If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Huffington Post) Spiffy London Philharmonic follows the money, releasing album of greatest video game music   (huffingtonpost.com) divider line 103
More: Spiffy, London Philharmonic, The Legend of Zelda, musical play, Angry Birds, music  
•       •       •

4283 clicks; posted to Geek » on 16 Oct 2011 at 1:06 AM   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»   |    Get this fabulous T-Shirt and impress the methane out of your friends! shirt it!



103 Comments   (+0 »)
   

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | » | Last | Show all
 
2011-10-16 01:07:48 AM
The London Philharmonic Orchestra actually does a ton of game music. They recorded the first OST for Xenosaga, which is one of Mitsuda's best works.

/nerrds
 
2011-10-16 01:16:09 AM
Tch. Not to be overly patriotic but I would prefer to hear a British orchestra choose to highlight the best British game music instead (new window).
 
2011-10-16 01:16:47 AM
Here (new window) is the actual track listing which the article omits for some strange reason.


There is a distinct lack of FF VII (although they did include the main theme and there's a piece from VIII)
 
2011-10-16 01:29:47 AM
Was it performed in monophonic 8 bit instruments?
 
2011-10-16 01:43:37 AM
Harry_Seldon: Was it performed in monophonic 8 bit instruments?

No, but I understand a great deal of the instruments had to be blown into to get them to work properly.
 
2011-10-16 01:43:54 AM
Want. Want so much.
 
2011-10-16 01:47:26 AM
The COD track embeded in the page is pretty good.

I dislike that player though, the volume on it is LOUD compared to everything else on my system.

Doesn't have anything on the Halo collection, Marty O'Donnell's stuff is made with goodness to begin with though. ODST's soundtrack(used in game and on CD) was very awesome. My only nitpick is that each track(a few, can't remember if they all do it) has a tendency to feel as if it's several spliced together. Very cool mellow jazzy stuff turns right into BOSS FIGHT!!...and then back, and then BOSS FIGHT!. Annoying, but still worth a listen.
 
2011-10-16 01:50:14 AM
Do I get to have a cheeseburger with President Reagan after listening to it?
 
2011-10-16 01:51:42 AM
Ok...someone explain this to me. COD: MW and COD: MW 2 are on there for some reason. But there's nothing from Ace Combat 4/5/X and only one version of the MGS's theme. What teh f*ck?

Also, the title :The Greatest Video Game Music? This is exactly like those idiotic "Best Games Ever" lists that only sample games from 2004 on.

/Still going to buy it
//VG music is under-appreciated
 
2011-10-16 02:20:41 AM
Robo Beat: Harry_Seldon: Was it performed in monophonic 8 bit instruments?

No, but I understand a great deal of the instruments had to be blown into to get them to work properly.


heh. nice
 
2011-10-16 02:23:40 AM
Like more metal (new window) sounding ones, too.
 
2011-10-16 02:33:34 AM
Meh, that list is way too skewed toward modern games and most modern games have uninspiring generic music with zero melody.

Also, the fark is Angry Birds doing there...? Jeez, follow the money indeed.
 
2011-10-16 02:34:17 AM
No Megaman? NO MEGAMAN? That's criminal...

Ditto for no Street Fighter...
 
2011-10-16 02:36:49 AM
rocky_howard: No Megaman? NO MEGAMAN? That's criminal...

Ditto for no Street Fighter...


Here you go...

Part 1 (new window)
Part 2 (new window)
 
2011-10-16 02:43:08 AM
Gordon Bennett: Tch. Not to be overly patriotic but I would prefer to hear a British orchestra choose to highlight the best British game music instead (new window).

I was hoping a track by the Follin brothers would end up on the list.
 
2011-10-16 03:30:09 AM
On some level, I know it'll never happen, but I still can't help but wish for a song or two from NieR to be included in collections like this. Still a pretty cool collection of songs -- maybe Angry Birds aside.
 
2011-10-16 03:32:52 AM
Shambling_Corp_Presence: On some level, I know it'll never happen, but I still can't help but wish for a song or two from NieR to be included in collections like this. Still a pretty cool collection of songs -- maybe Angry Birds aside.

Thus, too.
 
2011-10-16 03:35:33 AM
inkblot: Shambling_Corp_Presence: On some level, I know it'll never happen, but I still can't help but wish for a song or two from NieR to be included in collections like this. Still a pretty cool collection of songs -- maybe Angry Birds aside.

Thus, too.


I mean this. THIS. I need sleep.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D4VA8furPFs
 
2011-10-16 03:45:15 AM
Needs Star Control II, Mechwarrior II and Little Big Adventure.
 
2011-10-16 03:55:01 AM
Snapper Carr: Here (new window) is the actual track listing which the article omits for some strange reason.


There is a distinct lack of FF VII (although they did include the main theme and there's a piece from VIII)


I would suggest to you that you may look up "Tour de Japon." Its performed by the New Japan Philharmonic. It is also quite excellent. They pull off flawless renditions of many songs - all are FF songs. You can find it on youtube to view in its entirety(one song at a time) but I found a DVD image(MUCH BETTER sound quality) on a torrent site a long time ago. If I could read Japanese, maybe I could find a place to legitimately buy it. Its very well worth it.

I should also mention Nobuo Uematsu comes out and conducts a song himself.
 
2011-10-16 03:58:35 AM
Needs more Yasunori Mitsuda (new window)
 
2011-10-16 04:18:02 AM
For my money, the absolute best orchestral concert was Symphonic Shades. I'm not really happy with these selections, because too many of them are results of the desire for "epic" music that game composers seem to have when they get access to an orchestra. Mass Effect 2's Suicide Mission in particular is so overdramatic that it's almost a self-parody. The Oblivion piece has potential if they perform it as a suite, as Soule's compositions for that game include a lot of really nice subtle pieces. I especially like Watchman's Ease (new window).
 
2011-10-16 04:20:41 AM
omeganuepsilon: Doesn't have anything on the Halo collection

According to the link Snapper Carr posted, it has "One Final Effort" from Halo 3, which is an excellent track (one of my favorites, and I think Halo 3 has one of the best video game soundtracks ever). Overall, the album looks like a good mix of excellent game music from all over. I'm looking forward to it.

What it is truly lacking, unless it's mixed in to the Zelda Suite, is music from The Ocarina of Time. While Zelda Reorchestrated has that and pretty much all other Zelda music taken care of, I'd really like to hear actual performance versions of a lot of that music.
 
2011-10-16 04:22:30 AM
bVork: Mass Effect 2's Suicide Mission in particular is so overdramatic that it's almost a self-parody.

Heh. I like the track, but this is so true. Was it the vocal "bah-bah-BAP babah-bah-BAP..." that did it for you? Or is that just me. ;)
 
2011-10-16 04:31:03 AM
Yeah, that part where it sounds like they just use every instrument in an orchestra at the same time. With a wordless choir on top. It's just utterly ridiculous. I thought the Mass Effect 2 soundtrack as a whole was a massive step back from the understated analogue synth of the first game. Still a fantastic game, though.
 
2011-10-16 04:44:45 AM
mamoru: omeganuepsilon: Doesn't have anything on the Halo collection

According to the link Snapper Carr posted, it has "One Final Effort" from Halo 3, which is an excellent track (one of my favorites, and I think Halo 3 has one of the best video game soundtracks ever). Overall, the album looks like a good mix of excellent game music from all over. I'm looking forward to it.

I knew something of Marty's would make it as soon as I read the linked article, I did see the list, to check out which one made it.

I'm not familiar with other sound tracks as much as ODST, just what I manage to snag in the game really, ODST's sandbox style game got me a lot more exposure and interest in the music, so I listened to the CD, maybe someday I'll check out the other soundtracks, as they were all good from what I recall.
 
2011-10-16 04:47:02 AM
 
2011-10-16 04:51:29 AM
srtpointman: Do I get to have a cheeseburger with President Reagan after listening to it?

Only if you are a bad Dude....



///videogame arcade and home music composer :)
///love this thread
 
2011-10-16 04:53:03 AM
They're missing "To Zanarkand" from FFX. a terrible game, but better piece of music than most of what's on there.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P5tWGsQ2dtw
 
2011-10-16 05:02:49 AM
Old Battlefield themes > New Battlefield theme.
 
2011-10-16 05:07:05 AM
Also conspicuous by its absence, this remix of a song from some flower game, done in the style of some guys from England.
 
2011-10-16 05:24:19 AM
rocky_howard: Meh, that list is way too skewed toward modern games and most modern games have uninspiring generic music with zero melody.

Also, the fark is Angry Birds doing there...? Jeez, follow the money indeed.


Seriously... There are something like three or four tracks on the disk that are even remotely worth listening to (outside their respective games), and two of those are Tetris and Super Mario Bros.
 
2011-10-16 06:06:21 AM
Genju: rocky_howard: No Megaman? NO MEGAMAN? That's criminal...

Ditto for no Street Fighter...

Here you go...

Part 1 (new window)
Part 2 (new window)


That was wonderful!
 
2011-10-16 06:21:22 AM
For game music & more, I humbly submit Radio Rivendell.
Link
 
2011-10-16 06:25:26 AM
Wish they had done some stuff from this: t0.gstatic.com
 
2011-10-16 06:53:26 AM
No Megaman, No Street Fighter, and they omit the only piece of video game music to have won a Grammy.

Yeah, not that great a list.

/I would have groused about no Katamari there, but don't know how well it would have translated to orchestra
 
2011-10-16 07:15:48 AM
Hmmm....


dl.dropbox.com

I smell a lawsuit!
 
2011-10-16 07:18:57 AM
way south: Hmmm....


[dl.dropbox.com image 634x473]

I smell a lawsuit!

dl.dropbox.com


/You'd think I'd learn to always preview by now...
 
2011-10-16 07:25:48 AM
What about the theme from morrowind? Or the "over the sea" track from Rocket Knight?
 
2011-10-16 07:25:55 AM
I got to agree with some of the people complaining that most of the greatest videos games are apparently less than ten years old. The original old-school nintendo system had some suprisingly good music, but at least they took the best ones (FF, SMB, Tetric, and Zelda).

As a side note, does anyone else think the music for Oblivion is eerily similar to the music on the Pirates of the Caribbean movies?
 
2011-10-16 08:13:21 AM
Seriously... Angry Bird made it but not this?

Link

Objection! I grow tired of the foolish foolery of the foolish fools of this foolish pandering.
 
2011-10-16 08:33:53 AM
bVork: It's just utterly ridiculous. I thought the Mass Effect 2 soundtrack as a whole was a massive step back from the understated analogue synth of the first game. Still a fantastic game, though.

I definitely agree about the music, and mostly about it being a fantastic game. ME2 dropped the good story-telling, good consistent universe, and fairly ok character building of ME1 in favor of "rule of cool" all over the place. Focusing only on the music, you can hear it in just about every track of the soundtrack, all trying too hard to be EPIC AND AWESOME!!!1!!1oneone, and like you said, almost ending up a self-parody. And I say this despite liking the sound track well enough (I'd say "The Long Walk" is the best track on the ME2 soundtrack). However, I do see it for what it is.

Same with almost everything else in the game. Random nameless merc bands suddenly got brand-names and matching armor. Vacuum rated armor got replaced with spandex and high-heels. Space-suits with helmets for dangerous environments or vacuums got replaced with breathing masks, so as not to cover up the oh-so-important skin tight body suits. Story was weak, inconsistent and made little sense, especially with the addition of the last DLC. Everyone says the real meat of the game was building the team, but aside from going out and collecting a bunch of folks there was no *team-building* at all. There were no missions designed to forge the group into a team. There was no interaction between all of the folks you pick up (aside from a catfight and an annoyance) that would build team cohesion. There was nothing teambuilding at all except for getting the characters and putting them on your ship. Even the characters didn't really get a chance to shine, because of that. It's like Bioware/EA had all of those stories for cool characters, and they threw them into the pot, but they forgot to mix.

But, I digress, and I'm starting to rant. And, all that despite actually liking the game quite a bit (I've just put in my 300th hour, and I still have probably about 15-20hrs left on this play through, which is meant to be my "canon" play-through to carry into ME3). I do like the game well enough. If anything I'm just disappointed by what it could have and should have been.

We'll just have to see if ME3 redeems it or not.
 
2011-10-16 08:55:16 AM
Cytokine Storm: Needs more Yasunori Mitsuda (new window)

Zarathustra from Xenosaga (new window)

Eighteen minute long Chrono Cross/Trigger live syphony (new window)
 
2011-10-16 09:15:52 AM
No Dancing Mad? Aria de Mezzo Carattere (FF6 opera scene)?
 
2011-10-16 09:17:59 AM
PonceAlyosha: Cytokine Storm: Needs more Yasunori Mitsuda (new window)

Zarathustra from Xenosaga (new window)

Eighteen minute long Chrono Cross/Trigger live syphony (new window)


Xenoblade (new window)
 
2011-10-16 09:26:58 AM
Niveras: No Dancing Mad? Aria de Mezzo Carattere (FF6 opera scene)?

Live orchestral FFVI opera scene (new window)
 
2011-10-16 09:30:31 AM
PonceAlyosha: The London Philharmonic Orchestra actually does a ton of game music. They recorded the first OST for Xenosaga, which is one of Mitsuda's best works.

/nerrds


I found Xenosaga I lacking, specially vis a vis Chrono Trigger/Cross/Xenogears. Heck, several parts of the game had no music at all in Xenosaga I

Xenosaga II and III got a bump in their OST with Yuki Kajiura
 
2011-10-16 09:37:17 AM
If the London Philharmonic is doing this for the money, and they are being paid well, I say good for them.

But if they're doing this a cultivation tool, thinking that people who buy the album will become interested in buying tickets to a concert of Brahms, Berlioz and Prokofiev, then they're being delusional.
 
2011-10-16 09:40:27 AM
Dinobot: PonceAlyosha: The London Philharmonic Orchestra actually does a ton of game music. They recorded the first OST for Xenosaga, which is one of Mitsuda's best works.

/nerrds

I found Xenosaga I lacking, specially vis a vis Chrono Trigger/Cross/Xenogears. Heck, several parts of the game had no music at all in Xenosaga I

Xenosaga II and III got a bump in their OST with Yuki Kajiura


Speaking of which, Orchestral version of "A Light from the Netherworld from Xenogears" (new window) and The Treasure that Can Not Be Stolen from the same. (new window)
 
2011-10-16 09:45:46 AM
PonceAlyosha:
Speaking of which, Orchestral version of "A Light from the Netherworld from Xenogears" (new window) and The Treasure that Can Not Be Stolen from the same. (new window)


Those are beautiful~

Have you check http://xenogears.ocremix.org/ ?
 
Displayed 50 of 103 comments

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | » | Last | Show all


This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »