If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(The New York Times)   Mitch Daniels: "Steve Jobs created more jobs than Obama's entire stimulus." Krugman: "Apple employs 700,000 people outside the US; 43,000 inside of it. There's a reason for that, bud"   (nytimes.com) divider line 153
    More: Interesting, Mitch Daniels, President Obama, Steve Jobs, auto bailouts, average cost, stimulus, logical assertion, crony capitalism  
•       •       •

4367 clicks; posted to Politics » on 27 Jan 2012 at 1:59 PM   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»



153 Comments   (+0 »)
   
View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest

Archived thread

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | » | Last | Show all
 
2012-01-27 02:43:51 PM
Weaver95: they just get (under)paid by Apple, Microsoft, HP, Dell, etc to make Apple Microsoft, HP, Dell, etc products but they're 'not employed' by Apple, Microsoft, HP, Dell, etc.

FTFA
 
2012-01-27 02:46:59 PM
Dusk-You-n-Me: You need a thousand rubber gaskets? That's the factory next door. You need a million screws? That factory is a block away. You need that screw made a little bit different? It will take three hours."

I am sad to admit, I got a little bit excited reading that. I migh not be able to stand from my cubicle for a while.

Stoopid suppliers and their 8 to 12 week leadtimes for a simple part and even then they miss it by 2 weeks.

/who me, bitter?
 
2012-01-27 02:48:03 PM
Tell Me How My Blog Tastes: Weaver95: Lando Lincoln:
Absolutely. And all those factories in China came about because American businesses wanted to save as much money as possible, so they closed down the factories in America and China picked up the demand.

And they tolerate levels of intellectual property theft that they'd NEVER put up with here in the states....but hey, at least they're making money, right?

Not for long, esp. when they get shut out of the domestic Chinese market by native firms and political protectionism.


yeah, but most execs don't seem to care about 5 years from now. they care about the money they're going to make THIS quarter and maybe next quarter. 5 years, 10 years from now? they really don't plan for that sort of thing.
 
2012-01-27 02:51:15 PM
Put simply, about 6,000 more iPhones are sold each day than babies are born world-wide.

Damn.

Link (new window)
 
2012-01-27 02:52:03 PM
tortilla burger: OK, let's differentiate between full-time employees and contract workers. If I'm not mistaken, most of Apple's business in other countries is done via contract work. Contract workers do not work for Apple, are not hired by Apple, and are not directly paid any wages or benefits by Apple.

They're paying a foreign company to do work for them. It's not the same thing.


Yeah, but it's Krugman...so I hope you weren't expecting intellectual honesty.
 
2012-01-27 02:52:25 PM
nevirus: A Republican talking shiat but offering no solutions?

[cdn.overclock.net image 320x176]

This is unprecedented. Usually they offer constructive criticisms with the goal of good policy that benefits the country.


What solutions were actually offered in the SOTU? I heard a lot of vague talking points, very little actual policy solutions.
 
2012-01-27 02:52:46 PM
Tell Me How My Blog Tastes: mat catastrophe: Tell Me How My Blog Tastes: qorkfiend: mat catastrophe: As much as the State of the Union was a bunch of flag-waving, war mongering, centrist bullshiat; the GOP response was just a long list of moronic oversimplification and flat-out lies.

buh..?

Because he didn't spit on the Joint Chiefs or tell the Iranians that the US would never, under any circumstances, fight them he's a war monger.

//Moderation is not a sin, people

Actually, the good lord Jesus did admonish people who were "lukewarm".

Suck it, moderates.

He also said something about rendering unto Caesar that which is Caesar's, and rendering unto God that which is God's. So, there's that about bringing religious dictates into politics (and it was used for a long time to justify the separation of church and state, and for Christians to no mix religion and politics).


JESUS WILL BURN THE FASCISTS OUT OF HIS TEMPLE AND BRING THE FREE MARKETS TO THE PEOPLE THROUGH A SERIES OF CENTRALLY PLANNED ECONOMIC WORK PROJECTS THIS IS TRUTH.
 
2012-01-27 02:53:55 PM
among other reasons, it takes 3 years to build a factory in the US, AFTER you get permission to build in an area that has the spotted green-toed frog on it.
 
2012-01-27 02:55:14 PM
Cataholic: tortilla burger: OK, let's differentiate between full-time employees and contract workers. If I'm not mistaken, most of Apple's business in other countries is done via contract work. Contract workers do not work for Apple, are not hired by Apple, and are not directly paid any wages or benefits by Apple.

They're paying a foreign company to do work for them. It's not the same thing.

Yeah, but it's Krugman...so I hope you weren't expecting intellectual honesty.


You're kidding, right? Daniels made the point that Apple hired more people than the President's stimulus and you have a problem with Krugman's credibility?
 
2012-01-27 02:56:51 PM
Cataholic: tortilla burger: OK, let's differentiate between full-time employees and contract workers. If I'm not mistaken, most of Apple's business in other countries is done via contract work. Contract workers do not work for Apple, are not hired by Apple, and are not directly paid any wages or benefits by Apple.

They're paying a foreign company to do work for them. It's not the same thing.

Yeah, but it's Krugman...so I hope you weren't expecting intellectual honesty.


As long as you rent your slaves from a third party, it's morally ethically fine.
 
2012-01-27 02:57:04 PM
mat catastrophe: As much as the State of the Union was a bunch of flag-waving, war mongering, centrist bullshiat; the GOP response was just a long list of moronic oversimplification and flat-out lies.

Wondered how long it'd take for "centrist" to become an epithet. "It's not enough that I win, the other side must be obliterated".

Given that by profession I'm a paid cynic (my job is to look for the inevitable flaws), this trend tells me that maybe Heinlein was right. We're done with the Crazy Years, now comes the new Dark Age.


/So who's leading the betting pool on being Scudder?
//...or should I say SCUDDER!
 
2012-01-27 02:57:41 PM
You know when Republicans argue that the stimulous was a failure and that the only solution to jobs creation is tax cuts, I like to point out that 300 of the total $800 Million were tax cuts.
 
2012-01-27 02:58:34 PM
tenpoundsofcheese: among other reasons, it takes 3 years to build a factory in the US, AFTER you get permission to build in an area that has the spotted green-toed frog on it.

not to mention that you can't just dump your toxic waste into the nearby streams, and then the locals get uppity when you try and burn toxic waste and vent the gasses into the local forest. oh, and the employees demand at least minimum wage and health benefits and not to be beaten into submission if they don't make quota that week.

bah!

just move the factory to china, right?
 
2012-01-27 02:58:53 PM
tenpoundsofcheese: among other reasons, it takes 3 years to build a factory in the US, AFTER you get permission to build in an area that has the spotted green-toed frog on it.


*cough* bullshiat *cough*
 
2012-01-27 03:00:06 PM
Obviously the solution is to move the factories to the US and automate them so that 0 Americans are employed instead of 0 Americans.
 
2012-01-27 03:00:26 PM
Weaver95: tenpoundsofcheese: among other reasons, it takes 3 years to build a factory in the US, AFTER you get permission to build in an area that has the spotted green-toed frog on it.

not to mention that you can't just dump your toxic waste into the nearby streams, and then the locals get uppity when you try and burn toxic waste and vent the gasses into the local forest. oh, and the employees demand at least minimum wage and health benefits and not to be beaten into submission if they don't make quota that week.

bah!

just move the factory to china, right?


Why can't the US look like this?



Darmed tree huggers!
 
2012-01-27 03:00:47 PM
praxcelis: Wondered how long it'd take for "centrist" to become an epithet.

It's never been a particularly good thing.
 
2012-01-27 03:01:41 PM
Philip Francis Queeg: Weaver95: tenpoundsofcheese: among other reasons, it takes 3 years to build a factory in the US, AFTER you get permission to build in an area that has the spotted green-toed frog on it.

not to mention that you can't just dump your toxic waste into the nearby streams, and then the locals get uppity when you try and burn toxic waste and vent the gasses into the local forest. oh, and the employees demand at least minimum wage and health benefits and not to be beaten into submission if they don't make quota that week.

bah!

just move the factory to china, right?

Why can't the US look like this?



Darmed tree huggers!


All righty let's try that again.

www.greenpacks.org
 
2012-01-27 03:04:12 PM
Philip Francis Queeg: All righty let's try that again.

[www.greenpacks.org image 450x315]


My drive into work today was just like that. A warm front full of moist air just came down after a few days of very cold days.
 
2012-01-27 03:04:48 PM
missiv: Impasse: Steve Jobs certainly helped employment in the cancer treatment industry.

Chinese executions squads too. Was there an industry he didn't exploit, I mean, touch? He was an amazing person.


www.jesus-is-savior.com

Removing profit-inhibiting vagrants to benefit the stockholders!
 
2012-01-27 03:05:43 PM
MyRandomName: What solutions were actually offered in the SOTU? I heard a lot of vague talking points, very little actual policy solutions.


Take away the deduction for outsourcing, make companies pay a minimum tax for profits
and jobs overseas, and reward companies for bringing jobs back to America: The President
believes that we need comprehensive corporate tax reform that will close loopholes, lower rates,
and eliminate incentives that make it more attractive to ship jobs overseas - corporate tax reform
that will:
• Remove tax incentives to locate overseas through an international minimum tax: The President
is proposing to eliminate tax incentives to ship jobs offshore by ensuring that all American
companies pay a minimum tax on their overseas profits, preventing other countries from
attracting American business through unusually low tax rates.
• Stop letting companies take a tax deduction for moving overseas and instead provide a credit for
moving jobs back home: The President wants to eliminate the tax deduction companies receive
for the cost of shutting down factories and moving production overseas, and create a new tax
credit to cover moving expenses for companies that close production overseas and bring jobs
back to the United States.
Lower tax rates for companies that manufacture and create jobs in the United States:
• Create new incentives to increase manufacturing in the United States: At the same time
he proposes to close special-interest loopholes, the President is proposing to ensure the
next generation of manufacturing jobs is created here in America by reducing tax rates for
manufacturers and doubling the tax deduction for high-tech manufacturers.
• Support companies that make new investments in the communities hardest hit by major job
losses: The President is proposing a new tax credit that provides support for companies seeking
to finance new factories, equipment, or production in communities that have been hardest hit by a
company choosing to relocate or a military base shutting down.


Link (new window, .pdf)

Extending the payroll tax cut through the end of the year would do the economy well also.
 
2012-01-27 03:06:06 PM
MyRandomName: What solutions were actually offered in the SOTU? I heard a lot of vague talking points, very little actual policy solutions.

There's this branch, called the "Legislative Branch" and they have this special job, see...
 
2012-01-27 03:07:47 PM
Saiga410: Philip Francis Queeg: All righty let's try that again.

[www.greenpacks.org image 450x315]

My drive into work today was just like that. A warm front full of moist air just came down after a few days of very cold days.


That's not moist air in the picture.
 
2012-01-27 03:08:34 PM
Saiga410: My drive into work today was just like that. A warm front full of moist air just came down after a few days of very cold days.

Except that your air was full of water vapor. Theirs...not so much.
 
2012-01-27 03:11:37 PM
Are we counting the jobs Apple creates outside its corporate walls in the peripheral market, programmers, support staff, sales, marketing, advertising, etc. due to its awesome products? Thousands upon thousands of people owe their livelihood due to Apple even though they are not directly employed by Apple. The same can be said about Microsoft -- mainly fixing their buggy shiat. :)
 
2012-01-27 03:16:50 PM
soy_bomb: Are we counting the jobs Apple creates outside its corporate walls in the peripheral market, programmers, support staff, sales, marketing, advertising, etc. due to its awesome products? Thousands upon thousands of people owe their livelihood due to Apple even though they are not directly employed by Apple. The same can be said about Microsoft -- mainly fixing their buggy shiat. :)

And did Mitch Daniels consider all the jobs that weren't cut because of the emergency funding to the states and the peripheral jobs saved by that?
 
2012-01-27 03:17:30 PM
Dusk-You-n-Me: Extending the payroll tax cut through the end of the year would do the economy well also.

Hey! You will stop that immediately and agree that both sides are bad, mkay? It's the only way people like myself and MyRandomName can bring ourselves to vote Republican! ESPECIALLY for Romney, god you know how hard that's gonna be? *groan* but both sides are bad, both sides are bad, don't think don't think don't think just do it, c'mon nevirus, you can pull that lever for Rom-.... AGAINST Obama, yeah!
 
2012-01-27 03:21:20 PM
When did Steve Jobs become the GOP's latest talking point? He was liberal as hell. Romney mentioned him lately. So did Santorum, I believe, and now Mitch Daniels. It's becoming a trend.

It's particularly funny for me because I clearly remember one of my teatard acquaintances telling me that he would never be caught dead using a MAC because (and I quote) "they're for liberals".
 
2012-01-27 03:21:44 PM
I_Am_Weasel: Eddie Adams from Torrance: Apple doesn't employ Americans because Obama has given us too much of his liberal pinko communism.

Obama is a Marxist and, I believe, a fascist.


Wrong, he's a Conservative Anarchist with a hint of National Bolshevism. Clearly.
 
2012-01-27 03:22:42 PM
mat catastrophe: Cataholic: tortilla burger: OK, let's differentiate between full-time employees and contract workers. If I'm not mistaken, most of Apple's business in other countries is done via contract work. Contract workers do not work for Apple, are not hired by Apple, and are not directly paid any wages or benefits by Apple.

They're paying a foreign company to do work for them. It's not the same thing.

Yeah, but it's Krugman...so I hope you weren't expecting intellectual honesty.

You're kidding, right? Daniels made the point that Apple hired more people than the President's stimulus and you have a problem with Krugman's credibility?


No, he said that Steve Jobs created more jobs...not hired more people. And if you want to use that criteria, and compare apples to apples, how many extra federal employees did we hire on account of the stimulus?
 
2012-01-27 03:24:12 PM
Philip Francis Queeg: Saiga410: Philip Francis Queeg: All righty let's try that again.

[www.greenpacks.org image 450x315]

My drive into work today was just like that. A warm front full of moist air just came down after a few days of very cold days.

That's not moist air in the picture.



Don't get all sciency on him. He'll just get a headache and beat his wife later...
 
2012-01-27 03:24:24 PM
Yes, there is a reason for that and Krugman understands very few of them.

And remember, the 43,000 people that work for Apple in the United States live in a vacuum in which they do not purchase goods or services from anyone else except each other so they couldn't possibly be creating more jobs through economic activity.

It also could never be the case that the products Apple sells in the United States involve the use of any domestic shipping. It certainly could never be the case that the products Apple sells in the US result in the sale of digital material to people using those products. This goes on and on. It's more than just who works for Apple directly.

I don't approve of the way Apple makes it's products either but to stick your head up your arse the way Krugman does whenever he writes something is just revolting.
 
2012-01-27 03:24:41 PM
Philip Francis Queeg: Philip Francis Queeg: Weaver95: tenpoundsofcheese: among other reasons, it takes 3 years to build a factory in the US, AFTER you get permission to build in an area that has the spotted green-toed frog on it.

not to mention that you can't just dump your toxic waste into the nearby streams, and then the locals get uppity when you try and burn toxic waste and vent the gasses into the local forest. oh, and the employees demand at least minimum wage and health benefits and not to be beaten into submission if they don't make quota that week.

bah!

just move the factory to china, right?

Why can't the US look like this?

Darmed tree huggers!


1funny.com

Australia to China
 
2012-01-27 03:27:01 PM
pwhp_67: Philip Francis Queeg: Saiga410: Philip Francis Queeg: All righty let's try that again.

[www.greenpacks.org image 450x315]

My drive into work today was just like that. A warm front full of moist air just came down after a few days of very cold days.

That's not moist air in the picture.


Don't get all sciency on him. He'll just get a headache and beat his wife later...


I was going to anyway.
 
2012-01-27 03:28:46 PM
DarnoKonrad: praxcelis: Wondered how long it'd take for "centrist" to become an epithet.

It's never been a particularly good thing.


So, your argument is that compromise and negotiation will always fail, because the "middle ground" is always fallacious? That picking a side and going scorched-earth to defend it is the only path to politics? I don't think that's what you're trying to say, but it sure comes across that way.

Anyone who truly subscribes to that thesis would be impossible to have rational discourse with. There'd be no "give and take", only debating points repeated over and over with increasing levels of hyperbole and vitriol.


/Not unlike much of the Politics tab...
 
2012-01-27 03:29:24 PM
I wonder what Apple Board of Directors member Al Gore thinks about the outsourcing.
 
2012-01-27 03:29:25 PM
Cataholic: how many extra federal employees did we hire on account of the stimulus?

I'm not sure on how many federal employees we hired directly on account of the stimulus. There was a slight uptick due to the census. But from Jan 09 to Jul 11 we lost 500,000 government jobs. Strange behavior for a socialist.

thinkprogress.org
 
2012-01-27 03:30:24 PM
Saiga410: pwhp_67: Philip Francis Queeg: Saiga410: Philip Francis Queeg: All righty let's try that again.

[www.greenpacks.org image 450x315]

My drive into work today was just like that. A warm front full of moist air just came down after a few days of very cold days.

That's not moist air in the picture.


Don't get all sciency on him. He'll just get a headache and beat his wife later...

I was going to anyway.



lol
 
2012-01-27 03:30:25 PM
Dusk-You-n-Me: Extending the payroll tax cut through the end of the year would do the economy well also.

It would do one person extremely well. Republicans are racking their brains at this very moment trying to figure out how they can be against this one tax cut. Bless their hearts, they're trying.
 
2012-01-27 03:31:50 PM
Dusk-You-n-Me: Cataholic: how many extra federal employees did we hire on account of the stimulus?

I'm not sure on how many federal employees we hired directly on account of the stimulus. There was a slight uptick due to the census. But from Jan 09 to Jul 11 we lost 500,000 government jobs. Strange behavior for a socialist.

[thinkprogress.org image 500x373]


Um, that doesn't distinguish between local, state and federal, right?
 
2012-01-27 03:33:03 PM
Krugman says that Obama's bailout of GM and Chrysler is justifiable because they were (and remain) a linchpin in a very complex ecosystem of employment, a group of factories owned by different people doing different things, all in the same general area, employing many people.

He says that China has a similar area devoted to electronics, and points out how the government in China built the factories and practically gave them away to their owners. He then infers that the US should do something similar.

But here's the thing. All of the statements I just rephrased from Krugman are true, but the conclusion doesn't follow. If GM and Chrysler were allowed to go under, their assets (the factories) would have likely been bought up at low prices by outsiders. These factories, now with more-easily-serviced notes on them, would be competitive to build whatever car. The "ecosystem" of factories and employment would have remained. The only difference would be who got paid first by the new owners.

Obama's bailout did not save jobs, long-term. The jobs would have come back. What it saved, or at least helped, was the union pensions at the two companies. Was that worth saving? Maybe. But let's not act like Obama gets the credit for the small rebound we see now in Detroit.
 
2012-01-27 03:34:04 PM
Cataholic: tortilla burger: OK, let's differentiate between full-time employees and contract workers. If I'm not mistaken, most of Apple's business in other countries is done via contract work. Contract workers do not work for Apple, are not hired by Apple, and are not directly paid any wages or benefits by Apple.

They're paying a foreign company to do work for them. It's not the same thing.

Yeah, but it's Krugman...so I hope you weren't expecting intellectual honesty.


Actually, Krugman didn't say that Apple has 700k non-US employees, that was subby making up a quote. What he actually said was:

Apple does, however, indirectly employ around 700,000 people in its various suppliers. Unfortunately, almost none of those people are in America.

Anyway, I'm not sure how contracting 700k non-US employees is any better (or worse) than directly employing 700k people outside the US.
 
2012-01-27 03:34:19 PM
Tell Me How My Blog Tastes: Um, that doesn't distinguish between local, state and federal, right?

I don't think so, no. I'm guessing "government jobs" probably covers all three.
 
2012-01-27 03:34:55 PM
randomjsa: Yes, there is a reason for that and Krugman understands very few of them.

And remember, the 43,000 people that work for Apple in the United States live in a vacuum in which they do not purchase goods or services from anyone else except each other so they couldn't possibly be creating more jobs through economic activity.

It also could never be the case that the products Apple sells in the United States involve the use of any domestic shipping. It certainly could never be the case that the products Apple sells in the US result in the sale of digital material to people using those products. This goes on and on. It's more than just who works for Apple directly.

I don't approve of the way Apple makes it's products either but to stick your head up your arse the way Krugman does whenever he writes something is just revolting.


Well, why stop there?

If I make $50k/year and spend $45k/year, I'm saving or creating thousands of jobs! I eat food EVERY DAY, I buy gas once a week, I buy clothes (although I can't remember many clothing purchases in 2011), I pay taxes, utility bills...

We get into Chris Rock territory here - I supported my local grocery stores and restaurants! "You're SUPPOSED to eat, ya dumb motherfarker!!"

How about "the only jobs you get to take credit for are the one whose salaries you pay"?

Goes for Obama, Steve Jobs, Woz, Bill Gates, Mitch Daniels, Mitt Romney (as much as that bolsters his record a lot, though in his case, he's directly responsible for job losses as well, so there's that to take into account) or anyone else. OK, Paul Krugman? OK, randomjsa?

This whole "jobs created" metric really is a steaming pile.

// demand "creates" jobs, supply "saves" them
// or vice-versa, but does it really matter?
 
2012-01-27 03:36:18 PM
praxcelis: So, your argument is that compromise and negotiation will always fail, because the "middle ground" is always fallacious?

Compromise and negotiation are not "middle ground" for the sake of saying you're there -- which is what "centrism" is. It's both without principal and uncompromising.
 
2012-01-27 03:37:32 PM
Why would anyone create jobs in the US when it's far cheaper and profitable to create them overseas? This is how capitalism works. Labor is a commodity. Profits are the goal.
 
2012-01-27 03:40:59 PM
"Why does Apple manufacture abroad, and especially in China? As the article explained, it's not just about low wages. China also derives big advantages from the fact that so much of the supply chain is already there. A former Apple executive explained: "You need a thousand rubber gaskets? That's the factory next door. You need a million screws? That factory is a block away." "

ahhhh, it's because much of the supply chain is there. Begs the question, doesn't it? Fortunately, you've already answered it for us when you said "low wages" in the previous sentence.
 
2012-01-27 03:42:22 PM
GentDirkly: If GM and Chrysler were allowed to go under, their assets (the factories) would have likely been bought up at low prices by outsiders. These factories, now with more-easily-serviced notes on them, would be competitive to build whatever car. The "ecosystem" of factories and employment would have remained. The only difference would be who got paid first by the new owners.

Well, if you say so.
 
2012-01-27 03:42:51 PM
skullkrusher: "Why does Apple manufacture abroad, and especially in China? As the article explained, it's not just about low wages. China also derives big advantages from the fact that so much of the supply chain is already there. A former Apple executive explained: "You need a thousand rubber gaskets? That's the factory next door. You need a million screws? That factory is a block away." "

ahhhh, it's because much of the supply chain is there. Begs the question, doesn't it? Fortunately, you've already answered it for us when you said "low wages" in the previous sentence.


Hey come on. They are all also there because the rest of the supply chain is there.
 
2012-01-27 03:46:08 PM
CPennypacker: skullkrusher: "Why does Apple manufacture abroad, and especially in China? As the article explained, it's not just about low wages. China also derives big advantages from the fact that so much of the supply chain is already there. A former Apple executive explained: "You need a thousand rubber gaskets? That's the factory next door. You need a million screws? That factory is a block away." "

ahhhh, it's because much of the supply chain is there. Begs the question, doesn't it? Fortunately, you've already answered it for us when you said "low wages" in the previous sentence.

Hey come on. They are all also there because the rest of the supply chain is there.


heh
 
Displayed 50 of 153 comments

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | » | Last | Show all

View Voting Results: Smartest and Funniest


This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »





Report