest and MD Bright, and rastifying the characters for the new millennium and making them brothers can go straight to hell.


Yeah, not sure I'm happy about that one, either.  But that doesn't mean their other books haven't been good.
 
2013-03-30 07:50:02 AM  

Dog Welder: FirstNationalBastard: Any company planning on rebooting Quantum and Woody without Christopher Priest and MD Bright, and rastifying the characters for the new millennium and making them brothers can go straight to hell.

Yeah, not sure I'm happy about that one, either.  But that doesn't mean their other books haven't been good.


That is true.

But Quantum and Woody? That book was Priest and Bright. It was essentially creator-owned. To do it without them is like doing Watchmen without Alan Moore.

/and considering Acclaim screwed the creators out of the characters, that makes it even worse.
 
2013-03-30 08:11:57 AM  

FirstNationalBastard: Dog Welder: FirstNationalBastard: Any company planning on rebooting Quantum and Woody without Christopher Priest and MD Bright, and rastifying the characters for the new millennium and making them brothers can go straight to hell.

Yeah, not sure I'm happy about that one, either.  But that doesn't mean their other books haven't been good.

That is true.

But Quantum and Woody? That book was Priest and Bright. It was essentially creator-owned. To do it without them is like doing Watchmen without Alan Moore.

/and considering Acclaim screwed the creators out of the characters, that makes it even worse.


I'm wondering if we'll see a Trinity Angels books without Kevin Maguire.  He'll be PISSED if that happens.
 
2013-03-30 08:26:11 AM  

lewismarktwo: http://24.media.tumblr.com/0beae860c94aed59f79e6ee59f8fab64/tumblr_m j 0 hz98ZOK1rkxcqho1_500.jpg[24.media.tumblr.com image 500x302]Knows of one graphic novel you should NOT be reading...


Where is Jessica Hyde?
 
2013-03-30 08:35:05 AM  
WTF is up with this list?

Yes, list definitely fails without Transmetropolitan, but no consideration for:

upload.wikimedia.org

I mean, the place is populated by women, dealing with their grief over the loss of all males everywhere.  The comic series is loved by both sexes, and she didn't pick this one?!

/still waiting for a movie trilogy to come out for this one...
 
2013-03-30 08:37:35 AM  

blue_2501: WTF is up with this list?

Yes, list definitely fails without Transmetropolitan, but no consideration for:

[upload.wikimedia.org image 250x388]

I mean, the place is populated by women, dealing with their grief over the loss of all males everywhere.  The comic series is loved by both sexes, and she didn't pick this one?!

/still waiting for a movie trilogy to come out for this one...


If it were any company other than DC, Preacher, Transmetropolitan, and Y: The Last Man would already have been developed for live action, and Fables would have been on one of the networks instead of Grimm or Once Upon A Time.

But for the most part, WBDC really sucks at developing their properties into successful movies or TV shows, unless the main character has bat ears.
 
2013-03-30 08:43:24 AM  

albuquerquehalsey: No Cerebus, or at least Jaka's story or High Society. What a surprise.


Cerebus before Dave Sim went insane was really good. That's what happens when you stop smoking pot, though.

/and she left out Transmetropolitan
 
2013-03-30 08:46:15 AM  
Could they even make a movie, or perhaps an HBO series, out of Transmetropolitan?  Maybe there aren't enough drugs in the world to pull it off.
 
2013-03-30 08:48:11 AM  

quatchi: Just sayin'.


SPOILERS AHEAD

I think Fone Bone should have stayed with Thorn. It didn't seem right that they went through all that together and he just takes off.
 
2013-03-30 08:54:15 AM  

Lady Beryl Ersatz-Wendigo: Could they even make a movie, or perhaps an HBO series, out of Transmetropolitan?  Maybe there aren't enough drugs in the world to pull it off.


About a decade or so ago, Patrick Stewart wanted to star as Spider Jerusalem.
 
2013-03-30 08:54:39 AM  
"Should be reading" definitely applies to things that are running or releasing  now. You shouldn't  be reading "The Watchmen", you should  have read "The Watchmen".

Dog Welder: Saga


"Saga" is one of my "looks forward to" books every month. "Chew" and "Skullkickers" are also high up on the list.
 
