If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Mother Nature Network)   If you want your child to be a problem-solver, put him in preschool. If you want your child to be terrified of all adults who aren't Mommy or Daddy, keep him in your home until kindergarten   (mnn.com) divider line 164
    More: Obvious, preschools, kindergartens  
•       •       •

8032 clicks; posted to Main » on 13 Aug 2012 at 6:58 AM   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»



164 Comments   (+0 »)
   
View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest

Archived thread

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | » | Last | Show all
 
2012-08-13 09:39:28 AM
Ah yes, the "molding" approach to raising children. And let's not forget how important it is that children become "socialized," no matter if they're naturally introverted, shy, or just don't care for people much. This is the only way your kids can fit in in the modern world!

I (and my siblings) are living proof of what happen when parents try to "mold" their kids. None of us turned out OK, and 2 of us are still trying to figure out what "normal" is. Because we weren't allowed to just grow up, be ourselves, and find out what kind of people we were, when we grew up. We needed to be molded into good citizens. And we are--you'd never even know that my sister is a psychopath, unless you know her well.
 
2012-08-13 09:40:09 AM
what_now: My children will be working a 12 hour shift in the mill by the time they're 7, so I'm not too concerned about this.

Small hands weave the finest cloth.
 
2012-08-13 09:43:02 AM
HotIgneous Intruder: sid244: - How "clicks" work

As in safe cracking?
I think you mean, "cliques."


The safecracking program at my kid's preschool is terrific. He can't speak in full sentences yet, but he can open an AMSEC 5019 in 24 seconds.
 
2012-08-13 09:44:24 AM
Went to preschool, was a lot more social with peers as a kid, discovered most people suck when I was a teenager, still feel that way at nearly 30. So while it probably prepared me better for kindergarten class where we learned to tie our shoes and had milk and nap breaks, I don't think it had much more of an effect on me.
 
2012-08-13 09:44:48 AM
cryinoutloud: We needed to be molded into good citizens. And we are--you'd never even know that my sister is a psychopath, unless you know her well.

Fit right into the American Empire.

/Like goot Chermans.
 
2012-08-13 09:45:41 AM
Monkeylint: We stopped bottles cold and switched to sippy cups.

Despite the recent fad research, the long term studies have shown that keeping your child on bottles until their fifth birthday leads to greater academic success than forcing them to use a sippy cup by their first birthday. Mostly because they'll have a lot of time to study when they are ostracized for being a bottle sucking douche bag.
 
2012-08-13 09:47:40 AM
i HAd preeskool and i HatE peeple! Not juss sum of them, aLL peeple!! Hate em!!

/Stop lookin at mE!!
 
2012-08-13 09:50:29 AM
Why should I have to take care of my own children?
 
2012-08-13 09:52:01 AM
All my kids socialization has been learned from DVDs of The Wire set to play over and over.
It's all there: Office politics, product sales and marketing, greed, honesty, the role of police in society, etc.
 
2012-08-13 09:52:48 AM
Good parenting and good teaching are what they are, and will provide children the best platform for future success. You can get both from preschool or home-school.

BUT, not every kid does well being thrust into kindergarten with no preparation - and every parent should consider testing out socialization activities ahead of time if for no other reason than to see if there are any problems on the horizon. If your kid screams bloody murder endlessly when you drop them off and walk out the door, you might want to work that out BEFORE kindergarten so they can actually learn and participate in it instead of being a total pain in everyone's ass. Not saying full-time daycare from 18 months - 6 years is the way to go, but it's worth testing the waters, both for you the parent and for the kid.
 
2012-08-13 09:55:18 AM
HotIgneous Intruder: sid244: - How "clicks" work

As in safe cracking?
I think you mean, "cliques."


(home schooled)
 
2012-08-13 09:59:55 AM
Monkeylint: Here's my serious answer to your somewhat tongue-in-cheek request. With both of us working, some kind of day care was necessary. We don't have family close enough to watch him every day, and we didn't like the idea of a nanny since that seemed too much like giving up our role to one person without the benefit of having lots of other kids around to socialize, so we put our son in a pre-school with an infant/toddler program when my wife had to go back to work when he was 6 months.

All depends on the place, I suppose. I saw some daycare/preschool centers that were little more than kiddie warehouses, dark, depressing, chaotic. The one we ended up with was on the upper-middle end of the price range but has a big open building with lots of natural light, big outdoor play areas, and the place is really run like a school, even with a motor/communication skills "curriculum" for the infants. For us and our boy, it's been a great experience.

He loves going to school. He's got his little buddies and his routine, and being around other kids all the time he's ahead of the curve on verbal and motor skills development and even picked up a little sign language from watching the few signers in the group. Kids' brains are amazing. And in the evenings and the weekends, we spend as much time with him as possible: take him places, run around outside, play with him. I think it's a good balance. He's very social and takes to new people with very little adjustment: he met 4 new adults with us this weekend and within a few minutes was playing with them. We don't know many people with kids his age, so I really like the socialization aspect, and being first time parents with virtually no experience with infants/toddlers it helped to have the staff, other parents, and kids around to get ideas and get a feel for where he is in development compared to others

TLDR: Pre-school is working great for my kid, even starting as an infant.


Thanks ! My wife is planning the three months off for maternity but that's it, daycare after that. We are fortunate to make pretty good money. We bought a new home in a new neighborhood with at least 10+ kids all running around (ages 3-7 with three somewhat newborns). Our parents may watch the girl once or twice a week, but that would be their decision not because we cannot afford daycare, by request, etc. It may change after our second, whenever that will be.

You hear studies and articles, like linked here, saying daycare breeds disruptive children. I figure we will do our best, set good examples and have unwavering love.

\my tongue in cheek is only because this is fark, where it's not only expected, it's welcomed :)
 
2012-08-13 09:59:56 AM
cefm: and will provide children the best platform for future success.

Because ... SUCCESS!

Success. That word means nothing. It's vague and irrelevant in the context of creating functional, thinking adults.

/In the United States, it mostly means taking as much of other people's money as possible, as quickly as possible, then flaunting it.
 
2012-08-13 10:00:03 AM
So according to this before the time of Box school education, EVERYONE was maladjusted. I don't think so.
 
2012-08-13 10:01:15 AM
HotIgneous Intruder: All my kids socialization has been learned from DVDs of The Wire set to play over and over.
It's all there: Office politics, product sales and marketing, greed, honesty, the role of police in society, etc.


...how to shoot Omar to impress your other 10 year old friends...
 
2012-08-13 10:03:22 AM
attention span of a retarded fruit fly: So according to this before the time of Box school education, EVERYONE was maladjusted. I don't think so.

If anything, there are more sociopaths per square foot than ever.
 
2012-08-13 10:05:00 AM
brainlordmesomorph: I didn't go to preschool, or to kindergarten, my first day of school was 1st grade.
And I turned out just fine ...NARF!


Quiet, Pinky! Or I shall have to hurt you!

/Are you pondering what I'm pondering?
 
2012-08-13 10:05:30 AM
When I was a kid I don't recall anyone sending their kids to pre-school.
My mom was a single mother of 3, so I think that she would be the type of person to benefit from having someplace to send us kids while she was working. . . .

blah, blah, blah, we all grew up to be productive members of society and law abiding citizens with plenty of friends, and families of our own . . .

/Of course, my story begins in nineteen-dickety-two. We had to say "dickety" because the Kaiser had stolen our word "twenty". I chased that rascal to get it back, but gave up after dickety-six miles.
 
2012-08-13 10:11:17 AM
Never send your daughter to pre-school... it's the first step in her learning "no, that's NOT how a Daddy is supposed to show his love".
 
2012-08-13 10:16:36 AM
attention span of a retarded fruit fly: So according to this before the time of Box school education, EVERYONE was maladjusted. I don't think so.

Before preschool, rich kids stayed with their nannies and maybe saw their parents once a day when they were trotted out to impress guests. Poor kids hung around the family workshop or farm while the parents worked, or got sent to whatever gin-sodden neighbour or relative would watch them on the cheap. It was the number of poor babies dying in the latter conditions that prompted the French to institute national daycare.
 
2012-08-13 10:34:03 AM
Preschool made me terrified of teachers/adults. Terrified of how stupid they are.

I have several distinct memories from preschool. The main thing I remember is how boring and menial all the busy work was. "Find and cut out dogs from these magazines... Now find and cut out girl faces... Now find and cut out boy faces". Even at 4 or 5 years old I was thinking "WTF is this shiat? Do they think we are stupid?" That set the tone for the rest of my school career because I literally gave up right then and never wanted anything to do with school.
 
2012-08-13 10:35:47 AM
vodka: Preschool made me terrified of teachers/adults. Terrified of how stupid they are.

I have several distinct memories from preschool. The main thing I remember is how boring and menial all the busy work was. "Find and cut out dogs from these magazines... Now find and cut out girl faces... Now find and cut out boy faces". Even at 4 or 5 years old I was thinking "WTF is this shiat? Do they think we are stupid?" That set the tone for the rest of my school career because I literally gave up right then and never wanted anything to do with school.


Too Cool for Pre-school.

I like it.
 
2012-08-13 10:48:45 AM
Went to preschool. Was a problem-solver. Was still terrified of non-parental adults for years.
 
2012-08-13 10:52:54 AM
Sybarite: Studies so far seem to point to preschool being a good idea.

The article mainly deals with language skills, not social adaptation.
 
2012-08-13 11:03:31 AM
hasty ambush: Of course there is always the governmemt or "professionals" can raise your kids better than parents can crowd.

Given what I see around this area on a regular basis, I'm beginning to think a Skinner box could raise some people's kids better than they can. Yes, some people here really are that scary.
 
2012-08-13 11:07:44 AM
vodka: Preschool made me terrified of teachers/adults. Terrified of how stupid they are.

I have several distinct memories from preschool. The main thing I remember is how boring and menial all the busy work was. "Find and cut out dogs from these magazines... Now find and cut out girl faces... Now find and cut out boy faces". Even at 4 or 5 years old I was thinking "WTF is this shiat? Do they think we are stupid?" That set the tone for the rest of my school career because I literally gave up right then and never wanted anything to do with school.


So I guess your life is a giant refutation of the usefulness of education?
Or are you one of the farkers who never finished the eighth grade, yet owns his own computer consulting company, drives a Corvette and owns his own seaside home free and clear no mortgage?
 
2012-08-13 11:10:22 AM
vodka: Preschool made me terrified of teachers/adults. Terrified of how stupid they are.

I have several distinct memories from preschool. The main thing I remember is how boring and menial all the busy work was. "Find and cut out dogs from these magazines... Now find and cut out girl faces... Now find and cut out boy faces". Even at 4 or 5 years old I was thinking "WTF is this shiat? Do they think we are stupid?" That set the tone for the rest of my school career because I literally gave up right then and never wanted anything to do with school.


God forbid you'd devise a more complicated task for yourself that gave the appearance of you working while simultaneously fulfilling your own objectives.
 
2012-08-13 11:10:36 AM
Monkeylint: HotIgneous Intruder: sid244: - How "clicks" work

As in safe cracking?
I think you mean, "cliques."

The safecracking program at my kid's preschool is terrific. He can't speak in full sentences yet, but he can open an AMSEC 5019 in 24 seconds.


Is this your kid?
 
2012-08-13 11:16:26 AM
Life was simpler back in my day.

There were Indoor Children and Outdoor Children. Outdoor children roamed the woods and fields, semi-feral, or roamed the village street side-by-side, sometimes as many as seven at a time, which I still regard as low class behaviour, as it blocks the road and is therefore inconsiderate, although traffic-calming. Respectable people walk two-by-two or in single file, leaving enough room for people and vehicles coming the other way. They don't bogart the street (or streets, as may be the case in larger villages).

Indoor Children played the piano or some other musical instrument, or had parents who were Devout Christians, and thus were hideous pale monsters who could not be trusted out of sight. Also, they were prone to outbreaks of piano-playing at inopportune moments, such as any time that your parents visited their parents.

There are still two basic types of children: those who misbehave when their parents are not around, and those who misbehave when their parents are around. The latter are worse--some of the children who misbehave when their parents are not around are teachable, with the aid of discrete threats or violence, but the children who misbehave under the blythely blind gaze of their parents are as incorrigible as their parents. If you are going to discipline children of the Second Variety, you might as well beat up their parents as well, if you are up to it. They are often bullies, however, and self-righteous bullies at that. Best to give them a miss.

Still, Indoor Children were to be pitied, because despite their psychosis, they were missing out on life and probably several different kinds of immunity.

The fable of the monkey who smothered her favourite child to death, while the unloved child prospered is still valid today. The more you protect people, the less they are able to fend for themselves. Humans are lazy as well as stupid, and don't learn what they don't need. This is why the best way to learn a language to is to get a job in, say, a lumber camp where, if you don't learn to ask in French for food to be passed at the camp table, you don't eat. After real life immersion, a girlfriend or boyfriend with unilingual family is best. You have to learn the language to stop his parents and siblings from saying awful things to your face.

By the standards of my day, we were probably Good Children, which is to say Sissies and a Terrible Example to all children, but by today's standards we were Nielson Muntz--able to thrive despite total parental neglect and even malice.

Now you must excuse me, as I have to go play in the traffic. Children playing in the streets make the best speed bumps a leafy suburb can have.
 
2012-08-13 11:20:28 AM
I have started my 4 month old on a daily regimen of algebra, geometry, basic physics, foreign language study (French, Spanish, and Chinese), vocabulary, culinary arts, graphic design, and many other subjects. She hasn't really taken to my teachings as of yet, but I certainly feel superior to any of the other parents in this thread. As a special treat today, I am taking her to the gym in 26 minutes.
 
2012-08-13 11:24:53 AM
kingflower: I have started my 4 month old on a daily regimen of algebra, geometry, basic physics, foreign language study (French, Spanish, and Chinese), vocabulary, culinary arts, graphic design, and many other subjects. She hasn't really taken to my teachings as of yet, but I certainly feel superior to any of the other parents in this thread. As a special treat today, I am taking her to the gym in 26 minutes.

Watch out boys! She'll one day have a corvette and still be a gold digger because she can, she's that awesome.
 
2012-08-13 11:25:11 AM
robodog: Basily Gourt: Kindergarten IS preschool, for christ's sake.

Not any more, at least around here kids are expected to know their ABC's before kindergarten and they start doing math part way through the year.

I sent my sons to preschool not because I was unable to teach them their ABC's, but because they both needed speech therapy and pre-k kids are a LOT less judgemental than older kids about that sort of thing.


If they don't know their ABCs by the time they are in K then jesus what were you doing with the kids for 5 years. My kids are in Pre-K and it's great they learn a lot and they get the structure of the teacher/student role down. Oldest starts K soon and he's exicited to go which probably isn't the case with kids that don't get any kind of school before it.

To each their own and those studies are messing up Pre-K (which is has guidelines from the State on what needs to be taught) and just daycare. I will say when we had our one in daycare he did pick up on some bad habits and some interesting words.
 
2012-08-13 11:27:30 AM
Starfly: As a first time dad in a few months, I look forward to hearing all stories of other farkers on raising their kids and why or why not they placed them in daycare/pre-school.

yes i am not expecting good, valid advice :)


I'm a stay-at-home dad of a 3 year old, and I feel very strongly that kids need preschool. It's about learning things like sitting still for 10 minutes while the teacher reads a story, or lining up, or how to interact with other kids. Perhaps most importantly, it's about the kid's self confidence.

Bborchar already said it, but daycare and preschool are two different things. Daycare is for watching kids while parents are at work, and the kid is often there for 8 or 9 hours a day. Preschool is for learning skills that a kid will need as a kindergartener, and meet just a few hours a week. My kid's preschool is 6 hours a week.
 
2012-08-13 11:27:46 AM
Worldwalker: hasty ambush: Of course there is always the governmemt or "professionals" can raise your kids better than parents can crowd.

Given what I see around this area on a regular basis, I'm beginning to think a Skinner box could raise some people's kids better than they can. Yes, some people here really are that scary.


Agreed. Notice all the religious nut bags in this country. Do we really want them teaching science to the next generation? Seems like after college most adults will become more intelligent and skilled at whatever career they have, and complete dumbasses at everything else.
 
2012-08-13 11:28:28 AM
TNel: If they don't know their ABCs by the time they are in K then jesus what were you doing with the kids for 5 years.

What part of "needed speech therapy" did you not understand?
 
2012-08-13 11:30:54 AM
Starfly: kingflower: I have started my 4 month old on a daily regimen of algebra, geometry, basic physics, foreign language study (French, Spanish, and Chinese), vocabulary, culinary arts, graphic design, and many other subjects. She hasn't really taken to my teachings as of yet, but I certainly feel superior to any of the other parents in this thread. As a special treat today, I am taking her to the gym in 26 minutes.

Watch out boys! She'll one day have a corvette and still be a gold digger because she can, she's that awesome.


I'm hoping that she will eventually hook up with John Fitzgerald Page's offspring and go on to form a race of super-humans, super AWESOME humans.
 
2012-08-13 11:33:34 AM
kingflower: Starfly: kingflower: I have started my 4 month old on a daily regimen of algebra, geometry, basic physics, foreign language study (French, Spanish, and Chinese), vocabulary, culinary arts, graphic design, and many other subjects. She hasn't really taken to my teachings as of yet, but I certainly feel superior to any of the other parents in this thread. As a special treat today, I am taking her to the gym in 26 minutes.

Watch out boys! She'll one day have a corvette and still be a gold digger because she can, she's that awesome.

I'm hoping that she will eventually hook up with John Fitzgerald Page's offspring and go on to form a race of super-humans, super AWESOME humans.


Or she'll graduate high school, won't be able to find a job, will join the military and get killed in a car bombing in Southwest Asia at the age of 24.

At which point she'll be lauded as a HERO and a SUCCESS.
 
2012-08-13 11:34:32 AM
HotIgneous Intruder: Or she'll graduate high school, won't be able to find a job, will join the military and get killed in a car bombing in Southwest Asia at the age of 24.

At which point she'll be lauded as a HERO and a SUCCESS.


You do work hard in these things, don't you?
 
2012-08-13 11:35:09 AM
If you want your child to be a problem-solver, put him in preschool.

Brought to you by the American Preschool System.
 
2012-08-13 11:49:42 AM
Mother Jones Pimping For Teachers Unions, Volume VII™
 
2012-08-13 11:55:39 AM
vodka: Preschool made me terrified of teachers/adults. Terrified of how stupid they are.

I have several distinct memories from preschool. The main thing I remember is how boring and menial all the busy work was. "Find and cut out dogs from these magazines... Now find and cut out girl faces... Now find and cut out boy faces". Even at 4 or 5 years old I was thinking "WTF is this shiat? Do they think we are stupid?" That set the tone for the rest of my school career because I literally gave up right then and never wanted anything to do with school.


Ditto, though when my daughter entered preschool, I got the parents-eye view. Yes, Half of them ARE that stupid. It generally fell on economic lines.

I'm always torn listening to Hannity. No, the government can't afford to offer free (quality) daycare, but we aren't doing ourselves any favors by telling them they are on their own. I'm grateful for being born to upper-middle class, and for being able to pass those benefits on.
 
2012-08-13 12:14:21 PM
spentmiles: God forbid you'd devise a more complicated task for yourself that gave the appearance of you working while simultaneously fulfilling your own objectives.

Yeah because that's exactly what a 5 year old would think to do during their first experiences on their own out in the world. Especially since it's not like the school tried to hammer the point home that you had to follow the rules or bad things would happen.
 
2012-08-13 12:44:43 PM
farkindood: Homeschooler, getting a kick out of these replies.

Ditto, also pretty dang social for an engineer if I do say so myself
 
2012-08-13 12:46:41 PM
What if your parents run a preschool out of their home? Do you get the problem-solving skills and a fear of adults?
 
2012-08-13 12:50:57 PM
Whether you send your kid to preschool or not all depends on whether you are actually a good parent, and have good habits to show your kids. 9 times out of 10 this isn't the case, especially if you think you are such a parent. So preschool is better because even if the teacher is not that great the interaction with other kids will broaden their minds.
 
2012-08-13 12:51:13 PM
In America it's simply way too expensive to have a kid.

Either one parent has to put their career on hold for 5 years or you have to pay through the nose to babysitters/daycare.

You have to buy into a good school district or pay for private school.

Not to mention paying for things like sports teams, etc so they'll be well-rounded individuals and get into colleges.

This makes me sad
 
2012-08-13 12:54:04 PM
stenciledb: Whether you send your kid to preschool or not all depends on whether you are actually a good parent, and have good habits to show your kids. 9 times out of 10 this isn't the case, especially if you think you are such a parent.

Reading this made me seasick.
 
2012-08-13 12:56:18 PM
spentmiles: Just what American mothers need, another opportunity to separate themselves from their children. Can't have a child crying for your attention while your trying to concentrate on the television. If these stay-at-home women were actual mothers, we wouldn't need trained professionals to raise our children. I guarantee the same women who send their children to pre-school also plopped them down in front of the television for 85% of their waking lives. Kids thrive on interaction and attention. Without it, we end up wondering why our kids are "sick" with autism and attention deficient disorder. Maybe if there were a lot more parents actually parenting, we wouldn't require these institutions to socialize our children.

I'm not sure if you're serious, but since that view is a fairly common one...autism and ADHD are not rooted in any form of parenting, even abuse. Now, the misdiagnosis of ADHD\ADD is actually linked to adults who expect young boys to sit still and color while their bodies are still telling them 'get up run around and play', but there isn't many of those links for autism. We're just experiencing a rise in all mental illnesses, mostly because we can finally diagnose neurologically-based mental illnesses with accuracy above that of an ape flinging its own shiat.
 
2012-08-13 01:01:57 PM
vodka: Preschool made me terrified of teachers/adults. Terrified of how stupid they are.

I have several distinct memories from preschool. The main thing I remember is how boring and menial all the busy work was. "Find and cut out dogs from these magazines... Now find and cut out girl faces... Now find and cut out boy faces". Even at 4 or 5 years old I was thinking "WTF is this shiat? Do they think we are stupid?" That set the tone for the rest of my school career because I literally gave up right then and never wanted anything to do with school.



Yes, teaching young children hand-eye coordination (cutting things out) and how to identify things in pictures (faces, genders, animals) is a pointless exercise.
 
2012-08-13 01:03:47 PM
The Muthaship: HotIgneous Intruder: Or she'll graduate high school, won't be able to find a job, will join the military and get killed in a car bombing in Southwest Asia at the age of 24.

At which point she'll be lauded as a HERO and a SUCCESS.

You do work hard in these things, don't you?


Only if it looks like hard work to you.

/Yes, I got warehoused in "nursery school" as they called it back then.
 
Displayed 50 of 164 comments

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | » | Last | Show all

View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest


This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »





Report