If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Some Guy) Asinine All electric cars qualifying for California's $5000 rebate and permission to carry a single rider in an HOV lane please roll forward. Not so fast there, Chevy Volt   (greencarreports.com) divider line 287
More: Asinine, Chevy Volt, Nissan LEAF, gasoline engines, hov, Detroit Auto Show, kilowatt hours, plug-in hybrids, battery packs  
•       •       •

23654 clicks; posted to Main » on 29 Jul 2010 at 5:48 AM   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»   |    Get this fabulous T-Shirt and impress the methane out of your friends! shirt it!



287 Comments   (+0 »)
   

Archived thread

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | » | Last | Show all
 
2010-07-28 09:23:59 PM
The volt is an all-electric car?
 
2010-07-28 09:31:25 PM
Dinki: The volt is an all-electric car?

methinks you added a - where one ought not be
 
2010-07-28 10:12:24 PM
cmunic8r99: Dinki: The volt is an all-electric car?

methinks you added a - where one ought not be


Are you rotsky?
 
2010-07-28 10:23:26 PM
cameroncrazy1984: Are you rotsky?

me?

nope. i'm just me.
 
2010-07-28 10:26:50 PM
cmunic8r99: cameroncrazy1984: Are you rotsky?

me?

nope. i'm just me.


Well then I don't get the joke, because "all-electric" is perfectly acceptable in this case.
 
2010-07-29 12:02:25 AM
That was a perfectly cromulent hyphen, cmunic8r99.
 
2010-07-29 12:58:09 AM
Farking compound-word adjectives. How do they work?
 
2010-07-29 05:04:34 AM
The headline is equally grammatical, but conveys two different meanings, with or without the hyphen.


"All electric cars" - all cars which are electric, i.e. can run in part off a battery

"All-electric cars" - cars which run solely on electricity, with no gasoline engine


The first use makes more sense in the headline, the latter use is used in the article to explain why the electric but not all-electric Volt does not qualify for California's tax rebate.

Are we clear now?
 
2010-07-29 05:24:19 AM
Jay-Z gets his own lane?
 
2010-07-29 05:58:26 AM
Dinki: The volt is an all-electric car?

Yes and no. Yes for the first 40 miles then a gas motor kicks in to charge the batteries.
 
2010-07-29 06:11:51 AM
Smitty obviously ain't from Cal-i-for-ni-a because we call the "HOV" lane a "carpool" lane.
 
2010-07-29 06:12:00 AM
It doesn't matter, since California cannot even pay its employees or its state tax refunds.
 
2010-07-29 06:12:40 AM
Wow. the Volt is the biggest pile of fail ever to creak its way out of Detroit, it is almost a parody of everything that's wrong with American car makers:

Japan: here's a cool idea: let's build a mid-sized car that runs on a hybrid of gas and electric power and gets roughly 60 mPH

Detroit: meh it's a fad

Japan: wow we've sold a shiatton of these can't keep them in stores

Detroit: hey we'll pay you for that technology and cram it into all sorts of inappropriate cars like SUVs and heavy trucks that will barely benefit from it and then trumpet how "green" we are

Japan: How's that working out for you?

Detroit: Screw You! were sinking billions of dollars into a revolutionary ALL-electric plug in car that'll be tons better than yours and be 16 awesome and save our company and fix your asses

Japan: hey what do you think of this pure electric we have called the Leaf? seems your governments will subsidize then up to $12,000. neat huh?

Detroit: Shut up Shut up Shut UP! we'll have our car out any day now...

any day now...

Japan: yawn

Detroit: SO here it is: our REVOLUTIONARY Super Awesome Mobile

Japan:" What's it do

Detroit: Get this is plugs in, takes ONLY 10 hours to charge, and then can go 40 miles! 40! Woot! 11! suck it haters!

Japan: 40 Miles and then what?

Detroit: Well, then basically its a hybrid just like you guy's but way more complicated

Japan: but it's cheap right?

Detroit: uhhhha bout the same as a Merceedes

Japan: Bhudda! that tiny little subcompact is the price of TWO Priuses?! well at least you get all those rebates and special electric car bennies right?

Detroit: Well, no. Apparently Our engineers never bothered to look up those regulations to see how to make the car qualify and none of out lobbyists contacted anyone to get the car on the list soo......
 
2010-07-29 06:13:32 AM
FTS: "The first two plug-in cars from major manufacturers will go head-to-head on warranties and lease prices: $350 a month for the 2011 Chevrolet Volt, $349 for the 2011 Nissan Leaf."

Seriously, what the crap is up with these names? I mean, 'Volt' isn't a great name for a car but 'Leaf'? What are they going to do, follow it up with the 'Gurgling Brook' and 'Happy Fluffy Bunny'? I don't think car names should be ultra-testosterone fueled bouts of idiocy, but come one. At least choose a name that's sounds a bit like a tonne of metal rolling at dozens of miles an hour over poured tarmac.
 
2010-07-29 06:16:19 AM
Foxie299: 2011 Nissan Leaf

i26.tinypic.com
 
2010-07-29 06:20:16 AM
Foxie299: FTS: "The first two plug-in cars from major manufacturers will go head-to-head on warranties and lease prices: $350 a month for the 2011 Chevrolet Volt, $349 for the 2011 Nissan Leaf."

Seriously, what the crap is up with these names? I mean, 'Volt' isn't a great name for a car but 'Leaf'? What are they going to do, follow it up with the 'Gurgling Brook' and 'Happy Fluffy Bunny'? I don't think car names should be ultra-testosterone fueled bouts of idiocy, but come one. At least choose a name that's sounds a bit like a tonne of metal rolling at dozens of miles an hour over poured tarmac.


Next thing you know, they'll come out with a car called the Fluffer.
 
2010-07-29 06:31:56 AM
Magorn: Wow. the Volt is the biggest pile of fail ever to creak its way out of Detroit, it is almost a parody of everything that's wrong with American car makers:


Japan: Bhudda! that tiny little subcompact is the price of TWO Priuses?! well at least you get all those rebates and special electric car bennies right?

Detroit: Well, no. Apparently Our engineers never bothered to look up those regulations to see how to make the car qualify and none of out lobbyists contacted anyone to get the car on the list soo......


-------------------------
The Volt definitely ISN'T a fail. California law is a fail. The Volt is a totally new idea (in the auto industry, anyways) and CA law failed to account for its possibility. I'm sure some changes to the law will be made to account for it. The Volt has a range- extending gasoline engine that runs the electric motor after the battery runs down. The car runs in all- electric mode for the first 40 miles, and all- gas mode for the rest of the time. There's no switching. So the Volt doesn't NEED additional heating of the catalytic converter to qualify for AT- PZEV in that case. It DOES need to have no evaporative emissions while under gas power, which apparently, the Volt lacks (which IS, in its own way, a fail, but like I said, it reduces overall emissions beyond what AT-PZEV does, so I'm sure CA will come up with a solution. Interesting to note: There are gasoline- only cars that qualify as AT- PZEV vehicles- The Subaru Outback, for example, is available in AT- PZEV form.
 
2010-07-29 06:47:16 AM
But if you pick up a couple of your friends, you can drive your '74 Impala that gets 14 miles/gallon, and leaks oil like a PB well, in the HOV lanes all day.


/The low rider is a real goer!
 
2010-07-29 06:50:01 AM
BKITU: Farking compound-word adjectives. How do they work?

Lawl...farker
 
2010-07-29 07:01:19 AM
Magorn: Detroit: Well, no. Apparently Our engineers never bothered to look up those regulations to see how to make the car qualify and none of out lobbyists contacted anyone to get the car on the list soo......

You could also say the regulators failed to look at one of the most hyped fuel efficient vehicles of the last decade.
The volt is closer to being an all electric car than the Prius, and its a more realistic electric vehicle than the battery cars being sold today.
To own a short range vehicle means you either never drive more than ~50 miles round trip, or you have the where with all to own multiple vehicles. Paying $40k for one car with both options is not an unreasonable solution.
 
2010-07-29 07:03:22 AM
That's a whole lot of fail on the part of California.

Of course, so is letting solo drivers into HOV lanes, the whole point of which was to ease congestion by offering an incentive to carpool. I'd love to slap the first politician who thought of the idea of giving HOV privileges to single-occupant hybrids. What are you going to do when half the cars on the road are hybrids, you farkwits?

/Californian
 
2010-07-29 07:15:09 AM
Well, at least we know the Volt is not a glorified golfcart, which seems to be the requirement for this lane.
 
2010-07-29 07:18:46 AM
DontBeStupid: Dinki: The volt is an all-electric car?

Yes and no. Yes for the first 40 miles then a gas motor kicks in to charge the batteries.


No: It's a hybrid that is programmed to run off the battery first. There is no significant difference between the Volt and, say, a Prius, other than how the software that controls the drivetrain is programmed.
 
2010-07-29 07:27:00 AM
dittybopper: DontBeStupid: Dinki: The volt is an all-electric car?

Yes and no. Yes for the first 40 miles then a gas motor kicks in to charge the batteries.

No: It's a hybrid that is programmed to run off the battery first. There is no significant difference between the Volt and, say, a Prius, other than how the software that controls the drivetrain is programmed.


Can you go 40 miles in a Prius without gas?
 
2010-07-29 07:29:01 AM
What, no Amusing tag?
 
2010-07-29 07:29:49 AM
Detroit: Get this is plugs in, takes ONLY 10 hours to charge, and then can go 40 miles! 40! Woot! 11! suck it haters!

Japan: 40 Miles and then what?

Detroit: Well, then basically its a hybrid just like you guy's but way more complicated


No numbnuts, a series hybrid is actually much simpler than a parallel hybrid. But why let anything factual get in your little fanboy rant...
 
2010-07-29 07:38:53 AM
Churchill2004: Are we clear now?

I was clear when I submitted it... :)
 
2010-07-29 07:53:29 AM
100 Watt Walrus: That's a whole lot of fail on the part of California.

Of course, so is letting solo drivers into HOV lanes, the whole point of which was to ease congestion by offering an incentive to carpool. I'd love to slap the first politician who thought of the idea of giving HOV privileges to single-occupant hybrids. What are you going to do when half the cars on the road are hybrids, you farkwits?

/Californian


If 8% of drivers take up 25% of the road (these are the actual numbers, IIRC - 4 lanes on average including one carpool, with only 8% of drivers using the carpool, as of about 3 years ago), how does this ease congestion? Can has math?

The people have spoken, carpool lanes are an idea that failed, and it's time to move on. California is only standing on their moral high-ground principle now. Open all lanes to general traffic. Alternately, I'll go with your premise, slightly altered: if 25% of the drivers are driving HOV-permitted single-occupancy vehicles, then the traffic flow will be maximized again.
 
2010-07-29 07:58:48 AM
dittybopper: DontBeStupid: Dinki: The volt is an all-electric car?

Yes and no. Yes for the first 40 miles then a gas motor kicks in to charge the batteries.

No: It's a hybrid that is programmed to run off the battery first. There is no significant difference between the Volt and, say, a Prius, other than how the software that controls the drivetrain is programmed.


The Prius has a mechanical drive train from the engine to the wheels, allowing it to bypass the electric motors. You can run on gas OR electricity.

The Volt's electric motor is only tied to a generator and cannot be used to power the wheels directly. You run on electricity. Period. It's only a question of weather that electricity is coming from a battery or a generator.

That's a very significant difference.
 
2010-07-29 08:00:01 AM
Correction: The volt's GAS motor is only tied to a generator.

If only there was some way to proof read these things before I hit POST.
 
2010-07-29 08:10:24 AM
Foxie299: Seriously, what the crap is up with these names? I mean, 'Volt' isn't a great name for a car but 'Leaf'? What are they going to do, follow it up with the 'Gurgling Brook' and 'Happy Fluffy Bunny'?

I was looking at a new Leaf. Couldn't even get the damn thing to turn over.
 
2010-07-29 08:13:32 AM
The volt tech is pretty close to be the best next step in hybrids. As battery/ capacitor technology increase, the gas motor becomes used less and less. The strain on the grid is reduced while still adding demand that will force utilities to increase capacity.

As it has been said a bazillion times before. Most trips are well under 40 miles, so it's a great start.

Pricing is a bit ridiculous right now, but so is any new tech. It will come down pretty quickly.
 
2010-07-29 08:17:31 AM
the volt os like a diesel locomotive - an engine turns a generator which creates electricity. this has been used since the 1930's in railroad applications. the biggest hurdle has been steep grades for cars and trucks with electric motors - transmissions eat efficiency and having the motor on the wheel eats energy. i'm curious to see how they have dealt with the transmission loss issue over at Chevy.
 
2010-07-29 08:20:58 AM
Magorn:
Detroit: Well, then basically its a hybrid just like you guy's but way more complicated


For fail on your part. As the basic engineering for the Volt drive train and power plant is much simpler then the Prius drive train and power plant.
 
2010-07-29 08:21:27 AM
Steve McQueen's Motorcycle: The volt tech is pretty close to be the best next step in hybrids. As battery/ capacitor technology increase, the gas motor becomes used less and less. The strain on the grid is reduced while still adding demand that will force utilities to increase capacity.

As it has been said a bazillion times before. Most trips are well under 40 miles, so it's a great start.

Pricing is a bit ridiculous right now, but so is any new tech. It will come down pretty quickly.


The other gem that makes the volt so neat is the fact that it's set up to allow for multiple power sources. Because it uses only electricity, any device that creates electricity could theoretically be used without any changes to the drivetrain. Right now it's unleaded gas, but in the future, clean diesel, bio diesel, fuel cells all could be put in place of the gas engine for electric generation.
 
2010-07-29 08:22:13 AM
liam76: dittybopper: DontBeStupid: Dinki: The volt is an all-electric car?

Yes and no. Yes for the first 40 miles then a gas motor kicks in to charge the batteries.

No: It's a hybrid that is programmed to run off the battery first. There is no significant difference between the Volt and, say, a Prius, other than how the software that controls the drivetrain is programmed.

Can you go 40 miles in a Prius without gas?


With a software update, probably.
 
2010-07-29 08:24:33 AM
Steve McQueen's Motorcycle: The volt tech is pretty close to be the best next step in hybrids. As battery/ capacitor technology increase, the gas motor becomes used less and less. The strain on the grid is reduced while still adding demand that will force utilities to increase capacity.

As it has been said a bazillion times before. Most trips are well under 40 miles, so it's a great start.

Pricing is a bit ridiculous right now, but so is any new tech. It will come down pretty quickly.


Plus it still qualifies for a $7500 Federal tax credit to buy outright. Or $2,500 at signing/$350 mo. lease with an option to buy. If this is someone's only daily driver, it's not so far out of reach. And you're right, batteries and all will become cheaper and better.

I think the Volt is one of the first things GM's done right in a long time. And it was in the works before all the bail outs and what not. As much as I hate GM products for the most part, they're def. on the right track here.

Now I'm wondering how it'd do with a small diesel to run the generator... then the next step would be bio-diesel.

Or if anyone's got an AWD version in the works with two or four smaller motors. One motor/wheel would be amazing for traction/handling abilities.
 
2010-07-29 08:28:12 AM
dittybopper: liam76: dittybopper: DontBeStupid: Dinki: The volt is an all-electric car?

Yes and no. Yes for the first 40 miles then a gas motor kicks in to charge the batteries.

No: It's a hybrid that is programmed to run off the battery first. There is no significant difference between the Volt and, say, a Prius, other than how the software that controls the drivetrain is programmed.

Can you go 40 miles in a Prius without gas?

With a software update, probably.


You really should just stop posting. At least until you've done something a little more productive than pulling things out of your rectum.
 
2010-07-29 08:29:25 AM
badLogic: Magorn:
Detroit: Well, then basically its a hybrid just like you guy's but way more complicated


For fail on your part. As the basic engineering for the Volt drive train and power plant is much simpler then the Prius drive train and power plant.


That's quite true, but it doesn't change the fact that both the Volt and the Prius are hybrids.

Denying that is like saying a 2 stroke gasoline engine isn't an internal combustion engine because it's much simpler than a 4 stroke gasoline engine.
 
2010-07-29 08:31:26 AM
Steve McQueen's Motorcycle: Most trips are well under 40 miles, so it's a great start.

I wonder about running the climate controls in congested traffic situations. Are you supposed to sit in 100 degree heat with the windows down, or are you supposed to not get where you were going? Also, most trips out here in the boonies are over 40 miles. It's 25 miles from my house to a city big enough to have a Wal-Mart, let alone anywhere worth shopping. All-electric cars are a good idea, but they'll have to get better before they're very good in the semi-arid rural southwest.

I do know a couple of people who own and drive Prius hybrids, and they're pretty happy with them. I couldn't put up with the lack of acceleration, but that'll improve with time. Hell, engineers were eventually able to produce a 3 gallon per flush (hyphen-optional) potty that would almost flush right.
 
2010-07-29 08:34:17 AM
Whereas the 2012 Toyota Prius Plug-In Hybrid that's being flogged down the freeway at 85 mph will consistently burn gasoline at its highest rate, and yet it will be able to do so from the HOV lane.

You guys read the article? Prius gets the HOV lane, Volt does not. Prius gets a partial tax rebate, Volt does not.

So Volt is as good or better than the Prius, but CA will not allow it HOV access or even a partial tax rebate. Both are hybrids.

Fark CA. That is just plain wrong. Nothing but anti-American bias from the liberal state of CA.
 
2010-07-29 08:34:20 AM
Steve McQueen's Motorcycle: Most trips are well under 40 miles, so it's a great start.

With a 35 minute commute, a Leaf will get me to work -- but a Volt or a Prius will get me home again.
 
2010-07-29 08:34:21 AM
Volt will save GM. Mark my words. They will sell all they can build, dealers will be charging premium over sticker, and GM is already planning to adapt the tech to other models, perhaps an SUV.
 
2010-07-29 08:34:54 AM
badLogic: Magorn:
Detroit: Well, then basically its a hybrid just like you guy's but way more complicated


For fail on your part. As the basic engineering for the Volt drive train and power plant is much simpler then the Prius drive train and power plant.


So Toyota can build a much more complicated car with a high mpg for half the cost of a Volt. Gotcha.
 
2010-07-29 08:35:19 AM
way south: Magorn: Detroit: Well, no. Apparently Our engineers never bothered to look up those regulations to see how to make the car qualify and none of out lobbyists contacted anyone to get the car on the list soo......

You could also say the regulators failed to look at one of the most hyped fuel efficient vehicles of the last decade.
The volt is closer to being an all electric car than the Prius, and its a more realistic electric vehicle than the battery cars being sold today.
To own a short range vehicle means you either never drive more than ~50 miles round trip, or you have the where with all to own multiple vehicles. Paying $40k for one car with both options is not an unreasonable solution.


IF you are a major America Automaker with a Carthat has been in the planning stages as long as the Volt has been. Part of your JOB is to meet with regulators and legislaslators and rulemakers to make sure your car either meets all their requirements, or that they change the rules to confrom to your specs. That's why you have a lobbying arm and a legal division. By not doing that GM is effective giving away more than $2500 in free money in CA alone, why reducing a major selling point for thier cars. Big Mistake (I know the popularity of Hybrids in this area has everything to do with the "HOV only section of Rt 66 going into DC)

But beyond that this car is merely evolutionary when it needed to be revolutionary.

In my opinion if you are asking someone to plunk down the same chunk of change that the high-end luxury brands are asking for thier cars, you need to offer something turly spectacular. And I just don't think the Volt is it.


fer Insrance the electrics either needed to have better range (say 100 miles ) or a quicker charge time. The range number, I have no doubt was derived from some engieer going "let's see, the average person puts 15,000 miles on a car a year so if you divide that by 365...bang ! 41.09 miles a day" But humans don't actually drive like that and take longer and shorter trips depending ont he day and need. (an 40 miles at what speed exactly under what traffic conditions) But even that wouldn't be an issue if they had faster charging batteries so you could, say, drive it work, plug it in, and then drive it home, they might have something but instead their batteries take TEN hours to charge. Seriously how hard would it have been to speed that charge cycle up by two hours to match how people actually live? (8hr work days)

Secondly you have the size of the thing. Most people assume the Prius is a compact car. It is not, it's actually a mid-size with the same wheelbase as a Camry and slightly more interior room thanks to the "hump". As a 6'2 fat guy I can sit comfortably in its back seats. The Volt was desribed by one reviewer yesterday as "a compact that feels like a sub-compact". Not good. And there are other ergonomics to consider too: That "thermos bottle" that the Prius has that the Volt doesn't? Not only is it there to help the catalytic converter be more efficent, but it also can provide heat tot he cabin on a cold morning even when the prius is still in all-electric mode and they gas engine is kicking over.

What will the Volt do under the same circumstance? If it uses a supplemental electric heater it will kill the batteries and the car's range. If it kicks in the gas engine plant to warm the car it kills the gas savings of having the "all electric" concept. If it just lets the passengers freeze, it's going to be a wildly unpopular car.

Bottom line: is the Volt an interesting piece of tech? Yeah it is.
Is it the revolutionary vehicle that's going to inspire the "I must have one !" fervor of the Prius? Not a chance, and GM needed it to be.
 
2010-07-29 08:36:44 AM
Driedsponge: dittybopper: liam76: dittybopper: DontBeStupid: Dinki: The volt is an all-electric car?

Yes and no. Yes for the first 40 miles then a gas motor kicks in to charge the batteries.

No: It's a hybrid that is programmed to run off the battery first. There is no significant difference between the Volt and, say, a Prius, other than how the software that controls the drivetrain is programmed.

Can you go 40 miles in a Prius without gas?

With a software update, probably.

You really should just stop posting. At least until you've done something a little more productive than pulling things out of your rectum.


OK, instead of making ass jokes, tell me why specifically?

Oh, and you can get Chevy Volt-like electric-only range, but it does require a battery and software upgrade. So I was at least half-right.
 
2010-07-29 08:37:42 AM
theBigBigEye:
Next thing you know, they'll come out with a car called the Fluffer.


Knowing what a fluffer is clearly marks someone from before the Age of Viagra. No such animals no more.
 
2010-07-29 08:38:01 AM
dittybopper: badLogic: Magorn:
Detroit: Well, then basically its a hybrid just like you guy's but way more complicated


For fail on your part. As the basic engineering for the Volt drive train and power plant is much simpler then the Prius drive train and power plant.

That's quite true, but it doesn't change the fact that both the Volt and the Prius are hybrids.

Denying that is like saying a 2 stroke gasoline engine isn't an internal combustion engine because it's much simpler than a 4 stroke gasoline engine.


I Never said it was not a hybrid, what I was saying is that your statement was factually wrong, ie the Volt being more complicated then the Prius.
 
2010-07-29 08:39:28 AM
give me doughnuts: But if you pick up a couple of your friends, you can drive your '74 Impala that gets 14 miles/gallon, and leaks oil like a PB well, in the HOV lanes all day.


/The low rider is a real goer!


In '74 EFI wasn't used in Chevies. If you had an Impala with the big V-8 and a 4-bbl carb, 14mph was a dream achieved only going downhill with a tailwind. 8 or 9 mph was more the norm. Pulled a small travel trailer with one. Got 3mph except for that time I went through the Rockies - then it got ugly! And, BTW, it did not leak oil. It burned oil. A quart per 1000 miles. But when you put your foot in it, that sucker hauled a$$. Just an idle question: is there a passenger car available today that will pull a travel trailer? Or is that why we need SUVs?
 
2010-07-29 08:39:56 AM
Is it the revolutionary vehicle that's going to inspire the "I must have one !" fervor of the Prius?

This happened?
 
Displayed 50 of 287 comments

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | » | Last | Show all


This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »