If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(CBS) Asinine If you believe the Cal Trans safety inspection team, I have a bridge safety report to sell you   (losangeles.cbslocal.com) divider line 45
More: Asinine, warps, safety inspections, Department of Transportation, Southland  
•       •       •

5773 clicks; posted to Main » on 14 Nov 2011 at 5:35 PM   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»   |    Get this fabulous T-Shirt and impress the methane out of your friends! shirt it!



45 Comments   (+0 »)
   
 
2011-11-14 02:13:14 PM
Close enough for government work.
 
2011-11-14 02:53:39 PM
I like that the engineer responsible for faking the tests is still employed by Caltrans. He was merely disciplined, which likely means he spent a week at home on paid leave and had to promise not to do it again.
 
2011-11-14 05:43:30 PM
ShawnDoc: I like that the engineer responsible for faking the tests is still employed by Caltrans. He was merely disciplined, which likely means he spent a week at home on paid leave and had to promise not to do it again.

Caltrans: Whateva! I got paid. I do what I want!
 
2011-11-14 05:45:23 PM
FTFA :"Wiles, who is also responsible for the new San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge, has been placed on administrative leave."


Paid vacation. The horror.


But don't you dare badmouth government employee unions
 
2011-11-14 05:50:52 PM
I drive over this bridge twice a day, so I know a thing about crumbling bridges. I especially like the part of the article where it talks about chunks of falling concrete. If Cal Trans was sugar-coating things, then I'm real curious about how bad it really is.
 
2011-11-14 05:57:04 PM
The contractor they had doing inspections on the pieces of the new Bay Bridge being produced in China was failing too many pieces, so Caltrans replaced them with one that would keep the project on schedule.

And now the installation inspector is faking reports.


It's a good thing that bridge isn't located in an earthquake prone area
 
2011-11-14 05:59:45 PM
ShawnDoc: I like that the engineer responsible for faking the tests is still employed by Caltrans. He was merely disciplined, which likely means he spent a week at home on paid leave and had to promise not to do it again.

Interesting.

The Association of Professional Engineers where I live (I am a P.Eng.) would likely:
1. ask you to explain what the heck you were doing,
2. ask why in the world they'd let you practice Engineering again, and
3. determine when are you going to pay this enormous fine before they let you re-register?

And if you're not registered, you're not working.
 
2011-11-14 06:08:00 PM
Give the guy a break, he was busy thinking about some sweet 17 year old titties and the trouble they got him into. My focus would be shot too.
 
2011-11-14 06:13:24 PM
Mr Rusty Shackleford: Give the guy a break, he was busy thinking about some sweet 17 year old titties and the trouble they got him into. My focus would be shot too.

Great. Titties thread!
 
2011-11-14 06:14:51 PM
WTF is with CalTrans....I'm a little confused. Perhaps it's an inter-departmental thing with.On one hand, the highway through town here was carved up and repaved in lightspeed time, yet another section of said highway just had $15 million taken from a "safety corridor" project 3 miles away that after 10 years, absolutely nothing has happened....and a 100 year old bridge (that justifiably is, and has survived everything short of Nazi panzers and should be) got recertifed. AND with friends that work as engineers for CalTrans...I just do not know what that clusterfark of management exists there. And then there is this shiat that ends on Fark.
 
2011-11-14 06:17:18 PM
theMagni: Interesting.The Association of Professional Engineers where I live (I am a P.Eng.) would likely:1. ask you to explain what the heck you were doing,2. ask why in the world they'd let you practice Engineering again, and3. determine when are you going to pay this enormous fine before they let you re-register?And if you're not registered, you're not working.

I wonder what his liability is for signing off on failed freeway foundations, does he face future fining, and face felony fingering?

//ffffff
 
2011-11-14 06:25:04 PM
One Bad Apple: But don't you dare badmouth government employee unions

Now where in the heck does that fit into anything? Unions... SOSHLIZMZ!!

Go away, troll.
 
2011-11-14 06:27:06 PM
Made in China?! Haven't we learned anything?!
 
2011-11-14 06:27:27 PM
Caltrans management is beyond incompetent.
The guy will never get fired and his boss will never face any disciplinary action, either.

Caltrans is an engineering organization so it would take much more than this to get an engineer fired.
My guess is he took loads of kickbacks from the contractor and looked the other way.
The push for 'On time, under budget' is incentive enough to look the other way on things but add in a little graft and there is no chance for a quality project to ever get done.
 
2011-11-14 06:39:56 PM
theMagni: ShawnDoc: I like that the engineer responsible for faking the tests is still employed by Caltrans. He was merely disciplined, which likely means he spent a week at home on paid leave and had to promise not to do it again.

Interesting.

The Association of Professional Engineers where I live (I am a P.Eng.) would likely:
1. ask you to explain what the heck you were doing,
2. ask why in the world they'd let you practice Engineering again, and
3. determine when are you going to pay this enormous fine before they let you re-register?

And if you're not registered, you're not working.


You can work as an engineer for the government without a PE. It's one of the listed exceptions.
 
2011-11-14 06:40:35 PM
special20: One Bad Apple: But don't you dare badmouth government employee unions

Now where in the heck does that fit into anything? Unions... SOSHLIZMZ!!

Go away, troll.


It has little to do with socialism and every thing to do with retaining lousy employees for the sake of padding union dues. Take your spelling teacher for example.
 
2011-11-14 06:51:52 PM
One Bad Apple: special20: One Bad Apple: But don't you dare badmouth government employee unions

Now where in the heck does that fit into anything? Unions... SOSHLIZMZ!!

Go away, troll.

It has little to do with socialism and every thing to do with retaining lousy employees for the sake of padding union dues. Take your spelling teacher for example.


Your mom? Sure, she's not that busy.
 
2011-11-14 06:58:25 PM
Sybarite: Close enough for government work.

Imagine what it will do with your health care.

FTFA: The Caltrans engineer responsible for making those measurements, 58-year-old Duane Wiles, was disciplined for faking test results.

Wiles, who is also responsible for the new San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge, has been placed on administrative leave


Administrative leave? Why not fired? Oh, right he is a civilian government employee.

SEC
MMS
Fannie Mae
Freddy Mac
FHA
ATF
DOJ
DOE
TSA
Cal Trans
 
2011-11-14 06:59:03 PM
My favorite part of CalTrans is where they shut down a section or roadway, and then proceed to do nothing with it for 2-3 years.

And before you say "Well, they're working on it when you aren't there" this happened with a stretch near my home. They weren't working on it during the day, morning, or evening. They just farked up traffic for a couple years before deciding to actually begin the work. Once they started, work was done in just a few months, but there was no reason to shut those lanes down ahead of time.

And from what I've heard from other people its their standard operating procedure.
 
2011-11-14 07:03:56 PM
Nothing wrong with this bridge.. Whats a few potholes anyways..
i.imgur.com
 
2011-11-14 07:05:11 PM
theMagni: ShawnDoc: I like that the engineer responsible for faking the tests is still employed by Caltrans. He was merely disciplined, which likely means he spent a week at home on paid leave and had to promise not to do it again.

Interesting.

The Association of Professional Engineers where I live (I am a P.Eng.) would likely:
1. ask you to explain what the heck you were doing,
2. ask why in the world they'd let you practice Engineering again, and
3. determine when are you going to pay this enormous fine before they let you re-register?

And if you're not registered, you're not working.


Sounds like too much regulation to me. Let the free market handle it. People should just avoid bridges that were inspected by CalTrans, simple enough.
 
2011-11-14 07:13:13 PM
ShawnDoc: My favorite part of CalTrans is where they shut down a section or roadway, and then proceed to do nothing with it for 2-3 years.

And before you say "Well, they're working on it when you aren't there" this happened with a stretch near my home. They weren't working on it during the day, morning, or evening. They just farked up traffic for a couple years before deciding to actually begin the work. Once they started, work was done in just a few months, but there was no reason to shut those lanes down ahead of time.

And from what I've heard from other people its their standard operating procedure.


Weird. I've lived in California for quite a few decades and have never seen anything like that. What project was that?
 
2011-11-14 07:14:45 PM
There must be different sectors of CalTrans. Or departments, whatever. The one down in So Cal is actually very good and works like gangbusters whenever they have to shut down the freeways. They're doing expansions on the 405/22 interchange by my house, and while the traffic has been bad, the construction is proceeding apace and without too much horribleness.

I remember seeing a program a while back, not on engineering but on education, which might be relevant here. It was an engineer discussing how "consensus building" and "but I TRIED" was going to have repercussions down the road: He said that having a bunch of kids decide that their calculations were close enough might make everyone feel good, but do you really want an architect or engineer deciding that getting his calculations down to within an inch was 'close enough" and calling it a day? Or in this case, deciding that the readings matched most of the time, and he didn't need to check any further?
 
2011-11-14 07:25:19 PM
Mr Rusty Shackleford: Weird. I've lived in California for quite a few decades and have never seen anything like that. What project was that?

22 near Garden Grove/Anaheim.
 
2011-11-14 07:34:23 PM
hasty ambush: Administrative leave? Why not fired?

img1.fark.net

FIRED. and his boss. (new window)
 
2011-11-14 07:37:32 PM
loonatic112358: theMagni: Interesting.The Association of Professional Engineers where I live (I am a P.Eng.) would likely:1. ask you to explain what the heck you were doing,2. ask why in the world they'd let you practice Engineering again, and3. determine when are you going to pay this enormous fine before they let you re-register?And if you're not registered, you're not working.

I wonder what his liability is for signing off on failed freeway foundations, does he face future fining, and face felony fingering?

//ffffff


Seems to be about $50k from the California PE Act, section 6770.2. He could still be sued, as far as I know. I know nothing at all about US Law unless it's been on Law & Order. One case here the guy got $52k in fines even though the limit is $25k. (He totally deserved it.)

This text is now purple: You can work as an engineer for the government without a PE. It's one of the listed exceptions.

Federal Government, not state. 6739, Officers and Employees of the USA ... are exempt.

www.pels.ca.gov/licensees/pe_act.pdf
 
2011-11-14 07:59:42 PM
Gyrfalcon: There must be different sectors of CalTrans. Or departments, whatever. The one down in So Cal is actually very good and works like gangbusters whenever they have to shut down the freeways. They're doing expansions on the 405/22 interchange by my house, and while the traffic has been bad, the construction is proceeding apace and without too much horribleness.


100% agree.

I go through there every day. I actually emailed the directors or the two Cal Trans districts to compliment them on their work so far. I also thanked them for smoothing the bumps on the 110 south of the 405 and the excellent job they did repaving the 405 by Costa Mesa. They both replied thanking me for the nice note.
 
2011-11-14 08:20:52 PM
clear_prop: The contractor they had doing inspections on the pieces of the new Bay Bridge being produced in China was failing too many pieces, so Caltrans replaced them with one that would keep the project on schedule.

And now the installation inspector is faking reports.


It's a good thing that bridge isn't located in an earthquake prone area


And remember, even though they're spending $12 billion (plus interest) to build one segment of a bridge, that's a great deal -- but spending $90 billion to build a high-speed public transit that covers the entire state is OMG OUTRAGE!!!111
 
2011-11-14 08:35:16 PM
Pfft. When was the last time anything in or from California was right, much less CalTrans?
 
2011-11-14 08:37:57 PM
Get Lost: Nothing wrong with this bridge.. Whats a few potholes anyways..
[i.imgur.com image 640x480]


...daaaamn, which bridge was that?
 
2011-11-14 08:39:09 PM
Mr Rusty Shackleford: Weird. I've lived in California for quite a few decades and have never seen anything like that. What project was that?

Clearly, you haven't been paying attention.
 
2011-11-14 08:40:06 PM
MrEricSir: clear_prop: The contractor they had doing inspections on the pieces of the new Bay Bridge being produced in China was failing too many pieces, so Caltrans replaced them with one that would keep the project on schedule.

And now the installation inspector is faking reports.


It's a good thing that bridge isn't located in an earthquake prone area

And remember, even though they're spending $12 billion (plus interest) to build one segment of a bridge, that's a great deal -- but spending $90 billion to build a high-speed public transit that covers the entire state is OMG OUTRAGE!!!111


[welcometocalifornia.png]
 
2011-11-14 09:25:10 PM
Shvetz: theMagni: ShawnDoc: I like that the engineer responsible for faking the tests is still employed by Caltrans. He was merely disciplined, which likely means he spent a week at home on paid leave and had to promise not to do it again.

Interesting.

The Association of Professional Engineers where I live (I am a P.Eng.) would likely:
1. ask you to explain what the heck you were doing,
2. ask why in the world they'd let you practice Engineering again, and
3. determine when are you going to pay this enormous fine before they let you re-register?

And if you're not registered, you're not working.

Sounds like too much regulation to me. Let the free market handle it. People should just avoid bridges that were inspected by CalTrans, simple enough.


www.agileproductdesign.com
 
2011-11-14 09:34:09 PM
MrEricSir: And remember, even though they're spending $12 billion (plus interest) to build one segment of a bridge, that's a great deal -- but spending $90 billion to build a high-speed public transit that covers the entire state is OMG OUTRAGE!!!111

I really hate to be in the position of defending CalTrans but that bridge in general not being there would end up costing the state a whole lot more than that if it weren't there after an earthquake. Most of the extra cost has to do with people wanting another signature bridge instead of a simple like for like replacement bridge to replace the cantilever section that absolutely needed to be replaced for many reasons. The section built like most bridges (flat and sitting on pilings 20 feet or so above high tide) was done years ago. It's the new suspension span (that really could have never been done at all) that is driving up the costs. Bay shipping traffic doesn't go on that side of TI the bay isn't dredged out there to make it past TI, the channel is on the San Francisco side of TI meaning they didn't need the height or the span that they got with the suspension section.

Link (new window)

But it sure will look pretty I guess.
 
2011-11-14 09:45:27 PM
ShawnDoc: Mr Rusty Shackleford: Weird. I've lived in California for quite a few decades and have never seen anything like that. What project was that?

22 near Garden Grove/Anaheim.


Ugh! I remember that shiat! Freaking zig-zagging lanes all over the place and unable to see the lane dividers during sunrise and sunset (depending on which direction you were heading)

/Honorable mention: The 55/405 carpool connector/dumpramp at JWA.
//2nd honorable mention: The El Toro Y expansion project
///3rd honorable mention: The 91/57 carpool connector (went to CSUF for 3 years before they finished it)
////Which one of these had the 2-year extension because they had to restart from scratch because of some kind of concrete density problem?
//Fark you CalTrans!!!!
 
2011-11-14 09:46:32 PM
MrEricSir: And remember, even though they're spending $12 billion (plus interest) to build one segment of a bridge, that's a great deal -- but spending $90 billion to build a high-speed public transit that covers the entire state is OMG OUTRAGE!!!111

the bolded part - not really. Sac to LA via SF (or maybe all the way to SD). Northern and Central can suck it. :)
 
2011-11-14 09:53:44 PM
doofusgumby: the bolded part - not really. Sac to LA via SF (or maybe all the way to SD). Northern and Central can suck it. :)

Last I checked, Sacramento and San Francisco were both in Northern California, and Fresno and Bakersfield were both in the Central Valley. (But yeah, I see your point.)
 
2011-11-14 10:39:36 PM
Cup Check: ////Which one of these had the 2-year extension because they had to restart from scratch because of some kind of concrete density problem?

Wait... What? You slump test it right off of the truck and if it fails you send it back before any gets poured. You also keep an eye on the operator to make sure that he doesn't add too much water to make it easier to handle after the slump test. That's concrete 101 type stuff. You also have someone in the plant to QA the mix (correct type of aggregate, moisture content of the sand and proportions mostly with an occasional random slump test and test cylinder during the shift) when you're dealing with that amount of concrete. Those two positions make it pretty much impossible to mess up the mud to where you need to add two years to a job to fix it.
 
2011-11-15 12:36:33 AM
MrEricSir: doofusgumby: the bolded part - not really. Sac to LA via SF (or maybe all the way to SD). Northern and Central can suck it. :)

Last I checked, Sacramento and San Francisco were both in Northern California, and Fresno and Bakersfield were both in the Central Valley. (But yeah, I see your point.)


My friend, anyone from the The Jefferson Statehood Project would tell you that is definitely NOT Northern California.

/my 2cents is that the HSR project is absolutely DOOMED to fail.
 
2011-11-15 01:39:07 AM
Gyrfalcon: There must be different sectors of CalTrans. Or departments, whatever. The one down in So Cal is actually very good and works like gangbusters whenever they have to shut down the freeways. They're doing expansions on the 405/22 interchange by my house, and while the traffic has been bad, the construction is proceeding apace and without too much horribleness.

I remember seeing a program a while back, not on engineering but on education, which might be relevant here. It was an engineer discussing how "consensus building" and "but I TRIED" was going to have repercussions down the road: He said that having a bunch of kids decide that their calculations were close enough might make everyone feel good, but do you really want an architect or engineer deciding that getting his calculations down to within an inch was 'close enough" and calling it a day? Or in this case, deciding that the readings matched most of the time, and he didn't need to check any further?


It's akin to "tolerance stacking" in engine building. Every individual component may be technically within spec, but if everything is near the outside of the tolerance range, the finished engine will be crap. It's how you end up with brand new cars tha blow motors in less than 10k miles.
 
2011-11-15 03:26:50 AM
I would like to know... are these people minorities? CalTrans likes to promote minorities to positions they aren't qualified for. And it's true, a PE is only optional to work for CalTrans.

/ex husband worked for them as an engineer
 
2011-11-15 11:38:21 AM
Gyrfalcon: I remember seeing a program a while back, not on engineering but on education, which might be relevant here. It was an engineer discussing how "consensus building" and "but I TRIED" was going to have repercussions down the road: He said that having a bunch of kids decide that their calculations were close enough might make everyone feel good, but do you really want an architect or engineer deciding that getting his calculations down to within an inch was 'close enough" and calling it a day? Or in this case, deciding that the readings matched most of the time, and he didn't need to check any further?

You know how I know you're not an Engineer? ;)

You do first-order approximations to get a general idea of what the answer should be. Let's say you come up with about 1500.

Then you get a computer to figure out the answer. It should be in the ballpark of 1500. Let's say you get 1466.8977. Not bad.

Then get a second computer and get it to do the math. (If you can, use a different CPU, OS, and program) It comes up with 1527.123. Excellent.

Finally, choose between the part that can handle 1000 and the part that can handle 5000. Get into endless arguments as to why they can't just use the 1000 part everywhere.
 
2011-11-15 11:47:40 AM
theMagni: Gyrfalcon: I remember seeing a program a while back, not on engineering but on education, which might be relevant here. It was an engineer discussing how "consensus building" and "but I TRIED" was going to have repercussions down the road: He said that having a bunch of kids decide that their calculations were close enough might make everyone feel good, but do you really want an architect or engineer deciding that getting his calculations down to within an inch was 'close enough" and calling it a day? Or in this case, deciding that the readings matched most of the time, and he didn't need to check any further?

You know how I know you're not an Engineer? ;)

You do first-order approximations to get a general idea of what the answer should be. Let's say you come up with about 1500.

Then you get a computer to figure out the answer. It should be in the ballpark of 1500. Let's say you get 1466.8977. Not bad.

Then get a second computer and get it to do the math. (If you can, use a different CPU, OS, and program) It comes up with 1527.123. Excellent.

Finally, choose between the part that can handle 1000 and the part that can handle 5000. Get into endless arguments as to why they can't just use the 1000 part everywhere.


In the high school gym, all the girls in the class were lined up against one wall, and all the boys against the opposite wall. Then, every ten seconds, they walked toward each other until they were half the previous distance apart. A mathematician, a physicist, and an engineer were asked, "When will the girls and boys meet?"

The mathematician said: "Never."

The physicist said: "In an infinite amount of time."

The engineer said: "Well... in about two minutes, they'll be close enough for all practical purposes."

/ Old joke
 
2011-11-15 02:51:32 PM
doofusgumby: hasty ambush: Administrative leave? Why not fired?

[img1.fark.net image 54x11]

FIRED. and his boss. (new window)


Had to laugh:

while Liebich was fired for "misusing state materials."

... does looking at Fark during breaktime count as misusing state materials..? Uhhh... well, least I ain't CalTrans... if I got fired because of Fark I'd laugh my arse off all the way to the unemployment line; site ain't blocked so I can only assume it's cool. -IT, don't you take that as a cue neither.

On another note - holy fark, this guy was caught falsifying inspection records on numerous occasions prior to this? How the fark did he still have a JOB? Pretty sure that if one of our bridge inspectors forgot to even dot an "i" or cross a "t" they'd be reprimanded hardcore, and falsifying state documents is flat out illegal here; that's a firin' AND an arrestin'. Putting Joe Q. Public at risk is just farking taboo, the primary goals is to keep the traffic flowing while ensuring public safety. Heck, CalTrans pioneered a lot of pedestrian-friendly safety-intensive road and intersection designs, 'Complete Streets' specifically - so it's not like they're not focused on safety. I just don't get it. If you don't like your job, transfer. Quit. Don't put the public at risk because you're unhappy or just outright lazy.

/stickler for these things
//also terrified of bridges
///when one of your dept's bridge inspectors says "Yeaahh don't drive over X bridge", you don't drive over that farking bridge
 
2011-11-15 05:43:00 PM
WarszawaScream: doofusgumby: hasty ambush: Administrative leave? Why not fired?

///when one of your dept's bridge inspectors says "Yeaahh don't drive over X bridge", you don't drive over that farking bridge


When a welder tells you "I never go on that bridge. Gives me the willies..." that's bad too.

There's a drawbridge here that's half train, half car. They closed the train side to trains, then a few weeks later said "actually, don't walk on it either. It's closed to everyone." The car side is still open.

Same material.
Same age.
Same maintenance.
One side: fine for dumptrucks and buses; other side: don't let too many birds land on it.

It's one of the main arterial links between downtown and housing.

/Maybe it's venous. Not sure.
 
Displayed 45 of 45 comments


This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »