If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(The Laugh Button)   10 modern comedy albums that are already classics   (thelaughbutton.com) divider line 122
    More: Amusing  
•       •       •

9216 clicks; posted to Entertainment » on 12 Oct 2012 at 10:34 AM (1 year ago)   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»



122 Comments   (+0 »)
   
View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest

Archived thread
 
2012-10-12 10:07:21 AM
Okay, since I'm not clicking through their shiatty, slow-ass slideshow, I'm going by the image on the first page...

Anything with Dane Cook fails.

Also, Patton Oswalt's Feelin' Kinda Patton/222 is infinitely funnier than Lollipops and Werewolves. The only thing Lollipops had was the KFC bit. All the great material was on his first album.
 
2012-10-12 10:12:51 AM

FirstNationalBastard: Okay, since I'm not clicking through their shiatty, slow-ass slideshow


Yeah, the page froze on me. So I'm assuming that Eddie Izzard's "Dressed to Kill" is not there and the list therefore fails in spectacular fashion.
 
2012-10-12 10:14:33 AM
No road trip is complete without "Skanks for the Memories".
 
2012-10-12 10:29:39 AM

FirstNationalBastard: Anything with Dane Cook fails.

 
2012-10-12 10:38:42 AM
Who buys these? Once you have heard a joke do you really need to hear it again, especially to the point that you feel compelled to own it so you can hear it whenever you want? Music I get buying but the allure of comedy albums always escaped me.
 
2012-10-12 10:41:17 AM
shop.linncoweb.net

LIST. FAILS.
 
2012-10-12 10:42:03 AM
i actually tried to look at those things but apparently that website is driving with the e-brake on.
 
2012-10-12 10:42:54 AM
Will any of those albums let me get small?
 
2012-10-12 10:43:41 AM

FirstNationalBastard: Patton Oswalt's Feelin' Kinda Patton


That album is awesome.

upload.wikimedia.org

Another goodie
 
2012-10-12 10:46:15 AM
Also, a great 1-2 punch...

www.popstarsplus.com

oldies.s3.amazonaws.com
 
2012-10-12 10:46:42 AM

OtherBrotherDarryl: FirstNationalBastard: Anything with Dane Cook fails.

 
2012-10-12 10:48:36 AM

titwrench: Who buys these? Once you have heard a joke do you really need to hear it again, especially to the point that you feel compelled to own it so you can hear it whenever you want? Music I get buying but the allure of comedy albums always escaped me.


In the dark days before the internet, comedy central, and 35 HBO and Showtime channels if you wanted to hear a comedian you had to buy the album. I haven't bought one since about 1999 but I did buy a lot back in the day.
 
2012-10-12 10:51:23 AM
Does it mention Lewis Black at all? If not, laugh button can EABOD.
 
2012-10-12 10:51:26 AM
List Fails Without:

cdn.hmvdigital.com
 
2012-10-12 10:51:51 AM
Mitch Hedberg...taken from us too soon
 
2012-10-12 10:53:02 AM

titwrench: Who buys these? Once you have heard a joke do you really need to hear it again, especially to the point that you feel compelled to own it so you can hear it whenever you want? Music I get buying but the allure of comedy albums always escaped me.


My favorites make me laugh every time I listen. Maybe I'm just simple :P
 
2012-10-12 10:53:35 AM

Chabash: Does it mention Lewis Black at all? If not, laugh button can EABOD.


I withdraw my previous statement. Lewis Black is included.
 
2012-10-12 10:53:46 AM
images.bluebeat.com

Thought this one was pretty good too.
 
2012-10-12 10:54:25 AM
Dane Cook? Really? I think they just put that one in there to fark with us.

titwrench

"Who buys these? Once you have heard a joke do you really need to hear it again, especially to the point that you feel compelled to own it so you can hear it whenever you want? Music I get buying but the allure of comedy albums always escaped me."

You'd think that would be the case, wouldn't you? I suppose it's the same as watching a rerun of a favorite sitcom. I usually shelve my comedy albums for a couple of years 'til I forget them & give them another listen when they're semi-fresh again.
 
2012-10-12 10:55:23 AM
List Fails without

farm3.staticflickr.com
 
2012-10-12 10:56:08 AM
If you're going to write a bit about an amazing album, maybe you should listen to the farking album first so you don't misquote it. How hard is it to get a single line right, especially when you can go on youtube and download him actually saying the line on primetime television in like 30 seconds?

Your slideshow is bad and you should feel bad, and I hope you skate into an aids tree.
 
2012-10-12 10:56:19 AM

Burr: Mitch Hedberg...taken from us too soon


i.ytimg.com
 
2012-10-12 10:57:32 AM

GibbyTheMole: Dane Cook? Really? I think they just put that one in there to fark with us.


I liked that album when it came out.
 
2012-10-12 10:58:22 AM
If you have Netflix, you should watch this:

1.bp.blogspot.com
 
2012-10-12 11:03:07 AM
fark your farking slideshow.


Dave Attell - Skanks For The Memories (2003)
[Skanks For The Memories] Let's just go on record to say that Dave Attell might be one of the most mimicked comedians out there. His mannerisms and style resonate so well with people that you almost can't help but subliminally pick up on them.

Skanks For The Memories was an instant classic upon it's release as it captured Attell's razor-sharp wit, observations, and terrific ability to take any left of center idea and make it downright hilarious. Attell owns crowds and can take them on any journey he wants.

Though he's worked on a ton of projects in the decade since Skanks' release, Attell has yet to release a proper follow-up album. Rumor has it he's yet to like anything he's recorded since. If this is true he's probably harder on himself than any of his fans ever could be. But if there were a tortured genius in comedy Attell would probably be it



Mitch Hedberg - Mitch All Together (2003)
[Mitch All Together] The legend of Mitch Hedberg has only grown since his untimely death in 2005. A large part of this lore comes from Mitch All Together. His first album, Strategic Grill Locations was a terrific outing of the young comedian showing off his witty relaxed attitude and sometimes scatterbrained thoughts as a bass player rocked out smooth jazz to accentuate the one-liners.

However, it wasn't until a few years later when Mitch All Together showed how much the comedian had honed his style, upped the one-liner ante and delivered his swan song. He had such a loveable charm that even if he stumbled on a line or two he was able to pull it off with a grin and a smirk.

Mitch All Together is a documentation of a career that should've been longer and greater than it was. Still 7 years after his death, Hedberg's impact on the comedy world is felt.


Zach Galifianakis - Live at the Purple Onion (2007)
[Live At The Purple Onion] Released long before many knew how to properly pronounce Galifianakis, Live At The Purple Onion is Zach having a field day with his imagination. Part stand-up, part hilariously deconstructed themes, idiosyncratic buffoonery, unhinged piano play, and even a little bit Vegas lounge act.

Uncomfortably close camera angles help keep the viewer engaged as Galifianakis lays one-off zingers and random stream-of-consciousness thoughts as he haphazardly tugs on his hair and beard almost to keep the demons at bay.

The special does jump between brilliant stage antics and on the street actions with Galifianakis in character as his brother Seth. It's fun and breezy but not nearly as devastating as the stand-up it intermingles with.

Purple Onion is a hodgepodge of material as it blends stage antics taking down crowd members for being ridiculous hecklers. He jumps in the crowd to rant to the old ones and mock the Millennial ridiculousness of others. He lures the crowd to watch him pace around the stage, as he's near the edge of losing it and the crowd eats it up.

It's a documentation of the growing cult of Zach Galifianakis just years before he became the gifted geek breakout star we now know.



Dane Cook - Harmful If Swallowed (2003)
[Harmful if Swallowed] Dane Cook gets credit for elevating comedy in the modern setting by fully embracing burgeoning social media. Early MP3 download sites helped him amass a huge following that were the impetus of releasing some of the most successful albums of the 00′s.

Cook was able to launch wildly successful arena tours that brought him all the way to sold out Madison Square Garden shows. His rise was so meteoric that the backlash kicked in just as fast and out came the haters. Was it warranted? Of course not!

Harmful If Swallowed was Cook's first and highly quotable album. It captured Cook's high energy performance and funny observations on wordplay and scenarios. Fans could not get enough about bits about tires murdering Mary or hanging at the BK lounge. In fact, approach any 30 something and and yell, "fark This Game! YOU win grandma!" and they'd more than likely understand exactly what you are talking about.

Cook followed up Harmful... with the double disc, Retaliation. It crushed the Billboard charts and went gold in less than a week,, making it the best selling comedy album since Steve Martin's Wild And Crazy Guy in 1978. This success was not possible without the performance delivered on Harmful If Swallowed.


Louis C.K. - Hilarious (2010)
[Hilarious] The trajectory of Louis C.K.'s comedy career seemed to slowly simmer over the years until it completely and absolutely boiled over with the release of Hilarious.

Sure, he's had amazingly terrific specials before this that could easily make the list. But it was not until the release of Hilarious when C.K. made the full transition from well-respected comedian to those "in the know," into a full-fledged cultural and critical phenomenon. Gaining universal praise and compliments declaring him to be the best comedian working today.

Hilarious is where C.K. delivered instant classics such as his "Everything is amazing and nobody cares" bit which he performed on The Tonight Show and exploded virally. It was also the first stand-up comedy film that was accepted to Sundance and spread to the explosion of his FX TV show. Then, then at the peak of his rising career, C.K. decided to buck traditional comedy trends and self-release his follow-up albums and tour.

The era of Louis C.K. rightfully began with Hilarious.


Jim Gaffigan - Doing My Time (2004)
[Doing My Time] What did the world know about the Hot Pocket before Jim Gaffigan released Doing My Time? Well they probably ate them with a bit less knowledge of what exactly they were putting in their mouth for one. Gaffigan was just talking about his love/hate relationship with all kinds of food but he ended up creating a defining moment in his stand-up.

Doing My Time is Gaffigan running through tales of his Midwestern upbringings, boughts with laziness, and of course food. It also was the full realization of Gaffigan's now signature style which includes his "aside" voice, that of an easily offended and naive audience member.

Doing My Time kicked off a string of unbelievably consistent and great Gaffigan releases. Each release upping the next with terrific material and a bigger and bolder joke teller in Gaffifan. This will not be the only classic Jim Gaffigan album but it's his first.


Patton Oswalt - Werewolves and Lollipops (2007)
[Werewolves and Lollipops] "Thank you guys for coming out. I'm drunk. Here we go!" is how Patton Oswalt begins his second comedy album, Werewolves And Lollipops. To this day it's one of the best opening lines of any comedy album. Werewolves was released post Oswalt's Comedians Of Comedy tour. A grand experiment to push the boundaries of what the comedy show and tour looks like. Oswalt decided he didn't want to tour comedy clubs, opting to take the rock band approach and get his friends into a van and perform at rock clubs. The experiment was a success and helped draw the blueprint for the type of comedy fan we'd see in the "alternative" scene in the years afterward. The album's release on a non-traditional comedy label (Sub Pop) that in a small way helped people re-think how comedy can be presented to the masses.

On Werewolves, Oswalt is a wordsmith, meticulously deciding the proper phrases to say in what situations. He spent time re-arranging and re-working this set until it was polished and perfect. It's just as much a monologue or poetry as it is stand-up comedy. If you've never heard Werewolves, you might be surprised to recognize a lot of the material on it. Frankly because it's the well which pulled many of his infamous material like the KFC Famous Bowls, Birth Control and Costco, Physics for poets, Wackity Schmackity Doo!, and Death Bed.

Werewolves also contains one of the realest moments in heckling. During his Costco bit Patton has the room at complete attention building to an amazing peak, as he sets up the tale things get quiet (a referenced Pixies, quiet-loud moment) with the intent to peak with a terrific payoff. It's at that critical moment that a heckler disrupts the flow. Unable to contain himself Oswalt smashes the heckler with such funny precision it's unclear if the heckler even realized how much he "didn't get it."


Dave Chappelle - Killin' Them Softly (2000)
[Killin' Them Softly] Released right at the beginning of the new Millennium, this special ushered in the era of Dave Chappelle.

Killin' Them Softly is an abundance of highly refined and absolutely devastating material that showcases a young comedian becoming the master. Peaking just before his TV show took him on a sonic boom of a ride to become one of the pop-culturally relevant shows of the cable era.

Recorded in Washington D.C. Chappelle plunges into a wealth of anecdotes and observations about race, drugs, and culture. He re-tells wild takes of dealing with cops with a white person in the car, taking a limo to a crack house, and suggesting that some of our favorite childhood cartoon characters might be sex criminals.

Chappelle has been known for performing marathon sets and its easy to see seeds of that with this special. He thoroughly enjoys being on stage and telling tales and there aren't many better than Chappelle.


Lewis Black - Rules Of Enragement (2003)
[Rules of Enragement] It's really difficult to select one of Lewis Black's early releases for this list. They are all lengthy missives delivered by the Black and his head-scratchingly ability to pinpoint the exact moments when his head might explode. For the sake of narrowing things down we'll go with Enragement. It's the album before Black started off a string of Grammy nominated stand-up comedy records.

Black rages against the absurdities of life and modern politics which often bring him to the limits of sanity. While using sarcasm and hyperbole he twitches, shouts at the top of his lungs, uses well-timed curses and grunts through his teeth. Black has edge-of-a-nervous breakdown energy for 60 minutes, as if he's the only sane person in the room.

On Engragement, Black is as topical and biting as anything George Carlin or Bill Hicks would ever rail about. Black has become one of the most prolific and successful comedians of our generation. Starring in movies, TV shows, and a long-running segment on The Daily Show.



Greg Giraldo - Midlife Vices (2009)
[Midlife Vices] The first 15 minutes of Midlife Vices are so side-splittingy hilarious it should be illegal. Greg Giraldo was so refined and concise with this performance that it's Goddamn heartbreaking to realize this is the last album we'll ever get from the man. Giraldo was razor sharp and too smart for his own good sometimes. Vices dissects social taboos, political commentary, and racial stereotypes with such thought and sarcasm.

Giraldo launches the offensive, rather than sitting back on the "have you ever noticed" vibe he decides to pick it all apart leaving no stone unturned. There are also moments on the album where he addresses his addictions which he unfortunately wasn't able to conquer.

Giraldo was a comic's comic, the type of comedian who had intelligence, style, and delivery down so well that it appeared nearly effortless. There are comedians that may have reached higher levels of success than Greg, but there are very few we can think of that were more respected by peers and critics or better on the stage.

If someone were to ask us how to do stand-up comedy we'd immediately hand them a copy of Midlife Vices and reply, "like this."
 
2012-10-12 11:04:15 AM
Jim Jeffries...don' t know if he has an album out but his amsterdam story has me in stitches everytime.
 
2012-10-12 11:05:06 AM
Shiatty Slide show doesn't work:

Big Bamboo.
Waiting for the Electrician or sombody like him.
Don't Crush That Dwarf, Hand Me The Pliers
How Can You Be In Two Places At Once When You're Not Anywhere At All?
I Think We're All Bozos On This Bus
The Tale of the Giant Rat of Sumatra
Just Folks ... A Firesign Chat
 
2012-10-12 11:07:23 AM
Where is Doug Stanhope?

Aside from that, Dave Attell SKANK FOR THE MEMORIES is there, so it's all good
 
2012-10-12 11:08:43 AM
No Doug Stanhope "Something to Take the Edge Off"??

No Stanhope at all? Or Jim Norton?

List sucks donkey balls.
 
2012-10-12 11:22:41 AM

Tanukis_Parachute: Jim Jeffries...don' t know if he has an album out but his amsterdam story has me in stitches everytime.


Alcoholocaust and I Swear to God. NSFW
 
2012-10-12 11:32:45 AM

XToughGuyX: List Fails without

[farm3.staticflickr.com image 333x500]


Came to say this. I've seen him twice, always funnier than anything I've heard from Dane Cook or Lewis Black.
 
2012-10-12 11:33:07 AM
For Mitch Fans...

I keep this on my reminders on my work desktop for bad days
 
2012-10-12 11:35:23 AM

vudukungfu: Shiatty Slide show doesn't work:

Big Bamboo.
Waiting for the Electrician or sombody like him.
Don't Crush That Dwarf, Hand Me The Pliers
How Can You Be In Two Places At Once When You're Not Anywhere At All?
I Think We're All Bozos On This Bus
The Tale of the Giant Rat of Sumatra
Just Folks ... A Firesign Chat


So... you didn't notice the word "modern" in the header, did you?

Besides, your old-school list is severely lacking in George Carlin and Richard Pryor.
 
2012-10-12 11:40:10 AM
Mike Birbiglia "2 Drink Mike" should be on there and I agree with FNB about Feeling Kinda Patton and Titus. Never did like Gaffigan, mostly because of that "aside" voice the article mentions.
 
2012-10-12 11:40:36 AM
Cook followed up Harmful... with the double disc, Retaliation. It crushed the Billboard charts and went gold in less than a week,, making it the best selling comedy album since Steve Martin's Wild And Crazy Guy in 1978.

I knew Wild and Crazy Guy, I owned Wild and Crazy Guy on vinyl. Harmful, you are no Wild and Crazy Guy.
 
2012-10-12 11:40:53 AM
"...but those titties ain't retarded!"
 
2012-10-12 11:47:44 AM
I find Dane Cook to the the recording that I'd prefer to listen to out of all of these. Mind you, I'm suicidally depressed and don't wish to be burdened by things that might actually cheer me up or bring out laughter in any way shape or form.
 
2012-10-12 11:47:53 AM

Chabash: Chabash: Does it mention Lewis Black at all? If not, laugh button can EABOD.

I withdraw my previous statement. Lewis Black is included.


They chose the wrong one, though. The White Album is definitely Black at his finest.

"If it wasn't for my horse..."
 
2012-10-12 11:48:37 AM

Mr_Fabulous: vudukungfu: Shiatty Slide show doesn't work:

Big Bamboo.
Waiting for the Electrician or sombody like him.
Don't Crush That Dwarf, Hand Me The Pliers
How Can You Be In Two Places At Once When You're Not Anywhere At All?
I Think We're All Bozos On This Bus
The Tale of the Giant Rat of Sumatra
Just Folks ... A Firesign Chat

So... you didn't notice the word "modern" in the header, did you?

Besides, your old-school list is severely lacking in George Carlin and Richard Pryor.


or Billy Connolly.
 
2012-10-12 11:49:50 AM

shidekigonomo: Chabash: Chabash: Does it mention Lewis Black at all? If not, laugh button can EABOD.

I withdraw my previous statement. Lewis Black is included.

They chose the wrong one, though. The White Album is definitely Black at his finest.

"If it wasn't for my horse..."


His Carnegie Hall performance was amazing as well.
 
2012-10-12 12:01:42 PM
for me the list fails because
*my friends and i were into zach g well before 2007 (not being hipster...it was a nationally televised show that got us into him). i have no idea if he had albums out before that, but his short-lived variety show thingie was on more like '03...?

*the inclusion of dane cook when there was no ron white, no david cross, no lots of others who could've been in his place

*if i'm not mistaken the "hot pockets" bit came from "beyond the pale" which was AFTER the jim g album mentioned in the article

*seriously come the fark on guys, larry the friggin cable guy (i actually like his schtick, despite what most farkers say) would've been MUCH better than the dane cook album!

*probably other reasons i can't think of right now
 
2012-10-12 12:08:32 PM

Jedekai: [shop.linncoweb.net image 335x475]

LIST. FAILS.


I could list others but not having THIS comedian is what truly makes list fail.
 
2012-10-12 12:18:14 PM
That's actually a pretty good list. Thanks to the dude up thread for posting.
 
2012-10-12 12:34:09 PM
Whar stanhope?
 
2012-10-12 12:42:05 PM
bakosy.files.wordpress.com

my favorite comedy album of all time. listened to it HUNDREDS of times. it STILL makes me laugh every single time.
 
2012-10-12 12:44:49 PM
ecx.images-amazon.com

Patton Oswalt called this "the most important comedy album of our time," and I agree with him because I don't know any better. Whereas most comedy albums edit together the best bits from several different nights of a theater tour full of fans who came specifically for the album recording, Pardo taped his set straight through at a nightclub in front of an audience of 50-60 people. This album, more than any other, presents what real stand-up comedy for a touring comedian is actually like.
 
2012-10-12 12:51:24 PM
Brian Regan
 
2012-10-12 12:52:20 PM

Crudbucket: [ecx.images-amazon.com image 280x280]

Patton Oswalt called this "the most important comedy album of our time," and I agree with him because I don't know any better. Whereas most comedy albums edit together the best bits from several different nights of a theater tour full of fans who came specifically for the album recording, Pardo taped his set straight through at a nightclub in front of an audience of 50-60 people. This album, more than any other, presents what real stand-up comedy for a touring comedian is actually like.


I will have to check it out. Thanks!
 
2012-10-12 01:00:06 PM
It occured to me the other day while listening to the comedy station on Pandora that a lot of todays comedians don't really have anything interesting to say. They just rage and anger. Exceptions for me are Louis C K, Mike Birbiglia and Dimitri Martin. Even when they're not particularly funny, they're interesting.

Talk about poignant, listen to Tig Notaro's set the day after she was diagnosed with cancer
Link
 
2012-10-12 01:01:22 PM
Mitch Hedberg was a hack. Talk about the emperor's new clothes!
 
2012-10-12 01:02:34 PM

Crewmannumber6: It occured to me the other day while listening to the comedy station on Pandora that a lot of todays comedians don't really have anything interesting to say. They just rage and anger. Exceptions for me are Louis C K, Mike Birbiglia and Dimitri Martin. Even when they're not particularly funny, they're interesting.

Talk about poignant, listen to Tig Notaro's set the day after she was diagnosed with cancer
Link


Patrice O'Neal was (sob) incredibly interesting and funny.

As are lots of other comedians. I guess I am trying to say that I completely disagree.
 
2012-10-12 01:03:22 PM

Crudbucket: [ecx.images-amazon.com image 280x280]

Patton Oswalt called this "the most important comedy album of our time," and I agree with him because I don't know any better. Whereas most comedy albums edit together the best bits from several different nights of a theater tour full of fans who came specifically for the album recording, Pardo taped his set straight through at a nightclub in front of an audience of 50-60 people. This album, more than any other, presents what real stand-up comedy for a touring comedian is actually like.


pardo always had me laughing on the way to work when he was on the bob and tom show. we no longer get the bob and tom show here in south florida. i listen to my ipod mostly now. i'll have to check this out. i'll chuckle at a lot of their guests but pardo had me laughing. then again, i like rodney carrington.
 
2012-10-12 01:09:41 PM

Tanukis_Parachute: Crudbucket: [ecx.images-amazon.com image 280x280]

Patton Oswalt called this "the most important comedy album of our time," and I agree with him because I don't know any better. Whereas most comedy albums edit together the best bits from several different nights of a theater tour full of fans who came specifically for the album recording, Pardo taped his set straight through at a nightclub in front of an audience of 50-60 people. This album, more than any other, presents what real stand-up comedy for a touring comedian is actually like.

pardo always had me laughing on the way to work when he was on the bob and tom show. we no longer get the bob and tom show here in south florida. i listen to my ipod mostly now. i'll have to check this out. i'll chuckle at a lot of their guests but pardo had me laughing. then again, i like rodney carrington.


No shame in that.

Rodney Carrington definitely has his moments. And his songs aren't too bad, either.

Unfortunately, he hasn't released a new album in years, and the last one was all music.
 
2012-10-12 01:12:19 PM
I understand the hate for Dane Cook now.

But I do not get all the hate for early Dane Cook (like Harmful if Swallowed)

The guy was phenomenal. I stopped following about 5 or 6 years ago.
 
2012-10-12 01:12:26 PM

Tanukis_Parachute: Crudbucket: [ecx.images-amazon.com image 280x280]

Patton Oswalt called this "the most important comedy album of our time," and I agree with him because I don't know any better. Whereas most comedy albums edit together the best bits from several different nights of a theater tour full of fans who came specifically for the album recording, Pardo taped his set straight through at a nightclub in front of an audience of 50-60 people. This album, more than any other, presents what real stand-up comedy for a touring comedian is actually like.

pardo always had me laughing on the way to work when he was on the bob and tom show. we no longer get the bob and tom show here in south florida. i listen to my ipod mostly now. i'll have to check this out. i'll chuckle at a lot of their guests but pardo had me laughing. then again, i like rodney carrington.


Jimmy was one of the first comedians to start doing a podcast back in 2006, and it's Never Not Funny. They don't do bits or sketches, it's just Jimmy, the producer Matt, and a guest talking for an hour and a half. The first 20 minutes can be downloaded free, the full episodes are $0.77 a piece. You pay for it because it's worth it.
 
2012-10-12 01:13:21 PM

FirstNationalBastard: Tanukis_Parachute: Crudbucket: [ecx.images-amazon.com image 280x280]

Patton Oswalt called this "the most important comedy album of our time," and I agree with him because I don't know any better. Whereas most comedy albums edit together the best bits from several different nights of a theater tour full of fans who came specifically for the album recording, Pardo taped his set straight through at a nightclub in front of an audience of 50-60 people. This album, more than any other, presents what real stand-up comedy for a touring comedian is actually like.

pardo always had me laughing on the way to work when he was on the bob and tom show. we no longer get the bob and tom show here in south florida. i listen to my ipod mostly now. i'll have to check this out. i'll chuckle at a lot of their guests but pardo had me laughing. then again, i like rodney carrington.

No shame in that.

Rodney Carrington definitely has his moments. And his songs aren't too bad, either.

Unfortunately, he hasn't released a new album in years, and the last one was all music.


i won tix to a carrington show in texarkana almost 5 years ago. really good show! severe thunderstorm nearly cut it short.
 
2012-10-12 01:16:34 PM
Also incorrectly missing from this list:


iconvsicon.com 

/Anything by C.B.M.
 
2012-10-12 01:19:07 PM

r1niceboy: Mr_Fabulous:
Besides, your old-school list is severely lacking in George Carlin and Richard Pryor.

or Billy Connolly.


My dad turned me on to those guys later on.
And modern albums?
They don't fit on my turntable,
get off my lawn and let the air out of your shoes.
 
2012-10-12 01:38:44 PM
I won tickets to go see Jim Gaffigan in a few weeks. I enjoy his humor.
 
2012-10-12 01:50:47 PM

WienerButt: I won tickets to go see Jim Gaffigan in a few weeks. I enjoy his humor.


I liked him on Law and Order as guy who killed his wife so he could have his tarded kids star on a reality show because he needed the money.
 
2012-10-12 01:56:44 PM
Dane Cook and no Ron White?

Your blog sucks, submitter
 
2012-10-12 02:13:02 PM
no russell peters? really?
 
2012-10-12 02:14:50 PM
FTA: Dane Cook, Jim Gaffigan

Uh, no thanks. I can't stand Gaffigan's high voice thing he does. Besides, his material just isn't funny. At all. And Cook just tries to hard. He has some funny material (small percentage, mind you), but his delivery ruins it for me.

Glad to see Giraldo, Attel, Hedberg, Oswalt, and C.K. on there. Masters of their craft.

Stanhope and Rogan are good, but seem to be in their own style that doesn't reach as large of a demographic. I enjoy them nonetheless. Though, I can see why they didn't make the list.
 
2012-10-12 02:17:43 PM

Bruxellensis: FTA: Dane Cook, Jim Gaffigan

Uh, no thanks. I can't stand Gaffigan's high voice thing he does. Besides, his material just isn't funny. At all. And Cook just tries to hard. He has some funny material (small percentage, mind you), but his delivery ruins it for me.

Glad to see Giraldo, Attel, Hedberg, Oswalt, and C.K. on there. Masters of their craft.

Stanhope and Rogan are good, but seem to be in their own style that doesn't reach as large of a demographic. I enjoy them nonetheless. Though, I can see why they didn't make the list.


i have found a lot of cook's stuff to be funny, but he gets REALLY annoying really quick. and gaffigan i find quite funny, and i like his "aside voice" stuff for about a minute, and then it becomes annoying. if he was to cut out 99% of his "aside voice" stuff he'd be far more enjoyable
 
2012-10-12 02:21:59 PM

Bruxellensis: ...And Cook just tries too hard. He has...


FTFM
 
2012-10-12 02:28:39 PM
No Ron White?   *sigh*
 
2012-10-12 02:29:36 PM

titwrench: Who buys these? Once you have heard a joke do you really need to hear it again, especially to the point that you feel compelled to own it so you can hear it whenever you want? Music I get buying but the allure of comedy albums always escaped me.


THIS. Comedy has even less replay value than tv episodes and mainstream movies, although there are idiots who will watch those over and over again as well. I'll never understand why one would watch something they have already seen over something they haven't unless they have worse short term memory than a 2 year old.
 
2012-10-12 02:31:58 PM

Crudbucket: [ecx.images-amazon.com image 280x280]
This album, more than any other, presents what real stand-up comedy for a touring comedian is actually like.


This this this this this this this. I love Jimmy Pardo. I enjoy that the joke he starts on track one doesn't really get finished until somewhere in track eight.

/Let's do one off my 15th album...
 
2012-10-12 02:32:11 PM

drewogatory: titwrench: Who buys these? Once you have heard a joke do you really need to hear it again, especially to the point that you feel compelled to own it so you can hear it whenever you want? Music I get buying but the allure of comedy albums always escaped me.

THIS. Comedy has even less replay value than tv episodes and mainstream movies, although there are idiots who will watch those over and over again as well. I'll never understand why one would watch something they have already seen over something they haven't unless they have worse short term memory than a 2 year old.


different strokes and all that

there are some movies and shows i will watch every single time i flip thru the channels and see them on. doesn't matter if i know every word and scene by heart.

comedy specials are about the same way for me
 
2012-10-12 02:33:16 PM

flashfry: But I do not get all the hate for early Dane Cook (like Harmful if Swallowed)


i don't get it either. he's great on stage too. maybe it's because he doesn't just stand in place and tell jokes like pretty much all stand up comedians do. instead he's like that guy at a party that does his best to reenact the funny story he's telling. ricky gervais does this as well, and both are very good at it.

lewis black has a new album out, but the pacing seems off. he usually raises his voice on the punch lines but on this album, he does it in the middle of the joke which makes it seem weird.

csb
dave attell is great on stage. my school had him on for the spring carnival back in early 2000. the warm up act was horrible, he was being booed the entire time (but he kept going which was admirable). attell came on to an upset crowd and turned it around instantly with "man, they should fly him over iraq since he bombs so hard."

/dave attell was on green room with paul provenza, is still great.
 
2012-10-12 02:33:58 PM
my comment ^^^ was #69

i don't care who you are, that's funny right there
 
2012-10-12 02:36:18 PM

not5am: flashfry: But I do not get all the hate for early Dane Cook (like Harmful if Swallowed)

i don't get it either. he's great on stage too. maybe it's because he doesn't just stand in place and tell jokes like pretty much all stand up comedians do. instead he's like that guy at a party that does his best to reenact the funny story he's telling. ricky gervais does this as well, and both are very good at it.

lewis black has a new album out, but the pacing seems off. he usually raises his voice on the punch lines but on this album, he does it in the middle of the joke which makes it seem weird.

csb
dave attell is great on stage. my school had him on for the spring carnival back in early 2000. the warm up act was horrible, he was being booed the entire time (but he kept going which was how he got paid admirable). attell came on to an upset crowd and turned it around instantly with "man, they should fly him over iraq since he bombs so hard."

/dave attell was on green room with paul provenza, is still great.


i miss the "insomniacs" show. i think my favorite was the anchorage episode where he's wondering around in nearly total sunlight at midnight
 
2012-10-12 02:40:49 PM

bungle_jr: i miss the "insomniacs" show. i think my favorite was the anchorage episode where he's wondering around in nearly total sunlight at midnight


+1 for Insomniac
 
2012-10-12 02:46:46 PM

drewogatory: titwrench: Who buys these? Once you have heard a joke do you really need to hear it again, especially to the point that you feel compelled to own it so you can hear it whenever you want? Music I get buying but the allure of comedy albums always escaped me.

THIS. Comedy has even less replay value than tv episodes and mainstream movies, although there are idiots who will watch those over and over again as well. I'll never understand why one would watch something they have already seen over something they haven't unless they have worse short term memory than a 2 year old.


That's what Firesign theater is for.
Just listen to some samples at their website.
Wear headphones.
 
2012-10-12 02:47:52 PM
Subrtact:
Dane Cook

Add:
Patrice O'neal - Elephant in the Room


Patrice was perhaps the quickest in the game. Brutal, truthful, hilarious, and spontaneous. The guy almost never wrote anything down. He was genius off the top of his head.

Chris Rock, Louis CK, etc, all thought he could be bigger than they were. But the fact was, Patrice didn't really want it.
 
2012-10-12 02:48:36 PM

Bruxellensis: bungle_jr: i miss the "insomniacs" show. i think my favorite was the anchorage episode where he's wondering around in nearly total sunlight at midnight

+1 for Insomniac


oh yeah, he also did an episode in little rock...filmed it just before i moved there. he visited SWEET SWEET CONNIE, the groupie made famous by the song "we're an american band"
 
2012-10-12 02:54:17 PM

bungle_jr: i miss the "insomniacs" show. i think my favorite was the anchorage episode where he's wondering around in nearly total sunlight at midnight


well, i find it admirable that he finished the set. it was a show at a college, is was probably for like $50 for a 8 minutes of getting booed by an angry crowd of college kids.

/he probably really needed the money.
 
2012-10-12 02:57:55 PM

vudukungfu: drewogatory: titwrench: Who buys these? Once you have heard a joke do you really need to hear it again, especially to the point that you feel compelled to own it so you can hear it whenever you want? Music I get buying but the allure of comedy albums always escaped me.

THIS. Comedy has even less replay value than tv episodes and mainstream movies, although there are idiots who will watch those over and over again as well. I'll never understand why one would watch something they have already seen over something they haven't unless they have worse short term memory than a 2 year old.

That's what Firesign theater is for.
Just listen to some samples at their website.
Wear headphones.


Considering you have to listen to a Firesign album 20 freaking times sometimes just to figure out what the hell is going on, they are somewhat exempt. I was referring more to stand -up than meta material like that.
 
2012-10-12 03:01:04 PM
fark, terrible hot linking error on that one (sorry folks). Preview button is your friend.

Anything by this man:
sharetv.org


I used to be a big fan of Dane Cook. Dude could tell some jokes. I think things turned for him after his parents died and his brother stole from him. He just hasn't been able to bring the funny back around since then. Vicious Circle seemed like the rantings of an obviously depressed comedian in the worst possible way.
 
