It's Not News It's Fark.com
Real news. Real funny
Log In
|
Sign Up »
Login
Password
Forgot password?
X
Fark
TotalFark
my
Fark
About/FArQ
Contests
Store
Contact Us
Mobile
Search:
Password
Login
Turn on javascript (or enable it for Fark) for a better user experience.
If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.
Main
Sports
Business
Geek
Entertainment
Politics
Video
When a judge finds it "highly implausible" 11 panelists would "stick their noses in jars of excrement and report 44 independent times that they smelled nothing unpleasant," you'll probably have to pull your commercial
(
chron.com
)
39
More:
Obvious
• • •
12095
clicks; posted to
Main »
on
05 Jan 2012
at
10:17 AM
|
Favorite
| share:
more»
|
shirt it!
Share this link:
URL:
http://fk.cm/go/6860459
Bookmark:
URL:
http://fk.cm/6860459
Bookmark:
Article
Comments
close
39 Comments
(
+0 »
)
Paginated (50/page)
Single page
Single page, reversed
Normal view
Change images to links
Show raw HTML
Show posts from ignored users
View Voting Results:
Smartest
and
Funniest
Bucky Katt
2012-01-05 01:52:55 AM
My litter box doesn't stink.
Tarkus
2012-01-05 02:50:20 AM
To be fair the judge should have tested the claim.
BurnShrike
2012-01-05 08:22:47 AM
Fark is my preferred jar of excrement to stick my nose into.
mauricecano
2012-01-05 09:37:43 AM
If the claim was true why not bring the jar of crap for the judge to smell himself?
BurnShrike
2012-01-05 09:51:43 AM
mauricecano
:
If the claim was true why not bring the jar of crap for the judge to smell himself?
Most judges don't tolerate much crap in their courtroom.
Bruxellensis
2012-01-05 10:19:32 AM
Jenkem?
Brother_Mouzone
2012-01-05 10:20:24 AM
Next thing you'll try and make me believe is that asshole douchebags dont get their spouses new cars without their input and give them as gifts with ribbons wrapped around them to surprise them.
HotWingConspiracy
2012-01-05 10:20:44 AM
Wouldn't they have some record of this testing panel to present?
phlegmmo
2012-01-05 10:22:42 AM
tonguedepressor
2012-01-05 10:23:49 AM
I always wondered what qualifications were needed for being a 'Panelist'. I guess now I know.
aremmes
2012-01-05 10:23:59 AM
Brother_Mouzone
:
Next thing you'll try and make me believe is that asshole douchebags dont get their spouses new cars without their input and give them as gifts with ribbons wrapped around them to surprise them.
Oh, but they do.
Gabrielmot
2012-01-05 10:24:02 AM
HotWingConspiracy
:
Wouldn't they have some record of this testing panel to present?
or witnesses. Although, I'd rather the CEO put his face in excrement for a few hours, kiss his wife, and then take the stand.
/if you believe in your product...
Sin_City_Superhero
2012-01-05 10:25:51 AM
tonguedepressor
:
I always wondered what qualifications were needed for being a 'Panelist'. I guess now I know.
Yeah, but of all the panels in the world to get stuck on, this one
would
be the shiattest.
Ghost Roach
2012-01-05 10:28:31 AM
Is it Cat-turd-day already?
cubic_spleen
2012-01-05 10:33:49 AM
Kind of like a Republican walking through a sweat shop. "Nope. I don't see anything wrong here."
eschatus
2012-01-05 10:39:06 AM
Sounds entirely plausible to me; you tell people you're conducting a test or an experiment and they will do their level best to give you the results you want.
You're the jerk... jerk
2012-01-05 10:41:01 AM
Brother_Mouzone
:
Next thing you'll try and make me believe is that asshole douchebags dont get their spouses new cars without their input and give them as gifts with ribbons wrapped around them to surprise them.
My wife hates those commercials for that exact reason, I have long been tempted to buy her one just to get her upset.
