kerpal32: Satanicpuppy: It's not your farking decision.

true, but I do have a right to support the father who made it.

/what part of this aren't you grasping?

in fact what you're saying is that it's your opinion that anyone who has sex with someone 40 years younger than them sould automatically be castrated, regardless of what laws are in place?

you lose at internet whight knighting 101

kerpal32: There are lots of things that there are no laws against that I also do not support and actually oppose.

like what?

I'm curious

kerpal32: uttertosh: in fact what you're saying is that it's your opinion that anyone who has sex with someone 40 years younger than them sould automatically be castrated, regardless of what laws are in place?

nope. just 1 to cull the herd as an example will do.

/works better than telling them Keyser Söze's going to get them

Awesome. So, by your logic, the "one" that needs culled to warn the rest of the heard has just had his cum-uppance, so there wil now never ever be anything like this happen again!

I'm so happy that you just solved all pedo problems by making this example!!

/feels safer already

Santa's Knee:

That ain't right.

neither's cutting the woman's consensual lover's testicles off with a bread knife.

crappy logic is crappy.

username101: lilistonic: haterade69: /seriously, how do you not know the half+7 rule?

It's not a rule for me if it means that 76 year-old men see themselves as eligible to date me. In fact, it's not a rule at all, just something someone made up in an essay somewhere, and it keeps getting repeated.

There's a rule for that, right? Something that's repeated endlessly so people think it's solid or useful, even though it's actually full of crap?

glwtta: Seriously it's a rule in the sense of a "useful guideline", and it's pretty spot on.

I am fully immature enough to be grossed about by men over 5 or 6 years older than me. I suppose I don't count because I'm middle-aged, but I'm certain I'm not the only person who thinks this. Or do men get to apply the rule and women just get to accept it as real?

When I was a young adult, I could imagine being with a man 10-12 years older than me. Now, at 45, sex with a 57 year-old man sounds slightly icky, please no offense to those here. At age 17, I would have found the notion utterly appalling.

Still, that German girl was plenty old enough to decide for herself who she wants to fark, as there is no indication of coercion at all.

Girls think they're old enough. Maybe a few are. It doesn't justify the outcome, but as a parent of three young adult women, I know something about 17 year-old girls. Also was one. Maybe he was even dumber than her, thinking this is okay. But it almost never is, and he should not have gotten involved with her. Young women are often more mature than young men, so men their own age seem like children at times. But they're still at a period of development in which they are still changing monthly. Parents still have a job to do, though perhaps a less horrifying one than castration, and a man that old must be aware of this or there's something wrong with him.

Two of my girls have boyfriends much older than themselves. (Not *that* much older!) With the 24 year-old, I get it, I get them together, it makes complete sense. With the 19 year-old, yeah, they're okay for now. I'm not really cool with it, wish he was about 5 years younger, but you have to always remain supportive of your kids as people, and that's a tough age to be, not quite grown-up, but nearly. Young women are often more mature than young men, so men their own age seem like children at times.

lilistonic: Young women are often more mature than young men, so men their own age seem like children at times.

Darn it. That sentence wants to copy itself infinitely.

Still won't let a 76 year-old near me, no matter who thinks that's a "rule."

eraser8: doglover: SpaceyCat: Would you feel the same way if the genders were reversed?

Yes. A 57 year old woman who had any attraction beyond sexual to a 17 year old is kinda weird. It's too big an age gulf, that's why 99% of the time we don't see it. Go watch Harold and Maude. That will explain everything.

Strom Thurmond's last wife was 44 years his junior. That's a bigger age gap than in this case. Should people have been calling for Strom's castration?

So his wife was a teenager when he married her?

TenJed_77: lilplatinum: ftfa: He went to police in the town of Bielefeld where he lives but officers said they were powerless to intervene.

I call bullshiat, Bielefeld does not exist...

For a city that doesn't exist it seems to be pretty good size
http://maps.google.fr/maps?hl=fr&q=Bielefeld&um=1&ie=UTF-8&hq=&hnear=Bielefeld, + Allemagne&gl=fr&ei=ACsGTdTjNs_xsgaplKz4CQ&sa=X&oi=geocode_result&ct=image&resnum =1&ved=0CBwQ8gEwAA

I'm guessing he didn't actually read the wiki entry he linked to since it does say the city exists. What's a myth is the claim that the city doesn't exist, again mentioned in the entry he linked to.

kerpal32: uttertosh: I'm so happy that you just solved all pedo problems by making this example!!

Is that really what you think I'm attempting to do? solve all pedo problems in the world your over simplification of the problem and irrational adherence to the absolute limits of the law where age of consent is concerned by my
a) pointing out how the 57 yr old was wrong,
b) pointing out that age of consent does not mean someone who is 17 makes rational or sound judgments
c) that does not excuse the 57 yr old
d) empathizing with the father instead of the victim
e) supporting the perpetuation of the psychotic over protective father in society because it does serve a purpose
f) a few other things you apparently can't grasp


whatever,


/go grow up and have some kids.

so, regardless of the ability of this particular 17 year old to have a healthy relationship with a 57 year old man (the ability or non ability has never been revealed)

It's "that's jus wrong" and "that guy deserves to have his filthy pedo balls cut off" regardless of what type of person he is, or what kind of relationship he had with her, Because all you can see is OMFGPEDOFILEZNEEDZCASTRATEDIZJUSNOTRITE!!!!

I genuinely wish there were far, far fewer of you in this world.

It's exactly that "I are the correct defendor of all that is inicint, bow to my higher morality, i haz a dottir you know, so grow up." mentality that drove my brother into drugs.

I farking hate you with every ounce of darkness in my soul. YOU are what pushed that 17 year old into making shiat life decisions. YOU are the one that cut her lovers balls off. YOU are all the tabloid accusations of that journalist that was legitimately taking photos at a school sports event. YOU!!!!

YOU!!!

Mykeru: uttertosh: kerpal32: uttertosh: I'm so happy that you just solved all pedo problems by making this example!!

Is that really what you think I'm attempting to do? solve all pedo problems in the world your over simplification of the problem and irrational adherence to the absolute limits of the law where age of consent is concerned by my
a) pointing out how the 57 yr old was wrong,
b) pointing out that age of consent does not mean someone who is 17 makes rational or sound judgments
c) that does not excuse the 57 yr old
d) empathizing with the father instead of the victim
e) supporting the perpetuation of the psychotic over protective father in society because it does serve a purpose
f) a few other things you apparently can't grasp


whatever,


/go grow up and have some kids.

so, regardless of the ability of this particular 17 year old to have a healthy relationship with a 57 year old man (the ability or non ability has never been revealed)

It's "that's jus wrong" and "that guy deserves to have his filthy pedo balls cut off" regardless of what type of person he is, or what kind of relationship he had with her, Because all you can see is OMFGPEDOFILEZNEEDZCASTRATEDIZJUSNOTRITE!!!!

I genuinely wish there were far, far fewer of you in this world.

It's exactly that "I are the correct defendor of all that is inicint, bow to my higher morality, i haz a dottir you know, so grow up." mentality that drove my brother into drugs.

I farking hate you with every ounce of darkness in my soul. YOU are what pushed that 17 year old into making shiat life decisions. YOU are the one that cut her lovers balls off. YOU are all the tabloid accusations of that journalist that was legitimately taking photos at a school sports event. YOU!!!!

YOU!!!

Dude, relax, read the subtext of this thread: It's all about dudes who want to touch other dude's junk, even if they have to cut them off after to provide cover.

Read the ball cutter's posts. Can't you just smell the musky undertone of homoeroticism?

actually it's more the quasi-Freudian "If I'm not allowed to even imagine what it'd be like to fark my 17 yo daughter, then if anyone old enough to not call me Mister actually does fark her, will be labelled a PERVERTPEDO and be subsequently subjected to a vigilante castration" but, yeah, it's totally been fun baiting the 'superdaddies' of fark.

/ciao

hasty ambush: WilderKWight: freewill: All I said, correctly, was that teenage brains are not fully developed and teenagers are not biologically equipped for adult decision-making. Saying they are is demonstrably wrong.

I could say that about some 40-year-olds. Likewise, I could point out teenagers that are far more adult than the so-called adults they put up with on a daily basis.

For example, it was not a very informed, adult decision to step outside the bounds of the law (and human decency) and castrate a man.

In fact, that was a rather immature, childish, impulsive action.

I would say the inverse is true. The 57 year old who thought he coudl get away with banging this guys 17 year old daughter was not very informed, rather immature and impulsive.

Castrating him reduced the chance of more like him bieng created.

The human gene pool was just improved

At 57 the odds of him producing any more like him were very small to being with.

bulok: I'm sure the question here everyone really wants to know is the daughter hot?

No, because most of the smart people in here have already figured out that if she was hot, she wouldn't have to settle for a guy old enough to be her grandfather.

crazytrpr: Sticky Hands: altinos: Sticky Hands: Yeah that's Fark.com. No outrage at all for old Afghan Muslims with 13 year old wives. not even a peep....

Well, this story is about the 17 year old wanting the relationship.

Story?
I'm not here to read stories... I'm here to feed trolls.

Although I once had a "17 year old" (so the person claimed...) contact me in a chat room. She wanted to be some kind of S&M slave... obviously I didn't go for that. Should I have, she said that was what she wanted. What says fark?

Run away like a scared little biatch. 70% chance of it being LEO. 30% of being pure psyco, the "slave" could have been 17,14 or 44, male or female who the fark knows. Either way no good for you.

I was thinking the same thing but then figured an actual LEO would have pretended to be in the 16 and under range, but as you say, no good would come of it.

socratesthekidd: Oznog: I knew this movie was trouble.

That one was seriously effed up.

/the cook on the last boat I worked brought it out for us
//she was a little odd too

I saw it at a movie theater when it was first release (the first movie I saw Karen Page in) and during the castration scene, I could hear a couple of "ladies" in the back snickering, which bothered me as much as the scene itself.

boobsrgood: Latinwolf: You sound like an old dude trying to justify his fantasy.

You sound like a sexually repressed adolescent. I have a bisexual wife who is 13 years younger than me. Your lack of sexual life experience may lead you to believe that middle-aged men are all icky and creepy, but reality is not a Twilight movie or an episode of Dancing with the Stars.

Middle-aged men have experience, money, and a steady hand. Young girls go nuts for that, even if they don't have daddy issues, as so many of them do. This girl was getting exactly what she wanted, as was he, and all the whining in the world isn't going to make it wrong. As for my fantasies, honestly, it sounds like you should be paying more attention to your own.

Correction, now you sound like a pedo trying to justify his beliefs.

Santa's Knee: PDX Ghost Hunter: If I can land a 17 year old when I'm 57 I expect high-fives from ALL of you.

Or a hand from her pimp.

More like the pimp sticking his hand out waiting to get paid.