2012-10-12 03:13:54 PM
So glad to see that they remembered the illustrious and highly hysterical Mitch Hedberg, but where's the love for Craig Shoemaker? His "Love Master" bit never fails to crack me up!
 
2012-10-12 03:22:04 PM
what about some RALPHIE MAY?

i don't see many farkers talk about him...good or bad...

opinions?
 
2012-10-12 03:31:41 PM

bungle_jr: what about some RALPHIE MAY?

i don't see many farkers talk about him...good or bad...

opinions?


He's fat.

/I think him and Gabriel Iglesias both suck
//they're like your annoying coworkers
 
2012-10-12 03:32:59 PM

bungle_jr: what about some RALPHIE MAY?

i don't see many farkers talk about him...good or bad...

opinions?


He kinda plateaued. There are only so many "im so fat" jokes you can make before people get tired of it. Happens to a lot of comedians. See: Lisa "i sucked a lot of black cranks" Lampanelli, Demetri "aren't i just so weird?" Martin, Carlos "Beaners Beaners Beaners!!!!" Mencia
 
2012-10-12 03:33:45 PM

WienerButt: bungle_jr: what about some RALPHIE MAY?

i don't see many farkers talk about him...good or bad...

opinions?

He's fat.

/I think him and Gabriel Iglesias both suck
//they're like your annoying coworkers


he's most definitely fat

i like him. gabriel definitely gets on my nerves...pretty much all his material is about being a fat latino...ralphie, imho, has some pretty good material
 
2012-10-12 03:36:14 PM

LemSkroob: bungle_jr: what about some RALPHIE MAY?

i don't see many farkers talk about him...good or bad...

opinions?

He kinda plateaued. There are only so many "im so fat" jokes you can make before people get tired of it. Happens to a lot of comedians. See: Lisa "i sucked a lot of black cranks" Lampanelli, Demetri "aren't i just so weird?" Martin, Carlos "Beaners Beaners Beaners!!!!" Mencia


lisa l = exactly that...i think that is ALL she knows how to talk about

i used to like carlos's show...can't remember the name right now...you know, his weekly variety show

demetri's first special was good and he pretty much never varied from that model since then
 
2012-10-12 03:38:29 PM

bungle_jr:

i used to like carlos's show...can't remember the name right now...you know, his weekly variety show



I believe it was called "Stuff George Lopez did last week."
 
2012-10-12 03:40:18 PM

FirstNationalBastard: bungle_jr:

i used to like carlos's show...can't remember the name right now...you know, his weekly variety show



I believe it was called "Stuff George Lopez did last week."


hey now! he stole from more than just george!
 
2012-10-12 03:41:29 PM

FirstNationalBastard: bungle_jr:

i used to like carlos's show...can't remember the name right now...you know, his weekly variety show



I believe it was called "Stuff George Lopez did last week."


bungle_jr: FirstNationalBastard: bungle_jr:

i used to like carlos's show...can't remember the name right now...you know, his weekly variety show



I believe it was called "Stuff George Lopez did last week."

hey now! he stole from more than just george!


after i posted that ^ i remembered he stole from t-t-t-timmah...got his head chopped off for a gay fish joke
 
2012-10-12 03:48:57 PM

FirstNationalBastard: Okay, since I'm not clicking through their shiatty, slow-ass slideshow, I'm going by the image on the first page...

Anything with Dane Cook fails.


This. Dane Cook is a running sore on the body of comedy.
 
2012-10-12 03:59:00 PM

bungle_jr: lisa l = exactly that...i think that is ALL she knows how to talk about


She does that because her act is horrible, bigoted, and uncreative. That's her excuse.

"Well, I suck a lot of black cawk, so I CAN'T be racist! Can I? Hur hur."


/I despise Sarah Silverman for a similar, non-bigotry-related habit
"Look at me, I'm moderately attractive and say f*ck! I also say poop and make dick jokes! LOVE ME!!!"
 
2012-10-12 04:08:12 PM
Decent list but no Bill Burr or Doug Stanhope? Dane cook was funny in the beginning but his schtick got old fast.
 
2012-10-12 04:10:48 PM
Also Anthony Jeselnik is farking hilarious
 
2012-10-12 04:13:58 PM
And Jimmy Carr......how can I forget Jimmy?

www.heatworld.com
 
2012-10-12 04:23:42 PM
Tommy Johnagin
 
2012-10-12 04:46:47 PM
I really like James P Connolly
 
2012-10-12 04:57:23 PM
No love for Dara O Briain?
 
2012-10-12 05:23:18 PM
Patrice O'Neal's last album, "Mr. P.", is hysterical. His audience work is masterful and the entire room is bursting into tears the entire time, rightfully so. Side note (not on the album), Jim Norton's story of how he got the name "Dr. Dildo" is hilarious too.
 
2012-10-12 06:03:57 PM
Standup comedians still release albums?

Hell, standup comedians still do standup comedy?

I thought podcasts and Twitter one-liners had made that whole ecosystem obsolete.
 
2012-10-12 06:08:30 PM
titwrench


Who buys these? Once you have heard a joke do you really need to hear it again, especially to the point that you feel compelled to own it so you can hear it whenever you want? Music I get buying but the allure of comedy albums always escaped me.


you must be tons of fun at parties.

I have a few Carlin records, a Steve Martin LP (the lesser known "Comedy Isn't Pretty"), Robin Williams "Reality what a concept!" (not all that funny, actually) and his "live at the Met 1985" (probably his best cd), a 2LP set of Woody Allen's early stand up (half of it is pretty good, what a very witty guy).

as for hearing them again,
I've listened to Steven Wright's "I Have a Pony" about 4 times, and it's STILL funny.
 
2012-10-12 06:14:07 PM

thecpt




For Mitch Fans...

I keep this on my reminders on my work desktop for bad days


Thank you good sir.
I was surprised I hadn't heard about 1/3 of those! Good stuff.

/ i read them in my head in his voice.
r.i.p. mitch
 
2012-10-12 06:30:57 PM
cdn3.hark.com

"Pancakes or pussy...pussy or pancakes?"
 
2012-10-12 06:32:08 PM
I've been to a lot of live shows by comedians and the best of them were: Lisa Lampanelli (where she did all-new unaired material - unheard of w/ today's comics), Paula Poundstone, Rita Rudner, Margaret Cho, and Louie Anderson.
In the middle were some British comics whose names escape me now, and the Redneck tour guys.
The worst was that baseball-hat guy from '30 Rock' - his shtick(sp?) sucked donkey balls.

/cue the 'all female comics are lousy' comments, from people who have -never- been to their live shows.
//time to grow up and quit making 'all people of this gender are ______' statements - they're never true.
 
2012-10-12 06:33:29 PM
 
2012-10-12 06:39:38 PM

Third_Uncle_Eno: titwrench


Who buys these? Once you have heard a joke do you really need to hear it again, especially to the point that you feel compelled to own it so you can hear it whenever you want? Music I get buying but the allure of comedy albums always escaped me.

you must be tons of fun at parties.

I have a few Carlin records, a Steve Martin LP (the lesser known "Comedy Isn't Pretty"), Robin Williams "Reality what a concept!" (not all that funny, actually) and his "live at the Met 1985" (probably his best cd), a 2LP set of Woody Allen's early stand up (half of it is pretty good, what a very witty guy).

as for hearing them again,
I've listened to Steven Wright's "I Have a Pony" about 4 times, and it's STILL funny.


I am a lot of fun at parties because I don't rely on a bunch of overdone, hackney comedy routines to be witty or clever. I rely on rum and Guinness.
 
2012-10-12 07:07:44 PM
Patton Oswalt ends one of his albums with a hobo song that I thought was amazing. I couldn't decide if it was reality based or made up out of whole cloth. Anyway, it was a step above stand up.
 
2012-10-12 07:13:32 PM
upload.wikimedia.org
about an hour of nothing but gold....
 
2012-10-12 07:17:03 PM

thecpt: For Mitch Fans...

I keep this on my reminders on my work desktop for bad days


Thank you for this, seriously.

/misses Mitch.
 
2012-10-12 07:37:02 PM
No Marc Maron? WTF?
 
2012-10-12 08:00:17 PM

Crewmannumber6: Tommy Johnagin


I opened for this guy a few weeks ago, he's hilarious and really impressive at crowd work which I wasn't expecting.
 
2012-10-12 08:51:28 PM
Doug Stanhope "Dead Beat Hero" and "Something to Take the Edge Off" are farking brilliant. Either one should be on there.
 
2012-10-12 08:57:17 PM
Lots of good names here.

Reiterating Mike Birbiglia - if you've only heard bits of "Sleepwalk With Me" you have no idea what a wonderful, twisting narrative the whole thing is.
 
2012-10-12 09:22:03 PM
i290.photobucket.com
 
2012-10-12 10:19:15 PM
'Modern' and 'Classic' should never be in the same sentence.

//dnrtfa
///define 'modern'
 
2012-10-12 10:47:48 PM

drewogatory: Considering you have to listen to a Firesign album 20 freaking times sometimes just to figure out what the hell is going on, they are somewhat exempt. I was referring more to stand -up than meta material like that.


Bozos is a conceptual album that deal with an administrator hacking into a computer net work and rebooting it in the early 70s.
Yeah.
You need time to figure that out.
Now re-inflate your shoes.
 
2012-10-12 11:47:18 PM
imageshack.us

I have no idea how Mike Birbiglia doesn't get more attention.

"Hey, cracka, pass the Sun Chips!"
"Not until we get to the picnic, cracka!"
 
2012-10-13 02:46:54 AM
"Let's Get Small"

That is all.
 
2012-10-13 08:25:30 AM

drewogatory: titwrench: Who buys these? Once you have heard a joke do you really need to hear it again, especially to the point that you feel compelled to own it so you can hear it whenever you want? Music I get buying but the allure of comedy albums always escaped me.

THIS. Comedy has even less replay value than tv episodes and mainstream movies, although there are idiots who will watch those over and over again as well. I'll never understand why one would watch something they have already seen over something they haven't unless they have worse short term memory than a 2 year old.


yeah, people who do something more than once are stupid. if i hear a song one time, i never listen to it again, no matter how much i like it. listening to it one time is enough to get all the enjoyment out of it that i possibly can. i've only seen my favorite movie once nine years ago, because watching it again would be a waste of my valuable time. why should i watch a movie i know i like, when i can watch an adam sandler movie i've never seen before instead? in fact, when i meet new people and make new friends, i visit them once and then never again. why would i bother to visit people i've seen before? i do everything once. doing something two times is pointless.
 
2012-10-13 11:58:29 AM
img.photobucket.com
Firesign Theater

i26.photobucket.com

/The Natl Lampoon album has a great Olympics bit and a lot of SNL alums from the first few seasons.
 
2012-10-13 01:11:43 PM
While I do understand the disdain for Cook, I can't for the life of me understand the love or Oswalt.
Also, no Dylan Moran!? The list is very American.
 
2012-10-13 05:55:55 PM
List fails without :
4.bp.blogspot.com
 
2012-10-13 05:58:57 PM

sadbad



List fails without :
4.bp.blogspot.com


OMG she's one of my favourite female comics ( i don't know many) but for the life of me I couldn't remember her name or where I saw her on.
thanks!

plus she's cute
 
2012-10-14 06:11:16 AM
COMEDY THREAD! anyone looking for a good starter comedy cd should pick up the Comedy Death-Ray cd. excellent stuff
 
Displayed 122 of 122 comments

View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest


This thread is archived, and closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »






Report