If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Some Guy)   Student stabs himself in the hand with a pen to prove the existence of God. It didn't work   (collegiatetimes.com) divider line 439
    More: Strange, stabbing, emergency calls, student groups, stabs, Student stabs, Nicole Schrand, existence, resisting arrest  
•       •       •

15471 clicks; posted to Main » on 14 Apr 2011 at 3:04 AM   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»



439 Comments   (+0 »)
   

Archived thread

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | » | Last | Show all
 
2011-04-13 11:45:00 PM
Your Bic has forsaken you.
 
2011-04-13 11:46:38 PM
FTFA: Alexander M. Huppert, a freshman university studies major

What's a university studies major..... do they study universities?
 
2011-04-13 11:52:37 PM
Ugh, at this rate we'll switch from racial and religious profiling to "Have you ever been a student at Virginia Tech?" =/
 
2011-04-13 11:52:42 PM
Always a bummer when the schizo fires up in the kiddies.
 
2011-04-13 11:52:56 PM
Arthur Jumbles: FTFA: Alexander M. Huppert, a freshman university studies major

What's a university studies major..... do they study universities?


www.fatguygolf.net
 
2011-04-13 11:55:59 PM
Arthur Jumbles: What's a university studies major..... do they study universities?

Kinda, it's Tech's "undecided" option, you can be there for your 1st two years.
 
2011-04-13 11:57:30 PM
TFA:If it had been a more streamlined pen, I would have expected it to go through
images.easyart.com
 
jbc [TotalFark]
2011-04-13 11:57:35 PM
Someone needs to check his computer for a Richard McBeef sequel.
 
2011-04-13 11:58:12 PM
A for effort, E for execution. So we'll give it a C.
 
2011-04-13 11:59:18 PM
Arthur Jumbles: FTFA: Alexander M. Huppert, a freshman university studies major

What's a university studies major..... do they study universities?


I hear they weave a mean basket.
 
2011-04-14 12:02:06 AM
Theaetetus: A for effort, E for execution. So we'll give it a C.

And what does Jesus's last name start with?

Bam, there's your proof.
 
2011-04-14 12:02:19 AM
I'm not sure how stabbing a cross on the back of someone's hand will prove the existence of God.
 
2011-04-14 12:04:56 AM
I wish my campus atheist group had seen crazy like this.
 
2011-04-14 12:07:38 AM
The "use" of "quotes" throughout the "article" was "commendable."
Thank "GOD" for those "brave" and "courageous" people that "saved" everyone from that "pen-wielding" *hic* "drunk" *hic* freshman
 
2011-04-14 12:20:42 AM
Atheist groups are weird.

Religion is a community. Christians, Muslims, Jews, Buddhists, Daoists, Wiccans; they all have provisions in their religions that create an organization of other members. In the monotheistic religions, their clergy are the voice of god on Earth. In the non-theistic religions like Buddhism, the community is seen as nessecary to provide the ideal environment for study of the religious principles so you can get deeper quicker and without wasting years and decades like the Buddha did.

But atheism merely requires you do nothing. And not all atheists are atheists for the same reason. Some approach it from a position of educated wisdom, but many more approach it out of reactionary ignorance. The whole "Prove god exists and I'll believe." doesn't work when you don't actually go take a look at the proof which is found in certain religious practices. Oh, but wait, that takes physical and mental discipline to actually accomplish the proper depth of meditation so I'll just ignore 10,000s of years of indirect evidence of something important being here and just call it a life.

If you've actually taken the time, put in the sweat, touched the divine and still decided you do not believe that there's anything worthwhile to religion that's a commendable choice on your part, but STILL the group confuses me. You deny something for various reasons, so you don't care about it at all. It shouldn't even be a part of your life. Why waste time with declaring how much you don't believe in something with a bunch of people who feel the same way? Go play a sport or have another beer or something.

It would be like a group of people who were blind from birth getting together to discuss how they don't like the color of rooms in houses they've never been in or heard anyone describe to them.
 
2011-04-14 12:20:47 AM
imfreakinoutman.jpg
 
2011-04-14 12:25:48 AM
How in the hell does a stab wound in the hand prove or disprove anything except what a dicknut you are?
 
2011-04-14 12:28:44 AM
doglover: Atheist groups are weird.

And they get so offended if you point out that atheism is just another religion. If you spend your time in an atheist group talking about how much you love being an atheist and setting up tables to convert other people to atheism then for that person, atheism is a religion.
 
2011-04-14 12:31:08 AM
kitryne: How in the hell does a stab wound in the hand prove or disprove anything except what a dicknut you are?

It can prove that you're a total badass, but I don't think the god you would be proving would be the Christian one.

More like Tyr or Thor or Odin. I think berserks were said to have Odin's battle rage. If you are frothing at the mouth and fire cannot harm you and then you stab yourself in the hand, you might just be one of the faithful.
 
2011-04-14 12:32:19 AM
doglover: It would be like a group of people who were blind from birth getting together to discuss how they don't like the color of rooms in houses they've never been in or heard anyone describe to them.

That's all very silly of you to say.
A) plenty of atheists are active in their atheist communities, some, much to many people's chagrin even proselytize.

2) It takes more effort to think for yourself than to follow

c)All of that is explainable by science.

Atheists aren't weird. We're the same as everyone, we just prove to believe what's written in the science books instead of religious text. Many atheists meditate. Buddhism is an atheistic religion, and those dudes are the kings of meditation.

Some people want to get together with other people who see things the same general way as they do so they can discuss things. Same as religions. You don't need to have faith in a deity for that.

And some people want to dispel the image that people have of us, that we're evil sinners who'll suck you into damnation or whatever the hell it is people think we do. They don't like us, that's the point. And we would like to change that, because we're pretty cool and maybe you might learn something in the process.
 
2011-04-14 12:33:15 AM
doglover: If you've actually taken the time, put in the sweat, touched the divine

How do you touch the divine if you don't believe in the divine? Unless you meant "divan," in which case, I've done that. I was unimpressed. It was comfy and all, but that's about it.
 
2011-04-14 12:33:45 AM
doglover: More like Tyr or Thor or Odin. I think berserks were said to have Odin's battle rage. If you are frothing at the mouth and fire cannot harm you and then you stab yourself in the hand, you might just be one of the faithful.

See, like, I could see putting a cigar out on your face before going into a murder-rage working here, but somehow, a bic pen slightly denting your hand is just silly.
 
2011-04-14 12:34:13 AM
Sudo_Make_Me_A_Sandwich: If you spend your time in an atheist group talking about how much you love being an atheist and setting up tables to convert other people to atheism then for that person, atheism is a religion.

And a boring one at that! Seriously, would you rather party with the dudes who say "Our god is the god of wine. For him, AN ORGY!" or the guys who say "There's nothing but what physics already knows to life. Nothing. Yep. Still nothing."
 
2011-04-14 12:36:23 AM
doglover: And a boring one at that! Seriously, would you rather party with the dudes who say "Our god is the god of wine. For him, AN ORGY!" or the guys who say "There's nothing but what physics already knows to life. Nothing. Yep. Still nothing."

Man, are you kidding? Scientists make the BEST shiat. Those dudes can get down, with their labs and titration and abilities to buy chemicals without being asked a lot of questions.
 
2011-04-14 12:37:35 AM
Did he use a Bic Biro, Waterman 400 or a Montblanc 149? To really show proof of God he should have gone for a Namiki Emperor, it leaves a bigger hole.
 
2011-04-14 12:39:23 AM
Remember that time when Ashton Kutcher was in prison and he told his cellmate that he was Jesus? Then he went back in time and stabbed his hands in elementary school and when he came back to prison the religious guy believed him?

This is like that.
 
2011-04-14 12:39:40 AM
Sudo_Make_Me_A_Sandwich: If you spend your time in an atheist group talking about how much you love being an atheist and setting up tables to convert other people to atheism then for that person, atheism is a religion.

So political parties are religions too?
 
2011-04-14 12:42:45 AM
bighasbeen: So political parties are religions too?

...well...
 
2011-04-14 12:42:47 AM
bighasbeen: So political parties are religions too?

Are political parties organized around beliefs regarding the divine? Well, besides the GOP.
 
2011-04-14 12:51:46 AM
RodneyToady: How do you touch the divine if you don't believe in the divine?

A fair point. You put aside your childish beliefs in a magic sky jew and your adult beliefs in electromagnetic waves and atomic structure and practice a religion with an open mind for a change, expecting nothing. Then you may truly judge its worth. Chances are you will be surprised but likely not converted. (Unless it's Buddhism. Very tricksy, Buddhism is. But it's so full of amicable things almost anyone will find SOMETHING appealing. Especially if they don't believe in gods.)

That's all it takes. Find ONE religion and give it an honest chance and you will invariably find you were wrong about it. But be careful. It takes more than just sitting in a bench like a sheep. You have to pray or meditate or fast or climb the mountain or eat the cactus. You can't just sit there and expect something many, many, MANY wise men and women spent their whole lives seeking to understand to be presented up to you on a silver platter.

The whole point of religion is this effort on YOUR PART. It's something you do, not something you read. Going to Church on Sundays and saying grace isn't nearly the same thing as actually being a Christian. Nor is squating down five times a day and growing a beard gonna make you an actual Muslim. You have to change your mind from closed to open and then try honestly without expectations in order to observe something property.


kitryne: Atheists aren't weird. We're the same as everyone, we just prove to believe what's written in the science books instead of religious text.

That's not weird. What's weird is a community based around what is not even a lack, just a nothingness. You deny religion as though religion denied science. It doesn't, usually. You only experience red neck senators who wouldn't know about prayer if it bit them in the ass trying to endumben the public with retarded laws because "Science is hard." or "Babies are good!"

Look at a man like Mr Rogers. THAT is a practicing Christian. That is not only the ideal, but the inevitable result of the practices set forth in the Bible performed properly diligently.

Never confuse laypeople with the actual members of a religion. Even Scientologists can do a lot of good in the community via entertainment. I've also heard they're all smiles and work ethic on set, too. Just remember never to confuse authority in the cult with honest practice of the religion. Not always the same thing.
 
2011-04-14 12:53:22 AM
doglover: drivel

0/10
 
2011-04-14 12:54:16 AM
doglover: Why waste time with declaring how much you don't believe in something with a bunch of people who feel the same way?

Keep your religion out of my government, entirely, and I won't give a rat's ass about your religion. But when you use religion for justification from everything to anti gay marriage, anti choice, anti planned parenthood funding, creationism in schools, and even, somehow, farking economic policy ("Jesus didn't believe in the minimum wage"), then you're forcing me to get involved with your religion. Keep it to your own damn self and you won't have any problems.

/May not refer to you, but refers to many many religious people in America
 
2011-04-14 12:54:49 AM
Sudo_Make_Me_A_Sandwich: Are political parties organized around beliefs regarding the divine?

I just don't see advocacy of a position equaling religion.

kitryne: bighasbeen: So political parties are religions too?

...well...


I mean, it is zealotry.
 
2011-04-14 12:58:25 AM
doglover: adult beliefs in electromagnetic waves and atomic structure

Science is the search for fact, not truth. If it's truth you're interested in Dr. Tyree's philosophy class is right down the hall.
 
2011-04-14 01:04:18 AM
TheOnion: doglover: Why waste time with declaring how much you don't believe in something with a bunch of people who feel the same way?

Keep your religion out of my government, entirely, and I won't give a rat's ass about your religion.


Isn't it a bit ironic that you're angry about "religion" forcing itself into government, but you have no problem with atheism forcing itself in just the same way?

If you want to talk about brainwashing children, why don't we start with forcing Evolutionism down the throats of today's public school students?
 
2011-04-14 01:07:26 AM
doglover: That's all it takes. Find ONE religion and give it an honest chance and you will invariably find you were wrong about it.

Lawd, you're being serious.

When you look at the data, you'll find that atheists/agnostics know more about religion than any other group (new window).

The days of being able to accuse us of not knowing what it is that we're criticising are over, I'm happy to say.

doglover: The whole point of religion is this effort on YOUR PART. It's something you do, not something you read. Going to Church on Sundays and saying grace isn't nearly the same thing as actually being a Christian. Nor is squating down five times a day and growing a beard gonna make you an actual Muslim. You have to change your mind from closed to open and then try honestly without expectations in order to observe something property.

To be religious requires at least some kind of supernatural belief. If that's not what you mean by being religious, I don't know what you're talking about.

There is nothing that needs to be presupposed on insufficient evidence in order to reject all of the theistic doctrines on offer. All an atheist is is someone who has heard the claims made by the religious, considered them carefully and honestly, and found them to be ridiculous.

Atheist activists like the group in the story are people who want to educate and encourage critical thinking, and hopefully go some way to minimising the harm that is caused by religion (which there is no shortage of).

doglover: What's weird is a community based around what is not even a lack, just a nothingness.

The natural world, the world as it really is, is not nothing at all. In fact it's everything. The empty supernatural claims of believers - they're what really represent nothing. Atheist and skeptical activists do much good work, like promoting science education and resisting the infiltration of dogma into politics and other places it doesn't belong. We have well formed and rounded morals and philosophies. We exist as groups because we live in a world where many many people believe many very strange things. Organising how we do makes perfect sense in the context of the strange beliefs in society.

Another good thing we do is support many secret non-believers, who are unable to be honest about their atheism for fear of losing their family and friends - or even face the threat of abuse. This is a big problem for a lot of people, not just in the Islamic world but in middle America too.
 
2011-04-14 01:08:43 AM
AverageAmericanGuy: If you want to talk about brainwashing children, why don't we start with forcing Evolutionism down the throats of today's public school students?

8/10

You didn't overplay it, and you'll probably get a few bites.
 
2011-04-14 01:10:29 AM
AverageAmericanGuy: Isn't it a bit ironic that you're angry about "religion" forcing itself into government, but you have no problem with atheism forcing itself in just the same way?

Do you have any idea how nonsensical that question is? It's like saying "You spend all your time keeping guns out of schools, but you have no problem with NOTguns getting in?"

Ridiculous.
 
2011-04-14 01:11:50 AM
Sudo_Make_Me_A_Sandwich: You didn't overplay it, and you'll probably get a few bites.

>:|

fine...
 
2011-04-14 01:16:46 AM
doglover: And a boring one at that! Seriously, would you rather party with the dudes who say "Our god is the god of wine. For him, AN ORGY!" or the guys who say "There's nothing but what physics already knows to life. Nothing. Yep. Still nothing."

I can't speak for ancient Romans but in my experience the atheists and freethinkers are the ones most likely to take part in something like an orgy. Plus we've got science on our side, so it would be more like: "You kids have fun with your wine. We just grew some pot with triple the THC content and Andrew just made some LSD. Who wants to get farked up and have an orgy?"
 
2011-04-14 01:16:52 AM
Fuller: Sudo_Make_Me_A_Sandwich: You didn't overplay it, and you'll probably get a few bites.

>:|

fine...


I was halfway into typing "Establishment Clause" before I reconsidered and hit refresh.
 
2011-04-14 01:17:02 AM
doglover: Going to Church on Sundays and saying grace isn't nearly the same thing as actually being a Christian. Nor is squating down five times a day and growing a beard gonna make you an actual Muslim. You have to change your mind from closed to open and then try honestly without expectations in order to observe something property.

I'm an agnostic, not an atheist. I was raised Catholic, but it didn't take. By your standards, I know legitimate Catholics, other Christians, Jews, etc. I don't take issue with them. They embody the spiritual as well as nominal aspects of their faiths. But the vast majority of followers lack the spiritual aspect. They're born into their religion, or choose it out of desperation after illness or addiction. And they vote, and have political positions, and make laws. And they help drive whatever positive feelings I have about religion into the ground.

Many truly seek the divine, and some find it, and that's great. I'm fine with the concept of a deity, or many deities, in an abstract way. I'm fine with some people who believe in an interpersonal God who cares about them as an individual. I stop being fine when people tell me I should live my life, and we should base our laws, on some old book that claims to be the "Word of God."

Sorry. No.

A god or gods may or may not have created the universe. I don't know, and in a pretty fundamental way, I don't think it matters. But there's no way anyone is going to convince me that this god (or these gods) have any interest at all on the gender of the person I'm screwing, or whether or not I have a beard, or what I'm eating on any particular day of the week or year.
 
2011-04-14 01:21:20 AM
doglover: What's weird is a community based around what is not even a lack, just a nothingness.

See, that's not true at all. We believe that science made some pretty biatchin stuff and damned if we're not gonna learn everything about it.

I personally believe that the fact our existence happened pretty much by random chance on the grand scale of the universe(s?) is far more awe inspiring than to think that some dude put it together. It's just too easy of an answer.
 
2011-04-14 01:23:01 AM
doglover: What's weird is a community based around what is not even a lack, just a nothingness.

It helps understanding if you can grasp the notion that most of the "atheist communities" are not so much atheist as secularist.

TheOnion: Keep your religion out of my government, entirely, and I won't give a rat's ass about your religion.

...for example.

Fuller: To be religious requires at least some kind of supernatural belief.

"Supernatural" isn't the best dividing line, from what I can see; my impression is that a couple strains of Buddhism avoid it. The element of ritual seems a more precise demarcation - although the precise definition of "ritual" is anthropologically fuzzy.
 
2011-04-14 01:26:45 AM
doglover - here's a short piece to help you understand skeptical/atheist philosophy. It's new, and it's funny and entertaining even if you (somehow) come away disagreeing with it.

Link (new window)
 
2011-04-14 01:30:40 AM
abb3w: "Supernatural" isn't the best dividing line, from what I can see; my impression is that a couple strains of Buddhism avoid it. The element of ritual seems a more precise demarcation - although the precise definition of "ritual" is anthropologically fuzzy

Yeah I go with supernatural even though it may not be an absolutely perfect divider - the difference between natural and supernatural is about as clear as you can get. 'Ritual' is far more vague.

Fuller: doglover - here's a short piece to help you understand skeptical/atheist philosophy. It's new, and it's funny and entertaining even if you (somehow) come away disagreeing with it.

Link (new window)


Sorry should have warned NSFW - there's a couple of swears in there, nothing especially bad though.
 
2011-04-14 01:38:40 AM
Fuller: doglover - here's a short piece to help you understand skeptical/atheist philosophy. It's new, and it's funny and entertaining even if you (somehow) come away disagreeing with it.

Link (new window)


Wow, he certainly murdered that strawman.
 
2011-04-14 01:40:20 AM
See, we can get along! There just needs to be someone even crazier nearby.
 
2011-04-14 01:40:58 AM
Fuller: doglover - here's a short piece to help you understand skeptical/atheist philosophy. It's new, and it's funny and entertaining even if you (somehow) come away disagreeing with it.

Link (new window)


That was farking BEAUTIFUL. Thank you.
 
2011-04-14 01:43:48 AM
doglover: kitryne: How in the hell does a stab wound in the hand prove or disprove anything except what a dicknut you are?

It can prove that you're a total badass, dumbass but I don't think the god you would be proving would be the Christian one.

More like Tyr or Thor or Odin. I think berserks were said to have Odin's battle rage. If you are frothing at the mouth and fire cannot harm you and then you stab yourself in the hand, you might just be one of the faithful dumbasses.


ftfy
 
Displayed 50 of 439 comments

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | » | Last | Show all



This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »





Report