If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Chronicle of Higher Ed) Sad Not news: Baby tested for fear of rat, dog and monkey. News: Unafraid until accompanied by loud clang. Fark: He was probably autistic, and the shady research psychologists knew it. Ultrafark: The year was 1920   (chronicle.com) divider line 39
More: Sad, dogs, Little Albert, fear of mice, Appalachian State University, academic fraud, monkeys, meningitis, psychologists  
•       •       •

2813 clicks; posted to Geek » on 05 Feb 2012 at 12:08 PM   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»   |    Get this fabulous T-Shirt and impress the methane out of your friends! shirt it!



39 Comments   (+0 »)
   
View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest
 
2012-02-05 02:04:54 AM
Someone bring me a baby, a laboratory rat, and an air horn. Clearly, there is only one way we're going to solve this problem... >_>
 
2012-02-05 02:23:24 AM
SuperMegaUltraFark: It's just some research paper for a periodical.

And it's less persuasive than all the conflicting DB Cooper identities. Less interesting to say the least.
 
2012-02-05 02:59:25 AM
So the shrink knew the boy had autism in 1920, when it wasn't even defined as we know it until the early 40's?
 
2012-02-05 03:14:38 AM
ArkAngel: So the shrink knew the boy had autism in 1920, when it wasn't even defined as we know it until the early 40's?

From Wikipedia:

A few examples of autistic symptoms and treatments were described long before autism was named. The Table Talk of Martin Luther, compiled by his notetaker, Mathesius, contains the story of a 12-year-old boy who may have been severely autistic.[169] Luther reportedly thought the boy was a soulless mass of flesh possessed by the devil, and suggested that he be suffocated, although a later critic has cast doubt on the veracity of this report.[170] The earliest well-documented case of autism is that of Hugh Blair of Borgue, as detailed in a 1747 court case in which his brother successfully petitioned to annul Blair's marriage to gain Blair's inheritance.[171] The Wild Boy of Aveyron, a feral child caught in 1798, showed several signs of autism; the medical student Jean Itard treated him with a behavioral program designed to help him form social attachments and to induce speech via imitation.[172]

The New Latin word autismus (English translation autism) was coined by the Swiss psychiatrist Eugen Bleuler in 1910 as he was defining symptoms of schizophrenia. He derived it from the Greek word autós (αὐτός, meaning self), and used it to mean morbid self-admiration, referring to "autistic withdrawal of the patient to his fantasies, against which any influence from outside becomes an intolerable disturbance".[173]
 
2012-02-05 03:33:26 AM
Bathia_Mapes: A few examples of autistic symptoms and treatments were described long before autism was named.

Your information supports very well the claim that bogus headline is bogus.

Also, autism being a spectrum disorder means even normal people "display signs and symptoms" in the course of their life. Perhaps the kid just had an off day, or liked mice. I like mice. I've never been afraid of them. Rats are just big mice.
 
2012-02-05 04:26:03 AM
Bathia_Mapes: ArkAngel: So the shrink knew the boy had autism in 1920, when it wasn't even defined as we know it until the early 40's?

From Wikipedia:

A few examples of autistic symptoms and treatments were described long before autism was named. The Table Talk of Martin Luther, compiled by his notetaker, Mathesius, contains the story of a 12-year-old boy who may have been severely autistic.[169] Luther reportedly thought the boy was a soulless mass of flesh possessed by the devil, and suggested that he be suffocated, although a later critic has cast doubt on the veracity of this report.[170] The earliest well-documented case of autism is that of Hugh Blair of Borgue, as detailed in a 1747 court case in which his brother successfully petitioned to annul Blair's marriage to gain Blair's inheritance.[171] The Wild Boy of Aveyron, a feral child caught in 1798, showed several signs of autism; the medical student Jean Itard treated him with a behavioral program designed to help him form social attachments and to induce speech via imitation.[172]

The New Latin word autismus (English translation autism) was coined by the Swiss psychiatrist Eugen Bleuler in 1910 as he was defining symptoms of schizophrenia. He derived it from the Greek word autós (αὐτός, meaning self), and used it to mean morbid self-admiration, referring to "autistic withdrawal of the patient to his fantasies, against which any influence from outside becomes an intolerable disturbance".[173]


As much as I enjoyed reading that, you should probably add a few sentences of your own to explain how this quotation supports your point. Or, it might be a good idea to state what your point is.