2013-03-30 08:56:15 AM  

FirstNationalBastard: About a decade or so ago, Patrick Stewart wanted to star as Spider Jerusalem.


Which I still don't really see working. Given his work on  Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, Johnny Depp would have made a better Spider.
 
2013-03-30 09:53:39 AM  
Damnit woman, I don't have time to waste on fanciful comic book adventure stories; I'm too busy in the kitchen.
 
2013-03-30 10:00:18 AM  

Cagey B: Baron Harkonnen: Someone recommended Preacher to me, so I gave it a chance.  This is what I remember of it:  a guy getting his dick chopped off, someone getting shiat smeared on his face, vomit, a disgustingly obese man, that obese man getting shiat smeared on his face, someone else getting their dick ripped off, vomit, disembowelment, a guy getting his jaw blown off, a guy being forced to wipe another man's ass, homosexual rape and another guy getting his dick ripped off and having it replaced with a spigot for comedic effect.

No other comic I've read comes anywhere close to being so vile.  Preacher is a disgustingly irredeemable comic book, and Warren Ellis has issues.

Warren Ellis didn't do Preacher.


I was waiting for someone to point this out.
 
2013-03-30 10:04:58 AM  

cato113: Baron Harkonnen: Preacher is a disgustingly irredeemable comic book, and Warren Ellis Garth Ennis has issues.
FTFY

Hitman was pretty fun


Not just fun, but awesome. Hitman is one of my top three favorite series of all time, along with Sandman and Starman.

goodcomics.comicbookresources.com
 
2013-03-30 10:09:44 AM  
I agree with above poster that Y: The Last Man is one of the all-time greats.  After that, there's just not much, though Planetary was good.

\Watchmen is overrated, mostly because it is typical Alan Moore pretentiousness
 
2013-03-30 10:12:28 AM  
Fails without Transmetropolitan, 100 Bullets, and Powers.
 
2013-03-30 10:14:30 AM  
I'd like to have seen Atomic Robo on a best comics list, but I'm not sure it'll ever make a Top 5 or Top 10 as an independent.

/Same for Fables
 
2013-03-30 10:18:41 AM  
Baron Harkonnen:  I know there's an adventure story going on there

I always thought it was a love story.  Sure felt like it at the end.

Also, you forgot to mention the giant "woman" made out of meat products that the sad, shriveled old man would fark while yelling WORK THE SHAFT.

/were there really that many dicks chopped off?  The one that the dog got doesn't count.
 
2013-03-30 10:21:40 AM  

Bamboozler: List is not complete without Transmetropolitan and The Boys


Chick did put Druuna, Little Ego, and Crossing Midnight on there, so there's that.
 
2013-03-30 10:22:41 AM  

Lady Beryl Ersatz-Wendigo: Could they even make a movie, or perhaps an HBO series, out of Transmetropolitan?  Maybe there aren't enough drugs in the world to pull it off.


Once we get 3D printers good enough...
 
2013-03-30 10:24:03 AM  

Mulchpuppy: Baron Harkonnen:  I know there's an adventure story going on there

I always thought it was a love story.  Sure felt like it at the end.

Also, you forgot to mention the giant "woman" made out of meat products that the sad, shriveled old man would fark while yelling WORK THE SHAFT.

/were there really that many dicks chopped off?  The one that the dog got doesn't count.


Herr Starr lost his dick to the dog, Sheriff Root cut his dick off and shoved it up his ass, and Cassidy got his dick shot off by Frankie the Eunuch, whose dick was also cut off at some point in the past by mafia rivals.

Other lost body parts include Jesse's eye being bitten out by God, Herr Starr's leg was taken by the Chunt brothers, Arseface's face...
 
2013-03-30 10:27:50 AM  

cheezitmojo: I'd like to have seen Atomic Robo on a best comics list,


It doesn't belong there. It's good, but it's fluff.
 
2013-03-30 10:33:20 AM  

Mulchpuppy: I always thought it was a love story.  Sure felt like it at the end.


There was a lot of things Ennis threw into Preacher. Love story, Western, History Channel conspiracies, something something treatise on immortality... What can I say, he was young and drunk.
 
2013-03-30 10:56:41 AM  

Jim_Tressel's_O-Face: Mulchpuppy: I always thought it was a love story.  Sure felt like it at the end.

There was a lot of things Ennis threw into Preacher. Love story, Western, History Channel conspiracies, something something treatise on immortality... What can I say, he was young and drunk.


What's his excuse now?  I picked up a copy of The Boys a few weeks ago, and goddamn, the thing was just a few panels removed from being a porn/snuff comic.  No storyline that I could discern.  Just a large amount of books and slaughter.  It's very much a fanboy comic, and I think that's where Ennis resides in popularity: with the fanboys.

\even his Dredd stuff was excessive
\\Dredd!
 
2013-03-30 11:14:40 AM  

Banacek: Worst "Paid for" Fark link ever? No, not in a world whereWampler exists.


The darks days of Wampler appear to be in Fark's past. An experiment that was conceived in mediocrity and executed by thumbless trees.
 
2013-03-30 11:18:36 AM  
Anyone not reading Fables is really missing out.
 
2013-03-30 11:40:04 AM  

soporific: Anyone not reading Fables is really missing out.


Agreed.
 
2013-03-30 12:05:08 PM  

Dog Welder: As others have said, that list is pretty much 1995 all over again.

Want some modern stuff?

Saga
The Massive
Hawkeye
Deadpool Killistrated
Batman (yes, it's been good)
Adventure Time
The new relaunch of the Valiant books (Shadowman, Archer & Armstrong, Bloodshot, X-O Manowar and Harbinger are all solid)


Is deadpool killistrated really good? I'm a huge deadpool nerd, and really think cable and deadpool was one of the best books of the Last decade, but i was very disappointed with the series reboot post the whole Thor vs. Osborn thing. I just felt like they went too slapstick after spending years trying to make deadpool a semi-serious character.

I want to go back to the desperately trying to atone, but unable to through no fault of his own style of writing.
 
2013-03-30 12:13:42 PM  

soporific: Anyone not reading Fables is really missing out.


Did they finally get around to finishing it? I know there was a long period where they just stopped putting out new issues (after the big war, when boy blue was dead).

I used to read that religiously, though.
 
2013-03-30 12:23:26 PM  
HAWKEYE
AVENGERS
NEW AVENGERS
CAPTAIN AMERICA
FANTASTIC FOUR

Are they all Marvel? Yes. Because the Marvel Now stuff has been awesome!
 
2013-03-30 12:35:57 PM  
I haven't read Planetary or his X-Men, but everything I've read by Ellis (Ultimate Galactus Trilogy, Nextwave, Doom 2099, Invisibles) has been weapons-grade meh.
 
2013-03-30 12:36:19 PM  

whizbangthedirtfarmer: Jim_Tressel's_O-Face: Mulchpuppy: I always thought it was a love story.  Sure felt like it at the end.

There was a lot of things Ennis threw into Preacher. Love story, Western, History Channel conspiracies, something something treatise on immortality... What can I say, he was young and drunk.

What's his excuse now?  I picked up a copy of The Boys a few weeks ago, and goddamn, the thing was just a few panels removed from being a porn/snuff comic.  No storyline that I could discern.  Just a large amount of books and slaughter.  It's very much a fanboy comic, and I think that's where Ennis resides in popularity: with the fanboys.

\even his Dredd stuff was excessive
\\Dredd!


The Boys deconstructs the torture porn tendency of modern dark comics in an absurdly violent way to underscore what he's talking about.  It's Authority and Watchmen on acid and coke; Ennis just works in violence the way Pollack worked with paint splatters.  His two runs on The Punisher (Marvel Knights and MAX both) go to that - while the MK Punisher was too close to Preacher in slapstick tone, the MAX run goes again to his ability to research and present controversial stuff in very unavoidable ways.  His arc on the sex slave trade was horrifying.

Also:

Nina_Hartley's_Ass: "Five Comics My Boyfriend Told Me Were Good"


Get farked.
 
2013-03-30 12:39:28 PM  

Wendy's Chili: I haven't read Planetary or his X-Men, but everything I've read by Ellis (Ultimate Galactus Trilogy, Nextwave, Doom 2099, Invisibles) has been weapons-grade meh.


Invisibles was Grant Morrison during his "let's take a farkton of drugs and write" phase.
 
2013-03-30 12:58:22 PM  

Wendy's Chili: I haven't read Planetary or his X-Men, but everything I've read by Ellis (Ultimate Galactus Trilogy, Nextwave, Doom 2099, Invisibles) has been weapons-grade meh.


...

Not sure if trolling? You've got a great hodgepodge of Ellis and  Ennis mixed in there. And Nextwave was farking awesome. It healed America by beating people up.
 
2013-03-30 12:59:30 PM  

Baron Harkonnen: Crap, I know who both of them are, and had a brain fart moment.  I meant to say Garth Ennis.  I screwed that up, and it kind of ruined my point for me.

I wasn't trolling.  That's really my opinion.  I know that a lot of people like Preacher.  I don't know how they can stomach that kind of stuff.  I know there's an adventure story going on there, and some cool and interesting characters at the heart of it, but they're at the bottom of a huge pile of shiat, blood, vomit, pus, severed penises and ripped intestines.  I'm not digging thru that.  I don't think it's sanctimonious to point out that Ennis made the whole comic as gross and disgusting as he possibly could, and did a damned fine job of it.  Now, if you're into that sort of thing, fine, I, but what really bugs me about Preacher is that it somehow has this fantastic reputation when it's nothing more than an extended geek show designed to gross out the reader.  A well-written geek show, true, but a geek show.


Never read Crossed. It goes further than Preacher.
 
2013-03-30 01:01:10 PM  
Same difference. Ellis, Ennis, Morrison, and Whedon are all overrated.They're names thrown around by people who don't read comics.The best in the medium, imo, are Vaughn, Brubaker, Hickman, and Azzarello./Transmetropolitan was meh too.
 
2013-03-30 01:05:00 PM  
t3knomanser, which of those is by Ennis?
 
2013-03-30 01:12:33 PM  
"The Invisibles" was Morrison, so neither Ennis or Ellis. I got it in my head that it was Ennis. It's possible that Ellis has done an X-Men run at some point (who hasn't?), but it's Ennis who's well known for his turn at the helm. And I checked, so yes, Ellis is actually currently doing X-Men? Who knew?

Wendy's Chili: Ellis, Ennis, Morrison, and Whedon


I don't think this is untrue. I do have a soft spot for Ellis when he's at his most gonzo, but he seems to be saving that for novels, these days.

Wendy's Chili: Vaughn, Brubaker, Hickman, and Azzarello


Also not untrue.

Wendy's Chili: Transmetropolitan was meh too


Transmet is to the 90s what Watchmen was to the 80s. Neither has aged well.
 
2013-03-30 01:39:43 PM  

t3knomanser: Transmet is to the 90s what Watchmen was to the 80s. Neither has aged well.


Bullshiat.  I read them both 4-5 years ago.  The ending to Watchmen has aged quite a bit, which is why it was changed in the movie.  Transmet will always be awesome, though.
 
2013-03-30 01:45:51 PM  

The Martian Manhandler: cato113: Baron Harkonnen: Preacher is a disgustingly irredeemable comic book, and Warren Ellis Garth Ennis has issues.
FTFY

Hitman was pretty fun

Not just fun, but awesome. Hitman is one of my top three favorite series of all time, along with Sandman and Starman.

[goodcomics.comicbookresources.com image 643x680]


media.comicvine.com
 
2013-03-30 02:03:49 PM  

KhamanV: whizbangthedirtfarmer: Jim_Tressel's_O-Face: Mulchpuppy: I always thought it was a love story.  Sure felt like it at the end.

There was a lot of things Ennis threw into Preacher. Love story, Western, History Channel conspiracies, something something treatise on immortality... What can I say, he was young and drunk.

What's his excuse now?  I picked up a copy of The Boys a few weeks ago, and goddamn, the thing was just a few panels removed from being a porn/snuff comic.  No storyline that I could discern.  Just a large amount of books and slaughter.  It's very much a fanboy comic, and I think that's where Ennis resides in popularity: with the fanboys.

\even his Dredd stuff was excessive
\\Dredd!

The Boys deconstructs the torture porn tendency of modern dark comics in an absurdly violent way to underscore what he's talking about.  It's Authority and Watchmen on acid and coke; Ennis just works in violence the way Pollack worked with paint splatters.  His two runs on The Punisher (Marvel Knights and MAX both) go to that - while the MK Punisher was too close to Preacher in slapstick tone, the MAX run goes again to his ability to research and present controversial stuff in very unavoidable ways.  His arc on the sex slave trade was horrifying.

Also:

Nina_Hartley's_Ass: "Five Comics My Boyfriend Told Me Were Good"

Get farked.


I don't see that.  What I see is a guy being sensationalistic for the sake of being sensationalistic.  There's nothing but a full-hearted embrace of gore and sex in much of his work; the parody/critical element you claim to exist is simply not there.  Like I said after I saw the Dredd movie, there's a fine line between glorifying/fetishizing violence and criticizing/parodying it.  Ennis, like Dredd, crosses it.
 
2013-03-30 02:18:04 PM  

blue_2501: I read them both 4-5 years ago.


I read them both more recently. Neither really feels as strong or well executed as it did the first time I read them.
 
2013-03-30 02:39:54 PM  
I used to love comics. However, I can no longer abide by the idea of paying $4-5 for thirty pages of art and one page of text. I'll drop $9 on a 400-page novel instead.
 
2013-03-30 03:12:53 PM  

INeedAName: I used to love comics. However, I can no longer abide by the idea of paying $4-5 for thirty pages of art and one page of text. I'll drop $9 on a 400-page novel instead.


Yep.  I feel horrible buying a comic for 4.99 when I look at it for 15 minutes and then put it away for a few years.  If it is something I am DYING to have (which happens rarely), I'll buy the graphic novel.  Otherwise, I'll just Kindle a book and move on.
 
2013-03-30 04:06:07 PM  
www.westfieldcomicsetc.com

Also  Freak Angels by Warren Ellis and Paul Duffield, which is online in its entirety and totally free.
 
2013-03-30 04:49:55 PM  

t3knomanser: blue_2501: I read them both 4-5 years ago.

I read them both more recently. Neither really feels as strong or well executed as it did the first time I read them.


No, I read them for the first time 4-5 years ago.
 
2013-03-30 07:38:16 PM  

whizbangthedirtfarmer: I don't see that. What I see is a guy being sensationalistic for the sake of being sensationalistic.


I was once trying to explain to someone what a Garth Ennis book was like. The best I could come up with was to imagine a smug Irishman yelling "do I shock you?" in your face over and over and over again.

/No, Garth, you don't shock me.
 
2013-03-30 07:49:35 PM  
I liked this one if just for the talking communist monkey:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Filth_%28comics%29
 
2013-03-30 08:56:49 PM  
I liked Garth Ennis' work on Punisher Max, probably my fave take on him.

Also, where is the love for transformers more than meets the eye?
 
2013-03-30 11:36:38 PM  
If we're talking comics from the 90s, where is the love for Astro City?
 
2013-03-31 02:49:16 AM  

blue_2501: I mean, the place is populated by women, dealing with their grief over the loss of all males everywhere. The comic series is loved by both sexes, and she didn't pick this one?!


Funny you mention this one. I  picked up this comic because I kept seeing it on the shelves but it didn't really click until I saw this one woman engrossed in it on TTC subway that pushed me over the edge into actually picking it up and reading it.

Much to be said for "in-the-wild" sightings of comics-lovers making influence.
 
2013-04-01 10:53:35 AM  
Gunnerkrigg Court
Amelia Rules
Chi's Sweet New Home
Girl Genius
Bone
 
Great comics with storytelling, characterization, dialogue, and art.
 
/Yes, I do have children. They're a great excuse.
 
Displayed 89 of 89 comments

View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest

This thread is archived, and closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »
On Twitter






In Other Media


  1. Links are submitted by members of the Fark community.

  2. When community members submit a link, they also write a custom headline for the story.

  3. Other Farkers comment on the links. This is the number of comments. Click here to read them.

  4. Click here to submit a link.

Report