MayorOfJefferton
2012-01-05 10:53:01 AM
I think the problem was that they didn't report they recruited the panelists from a particularly dark corner of craigslist, and that they not only did not find the smell offensive, but were pretty turned on by the whole ordeal.
wambu
2012-01-05 10:53:19 AM
Oakland, Calif.-based Clorox says it's disappointed in Tuesday's ruling. It says it defends the ad's truthfulness.
No shiat?
RatLiver
2012-01-05 10:54:00 AM
Take the Pepsi challenge. I prefer the fuzz.
Director_Mr
2012-01-05 11:06:20 AM
MayorOfJefferton
:
I think the problem was that they didn't report they recruited the panelists from a particularly dark corner of craigslist, and that they not only did not find the smell offensive, but were pretty turned on by the whole ordeal.
You, sir, owe me some glass cleaner and paper towels. And I have marked your posts so I can avoid drinking coffee as I read them in the future.
DontMakeMeComeBackThere
2012-01-05 11:13:43 AM
cubic_spleen
:
Kind of like a Republican walking through a sweat shop. "Nope. I don't see anything wrong here."
Look, we all know that during election time you watch CSPAN and MSNBC and gently touch yourself all day long - but not everything is fodder for political comments.
Mikey1969
2012-01-05 11:20:21 AM
Yeah, I don't buy the kitty litter claim, but I'm awfully confused how the judge can arbitrarily make this decision without any kind of actual documentation or a demonstration of the effectiveness of the litter. He just gets to decide because HE thinks it's ludicrous? I thought that's why we had the courts in the first place, so we had somewhere where it came down to 'prove it' or lose.
cubic_spleen
2012-01-05 11:26:06 AM
DontMakeMeComeBackThere
:
cubic_spleen: Kind of like a Republican walking through a sweat shop. "Nope. I don't see anything wrong here."
Look, we all know that during election time you watch CSPAN and MSNBC and gently touch yourself all day long - but not everything is fodder for political comments.
Just testing the limits of Poe's law. Haven't reached them yet.
And I haven't watched cable or network news (or touched myself) since the day I got teh internets, back in 1995.
PsiChi
2012-01-05 11:28:39 AM
HotWingConspiracy
:
Wouldn't they have some record of this testing panel to present?
PsiChi
2012-01-05 11:30:18 AM
You're the jerk... jerk
:
Brother_Mouzone: Next thing you'll try and make me believe is that asshole douchebags dont get their spouses new cars without their input and give them as gifts with ribbons wrapped around them to surprise them.
My wife hates those commercials for that exact reason, I have long been tempted to buy her one just to get her upset.
Hence the name?
jabelar
2012-01-05 11:56:48 AM
You know, I'm always surprised that anyone would be subjects of many types of studies. Especially medical and drug studies where it says stuff like "we gave 11 healthy individuals such and such" -- I mean people that aren't even sick are willing to let experimental drugs be given to them. It is pretty common for deodorant studies to actually have people sniffing sweaty armpits or socks. I'm pretty sure Clorox could have actually done the study mentioned, even if the judge wasn't up to it.
LesserEvil
2012-01-05 11:59:26 AM
Now if somebody could do something about the idiotic Toyota Tundra commercials.
cefm
2012-01-05 12:15:16 PM
Like Cheerios and their bullshiat "lowers cholesterol" claims, it's a problem of exaggeration that isn't obviously a joke (Toyota Tundra passes that test as it is so over the top it's clearly a joke). They're showing people smelling cat poop in litter at mere inches away, then saying they "can't smell anything". That is absolutely not true and misleading. Of course you smell something and it isn't a wonderful odor. You could say "I smell less bad" or show them smelling the room and say "I don't smell the kitty pan". Those might well be true. But this ad is implying that in order to be the same or superior, their competitors would have to create litter that masks ALL ODOR from inches away, and since they can't do that (and the product advertised can't do it either) then it's a misleading, untruthful and illegal advertisement.
Lsherm
2012-01-05 12:25:41 PM
Brother_Mouzone
:
Next thing you'll try and make me believe is that asshole douchebags dont get their spouses new cars without their input and give them as gifts with ribbons wrapped around them to surprise them.
My wife did that to me in 2006 and the first words out of my mouth were "what the hell did you do that for?"
/yes, it even had a bow.
Your Boss
2012-01-05 12:44:14 PM
Calling Mythbusters... Calling Mythbusters....
SkunkWerks
2012-01-05 12:52:45 PM
I'm less concerned what
only eleven people say
about, well, not just my preferred brand of cat litter, but damn near anything I buy.
Seriously? You're letting what is less than a jury decide on the products you buy? There may be more fundamental problems here than a dodgy Advertising claim if that's the case.
pnjunction
2012-01-05 02:10:11 PM
SkunkWerks
:
Seriously? You're letting what is less than a jury decide on the products you buy?
Because whether my cat box stinks is way more important than whether some sucker I've never met gets put away for life right? LOL
lack of warmth
2012-01-05 02:16:53 PM
Brother_Mouzone
:
Next thing you'll try and make me believe is that asshole douchebags dont get their spouses new cars without their input and give them as gifts with ribbons wrapped around them to surprise them.
A house in Grand Blanc, MI put their Corvettes on the lawn with big ribbons every Christmas season. Didn't enjoy that either.
SkunkWerks
2012-01-05 05:43:40 PM
pnjunction
:
SkunkWerks: Seriously? You're letting what is less than a jury decide on the products you buy?
Because whether my cat box stinks is way more important than whether some sucker I've never met gets put away for life right? LOL
Considering the job our justice system does with 12 people...
benbenbenbenben
2012-01-05 06:03:44 PM
They probably did the sampling in Germany...
supayoda
2012-01-05 07:51:09 PM
Ideas for the next Febreze commercial...
ykarie
2012-01-06 05:58:12 AM
cefm
:
Like Cheerios and their bullshiat "lowers cholesterol" claims, it's a problem of exaggeration that isn't obviously a joke (Toyota Tundra passes that test as it is so over the top it's clearly a joke).
Cheerios' problem was not 'truth in advertising' law, but the FDA. High fiber foods have been found to lower cholesterol. Cheerios is high in fiber. So, Cheerios should help lower your cholesterol. But the FDA drug laws say that if you want to make a medical claim, you have to do the study on the compound you are selling and have it restricted by drug laws. Some almond company ran into the same problem last year, almonds were found to do something, they put that on their label, and the FDA told them to stop making medical claims or expect their product to be controlled like a medicine.
Haven't a clue what Toyota adds you are talking about, though.
Bigdogdaddy
2012-01-07 06:58:07 AM
Only politicians are allowed to lie in commercials, and the stench is usually worse than a dirty litter box...just sayin'
Displayed
39
of
39
comments
View Voting Results:
Smartest
and
Funniest
Redisplay/refresh comments
This thread is closed to new comments.
Submit a Link »
Like Fark!
+1 Fark!
Follow @fark on Twitter
Fark via RSS
Top Links
Top Comments
Top Submitters
Press/Publicity
Headlines of the Week
All Latest
Fark Forum
Link Voting
Sports Forum
Fark Blogs
Geek Forum
Fark Book
Entertainment Forum
Fark Travel Guide
Politics Forum
Fark Parties
Fark Party Forum
Fark Chat
Photoshop Forum
PS/Photo Browser
Farktography Forum
Fark Quiz
From the
Fark Shop
:
Wanted: The Good. The Bad. The Farked
Pluto: Proof That Size Matters
Doctor Who - The Flesh Goo Pod
R2-D2 Nutcracker
More from the
Fark Shop
»
Stories from our partner sites:
5 Movie Roles Will Smith (Probably) N...
Katy Perry Seems Surprisingly Cool Ab...
The GIFs That Keep on Giving
This Baby Elephant is Almost Too Cute...
More news at Scribol »
UFC 146 Live Discussion - This Saturday
This Week In Posters And Stills
Will Smith's 15 Corniest Rap Verses
12 TV Stars We Love In Movies We Hate
More news at UPROXX »
Watercooler Stories
Jockstrip: The world as we know it.
Your Daily Horoscope
The almanac
More news at UPI »
Justin Bieber -- Battery Suspect
Mark Zuckerberg Romes During Honeymoon
Lindsay Lohan -- Chased Down Over $40...
Timothy Busfield -- Sexual Assault Ca...
More news at TMZ »