Are you suggesting that the researcher in question would have known about autism? If so, can you explain how your quote supports that point?
 
2012-02-05 08:19:43 AM
Bless their hearts. Bullsh*t is as bullsh*t does, or something.
 
2012-02-05 08:21:11 AM
hitchking: Bathia_Mapes: ArkAngel: So the shrink knew the boy had autism in 1920, when it wasn't even defined as we know it until the early 40's?

From Wikipedia:

A few examples of autistic symptoms and treatments were described long before autism was named. The Table Talk of Martin Luther, compiled by his notetaker, Mathesius, contains the story of a 12-year-old boy who may have been severely autistic.[169] Luther reportedly thought the boy was a soulless mass of flesh possessed by the devil, and suggested that he be suffocated, although a later critic has cast doubt on the veracity of this report.[170] The earliest well-documented case of autism is that of Hugh Blair of Borgue, as detailed in a 1747 court case in which his brother successfully petitioned to annul Blair's marriage to gain Blair's inheritance.[171] The Wild Boy of Aveyron, a feral child caught in 1798, showed several signs of autism; the medical student Jean Itard treated him with a behavioral program designed to help him form social attachments and to induce speech via imitation.[172]

The New Latin word autismus (English translation autism) was coined by the Swiss psychiatrist Eugen Bleuler in 1910 as he was defining symptoms of schizophrenia. He derived it from the Greek word autós (αὐτός, meaning self), and used it to mean morbid self-admiration, referring to "autistic withdrawal of the patient to his fantasies, against which any influence from outside becomes an intolerable disturbance".[173]

As much as I enjoyed reading that, you should probably add a few sentences of your own to explain how this quotation supports your point. Or, it might be a good idea to state what your point is.

Are you suggesting that the researcher in question would have known about autism? If so, can you explain how your quote supports that point?


Exactly. A case of "possession" and a pseudo-schizophrenic diagnosis does not equal a diagnosis of autism. Real research into autism was started by Hans Asperger in the late 30's and Leo Kanner in the early 40's.
 
2012-02-05 09:07:37 AM
hitchking: Bathia_Mapes: ArkAngel: So the shrink knew the boy had autism in 1920, when it wasn't even defined as we know it until the early 40's?

From Wikipedia:

A few examples of autistic symptoms and treatments were described long before autism was named. The Table Talk of Martin Luther, compiled by his notetaker, Mathesius, contains the story of a 12-year-old boy who may have been severely autistic.[169] Luther reportedly thought the boy was a soulless mass of flesh possessed by the devil, and suggested that he be suffocated, although a later critic has cast doubt on the veracity of this report.[170] The earliest well-documented case of autism is that of Hugh Blair of Borgue, as detailed in a 1747 court case in which his brother successfully petitioned to annul Blair's marriage to gain Blair's inheritance.[171] The Wild Boy of Aveyron, a feral child caught in 1798, showed several signs of autism; the medical student Jean Itard treated him with a behavioral program designed to help him form social attachments and to induce speech via imitation.[172]

The New Latin word autismus (English translation autism) was coined by the Swiss psychiatrist Eugen Bleuler in 1910 as he was defining symptoms of schizophrenia. He derived it from the Greek word autós (αὐτός, meaning self), and used it to mean morbid self-admiration, referring to "autistic withdrawal of the patient to his fantasies, against which any influence from outside becomes an intolerable disturbance".[173]

As much as I enjoyed reading that, you should probably add a few sentences of your own to explain how this quotation supports your point. Or, it might be a good idea to state what your point is.

Are you suggesting that the researcher in question would have known about autism? If so, can you explain how your quote supports that point?

Exactly. A case of "possession" and a pseudo-schizophrenic diagnosis does not equal a diagnosis of autism. Real research into autism was started by Hans Asperger in the late 30's and Leo Kanner in the early 40's.
Farky found 16 comments in this thread.


Fine, change the headline to read "retard waterbrain" to suit your levels of anal this morn.

Basically, the dr in question knew the baby was not "healthy/normal", and knew so from the start.
 
2012-02-05 09:23:17 AM
t0.gstatic.com

Why no testing for fear of Tiger, Dragon, Snake, Cock, Pig, Bull, Horse, Hare, or Sheep?

/Happy Lunar New Year
 
2012-02-05 09:30:13 AM
baka-san: Fine, change the headline to read "retard waterbrain" to suit your levels of anal this morn.

Basically, the dr in question knew the baby was not "healthy/normal", and knew so from the start.


This. The point is that he knew something was not right and continued anyway.
 
2012-02-05 10:00:24 AM
we're so sorry, Little Albert.
 
2012-02-05 10:49:55 AM
ArkAngel: Real research into autism was started by Hans Asperger in the late 30's and Leo Kanner in the early 40's.

They started it!!! THOSE BASTARDS!!!
 
2012-02-05 11:57:38 AM
Watson was a monster. We all knew this.

Also, anecdote about BF Skinner, for any other psych nerds out there: one of my committee members went to Harvard for grad school, and he said there was this legend about BF Skinner. He apparently hit on every woman that he met, and they finally brought him in to the Dean and told him to lay off. He explained that it was a base-rate issue -- the more he asked, the more likely he was to get laid. The single best and easiest way for him to get laid was to throw as many lines out into the water as possible. So he was both a total horndog, (which if you've seen pictures of him is horrifying to think of) AND he was kind of autistic in his approach to human interactions. Horny aspies, just what we need more of in the world.
 
2012-02-05 12:06:45 PM
baka-san: Fine, change the headline to read "retard waterbrain" to suit your levels of anal this morn.

Basically, the dr in question knew the baby was not "healthy/normal", and knew so from the start.


How about we change the headline to something remotely resembling English and not the word salad subby gave us? And is this the first time subby's ever heard of Baby Albert? wow.

And don't forget, we're talking about one paper that is apparently attempting to diagnose autism by watching films of Baby Albert during these sessions only. That's like deciding someone's an alcoholic by watching only vids of him at frat parties.
 
2012-02-05 12:19:30 PM
Yeah, but did he get an erection before the loud noise?

/baby tyrone
 
2012-02-05 12:25:27 PM
Wait a minute, D B Cooper was autistic and this is why?
 
2012-02-05 12:30:45 PM
Shabash: Why no testing for fear of Tiger, Dragon, Snake, Cock, Pig, Bull, Horse, Hare, or Sheep?

Damn you, Internet. When I looked at that list of animals my mind automatically started filling in their sexual perversions.

(link if you don't know WTF I'm talking about. Just cartoon animals but I still wouldn't click it from work.)
 
2012-02-05 12:42:22 PM
coco ebert: baka-san: Fine, change the headline to read "retard waterbrain" to suit your levels of anal this morn.

Basically, the dr in question knew the baby was not "healthy/normal", and knew so from the start.

This. The point is that he knew something was not right and continued anyway.


i1208.photobucket.com
 
2012-02-05 12:43:51 PM
people.virginia.edu
 
2012-02-05 01:05:31 PM
Wow, I didn't know they had vaccines back then.
 
2012-02-05 01:26:45 PM

FTFA:

researchers again produce the rat and place it next to the baby, but this time the rat's presence is accompanied by a loud, startling clang - a sound the baby clearly doesn't like. This is repeated multiple times until the baby starts to cry at the mere appearance of the rat

One time friends with a baby visited and I took the father holding the baby to show him the new garage door opener I had just installed. The sound upset the baby and made him cry. For a while (weeks?) thereafter when ever the baby saw me it would burst out crying until I found that taking off my heavy framed glasses made everything ok. I wonder if the kid still has some form of a glasses phobia.
 
2012-02-05 01:28:47 PM
img7.imageshack.us

-He was interested in the reactions... of the nervous system to... to fear.
-Fear?
-Fear. Especially fear in children and how they react to it. I think he learned a lot from me.
 
2012-02-05 02:00:58 PM
This is exactly why we cannot leave school curricula up to secular "science". There has to be room for obvious common sense.
 
2012-02-05 02:11:54 PM
RandomExcess: This is exactly why we cannot leave school curricula up to secular "science". There has to be room for obvious common sense.

Intelligent Scaring! Teach the Controversy!
 
2012-02-05 02:20:43 PM
Article fails with a dead video link.

Discovering Psychology footage.
 
F42
2012-02-05 03:03:33 PM
ArkAngel: So the shrink knew the boy had autism in 1920, when it wasn't even defined as we know it until the early 40's?

The word autism first took its modern sense in 1938 (wiki). Close enough.
 
2012-02-05 03:05:26 PM
I particularly like how they try to drum up controversy by saying it casts doubt on the findings.

Because this is the only piece of evidence that classical fear conditioning occurs in humans.
 
2012-02-05 03:21:11 PM
the only way to cure Autism is the method used by Elvis in
"Change of Habit", with a hot Mary Tyler Moore as a nun!
If only he had lived longer he coulda cured cancer
 
2012-02-05 04:15:41 PM
Makes sense to me. My kids liked Chinese food the first time they tried it too.
 
2012-02-05 04:50:41 PM
I was looking for summer camps for my daughter last night...one of the ones offered (through the YMCA, no less) is "Camp Fear", where participants get to face their fears. I can't figure out how that camp could end well...at least as how I would imagine it.

'Today's challenge is fear of the dark. You will be locked in a closet for the whole day."
 
2012-02-05 04:59:45 PM
DirtyDeadGhostofEbenezerCooke: Yeah, but did he get an erection before the loud noise?

/baby tyrone


Yes?
 
2012-02-05 05:04:01 PM
So I guess there is no Hippocratic Oath for psychologists?

Cancelling my appointment.
 
2012-02-05 05:27:28 PM
Poppa Zit: So I guess there is no Hippocratic Oath for psychologists?

Cancelling my appointment.


Hit up the link I posted above, which says ``Watson's pioneering study was controversial because of the way he used children. Such an experiment could not be conducted today because of strict ethical guidelines governing the treatment of all research subjects, humans and animals.''

So obviously, you should tell your shrink you want to become a research subject.
 
2012-02-05 06:03:43 PM
I'm a psychology major, and I'm very familiar with Little Albert. Has anyone in the thread or did the article itself mention that he died when he was about 4 or 6? It was some brain defect that got him. It was common back in those times so I wouldn't jump to the conclusion that his cause of death had anything to do with the experiment. They paid the mother a dollar or something if I remember correctly. She was a nurse or something of that nature. The Little Albert experiment shows how far we've progressed as far as experiments using humans go. If something like this happened today the person(s) responsible would be severely punished and imprisoned.
 
2012-02-05 06:20:23 PM
Tyrone Slothrop: DirtyDeadGhostofEbenezerCooke: Yeah, but did he get an erection before the loud noise?

/baby tyrone

Yes?


See? I knew you would respond.
 
2012-02-06 02:51:09 AM
Shabash: [t0.gstatic.com image 236x213]

Why no testing for fear of Tiger, Dragon, Snake, Cock, Pig, Bull, Horse, Hare, or Sheep?

/Happy Lunar New Year


First thing I thought of as well.
 
2012-02-06 02:34:09 PM
Maybe part of the reason an abnormal baby was chosen for that study (and possibly some of the other studies he might have been used for) was that if they thought that he wouldn't live to adulthood or that he was going to be institutionalized his entire life that they could feel free to not worry about any of the consequences that would result from the experiments. If he was never going to have the opportunity to be a grown-up who had to try and face dogs in the real world, there wasn't a lot of concern that he might grow up and be too terrified of dogs to walk down the street. It's sad to think about his short sad little life being made sadder. But I can see what they might have been thinking, if his already miserable situation could benefit the world at large, it might seem like an ok thing to do. We wouldn't consider that ok now, but it was a different time. Concepts like Eugenics weren't universally looked down upon back then. I can see the same type of thinking being applied to the ethics in that case.
 
2012-02-06 07:20:58 PM
did no one read the farking article?
 
Displayed 39 of 39 comments

View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest


This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »