WhoIsWillo: Again, this headline is extremely misleading.

It includes the phrase of "'....Total QB' rating is total BS...", so it's not that far off.

I'm sorry, but any ranking that doesn't have Tebow at #1 of all time is immediately invalid.

Your Zionist Leader: I wonder what Archie thinks about this?

He probably doesn't care. Eli is his least favorite Manning. That's why he always looks like he's going to cry.

Yeah, Orlovsky was brilliant in that game ... as soon as his team was trailing 31-3.

And great job by Palko, that 38-yard hail mary (his only TD and 24% of his passing yards) was all him.

GAT_00: WhoIsWillo: Matt Hasselbeck

Who by the way is having an absurdly good season. Was his accuracy always this good? Some of the throws he makes are just amazing. Now that CJ is running, the Titans are suddenly the danger I've been waiting for.

Keep dreaming. There's always next year...

Blaine Gabbert > Eli Manning? No farkin' way, subby's trolling hard.

_{(opens link, despite better judgement)}

/crickets

Wait, wait...who threw 25 INT's last year too? Anyone? Anyone?

Yanks_RSJ: And great job by Palko, that 38-yard hail mary (his only TD and 24% of his passing yards) was all him

Yeah, pretty much all he did right was not throw the ball directly to the Bears. They had 3 points on real drives. And he got yanked in the second quarter, only for Neckbeard to go out injured after one play.

Fortunately for Palko, Hanie chucked one crappy INT, had Roy Williams drop a TD that turned into an INT, and the Bears line reverted to the sieve it was a couple months ago.

There's probably only one guy in the league that Tebow can throw it deeper than, and that guy is Palko.

WhoIsWillo: Those are the rankings for the games played last weekend.

Eli Manning, Giants - 23/40 (57%), 347 yards, 3 TDs and an INT.
Blaine Gabbert - 19/33 (57%), 195 yards, 2 TD, 1 INT

just look at the year to date totals and it looks correct.

This rating is better viewed as a season, career long stat. Gabbert is dead last for the year.


So quit your whining it is a superior rating system then the old.

GAT_00: WhoIsWillo: Matt Hasselbeck

Who by the way is having an absurdly good season. Was his accuracy always this good? Some of the throws he makes are just amazing.

Yes.

Earguy: Palko?

[i561.photobucket.com image 559x437]

Made me chuckle. At least he's ranked better than tebow PLUS he can keep his religion in his pants.

/Palko Flakes™

I am sure the donkey that wrote this article trying to argue that Brady should be MVP over Rodgers (new window) is perfectly fine with this metric. When your analysis is clearly flawed, refine it. Or take the ESPN approach and tell everyone that they'll get over it.

//Keep riding that failwagon down Failslide Hill until you land in Dumbarse Creek, ESPN.
///I hate you too much to stop
///TEBOW

Donnchadha: Blaine Yo-Gabbert-Gabbert?

Quick & Dirty...

WhoIsWillo: GAT_00: WhoIsWillo: Matt Hasselbeck

Who by the way is having an absurdly good season. Was his accuracy always this good? Some of the throws he makes are just amazing. Now that CJ is running, the Titans are suddenly the danger I've been waiting for.

Well, he did lead the Seahawks to the Super Bowl.

There was a time when Hasselback was Elite, maybe he is going to have a Curt Warner style comeback.

Incog_Neeto: WhoIsWillo: GAT_00: WhoIsWillo: Matt Hasselbeck

Who by the way is having an absurdly good season. Was his accuracy always this good? Some of the throws he makes are just amazing. Now that CJ is running, the Titans are suddenly the danger I've been waiting for.

Well, he did lead the Seahawks to the Super Bowl.

There was a time when Hasselback was Elite, maybe he is going to have a Curt Warner style comeback.

pion: He probably doesn't care. Eli is his least favorite Manning. That's why he always looks like he's going to cry.

Cooper would like a word with you.

So it shows that Eli is overrated. Sounds about right.

skrame: Cooper would like a word with you.

Nope, Archie still likes Cooper better than Eli.

Words like "metric" and "statistic" should not be used when talking about Total QB Rating^TM. When someone shows me how it's calculated, then I'll care.

Anyone talking about the 28th ranked QB?

/please give me a reason to watch the whole game tonight

//pretty please

I'll preface this by pointing out that I'm a baseball guy, so I look at everything in baseball terms.

Am I correct in understanding that QBR is essentially Win Probability Added, with a few minor adjustments? Because in baseball there's a similar "problem" with WPA & starting pitchers: Pitcher A can throw a perfect game, but if his team scores 15 runs before he even takes the mound, he get as very low WPA. In a different game, Pitcher B might throw a complete game but allow 2 runs, and his team wins 3-2. He'll end up with a much better WPA, even though Pitcher A had a much better game.

I said "problem" because, because even though it looks weird, this is what the stat was designed to do. Team A would've won with just about any pitcher; the fact that they had a very good one is icing. Team B would've lost with most pitchers, but were lucky to have pitcher B.

That seems to be what's going on here. Am I right? It's not saying how "good" the QB is, just how much he added to his team's chance to win.

DeWayne Mann: Am I correct in understanding that QBR is essentially Win Probability Added, with a few minor adjustments?

Sort of, apparently. It's hard to say because they won't share how it's calculated.

John Nash: DeWayne Mann: Am I correct in understanding that QBR is essentially Win Probability Added, with a few minor adjustments?

Sort of, apparently. It's hard to say because they won't share how it's calculated.

photos are shown to chris berman, and very precise calipers measure his resulting erections, which takes into account both length and width, its the most accurate way to measure quarterbacks.

/thats what berman calls it
//rumblin stumblin bumblin, ahh damn it premature ejaculation again
///no thursday nite game thread?

so is this the Steelers-Browns thread?

farbekrieg: ///no thursday nite game thread?

I think we are taking over the Fark Luck thread.

Eli automatically get points deducted because he is such a doucheclown

Yup.

Peyton is the only Manning worth a shiat. Pops and little bro are coonts.