If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Huffington Post) Obvious Writer sues Hangover Part 2 filmmakers for using Find Word and Replace   (huffingtonpost.com) divider line 12
More: Obvious, copyright infringement, film makers  
•       •       •

4901 clicks; posted to Entertainment » on 18 Oct 2011 at 4:50 AM   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»   |    Get this fabulous T-Shirt and impress the methane out of your friends! shirt it!



12 Comments   (+0 »)
   
 
2011-10-17 10:58:35 PM
The biggest problem with lawsuits like this and the woman who complained about The Never Ending Story being false advertising and the guy who contended that the trailer to Drive wasn't the movie he was expecting (one of them may have been a Simpsons episode but none of them are far from each other) is that they never think they're going to win but it's often cost effective for the studio to settle than to fight the case. In summary, farking lawyers.
 
2011-10-17 11:03:40 PM
Man, he should be thankful people think someone ELSE is responsible for that movie. Why is he going out of his way to point the blame at himself?
 
2011-10-17 11:31:44 PM
Mugato: The biggest problem with lawsuits like this and the woman who complained about The Never Ending Story being false advertising and the guy who contended that the trailer to Drive wasn't the movie he was expecting (one of them may have been a Simpsons episode but none of them are far from each other) is that they never think they're going to win but it's often cost effective for the studio to settle than to fight the case. In summary, farking lawyers.

Studios, and corporations in general, should man up and fight each case to the death and make sure these crazy people don't get a penny. It may cost a few million dollars but if they do that a couple of times they will never have to do it again. Settling for "just" $50k or so works out far more expensive if you have to do that again and again....

Of course that only works where the studio is in the right and the person suing them hasn't got a case. In those cases they should settle because that's the right thing to do.
 
2011-10-17 11:44:42 PM
Flint Ironstag: Of course that only works where the studio is in the right and the person suing them hasn't got a case. In those cases they should settle because that's the right thing to do.

Right and if this guy did write a screenplay that the studio did steal somehow, he should be compensated. Obviously we don't know the whole story but while studios might be stupid when it comes to making creative decisions, they're not stupid about covering their ass legally. A lot of times a significant percent of a movie's budget goes to people who write a draft for them that they'll never use, just in case one idea ends up in the script that they do use. Studios know what they're doing and should fight this sort of shiat when they're in the right.
 
2011-10-18 01:05:52 AM
Mugato: Flint Ironstag: Of course that only works where the studio is in the right and the person suing them hasn't got a case. In those cases they should settle because that's the right thing to do.

Right and if this guy did write a screenplay that the studio did steal somehow, he should be compensated. Obviously we don't know the whole story but while studios might be stupid when it comes to making creative decisions, they're not stupid about covering their ass legally. A lot of times a significant percent of a movie's budget goes to people who write a draft for them that they'll never use, just in case one idea ends up in the script that they do use. Studios know what they're doing and should fight this sort of shiat when they're in the right.


for some reason, this popped into my head:

farm7.static.flickr.com
"...He tried to convince me to fire you, too, but no, that'd be too easy. Nah, you're under contract.
You're going to stay that way. Anything you write is going to be the property of Capitol Pictures. And Capitol Pictures is not going to produce anything you write...not until you grow up a little. You ain't no writer, Fink. You're a goddamn write-off."

farm7.static.flickr.com
"I... I tried to show you...something beautiful. Something about all of us. I..."

farm7.static.flickr.com
"You arrogant son of a biatch. You think you're the only writer that can give me
that Barton Fink feeling? I got 20 writers under contract I can ask for a Fink-type thing from!
You swell-headed hypocrite. You just don't get it, do you? You think the whole world revolves around
whatever rattles inside that little kike head of yours.

Get him out of my sight, Lou!

I want him in town, though. He's still under contract. I want you in town, Fink and out of my sight.

Now, get lost.

There's a war on."
 
2011-10-18 01:18:29 AM
Darn cdesign proponentsists are everywhere....
 
2011-10-18 08:21:58 AM
Maybe I should sue subby for linking to a summary, instead of to the full article. (new window)

My favorite part: where he sues the Hangover producers for defamation, because he gets wasted and proposes to a Thai ladyboy.
 
2011-10-18 08:54:32 AM
:%s/Subby/Moran who links to wrong artcile/g


/done and done.
 
2011-10-18 09:15:46 AM
Mugato: Flint Ironstag: Of course that only works where the studio is in the right and the person suing them hasn't got a case. In those cases they should settle because that's the right thing to do.

Right and if this guy did write a screenplay that the studio did steal somehow, he should be compensated. Obviously we don't know the whole story but while studios might be stupid when it comes to making creative decisions, they're not stupid about covering their ass legally. A lot of times a significant percent of a movie's budget goes to people who write a draft for them that they'll never use, just in case one idea ends up in the script that they do use. Studios know what they're doing and should fight this sort of shiat when they're in the right.


Well they pay for that draft anyway since they hired the writer to write it. I know a writer who wrote draft three and thirteen of a blockbuster movie. But generally only a couple of percent of a movies budget is the script.

The problem is you cannot copyright an idea, only the specific execution. Even the infamous Art Buchwald Coming To America case ended up with him losing the case for them stealing his idea and script. He only won the breach of contract case because they had actually signed a contract with him.

And the bigger problem is there are no new ideas. I could make a movie about a robot hippo who lived on the Moon and controlled the weather and there will be at least ten people who will genuinely believe I stole it from them and who will have a script that is very similar. I have written scripts and then seen identical plots produced. I would swear they stole it except for the fact that I had not finished mine and had sent it to no one.
 
2011-10-18 11:11:29 AM
Flint Ironstag: Mugato: Flint Ironstag: Of course that only works where the studio is in the right and the person suing them hasn't got a case. In those cases they should settle because that's the right thing to do.

Right and if this guy did write a screenplay that the studio did steal somehow, he should be compensated. Obviously we don't know the whole story but while studios might be stupid when it comes to making creative decisions, they're not stupid about covering their ass legally. A lot of times a significant percent of a movie's budget goes to people who write a draft for them that they'll never use, just in case one idea ends up in the script that they do use. Studios know what they're doing and should fight this sort of shiat when they're in the right.

Well they pay for that draft anyway since they hired the writer to write it. I know a writer who wrote draft three and thirteen of a blockbuster movie. But generally only a couple of percent of a movies budget is the script.

The problem is you cannot copyright an idea, only the specific execution. Even the infamous Art Buchwald Coming To America case ended up with him losing the case for them stealing his idea and script. He only won the breach of contract case because they had actually signed a contract with him.

And the bigger problem is there are no new ideas. I could make a movie about a robot hippo who lived on the Moon and controlled the weather and there will be at least ten people who will genuinely believe I stole it from them and who will have a script that is very similar. I have written scripts and then seen identical plots produced. I would swear they stole it except for the fact that I had not finished mine and had sent it to no one.


Hey... That Hippo was my idea... Im going to sue you now...

jk

And I actually had that happen to me when I was younger. I would get bored and pen stories for the heck of it. I had the finally all set in my head and ready to be written in the final story. And as I watched an anime, it ended the exact same way I was going to end my story. And I have never even heard of this anime till then. So I had no idea what it was about. I laughed and said oh well and wrote the ending anyways.
 
2011-10-18 01:51:39 PM
Flint Ironstag: And the bigger problem is there are no new ideas.

See also: writing songs in a guitar-based hard rock style. Hmmm...everything in E or A or D (or their minor equivalents), lots of riffs in the box pattern (D-E-G-A), the Bo Diddley rhythm etc.
 
2011-10-18 02:39:29 PM
Does no one else find it telling that his marriage ended during the honeymoon? Over what?

Money.

He sounds like a dick looking for an opportunity for easy money.
 
Displayed 12 of 12 comments


This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »