If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Foreign Policy) Fail American wasn't really that great   (foreignpolicy.com) divider line 152
More: Fail, Hellfire missiles, Wehrmacht, individual freedoms, political discussion, American exceptionalism, Russia, International Politics, political culture  
•       •       •

7619 clicks; posted to Politics » on 15 Oct 2011 at 5:57 PM   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»   |    Get this fabulous T-Shirt and impress the methane out of your friends! shirt it!



152 Comments   (+0 »)
   

Archived thread

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | » | Last | Show all
 
2011-10-15 04:44:42 PM
I know it tastes bad but reality is good for you.

/i'll give you a lolly after.
 
2011-10-15 05:59:14 PM
Next you are going to tell me that the terrorists didn't attack us because they hate our freedom.
 
2011-10-15 06:00:03 PM
I'm a Southwest guy myself.
 
2011-10-15 06:00:28 PM
That's why I fly Southwest.
 
2011-10-15 06:00:29 PM
Yakk: Next you are going to tell me that the terrorists didn't attack us because they hate our freedom.

Pfft I thought it was hip to praise the death of bankers and the firemen who went to rescue their corporate masters.
 
2011-10-15 06:00:56 PM
fta The idea that the United States is uniquely virtuous may be comforting to Americans. Too bad it's not true.

I never knew American Exceptionalism was a claim of unique virtue
 
2011-10-15 06:01:26 PM
www.roaneviews.com
 
2011-10-15 06:03:49 PM
Of course we're virtuous, that's why we use taxes and inflationary practices from the Federal Reserve to bail out bankers/failed automotive makers/fund the military-industrial complex to bomb non-capitalist countries.

USA! USA!
 
2011-10-15 06:04:54 PM
You mean our derp is not exceptional when compared to the WDMI? (World Derp Mean Index.)
 
2011-10-15 06:05:24 PM
We've had disciples of Leo Strauss in the government during both Bush administrations, the Reagan administration and the Ford administration, and these same people have been hired again in Romney's campaign. The big point of Strauss' philosophy was controlling the population through American mythology that the elites themselves aren't suppose to believe, the biggest one being the myth of American exceptionalism. Others politicians glom onto such beliefs and use it to boost their own election chances as well.
 
2011-10-15 06:11:18 PM
So, Obama compares America to some of history's greatest civilizations (including Ancient Greece, which was just about as awesome as civilizations get), and Romney has a problem with this?
 
2011-10-15 06:12:35 PM
img543.imageshack.us
 
2011-10-15 06:13:36 PM
red red wine. It tastes so fine....../over and over
ship crashes into dock
 
2011-10-15 06:13:45 PM
Notabunny: fta The idea that the United States is uniquely virtuous may be comforting to Americans. Too bad it's not true.

I never knew American Exceptionalism was a claim of unique virtue


Think about what you just said. Then realize how retarded it sounds.
 
2011-10-15 06:14:29 PM
sithon: I know it tastes bad but reality is good for you.

Agreed.

I'd rather hear a hard truth than a self-serving lie any day.

"Disillusioned" is not a fun word but it *is*, for the most part, a good word.

When discussing the myth of American Exceptionalism the difference between a justifiable sense of pride and dangerously myopic hubris is important to note.
 
2011-10-15 06:14:39 PM
B-b-b-but without nationalism, I can't take pride in something I have no part of controlling!!!
 
2011-10-15 06:15:11 PM
Every Nation/Culture has had and will have its great moments and its horrible moments. America is no exception.

The derp-squad teabaggers who think admitting this self-evident, basic truth is heresy are the ones who would ramp up the number of not-so-good moments for this country, all the while thinking and proclaiming loudly that they are acting infallibly and are in-line with the most caring of Christian principles.
 
2011-10-15 06:15:27 PM
Abraham Lincoln's admonition that our greatest concern should be "whether we are on God's side"

That's a good one.

/Abe was a RINO
 
2011-10-15 06:15:45 PM
There are actually two different meanings of "American Exceptionalism" that get conflated. One is the sense that TFA is talking about--that America is morally better than other countries, or that America is more virtuous.

But the other sense of "American Exceptionalism" is that America is an exception to moral rules which apply to others. That is, it would be wrong for other countries to use military force to ensure political and economic gain, but it is not wrong for America to use such force.

People don't usually distinguish between the two, and that leads to much confusion.
 
2011-10-15 06:16:05 PM
Ooh...Newt is not gonna like this!

/it's pretty much all he has left now
 
2011-10-15 06:17:36 PM
Gwyrddu: We've had disciples of Leo Strauss in the government during both Bush administrations, the Reagan administration and the Ford administration, and these same people have been hired again in Romney's campaign. The big point of Strauss' philosophy was controlling the population through American mythology that the elites themselves aren't suppose to believe, the biggest one being the myth of American exceptionalism. Others politicians glom onto such beliefs and use it to boost their own election chances as well.

That reminds me of a character in Henry Fielding's Tom Jones who believed that religion was to keep simple-minded people happy. It was useful to the rich and enlightened, but the ruling class did not consider it necessary to believe it themselves. It was just another one of their tools to confound the masses.
 
2011-10-15 06:18:45 PM
logic523: There are actually two different meanings of "American Exceptionalism" that get conflated. One is the sense that TFA is talking about--that America is morally better than other countries, or that America is more virtuous.

But the other sense of "American Exceptionalism" is that America is an exception to moral rules which apply to others. That is, it would be wrong for other countries to use military force to ensure political and economic gain, but it is not wrong for America to use such force.

People don't usually distinguish between the two, and that leads to much confusion.


Kinda like the whole "debt" vs "deficit" confusion that always seems to pop up during budget debates.
 
2011-10-15 06:20:50 PM
Tripp Johnston Private Eye: B-b-b-but without nationalism, I can't take pride in something I have no part of controlling!!!

There's always MNF.

*blinks*
 
2011-10-15 06:20:52 PM
Whar #OccupyEverything thread?
 
2011-10-15 06:22:07 PM
Huggermugger: Ooh...Newt is not gonna like this!

/it's pretty much all he has left now

Well that and the free publicity for he and his wife's books by pretending to run for POTUS
 
2011-10-15 06:23:16 PM
Tripp Johnston Private Eye: B-b-b-but without nationalism, I can't take pride in something I have no part of controlling!!!

Nationalism is the cog having a sense of accomplishment for the actions of the whole.

Liberal puke.
 
2011-10-15 06:23:23 PM
America is exceptional. Our constitution was unique in it's time, and has been a basis for nearly every national charter drafted since.

Now our people, on the other hand... We're pretty much a nation of 300million illiterate land cows and Lance Armstrong.
 
2011-10-15 06:26:28 PM
RanDomino: Whar #OccupyEverything thread?

The powers that be have red-lighted them.

We need:

#OccupyFARK

To be fair the headlines are not so good, and there is not much discussion in them.
 
2011-10-15 06:27:33 PM
logic523: There are actually two different meanings of "American Exceptionalism" that get conflated. One is the sense that TFA is talking about--that America is morally better than other countries, or that America is more virtuous.

But the other sense of "American Exceptionalism" is that America is an exception to moral rules which apply to others. That is, it would be wrong for other countries to use military force to ensure political and economic gain, but it is not wrong for America to use such force.

People don't usually distinguish between the two, and that leads to much confusion.


I've heard the first used to justify the second. That is, because we're morally superior, attacking another country must be right. It's an incredibly scary position.
 
2011-10-15 06:27:54 PM
Nothing untrue was said here....
 
2011-10-15 06:32:38 PM
Gwyrddu: We've had disciples of Leo Strauss in the government during both Bush administrations, the Reagan administration and the Ford administration, and these same people have been hired again in Romney's campaign. The big point of Strauss' philosophy was controlling the population through American mythology that the elites themselves aren't suppose to believe, the biggest one being the myth of American exceptionalism. Others politicians glom onto such beliefs and use it to boost their own election chances as well.

Fark, like a broken clock seems to be right twice a day. Well done.
 
2011-10-15 06:33:02 PM
sithon: I know it tastes bad but reality is good for you.

/i'll give you a lolly after.


It's watermellon flavored, isn't it?
 
2011-10-15 06:34:38 PM
sheilanagig: Gwyrddu: We've had disciples of Leo Strauss in the government during both Bush administrations, the Reagan administration and the Ford administration, and these same people have been hired again in Romney's campaign. The big point of Strauss' philosophy was controlling the population through American mythology that the elites themselves aren't suppose to believe, the biggest one being the myth of American exceptionalism. Others politicians glom onto such beliefs and use it to boost their own election chances as well.

That reminds me of a character in Henry Fielding's Tom Jones who believed that religion was to keep simple-minded people happy. It was useful to the rich and enlightened, but the ruling class did not consider it necessary to believe it themselves. It was just another one of their tools to confound the masses.


Wtf was Karl Marx doing in Tom Jones?
 
2011-10-15 06:35:19 PM
udhq: Our constitution was unique in it's time

True, but it hasn't aged well.

I don't know of any other democracy has such an institution as the Electoral College, for example. I don't understand why a voter from South Dakota should have more say in a Presidential election than a voter from California.
 
2011-10-15 06:38:31 PM
McManus_brothers: Wtf was Karl Marx doing in Tom Jones?

Opium. Duh.
 
2011-10-15 06:39:21 PM
farkityfarker: udhq: Our constitution was unique in it's time

True, but it hasn't aged well.

I don't know of any other democracy has such an institution as the Electoral College, for example. I don't understand why a voter from South Dakota should have more say in a Presidential election than a voter from California.


Becuase the founders wanted to be sure that the smaller states were being represented, and all the power and control didn't fall to just a couple of 'big' states.
 
2011-10-15 06:40:03 PM
www.ilovecopperplategothicbold.com
 
2011-10-15 06:40:36 PM
Newt is big on this theme - he just wrote the book A Nation Like No Other: Why American Exceptionalism Matters

Let's see how Amazon customers tag Newt's Exceptionalism
 
2011-10-15 06:42:24 PM
GodsTumor: Huggermugger: Ooh...Newt is not gonna like this!

/it's pretty much all he has left now
Well that and the free publicity for he and his wife's books by pretending to run for POTUS


Which wife?
 
2011-10-15 06:43:03 PM
McManus_brothers: Wtf was Karl Marx doing in Tom Jones?

There's nothing new under the sun, it would appear. I think it was used cynically in Tom Jones, to illustrate the obnoxious atheist from the ruling class.
 
2011-10-15 06:44:20 PM
Sovereignty to the people. Its the most powerful thing we collectively have, and its not exercised nearly enough.

Denouncements of nationalism need to have a sister component of the long and often connected series of struggles related to moving many from what used to be often hereditary rule regimes controlling large swaths of multi-ethnic, sweeping empires. Hipster U.S. developed this in a different way, sure, but I never seem to see people throw in this extremely important component when they proclaim themselves citizens of the world. This is exceptionally important as the powerful that has so much focus, has been described as shifting their focus internationally, and having much more connections to their class peers in far away lands than to the pleb living 10 miles away.

We live in a very peculiar and small slice of time where sovereignty belongs to the people. it has not been this way for thousands of years, and theres been a huge series of struggles to get us to that point. Remember and exercise that right, and be sure to add that in on any break down of nationalism.
 
2011-10-15 06:44:46 PM
hawcian: logic523: There are actually two different meanings of "American Exceptionalism" that get conflated. One is the sense that TFA is talking about--that America is morally better than other countries, or that America is more virtuous.

But the other sense of "American Exceptionalism" is that America is an exception to moral rules which apply to others. That is, it would be wrong for other countries to use military force to ensure political and economic gain, but it is not wrong for America to use such force.

People don't usually distinguish between the two, and that leads to much confusion.

I've heard the first used to justify the second. That is, because we're morally superior, attacking another country must be right. It's an incredibly scary position.


This is pretty much the position I've found among many of my friends who are hardcore Republicans. They see America as the literal city on the hill and believe that it is our duty to show other people, through force if necessary, that the American way is the only morally right way to run a society. It terrifies me that people can believe in preemptive war.
 
2011-10-15 06:45:23 PM
Embracing ignorance, promoting anti-science, selling fear, saying "fark the weakest of us"

we're a farking exception alright
 
2011-10-15 06:46:13 PM
Yeah_Right: farkityfarker: udhq: Our constitution was unique in it's time

True, but it hasn't aged well.

I don't know of any other democracy has such an institution as the Electoral College, for example. I don't understand why a voter from South Dakota should have more say in a Presidential election than a voter from California.

Becuase the founders wanted to be sure that the smaller states were being represented, and all the power and control didn't fall to just a couple of 'big' states.


I understand why it was originally there. I don't understand why it still is.

Would it be controversial for America to elect its President by popular vote of the people? After all, the Supreme Court has ruled similar systems as the electoral college at the state level to be unconstitutional as a violation of the "one man one vote" principle.
 
2011-10-15 06:47:11 PM
RanDomino: Whar #OccupyEverything thread?

Blairr: Tripp Johnston Private Eye: B-b-b-but without nationalism, I can't take pride in something I have no part of controlling!!!

Nationalism is the cog having a sense of accomplishment for the actions of the whole.

Liberal puke.


What accomplishments? The United States is a disgusting shiathole and has been for 30+ years. I have no desire to contribute to it until major political reform comes first. Then I could take a little pride.

Also, U MAD, BLAIRR?
 
2011-10-15 06:48:31 PM
It's official.

America has sharp knees.
 
2011-10-15 06:48:32 PM
The_Terminator: [www.ilovecopperplategothicbold.com image 425x312]

FAIL! No sparkles.
 
2011-10-15 06:48:51 PM
Notabunny: fta The idea that the United States is uniquely virtuous may be comforting to Americans. Too bad it's not true.

I never knew American Exceptionalism was a claim of unique virtue


Uhhh.. . Yeah, that's the whole point of it. We're exceptional and unique in the world and history.
 
2011-10-15 06:52:25 PM
Those colourful phrases are descriptions applied to the country and not the foreign policy. This article is indeed FAIL.

I've lived here for 5 years and I can report there's nothing exceptional about the country either. In fact I'm impressed by how utterly uninteresting it is.
 
2011-10-15 06:54:45 PM
Gwyrddu: disciples of Leo Strauss

If you get a chance: The Power of Nightmares (new window)

I am about as conservative as it gets, and there was a ton of good information in that little series. You can download it at that link for free, and it's worth watching.

Ignore the twits screaming that it's "Leftist Propaganda". I found it to be objective and amazingly good.

/sorry, gush mode off.
 
Displayed 50 of 152 comments

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | » | Last | Show all


This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »