If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Some World Mag)   David Barton's book "The Jefferson Lies" has been pulled by its publisher for being a pack of lies about Jefferson   (worldmag.com) divider line 201
    More: Amusing  
•       •       •

4428 clicks; posted to Politics » on 09 Aug 2012 at 6:09 PM   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»



201 Comments   (+0 »)
   
View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest

Archived thread

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | » | Last | Show all
 
2012-08-09 06:42:50 PM
It's amusing to me how much conservative christians want to believe that the founding fathers were also conservative christians. The founding fathers were educated intellectuals, which pretty much rules them out of being conservative christians
 
2012-08-09 06:43:20 PM
TheDumbBlonde: xynix:
You're better off being an ex-Southerner if you eat cold fried chicken as a hangover cure, Son.

Best thing ever! Two day old popeyes.. hell yeah. Certainly part of my hangover cure.. I also do the "full irish" at times.

The Cure: Eggs,[...]


Problem solved if you focus right there. Every pro-lifer Southerner knows that Eggs ARE Chickens, Therefore a breakfast containing fried eggs is a fried chicken breakfast

Denny's Prolife Grand-Slam: 2 Pancakes, two trips of bacon, two scrambled chickens.
 
2012-08-09 06:44:27 PM
WhyteRaven74: Smirky the Wonder Chimp: One version of it actually has TJ bringing a waffle iron back from France and starting the tradition. Of course it's Wikipedia, not the Encyclopedia Brittanica, so take it with a grain of whatever seasoning floats your boat.

Actually Jefferson did bring back an assortment of cooking stuff from France. And he did come up with macaroni and cheese, though he called it macaroni pie.


He didn't "come up with it", he merely imported it. It wasn't likely the elbow and cheddar nightmare most Americans eat either. (More likely something like spagetti and parm).
 
2012-08-09 06:44:35 PM
TheBeastOfYuccaFlats: The comments for that article are pretty derpy. One person posting about a turn of phrase meaning that scientists believed plants were sentient and/or sapient at some point in the past.

How do these people even get out of bed in the morning without accidentally killing themselves.


The floor is only three feet down.
 
2012-08-09 06:44:50 PM
Smirky the Wonder Chimp: Nobodyn0se: From the other David Barton thread:

As many of you know, my mother, Judy Jennings, recently ran for Texas State Board of Education. Fark helped her out with donations and spreading the word, but unfortunately she lost her race :(

During the campaign, she and her fellow Democratic SBoE nominee from another district ran a commercial about David Barton (I can't remember the exact reasoning. Barton was an adviser for both their opponents or something). During this commercial, it was claimed that Barton spoke at a white supremacist rally. Barton is now suing my mother and her fellow candidate, claiming the commercial is slander. His defense is (quite literally) "Yes, I spoke at a white supremacist rally, but I didn't know they were white supremacists at the time."

If you'd like more information, or if you'd like to know how you can help, please look up Judy Jennings on the Facebook. She is running for State Board of Education again in 2012, and we would appreciate any support.

Some more information for you:

Link

Link

Link

And here's a link to her Facebook. PLEASE "like" her and spread the word!

Facebook

How does someone NOT know that they're speaking at a gathering of white supremacists? Did they put a bag over his head, drive him along a circuitous route to confuse him, lead him onto the stage and remove the bag long enough for him to make the speech, and then put the bag over his head and remove him from the stage before anyone had a chance to actually speak to him? Or does he simply lets his secretary set up his speaking arrangements sight unseen, and then shuffle out on the stage in a senile haze to vomit forth whatever pseudobiblical, theocratic spew his neurons have haphazardly slammed together only to disappear immediately afterward in a manner not altogether unlike Batman's vanishings after delivering a quiet tip to Commissioner Gordon? Because if he's that incurious about the world he lives in, that would explain a great deal.


I think it's the opposite of this.
 
2012-08-09 06:45:44 PM
Let's try this again.
encrypted-tbn2.google.com
 
2012-08-09 06:46:19 PM
tenpoundsofcheese: Just curious, what were the major "lies" that he claimed?


You're just asking questions, right?
 
2012-08-09 06:47:34 PM
Archie Bunker has been the same since the Jefferson's left Queens
 
2012-08-09 06:50:05 PM
tenpoundsofcheese: Just curious, what were the major "lies" that he claimed?

Without even reading the book, I bet we can guess with at least with 75% accuracy:

- Jefferson was totally down with God and every scrap of Democracy he created was straight from Jesus' lips
- No way Jefferson had Jungle Fever, and you're racist for thinking so
- No really, Jefferson wanted 2012 America to bow in fear of Almighty God every hour of every day
- And even if he didn't, he really wasn't as involved with the Founders as we're lead to believe, he mostly sat outside sniffing opium and killing puppies
- The Louisiana Purchase was all Madison's idea. Also God's.
 
2012-08-09 06:50:18 PM
tenpoundsofcheese: Just curious, what were the major "lies" that he claimed?

Take a drink!
 
2012-08-09 06:50:25 PM
High-paying gig on FOX News in 3...2...


/forward by Glenn Beck says it all
 
2012-08-09 06:53:09 PM
jayhawk88: tenpoundsofcheese: Just curious, what were the major "lies" that he claimed?

Without even reading the book, I bet we can guess with at least with 75% accuracy:

- Jefferson was totally down with God and every scrap of Democracy he created was straight from Jesus' lips
- No way Jefferson had Jungle Fever, and you're racist for thinking so
- No really, Jefferson wanted 2012 America to bow in fear of Almighty God every hour of every day
- And even if he didn't, he really wasn't as involved with the Founders as we're lead to believe, he mostly sat outside sniffing opium and killing puppies
- The Louisiana Purchase was all Madison's idea. Also God's.


Survey says...
 
2012-08-09 06:53:52 PM
 
2012-08-09 06:53:57 PM
jackiepaper: It's amusing to me how much conservative christians want to believe that the founding fathers were also conservative christians. The founding fathers were educated intellectuals, which pretty much rules them out of being conservative christians

The were educated intellectual elitists who loved French culture.
 
2012-08-09 06:55:16 PM
CrackpipeCardozo: If you're looking for a biatch-fest of epic proportions, head over to the Amazon.com customer review section

Also if you want some easy action, check out the Amazon customer tags, page 2 and page 1.
 
2012-08-09 06:55:50 PM
They just don't realize they are slowly destroying the United States from within with their rewriting of history, their manufactured disdain for the federal government, and the placing of induvidual greed over the common good of the nation.
 
2012-08-09 06:56:16 PM
TheDumbBlonde: WhyteRaven74: Smirky the Wonder Chimp: One version of it actually has TJ bringing a waffle iron back from France and starting the tradition. Of course it's Wikipedia, not the Encyclopedia Brittanica, so take it with a grain of whatever seasoning floats your boat.

Actually Jefferson did bring back an assortment of cooking stuff from France. And he did come up with macaroni and cheese, though he called it macaroni pie.

He didn't "come up with it", he merely imported it. It wasn't likely the elbow and cheddar nightmare most Americans eat either. (More likely something like spagetti and parm).



You shut your goddamn commie mouth.
 
2012-08-09 06:56:42 PM
Jefferson, Jeff-er-son
Twelve stories high, made of radiation
 
2012-08-09 06:57:46 PM
TheDumbBlonde: You're better off being an ex-Southerner if you eat cold fried chicken as a hangover cure, Son.

i2.kym-cdn.com
 
2012-08-09 06:58:43 PM
 
2012-08-09 06:59:01 PM
tenpoundsofcheese: Just curious, what were the major "lies" that he claimed?

Apparently, one of the biggest problems with the book is that you wrote the foreword, and you're...well...less than credible, let's say.
 
2012-08-09 07:01:16 PM
Smirky the Wonder Chimp: Nobodyn0se: From the other David Barton thread:

As many of you know, my mother, Judy Jennings, recently ran for Texas State Board of Education. Fark helped her out with donations and spreading the word, but unfortunately she lost her race :(

During the campaign, she and her fellow Democratic SBoE nominee from another district ran a commercial about David Barton (I can't remember the exact reasoning. Barton was an adviser for both their opponents or something). During this commercial, it was claimed that Barton spoke at a white supremacist rally. Barton is now suing my mother and her fellow candidate, claiming the commercial is slander. His defense is (quite literally) "Yes, I spoke at a white supremacist rally, but I didn't know they were white supremacists at the time."

If you'd like more information, or if you'd like to know how you can help, please look up Judy Jennings on the Facebook. She is running for State Board of Education again in 2012, and we would appreciate any support.

Some more information for you:

Link

Link

Link

And here's a link to her Facebook. PLEASE "like" her and spread the word!

Facebook

How does someone NOT know that they're speaking at a gathering of white supremacists? Did they put a bag over his head, drive him along a circuitous route to confuse him, lead him onto the stage and remove the bag long enough for him to make the speech, and then put the bag over his head and remove him from the stage before anyone had a chance to actually speak to him? Or does he simply lets his secretary set up his speaking arrangements sight unseen, and then shuffle out on the stage in a senile haze to vomit forth whatever pseudobiblical, theocratic spew his neurons have haphazardly slammed together only to disappear immediately afterward in a manner not altogether unlike Batman's vanishings after delivering a quiet tip to Commissioner Gordon? Because if he's that incurious about the world he lives in, that would explain a great deal.


i99.photobucket.com

Can relate.
 
2012-08-09 07:01:49 PM
tenpoundsofcheese: Just curious, what were the major "lies" that he claimed?

One example: sections of the constitution were verbatim from Deuteronomy. That's the shiat he puts out in his "history" books. Made up shiat, made up of whole cloth.

Examples HERE
 
2012-08-09 07:05:06 PM
technicolor-misfit: TheDumbBlonde: WhyteRaven74: Smirky the Wonder Chimp: One version of it actually has TJ bringing a waffle iron back from France and starting the tradition. Of course it's Wikipedia, not the Encyclopedia Brittanica, so take it with a grain of whatever seasoning floats your boat.

Actually Jefferson did bring back an assortment of cooking stuff from France. And he did come up with macaroni and cheese, though he called it macaroni pie.

He didn't "come up with it", he merely imported it. It wasn't likely the elbow and cheddar nightmare most Americans eat either. (More likely something like spagetti and parm).


You shut your goddamn commie mouth.


Hey, it's not my fault Jeff was a Franco-phile, brown-sugar loving, dead-broke freakazoid. I love him.
 
2012-08-09 07:10:09 PM
jayhawk88: tenpoundsofcheese: Just curious, what were the major "lies" that he claimed?

Without even reading the book, I bet we can guess with at least with 75% accuracy:

- Jefferson was totally down with God and every scrap of Democracy he created was straight from Jesus' lips
- No way Jefferson had Jungle Fever, and you're racist for thinking so
- No really, Jefferson wanted 2012 America to bow in fear of Almighty God every hour of every day
- And even if he didn't, he really wasn't as involved with the Founders as we're lead to believe, he mostly sat outside sniffing opium and killing puppies
- The Louisiana Purchase was all Madison's idea. Also God's.


I found this on a site that's reasonably sympathetic to Barton, but which summarizes the arguments pretty well:
The "quotes" are Barton's so-called "Lies people believe about Jefferson" and the (parens) are Barton's amazing discovered truths:

"Thomas Jefferson fathered a child with Sally Hemings" (The DNA test results are inconclusive and merely show a Jefferson was their father);
"Thomas Jefferson Founded a Secular University" (The University of Virginia actually waived tuition for those training for the ministry);
"Thomas Jefferson Wrote His Own Bible and Edited Out the Things He Didn't Agree With" (the book was actually a devotional for his own use and included miracles);
"Thomas Jefferson was a Racist Who Opposed Equality for Black Americans" (Jefferson wanted to free his slaves but couldn't pay the heavy taxes required to do so by Virginia law);
"Thomas Jefferson Advocated a Secular Public Square through the Separation of Church and State" (Jefferson actually promoted worship services at the Capitol and attended faithfully);
"Thomas Jefferson Detested the Clergy" (only those who sided with England during the Revolution); and
"Thomas Jefferson was an Atheist and not a Christian" (He certainly held a liberal view of the Bible but adamantly defended his belief in an active God and called himself a Christian).

Based on the reviews, I'm not sure what the kerfuffle was all about (nor why "kerfuffle" is a recognized word); These alleged "lies" about Jefferson are not as "widely believed" or accepted by any student of history, and the (truths) are not as shocking or suppressed as Barton seems to think. For instance, regardless of any DNA work, it's widely accepted Jefferson fathered several of Heming's children, based on the way they were treated by Jefferson during his own lifetime. And it's well-known Jefferson got caught in the classic planter's dilemma about whether to free his slaves as he morally wanted to do or to keep them as he was economically pressed to do. The whole religion thingy is only relevant today, as we all know most of the Founders were deists, a theology quite in keeping with the times.

This sounds like a classic conservative approach: Take a discussion ("did Jefferson father Hemings' children?), make a controversial debate about it where none ever existed (OMG! Some people believe Jefferson didn't have kids with Sally Hemings!), create another side to your debate (Jefferson couldn't have been the father of her children!), discover "proof" for one side or the other, and then write a book exposing these heinous liberal lies about someone we know to have been seated right next to the Son of God. Profit. God knows other writers have done it already.
 
2012-08-09 07:10:10 PM
GAT_00: vernonFL: I know you shouldn't judge a book by its cover, but



"Foreword by Glenn Beck" is where I stopped reading.

You remember when Texas tried to rewrite what Jefferson did two years ago? That was David Barton's work.


That wasn't so much a re-write as it was an assassination and replacing Jefferson with an evil look-alike.
 
2012-08-09 07:10:17 PM
David Barton is a cancer.
 
2012-08-09 07:13:32 PM
YodaTuna: David Barton is a cancer.

Cancer killed my dad...

ANd I still hate it less than this dickhead.
 
2012-08-09 07:15:36 PM
www.skepticmoney.com

tx.english-ch.com
 
2012-08-09 07:18:18 PM
buster_v: [www.skepticmoney.com image 314x390]

[tx.english-ch.com image 346x288]


I swallows more spotted dick than an elderly London shut-in.
 
2012-08-09 07:21:55 PM
TheBeastOfYuccaFlats: How do these people even get out of bed in the morning without accidentally killing themselves.


God has a sense of humor and needs something to fill his day up with laughs
 
2012-08-09 07:21:59 PM
There's a scarily large faction out there that doesn't care whether it's true or not just as long as you stay on message.
 
2012-08-09 07:22:03 PM
Sabyen91: I swallows more spotted dick than an elderly London shut-in

Ewwwwwwwww.
 
2012-08-09 07:23:35 PM
MaxxLarge: I suppose next you're going to tell me that Abraham Lincoln never killed so much as a single vampire.

He did battle Cyborg Booth however.

1.bp.blogspot.com
 
2012-08-09 07:27:50 PM
jackiepaper: It's amusing to me how much conservative christians want to believe that the founding fathers were also conservative christians. The founding fathers were educated intellectuals, which pretty much rules them out of being conservative christians


The vocal Republican Christians today aren't even conservative Christians. They are born again radical Christians. When the Pope believes in evolution and you claim it's a lie, you know you're a toolbag.
 
2012-08-09 07:28:56 PM
edmo: There's a scarily large faction out there that doesn't care whether it's true or not just as long as you stay on message.

Ah yes, the "narrative is more important than fact" crowd. And guess which way they vote.
 
2012-08-09 07:31:12 PM
intelligent comment below: jackiepaper: It's amusing to me how much conservative christians want to believe that the founding fathers were also conservative christians. The founding fathers were educated intellectuals, which pretty much rules them out of being conservative christians


The vocal Republican Christians today aren't even conservative Christians. They are born again radical Christians. When the Pope believes in evolution and you claim it's a lie, you know you're a toolbag.


No, that's just because Catholics aren't REAL Christians and they have lost their way. Because of that, they are going straight to hell.

Gotta preach the message bro!
 
2012-08-09 07:32:48 PM
tenpoundsofcheese: Just curious, what were the major "lies" that he claimed?

tedmcginley.com
 
2012-08-09 07:33:46 PM
heavymetal: They just don't realize they are slowly destroying the United States from within with their rewriting of history, their manufactured disdain for the federal government, and the placing of induvidual greed over the common good of the nation.

Quoted for truthiness.
 
2012-08-09 07:35:17 PM
Gyrfalcon: Based on the reviews, I'm not sure what the kerfuffle was all about (nor why "kerfuffle" is a recognized word); These alleged "lies" about Jefferson are not as "widely believed" or accepted by any student of history, and the (truths) are not as shocking or suppressed as Barton seems to think. For instance, regardless of any DNA work, it's widely accepted Jefferson fathered several of Heming's children, based on the way they were treated by Jefferson during his own lifetime.

That isn't Barton's argument. He contends that one of Thomas Jefferson's brothers actually had babies with slaves and Tom was totally pure and had nothing to do with it. It's mainly supported by a historical foundation run by Jefferson's descendants who don't want to give Heming's descendants any reason to claim any part of Jefferson's estate.

The whole religion thingy is only relevant today, as we all know most of the Founders were deists, a theology quite in keeping with the times.

Barton is trying really, really hard to paint Jefferson and all of the Founding Fathers as evangelical Christians. Not just that they had religious feelings.
 
2012-08-09 07:41:50 PM
TheDumbBlonde: vernonFL: Fun Fact: Thomas Jefferson invented the soul food chicken and waffles breakfast.

Citation needed. No Southerner I know eats fried chicken for breakfast.


I have, on occasion, eaten chicken and waffles for breakfast. The Southerner has to be well versed in soul food, and must have passed his "Chicken Breast Sandwich" test (a whole chicken breast, bone in, in a bun or between two pieces of white bread), and must have eaten real Brunswick Stew (which isn't properly prepared unless it is indistinguishable from vomit). In addition, it is helpful if said southerner isn't familiar with non-cheese grits, and has had said food with fried catfish and/or raw and/or fried oysters (depending on how close said southerner is from the Atlantic Coast). Oh, and country fried steak is only served with brown gravy and Vidalia Onions, people. (I'm looking at you, Texas)

/born and raised in Georgia. Residing in Texas

Oh, and David Barton is a poophead.
 
2012-08-09 07:42:53 PM
meehaw: Oh, and country fried steak is only served with brown gravy and Vidalia Onions, people. (I'm looking at you, Texas)

BLASPHEMY!
 
2012-08-09 07:45:05 PM
Gyrfalcon: "Thomas Jefferson was a Racist Who Opposed Equality for Black Americans" (Jefferson wanted to free his slaves but couldn't pay the heavy taxes required to do so by Virginia law);

In Notes on the State of Virginia, he says that the slaves will never be able to co-exist with whites, so they should either remain slaves or, if they were to be freed, moved back to Africa.

And he talked several times about freeing his slaves, but in his later years his plantation suffered economically, and so he kept putting off freeing his slaves because he couldn't afford not to have the slave labor.

So I'd give that claim of Barton absolutely no credibility. And since the guy only has a B.A. in Religion from Oral Roberts, and every respectable historian I've heard weigh in has found this guy laughable, I'd be confident in saying nothing he writes isn't heavily distorted to satisfy his agenda.
 
2012-08-09 07:45:56 PM
sprawl15: jayhawk88: tenpoundsofcheese: Just curious, what were the major "lies" that he claimed?

Without even reading the book, I bet we can guess with at least with 75% accuracy:

- Jefferson was totally down with God and every scrap of Democracy he created was straight from Jesus' lips
- No way Jefferson had Jungle Fever, and you're racist for thinking so
- No really, Jefferson wanted 2012 America to bow in fear of Almighty God every hour of every day
- And even if he didn't, he really wasn't as involved with the Founders as we're lead to believe, he mostly sat outside sniffing opium and killing puppies
- The Louisiana Purchase was all Madison's idea. Also God's.

Survey says...

------------------

After a week of voting by readers, David Barton's "The Jefferson Lies" won with some 650 votes, narrowly edging the left-wing historian Howard Zinn's "People's History of the United States," which received 641 votes.

David Kaiser, a professor of military history at the Naval War College, charged "A People's History" - which has sold more than two million copies since its initial publication in 1980 - with damaging the country, "By convincing several generations of Americans that leadership does not matter and that all beneficial change comes from the bottom," he wrote, "it has played a significant role in the destruction of American liberalism."


The butthurt there is epic.
 
2012-08-09 07:46:10 PM
www.bitlogic.com
 
2012-08-09 07:47:39 PM
CrackpipeCardozo: If you're looking for a biatch-fest of epic proportions, head over to the Amazon.com customer review section

This one hit the nail right on the head.

Books like this are written essentially to give ideologues something to quote.
 
2012-08-09 07:47:49 PM
vygramul: TheDumbBlonde: vygramul: I saw this on the shelf at a bookstore in Charlottesville, VA. I took a look, say it had a forward by Glenn Beck, and put it back down, wondering how long it would be before roaming hordes of UVA students burned piles of them.

/UVA was the university founded by Jefferson

WOW. Who knew that? Thanks for heads up.

Normally, I wouldn't have said anything, but a few threads ago a couple of people went apeshiat over someone using "UVA" without explaining what it was.


When is there going to be another Cville Fark party?
 
2012-08-09 07:48:06 PM
Nobodyn0se: meehaw: Oh, and country fried steak is only served with brown gravy and Vidalia Onions, people. (I'm looking at you, Texas)

BLASPHEMY!


You sound as if you are wearing a cowboy hat. Take your sawmill gravy and go put it on a biscuit, or something.

(Actually, Babe's Fried Chicken has the best white gravy I've ever tasted, and I would be happy to have it on my country fried steak. But please don't tell mom.)
 
2012-08-09 07:48:26 PM
Insert Death to Smooch....

FatSteveWasted: Can relate


Ok... it's covered....
 
2012-08-09 07:49:37 PM
fusillade762: sprawl15: jayhawk88: tenpoundsofcheese: Just curious, what were the major "lies" that he claimed?

Without even reading the book, I bet we can guess with at least with 75% accuracy:

- Jefferson was totally down with God and every scrap of Democracy he created was straight from Jesus' lips
- No way Jefferson had Jungle Fever, and you're racist for thinking so
- No really, Jefferson wanted 2012 America to bow in fear of Almighty God every hour of every day
- And even if he didn't, he really wasn't as involved with the Founders as we're lead to believe, he mostly sat outside sniffing opium and killing puppies
- The Louisiana Purchase was all Madison's idea. Also God's.

Survey says...

------------------

After a week of voting by readers, David Barton's "The Jefferson Lies" won with some 650 votes, narrowly edging the left-wing historian Howard Zinn's "People's History of the United States," which received 641 votes.

David Kaiser, a professor of military history at the Naval War College, charged "A People's History" - which has sold more than two million copies since its initial publication in 1980 - with damaging the country, "By convincing several generations of Americans that leadership does not matter and that all beneficial change comes from the bottom," he wrote, "it has played a significant role in the destruction of American liberalism."

The butthurt there is epic.


Like I said in the last thread, Zinn doesn't practice the most thorough of historiography in People's History, and the book certainly has an agenda, but it's not exactly in the realm of lying for political purposes that Barton, DiLorenzo, and O'Reilly engage in - or the outright bullshiat in 1421.
 
Displayed 50 of 201 comments

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | » | Last | Show all

View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest


This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »





Report