If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Guardian)   British NASA astronaut to take a piece of Sir Isaac Newton's apple tree into space. Given the chance, wooden't you?   (guardian.co.uk) divider line 43
    More: Cool, zero gravity, shuttle missions, University of Edinburgh, NASA, Royal Society, Nasa astronaut, Atlantis, space stations  
•       •       •

3104 clicks; posted to Main » on 09 May 2010 at 3:07 PM   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»



43 Comments   (+0 »)
   

Archived thread
 
2010-05-09 11:38:06 AM
The funny thing about this is while Newton did record the apple falling as his inspiration for gravity, his farm had an apple orchard. So "the tree" you hear about nowadays is one that was planted by his study- likely that this was the correct tree, but what's to say he wasn't out for a walk and looking at the hundreds of other apple trees on his farm?
 
2010-05-09 11:42:54 AM
cdn.buzznet.com

Andromeda: The funny thing about this is while Newton did record the apple falling as his inspiration for gravity, his farm had an apple orchard. So "the tree" you hear about nowadays is one that was planted by his study- likely that this was the correct tree, but what's to say he wasn't out for a walk and looking at the hundreds of other apple trees on his farm?
 
2010-05-09 11:53:42 AM
bad idea. In zero-g the apple won't fall, thereby invalidating Newton's theory and all the physics hence.
 
2010-05-09 03:09:46 PM
Awesomeness
 
2010-05-09 03:11:22 PM
revrendjim: bad idea. In zero-g the apple won't fall, thereby invalidating Newton's theory and all the physics hence.

This entire article is science fail.

The tree is experiencing almost the same gravity as it would on earth, and is falling the entire time it is in orbit.
 
2010-05-09 03:12:47 PM
extraneousflickassery.files.wordpress.com

What a space-traveling tree might look like.
 
2010-05-09 03:14:17 PM
It's so full of seeds!!
 
2010-05-09 03:15:00 PM
HAHAHA Wood, get it!!
 
2010-05-09 03:16:56 PM
/Unavailable for comment:

i218.photobucket.com
 
2010-05-09 03:19:38 PM
Visordown: HAHAHA Wood, get it!!

I did viewing the ScarJo thread
 
2010-05-09 03:34:54 PM
Just don't bring Alan Turing's apple into space.
 
2010-05-09 03:42:17 PM
revrendjim: bad idea. In zero-g the apple won't fall, thereby invalidating Newton's theory and all the physics hence.

since the whole idea is about an apple being attracted by earth's gravity, I'd go on a space walk and throw the apple toward earth to generate a crispy apple comet
 
2010-05-09 03:46:05 PM
Dear God! They've gone from Nanny to Loony. Fire the Missles!
 
2010-05-09 03:48:09 PM
Arklop: What a space-traveling tree might look like.

Came here for a reference to The Fountain. Leaving most gratified. And posted so soon no less. Bravo, Arklop!
 
2010-05-09 03:49:06 PM
Tentacle: revrendjim: bad idea. In zero-g the apple won't fall, thereby invalidating Newton's theory and all the physics hence.

since the whole idea is about an apple being attracted by earth's gravity, I'd go on a space walk and throw the apple toward earth to generate a crispy apple comet


Gravity is the tinfoil hat the scientist cover themselves from God.

/Am I trolling right?
//Or do I need to link to a christian site?
 
2010-05-09 03:50:31 PM
Sir Isaac Newton is the deadliest son of a biatch in space!
 
2010-05-09 03:53:30 PM
upload.wikimedia.org

He also invented the cat-flap. It would be a bigger achievement to send a cat into space, why do they insist on a stupid plant? They could use the cat to demonstrate the effect gravity too.
 
2010-05-09 03:53:45 PM
Puns are awful but that one is especially weak.
 
2010-05-09 04:01:50 PM
turntable slave: Just don't bring Alan Turing's apple into space.

Dude, that would be hella gay.
 
2010-05-09 04:08:50 PM
Wood eye!?!

Big Nose!
 
2010-05-09 04:24:11 PM
fyrewede: Arklop: What a space-traveling tree might look like.

Came here for a reference to The Fountain. Leaving most gratified. And posted so soon no less. Bravo, Arklop!



Happy to serve, good sir. Though I gotta say, I didn't really get that film. My wife tried explaining some of the underlying themes to me, but it's still like watching a David Lynch episode of Lost.
 
2010-05-09 04:33:13 PM
libwebspace.library.cmu.edu:4430
www.argenqueen.com.ar
 
2010-05-09 04:46:47 PM
Arklop: Happy to serve, good sir. Though I gotta say, I didn't really get that film. My wife tried explaining some of the underlying themes to me, but it's still like watching a David Lynch episode of Lost.

It's nothing a little Karl Jung and a few games of Rifts wouldn't fix. it's pretty much straightforward psychobabble. It's well-written psychobabble, but I think the movie's redeeming charm is the eye candy and that's about it.
 
2010-05-09 04:53:39 PM
I always thought the apple thing was a complete myth.

Something handy to teach the kids, but just made up.
 
2010-05-09 05:17:13 PM
Haoie: I always thought the apple thing was a complete myth.

Something handy to teach the kids, but just made up.


richardwiseman.files.wordpress.com

Made up like this?
 
2010-05-09 05:22:25 PM
Horrible pun, subby. Didn't really have anything to do with the article.
 
2010-05-09 05:30:56 PM
Arklop: Happy to serve, good sir. Though I gotta say, I didn't really get that film. My wife tried explaining some of the underlying themes to me, but it's still like watching a David Lynch episode of Lost.

(chuckling) Ummm...just to clarify, I'm not a sir. (See profile pic.)

As for the movie -- I had to watch it at least like...three times before the pieces started to really fit together cohesively. It takes a pretty plastic (and open) mind to do it though. There are so many things layered on top of each other -- reincarnation & Buddhist philosophy, animism, space travel as it might look like in the distant future, human history, soulmates, you name it...
 
2010-05-09 05:36:30 PM
Gonna jump on the hatewagon here.

Punmitter, I am disappoint.
 
F42
2010-05-09 05:42:52 PM
I'm sure I approve of all this sentimental fetishism from astronauts.
 
F42
2010-05-09 05:43:52 PM
not sure, I'm NOT sure

/and my shiat's all retarded
 
2010-05-09 05:55:55 PM
So they finally built a tall enough ladder? Way to go, British Space Agency!
 
2010-05-09 06:01:40 PM
I'm sure it will Spruce up the ISS a bit...
 
2010-05-09 06:05:05 PM
Given that the apple story is widely regarded as a myth, maybe made up by Newton to explain gravity to stupid people (he was very antisocial and thought everybody stupid), and that there is much dispute over which trees may be descended from trees that Newton may have hung out with (similar to disputes over "true pieces of the cross"), this seems like a stupid thing for a "scientist" to do.

It would be sort of like doing something with a sliver of wood from the handle of the axe that George Washington used to chop down the cherry tree, even though the head and handle on that axe have both been replaced several times and the whole story of that episode was made up about a century after it supposedly happend.
 
2010-05-09 06:47:28 PM
"While it's up there, it will be experiencing no gravity,

This guy is an astronaut?
 
2010-05-09 06:49:00 PM
Newton thought he was so clever, but when he died... he fell over.

Gravity will not be mocked, my friends.
 
2010-05-09 07:45:41 PM
To those complaining about the 'No gravity' science fail...

The vast majority of people hold the (incorrect) idea of zero-g. It is easier for the Guardian, while writing an article about space, to just press the zero-g button so as to float the meat of the piece to it's readership.

I don't know why people put so much undue weight onto the misuse of the term when speaking to a general audience. Blast those who get it wrong when talking to those who should know what it is, and start working on educating the general public.

I know it's a strong pull to flame those who you feel are less intelligent, but it's actually kinda weak.
 
2010-05-09 07:50:31 PM
HairBolus:
It would be sort of like doing something with a sliver of wood from the handle of the axe that George Washington used to chop down the cherry tree, even though the head and handle on that axe have both been replaced several times and the whole story of that episode was made up about a century after it supposedly happend.


just like the ship of theseus!
 
F42
2010-05-09 08:35:48 PM
traylor: He also invented the cat-flap. It would be a bigger achievement to send a cat into space, why do they insist on a stupid plant? They could use the cat to demonstrate the effect gravity too.

0G cat (video, new window)
 
2010-05-09 09:26:10 PM
What about his entire collection of Johnny Cash?

i789.photobucket.com
 
2010-05-09 10:00:34 PM
so the tree branch will fit in a soyuz?
 
2010-05-09 10:11:50 PM
"British NASA astronaut to take a piece of Sir Isaac Newton's apple tree into space. Given the chance, wooden't you?"



Gnaw.
 
2010-05-10 10:23:21 AM
HairBolus: Given that the apple story is widely regarded as a myth, maybe made up by Newton to explain gravity to stupid people (he was very antisocial and thought everybody stupid), and that there is much dispute over which trees may be descended from trees that Newton may have hung out with (similar to disputes over "true pieces of the cross"), this seems like a stupid thing for a "scientist" to do.

It would be sort of like doing something with a sliver of wood from the handle of the axe that George Washington used to chop down the cherry tree, even though the head and handle on that axe have both been replaced several times and the whole story of that episode was made up about a century after it supposedly happend.


Perhapse you should read the article, which says and I quote:

Several sections stripped from the tree, which still stands at Woolsthorpe Manor, the physicist's former home in Lincolnshire, are stored in the society's vaults as part of a huge collection of Newton memorabilia donated by the antiquarian Sir Charles Turner in the 1700s.
 
2010-05-10 12:06:38 PM
HairBolus: It would be sort of like doing something with a sliver of wood from the handle of the axe that George Washington used to chop down the cherry tree, even though the head and handle on that axe have both been replaced several times and the whole story of that episode was made up about a century after it supposedly happend.

Like early Christians stealing existing mythos (see Mithras amongst others)and stating that Christ was born on December 25th?

/I want presents
 
Displayed 43 of 43 comments



This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »





Report