If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Think Progress)   In their latest move to boost the job market, Senate GOP moves to block home health care workers from receiving minimum wage   (thinkprogress.org) divider line 232
    More: Asinine, Senate GOP, home health care, GOP, Fair Labor Standards Act, Lamar Alexander, health care providers  
•       •       •

3836 clicks; posted to Politics » on 16 Jun 2012 at 7:52 PM   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»



232 Comments   (+0 »)
   
View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest

Archived thread

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | » | Last | Show all
 
2012-06-16 09:13:21 PM
Is this the new thing for rethuglicans? Pander to baby boomers?
 
2012-06-16 09:13:45 PM
dosboot: Marcus Aurelius: If those people are making under $20 an hour, there's something seriously farking wrong with this country.

My dad has been bed bound for over 2 years. He requires two attendants 24 hours a day, seven days a week. I couldn't afford to pay the helpers minimum wage. Instead I pay $140 a day, plus free room and board. The alternative is putting my dad in a nursing home which based upon my experience is not an acceptable due to the mal and mistreatment of the patients.c.

For all you calling for minimum wage, I hope you have saved your money so that you can care for your parents. Unless of course you expect the taxpayers to foot the bill.


Don't gotta worry about that both my parents died before I turned 25
 
2012-06-16 09:16:10 PM
MaudlinMutantMollusk: WTF is wrong with these people?

/seriously... WTF?


They want to legally pay what they currently pay to the illegal mexican who takes care of their mom.
 
2012-06-16 09:19:15 PM
Given that these aging Baby Boomers overwhelmingly vote republican against their own self-interests, I say fark em. Let them shiat themselves and die off early. It's do this country a world of good. This is the shiat they voted for, let them deal with it. I have zero pity for these assholes.

/ex-republican
 
2012-06-16 09:22:18 PM
Johnny Swank: Given that these aging Baby Boomers overwhelmingly vote republican against their own self-interests, I say fark em. Let them shiat themselves and die off early. It's do this country a world of good. This is the shiat they voted for, let them deal with it. I have zero pity for these assholes.



Yup. That's what this really is about. Welcome to Generational Warfare
 
2012-06-16 09:22:31 PM
ToxicMunkee: Don't let these people have money to put into the economy, whatever you do!

They'd probably just fritter it away on food and health care anyway.
 
2012-06-16 09:22:53 PM
dosboot: Marcus Aurelius: If those people are making under $20 an hour, there's something seriously farking wrong with this country.

My dad has been bed bound for over 2 years. He requires two attendants 24 hours a day, seven days a week. I couldn't afford to pay the helpers minimum wage. Instead I pay $140 a day, plus free room and board. The alternative is putting my dad in a nursing home which based upon my experience is not an acceptable due to the mal and mistreatment of the patients.c.

For all you calling for minimum wage, I hope you have saved your money so that you can care for your parents. Unless of course you expect the taxpayers to foot the bill.


Goddammit, you teabaggers are the whiniest most entitled bunch of assholes who have ever set foot on this planet. Worse than the Roman aristocracy. Worse than the Chinese emperors and the Saudi royal house combined. You bastards think that you have the right to employ slaves to do your work.
 
2012-06-16 09:23:40 PM
It's an entire industry that functions this way... if they were worth more they'd be paid more. that's how it works. Don't cry, it's their own faults.
 
2012-06-16 09:31:20 PM
Smirky the Wonder Chimp: They'd probably just fritter it away on food and health care anyway.

Yeah, that money can be better used to bet on the people who own their houses defaulting!
 
2012-06-16 09:33:04 PM
Britney Spear's Speculum: Johnny Swank: Given that these aging Baby Boomers overwhelmingly vote republican against their own self-interests, I say fark em. Let them shiat themselves and die off early. It's do this country a world of good. This is the shiat they voted for, let them deal with it. I have zero pity for these assholes.



Yup. That's what this really is about. Welcome to Generational Warfare


If it's generational warfare, the boomers are clearly winning. I have no sympathy for folks that voted against their interest for 30+ years whining that the policy results of said votes are coming to roost in their last years. Fark em.
 
2012-06-16 09:34:24 PM
You all got trolled as shiat. Nothing like this is going on.

There are issues around companies that provide 24 hour a day coverage in homes. They now have to provide it in shifts, not as 24/7 live in companions that sleep at night and do their own thing around the home when they aren't needed. For years, these companion caregivers were paid a rate that came to under minimum if you factored in all 24 hours. They really aren't on all 24.

These live in companions are an affordable alternative to nursing home care that was deep sixed when the busy bodies insisted that they should be paid minimum for all 24 hours. Everybody lost. These were sweet gigs where you had your own room or even apartment in the house and just had to be available. You 'worked' about 5 hours a day. There were respite workers if you needed to be away from the home or run errands.

Think Progress is FOS
 
2012-06-16 09:35:02 PM
RobertBruce: It's an entire industry that functions this way... if they were worth more they'd be paid more. that's how it works. Don't cry, it's their own faults.

Yes whatever you do dont look any deeper into the issue than that. Your comprehension of the issue is breathtaking in its scope and insight.
 
2012-06-16 09:35:38 PM
Wait, wait, I thought the elderly voted Republican. If that's the case, why would they support a measure that would limit their home healthcare? The elderly are all about living forever and putting whatever they can afford to that end.
 
2012-06-16 09:38:13 PM
Johnny Swank: If it's generational warfare, the boomers are clearly winning. I have no sympathy for folks that voted against their interest for 30+ years whining that the policy results of said votes are coming to roost in their last years. Fark em.


That's a nice pension you have there. It would be a shame if something were to happen to it.
 
2012-06-16 09:40:24 PM
sk8r: There are issues around companies that provide 24 hour a day coverage in homes. They now have to provide it in shifts, not as 24/7 live in companions that sleep at night and do their own thing around the home when they aren't needed. For years, these companion caregivers were paid a rate that came to under minimum if you factored in all 24 hours. They really aren't on all 24.

Why shouldn't those care givers get paid the whole time they are on duty? Its not like they get to live their own lives during that time. I have friends that do this for a living and it really impacts their personal lives. They cant be home, they cant bring their partner or date over with them when they work at night. They must be ready to wake up at a moments notice to deal with any manner of unpleasant tasks. Its a difficult and important job and should be compensated accordingly.
 
2012-06-16 09:41:30 PM
If they succeed in this the funny part will be that when they are struck down by illness or just get old it'll be those underpaid home care workers that have the ability to pull their plug.

And I'm sure many with long memories would take that opportunity willingly.
 
2012-06-16 09:43:54 PM
I'm so tired of the GOP, their evil and their shamelessness. I just can't with these motherf*ckers anymore.
 
2012-06-16 09:44:57 PM
Cheesus: forgotmydamnusername: fusillade762: I guess they'll just have to supplement their income by stealing grandma's pills and selling them on the street.

The home health care worker tending to my terminally ill uncle stole his USGI Remington-Rand 1911A1, and various other smallish, salable household items not nailed down at the time. I think it's safe to say they already do that.

Because if 1 does it, they all do it.


No, but certainly some of them do it. The fact that there's lack of professionalism and people augmenting their income through theft as it is, suggests that maybe they're already underpaid.
 
2012-06-16 09:45:06 PM
Whose business is it of anyone aside from home health care workers and their employers how much money they make?

Don't like the money? Don't take the job.

Or better yet, learn how to stand up for YOUR OWN SELFISH INTEREST and negotiate an acceptable salary.
 
2012-06-16 09:48:38 PM
Mugato: Why don't these people just tie a girl to some rail road tracks and complete the image?

They'd need to find someone to knot the ropes.
 
2012-06-16 09:49:40 PM
quickdraw: sk8r: There are issues around companies that provide 24 hour a day coverage in homes. They now have to provide it in shifts, not as 24/7 live in companions that sleep at night and do their own thing around the home when they aren't needed. For years, these companion caregivers were paid a rate that came to under minimum if you factored in all 24 hours. They really aren't on all 24.

Why shouldn't those care givers get paid the whole time they are on duty? Its not like they get to live their own lives during that time. I have friends that do this for a living and it really impacts their personal lives. They cant be home, they cant bring their partner or date over with them when they work at night. They must be ready to wake up at a moments notice to deal with any manner of unpleasant tasks. Its a difficult and important job and should be compensated accordingly.


They really aren't on duty 24/7 in these cases. They have to be provided 8 hours of uninterrupted sleep time at night and they can surf the net in their apartment while they aren't needed. They certainly can have partners/friends over depending on the situations. Many of these live in companions come in husband and wife pairs. If you know anyone who has to get up at night to deal with 'unpleasant tasks' then there are labor law violations afoot. Elders using the 24/7 companion live ins aren't the 'unpleasant task' level of care and they are independent enough to not have to wake someone at night unless it is a dire emergency.

The worker you describe is working in 8 or 12 hour shifts at night and they should be receiving minimum or more and they should be AWAKE.
 
2012-06-16 09:51:28 PM
Lernaeus: Whose business is it of anyone aside from home health care workers and their employers how much money they make?
Don't like the money? Don't take the job.

Or better yet, learn how to stand up for YOUR OWN SELFISH INTEREST and negotiate an acceptable salary.


So home health care workers should unionize or those on home health should just die off?
 
2012-06-16 09:59:59 PM
I rarely venture into the politics tab. Now I know how the real lawyers on Fark feel when the GED lawyers whip it out.

I'll just finish loading my gun and sipping on this whiskey while I real this thread.

Former CMS worker- Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Nurse manger for nice home care company- we pay WAY above minimum. Amazed at what I'm reading here. Please don't vote anymore.

Just put up the Welcome to Fark meme. I like the crying guy the best.
 
2012-06-16 10:03:44 PM
Raspil: I'm so tired of the GOP, their evil and their shamelessness. I just can't with these motherf*ckers anymore.

As compared to the democrats that insist on taking so much from your paycheck that you'll never be able to rise above the place where you entered the work force?

Neither one are right. We need something different. This same shiat different day thing hasn't worked for decades. Don't be part of the problem.
 
2012-06-16 10:08:33 PM
Smeggy Smurf: As compared to the democrats that insist on taking so much from your paycheck that you'll never be able to rise above the place where you entered the work force?

Oh no! A CEO that can't rise up the pay scale!?! The HORROR
 
2012-06-16 10:09:52 PM
I look forward to the next time there is a clamor for malpractice reform. There are a few choice arguments in here that will be nice to reheat.
 
2012-06-16 10:11:16 PM
Smeggy Smurf: As compared to the democrats that insist on taking so much from your paycheck that you'll never be able to rise above the place where you entered the work force?

No greater a force to delude ones self exists than the fear of taxes.
 
2012-06-16 10:11:45 PM
Raspil: I'm so tired of the GOP, their evil and their shamelessness. I just can't with these motherf*ckers anymore.

encrypted-tbn2.google.com
 
2012-06-16 10:13:29 PM
Smeggy Smurf: Raspil: I'm so tired of the GOP, their evil and their shamelessness. I just can't with these motherf*ckers anymore.

As compared to the democrats that insist on taking so much from your paycheck that you'll never be able to rise above the place where you entered the work force?

Neither one are right. We need something different. This same shiat different day thing hasn't worked for decades. Don't be part of the problem.


WTF are you talking about? Did you enter the workforce making $100K, and never marry? Even if you did, how does that make you ineligible for raises or promotions? The social welfare and labor policies that came in with Reagan are better correlated with stagnating upward mobility.
 
2012-06-16 10:15:39 PM
The Name: dosboot: For all you calling for minimum wage, I hope you have saved your money so that you can care for your parents. Unless of course you expect the taxpayers to foot the bill.

God forbid taxpayers should have to subsidize such evils as livable wages and quality care for the elderly.


Medicare is already one of the largest expenditures of the federal government. You really think the Feds should be paying 40k a year per senior for live-in help? At some point you have to ask what is actually a reasonable accommodation. Sorry, but not every elderly person gets a live in care take. The United States, nor any rational society, can afford it. Seniors average 300k in Medicare spending. They paid in less than 100k. Think about that. Not everything can be paid for magically cause it's the "right thing to do." If you continue on that path current workers are essentially slaves of the elderly.
 
2012-06-16 10:15:47 PM
Smeggy Smurf: As compared to the democrats that insist on taking so much from your paycheck that you'll never be able to rise above the place where you entered the work force?

You're stupid. Not because you haven't studied or learned anything, but because you regurgitate the propaganda you've been fed without questioning its accuracy (which is to say that is isn't accurate at all). Perhaps you wouldn't be so stupid if you started reading less fiction and started reading more facts. Just trying to help you out here... because you're stupid.

Of course your other option is to stop saying stupid things.
 
2012-06-16 10:17:58 PM
The real question is what big corporation(s) put these guys (contributed to their campaigns) up to this? Just follow the money and find out who profits.
 
2012-06-16 10:18:23 PM
Because FARK YOU grandma and fark the people who will one day likely be changing my soiled knickers.
 
2012-06-16 10:18:38 PM
Who's going to need home health care the most in the next 10-15 years? Those currently over 65. How does the 65+ crowd vote? It's a backdoor money giveaway to a very large voting demographic. This is what happens when you get your capitalism all over your democracy.
 
2012-06-16 10:18:51 PM
sk8r: I rarely venture into the politics tab. Now I know how the real lawyers on Fark feel when the GED lawyers whip it out.

I'll just finish loading my gun and sipping on this whiskey while I real this thread.

Former CMS worker- Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Nurse manger for nice home care company- we pay WAY above minimum. Amazed at what I'm reading here. Please don't vote anymore.

Just put up the Welcome to Fark meme. I like the crying guy the best.


And welcome to the FARK politics tab....where someone who actually knows what they are talking about are usually shouted down as a troll. Fact is, this is considered a Republican idea and it will be shouted down as evil no matter how practical or reasonable it may be. If the thought of some of these folks voting scares you, imagine them serving on juries.
 
2012-06-16 10:21:00 PM
The people that work in my home get between 20-35 dollars an hour. Nanny and housekeeper mostly. Garden tenders less.

The one bonus I give them is when they die, on their deathbed, they will receive total consciousness. So they got that goin' for them.

Which is nice.
 
2012-06-16 10:22:45 PM
3_Butt_Cheeks: Raspil: I'm so tired of the GOP, their evil and their shamelessness. I just can't with these motherf*ckers anymore.

encrypted-tbn2.google.com



Way to stick up for your party. Oh wait, you didn't! None of you Real Americans does anything but attack the messenger.

Maybe you should spend some of that effort on making the GOP something other than a bunch of selfish pricks who don't give a shiat about anyone but themselves.
 
2012-06-16 10:22:57 PM
sk8r: quickdraw: sk8r: There are issues around companies that provide 24 hour a day coverage in homes. They now have to provide it in shifts, not as 24/7 live in companions that sleep at night and do their own thing around the home when they aren't needed. For years, these companion caregivers were paid a rate that came to under minimum if you factored in all 24 hours. They really aren't on all 24.

Why shouldn't those care givers get paid the whole time they are on duty? Its not like they get to live their own lives during that time. I have friends that do this for a living and it really impacts their personal lives. They cant be home, they cant bring their partner or date over with them when they work at night. They must be ready to wake up at a moments notice to deal with any manner of unpleasant tasks. Its a difficult and important job and should be compensated accordingly.

They really aren't on duty 24/7 in these cases. They have to be provided 8 hours of uninterrupted sleep time at night and they can surf the net in their apartment while they aren't needed. They certainly can have partners/friends over depending on the situations. Many of these live in companions come in husband and wife pairs. If you know anyone who has to get up at night to deal with 'unpleasant tasks' then there are labor law violations afoot. Elders using the 24/7 companion live ins aren't the 'unpleasant task' level of care and they are independent enough to not have to wake someone at night unless it is a dire emergency.

The worker you describe is working in 8 or 12 hour shifts at night and they should be receiving minimum or more and they should be AWAKE.


Hmm well Im guessing there must be lots of different kinds of shifts and Im (fortunately) not in a situation where I need to know all the ins and outs. Obviously its different if you are living there and getting free room and board. But I have friends who do this for a living and they often work for 24 or 48 hours straight and dont live with their clients. They don't stay awake all night but they are there if needed rather than in the comfort of their own beds. They should get paid for that time.
 
2012-06-16 10:23:18 PM
Cataholic: sk8r: I rarely venture into the politics tab. Now I know how the real lawyers on Fark feel when the GED lawyers whip it out.

I'll just finish loading my gun and sipping on this whiskey while I real this thread.

Former CMS worker- Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Nurse manger for nice home care company- we pay WAY above minimum. Amazed at what I'm reading here. Please don't vote anymore.

Just put up the Welcome to Fark meme. I like the crying guy the best.

And welcome to the FARK politics tab....where someone who actually knows what they are talking about are usually shouted down as a troll. Fact is, this is considered a Republican idea and it will be shouted down as evil no matter how practical or reasonable it may be. If the thought of some of these folks voting scares you, imagine them serving on juries.


Sk8r has stated that his/her company pays home health workers more than minimum wage. Are the two of you so obtuse that you are unable to realize that it would be detrimental to Sk8rs' company to compete with home health care providers who refuse to pay their workers minimum wage? Sk8r should be all about this proposed law.
 
2012-06-16 10:27:21 PM
Smeggy Smurf: As compared to the democrats that insist on taking so much from your paycheck that you'll never be able to rise above the place where you entered the work force?

No one is buying your bullshiat and you shouldn't be selling it.
 
2012-06-16 10:28:02 PM
sk8r: I rarely venture into the politics tab. Now I know how the real lawyers on Fark feel when the GED lawyers whip it out.

I'll just finish loading my gun and sipping on this whiskey while I real this thread.

Former CMS worker- Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Nurse manger for nice home care company- we pay WAY above minimum. Amazed at what I'm reading here. Please don't vote anymore.

Just put up the Welcome to Fark meme. I like the crying guy the best.


Thats lovely that your personal experience is different than what this issue addresses. Its obvious you think these workers should be paid more than minimum and most of the farkers here agree with you. So Im not sure why your getting all whiskeyed up and rubbing on your gun - unless thats just a normal Friday night for a former nurse manager.
 
2012-06-16 10:29:06 PM
MyRandomName: If you continue on that path current workers are essentially slaves of the elderly.

So, you agree the with the proposed elimination of wage standard exemptions for home health care workers?
 
2012-06-16 10:32:14 PM
Smeggy Smurf: Marcus Aurelius: If those people are making under $20 an hour, there's something seriously farking wrong with this country.

The job is typically filled by CNAs that aren't good enough to wipe asses in a hospital or have gotten themselves fired from every hospital for misconduct. They shouldn't be working in the medical field in the first place let alone making good money doing it.


My home health person in Florida was great while I was re-learning to walk again... she was courteous, professional, and competent, she was exceedingly good at her job and certainly worth well over minimum wage. I'm pretty sure she made 15 or 16 an hour, imo she's worth more, but if she made much more, I probably wouldn't be able to get those services. Either way, since many of you haven't yet had the experience, I can assure you that when you are faceplanted on the floor in your bathroom and waiting for a scheduled someone to show up, you probably want someone who you've been paying like a professional, because they'll be on time. If you send the message that the person you employ in this capacity is not valued, guess how much they're going to value being timely for you?
 
2012-06-16 10:32:48 PM
Wow. They've finally crossed the line between regular villainy and cartoonish super-villainy
 
2012-06-16 10:34:52 PM
trivial use of my dark powers: Wow. They've finally crossed the line between regular villainy and cartoonish super-villainy

They haven't stolen 40 cakes yet. That would be terrible.
 
2012-06-16 10:35:02 PM
Smeggy Smurf: Raspil: I'm so tired of the GOP, their evil and their shamelessness. I just can't with these motherf*ckers anymore.

As compared to the democrats that insist on taking so much from your paycheck that you'll never be able to rise above the place where you entered the work force?

Neither one are right. We need something different. This same shiat different day thing hasn't worked for decades. Don't be part of the problem.


Check your history book there for last year, the party fighting for payroll tax breaks was the Democrats, the party fighting against them was the Republicans. One party wants rich people to take home more of their money, one party wants you to... so let's keep pretending they're equal if only to placate your delusion.
 
2012-06-16 10:35:42 PM
Smeggy Smurf: Raspil: I'm so tired of the GOP, their evil and their shamelessness. I just can't with these motherf*ckers anymore.

As compared to the democrats that insist on taking so much from your paycheck that you'll never be able to rise above the place where you entered the work force?

Neither one are right. We need something different. This same shiat different day thing hasn't worked for decades. Don't be part of the problem.



I will dislike the GOP if I want to because they openly and unapologetically do f*ckheaded hypocritical things that they know will hurt people and don't give a damn. That makes me "part of the problem"? Okay, if you say so, whoever you are. And to assume you know my lot in life from when I entered the workforce until now is pretty weird, but do what you want, it's fine with me.
 
2012-06-16 10:37:48 PM
And yet there are still a shaitload home health care workers that will still vote GOP in November.
 
2012-06-16 10:40:03 PM
MyRandomName: The Name: dosboot: For all you calling for minimum wage, I hope you have saved your money so that you can care for your parents. Unless of course you expect the taxpayers to foot the bill.

God forbid taxpayers should have to subsidize such evils as livable wages and quality care for the elderly.

Medicare is already one of the largest expenditures of the federal government. You really think the Feds should be paying 40k a year per senior for live-in help? At some point you have to ask what is actually a reasonable accommodation. Sorry, but not every elderly person gets a live in care take. The United States, nor any rational society, can afford it. Seniors average 300k in Medicare spending. They paid in less than 100k. Think about that. Not everything can be paid for magically cause it's the "right thing to do." If you continue on that path current workers are essentially slaves of the elderly.


Right, because I explicitly said that EVERY senior citizen should get live-in care. It's right up there, plain as can be, no question whatsoever that that's what I meant.
 
2012-06-16 10:41:10 PM
Cataholic: sk8r: I rarely venture into the politics tab. Now I know how the real lawyers on Fark feel when the GED lawyers whip it out.

I'll just finish loading my gun and sipping on this whiskey while I real this thread.

Former CMS worker- Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Nurse manger for nice home care company- we pay WAY above minimum. Amazed at what I'm reading here. Please don't vote anymore.

Just put up the Welcome to Fark meme. I like the crying guy the best.

And welcome to the FARK politics tab....where someone who actually knows what they are talking about are usually shouted down as a troll. Fact is, this is considered a Republican insanely farktarded dumbass idea and it will be shouted down as evil no matter how practical or reasonable it may be. If the thought of some of these folks voting scares you, imagine them serving on juries.


FTFY, Fark hates the stupid when it comes from the Dems, the fact that more Republicans seem to latch on to functionally retarded (evil?) policy proposals doesn't make fark anti-republican, still just anti-stupid. Ask around fark how many of em support Dodd-Frank, ask how many supported quality initiatives from the Dems like DADT. Frankly, for the Republican legislators who might read fark... stop being stupid and we'll stop calling you stupid.
 
Displayed 50 of 232 comments

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | » | Last | Show all

View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest


This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »





Report