FARK.com: (4741480) XKCD provides you with a perfect way to keep track of the LOTR trilogy

(XKCD)		XKCD provides you with a perfect way to keep track of the LOTR trilogy (xkcd.com)		201
		More: Cool, Lord of the Rings, Indexed, webcomic, copper, Dinosaur Comics, Buttercup Festival, jersey, Achewood

• • •

19582 clicks; posted to Geek » on 02 Nov 2009 at 7:11 AM | Favorite | share:

more» |

Get this fabulous T-Shirt and impress the methane out of your friends!

shirt it!

Share this link:

URL:

http://fk.cm/go/4741480

Bookmark:

Article Comments close

201 Comments (+0 »)

Archived thread

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | » | Last | Show all

Atvar

2009-11-02 03:31:32 AM

See kids, if you only drew stick figures, you could use the time you saved to come up with this!

namatad

2009-11-02 03:46:08 AM

this is so good it made me cry

mamoru

2009-11-02 03:51:26 AM

Obligatory: "All it was, was a bunch of people walking, three movies of people walking to a f*cking volcano." (NSFW language)

doglover

2009-11-02 05:05:09 AM

xkcd sucks

Munroe is terrible.

change1211

2009-11-02 05:56:53 AM

doglover: xkcd sucks

Munroe is terrible.

Boo your opinion!

Schadenfreude ist die schoenste Freude

2009-11-02 06:11:40 AM

xkcd is funny, but there are a decent amount of crap cartoons mixed in that either try to be preachy and screw up the message, or are just plain boring.

When he sticks to math humor, it's better.

Tachikoma

2009-11-02 06:23:12 AM

doglover: xkcd sucks

Munroe is terrible.

Your link is made funnier by the praise of today's comic.

/this one needs to be made a poster
//it's fun to track the characters on the chart and remember the sections of the book

Ennuipoet

2009-11-02 06:47:15 AM

doglover: xkcd sucks

Munroe is terrible.

Those who can, do. Those who can't, teach. Those who can do neither, create websites criticizing those who can.

SpinStopper

2009-11-02 06:56:26 AM

That was pretty cool. Now I want to watch Primer ;)

benlonghair

2009-11-02 07:22:00 AM

Except that Sarumon and Wormtongue don't die in the flooding of Isengard, they move to the Shire and take over there which is one of the last scenes of the book.

Hoboclown

2009-11-02 07:23:47 AM

I didn't realize LOTR was so hard to follow that people needed charts to figure out what happened.

mhd

2009-11-02 07:25:55 AM

benlonghair: Except that Sarumon and Wormtongue don't die in the flooding of Isengard, they move to the Shire and take over there which is one of the last scenes of the book.

There never was an industrial revolution in the Shire. There's no such person as Tom Bombadil. There never was sequel to Highlander.

Cozret

2009-11-02 07:26:11 AM

benlonghair: Except that Sarumon and Wormtongue don't die in the flooding of Isengard, they move to the Shire and take over there which is one of the last scenes of the book.

Darn it, you beat me to it.

Cozret

2009-11-02 07:27:30 AM

mhd:
There never was an industrial revolution in the Shire. There's no such person as Tom Bombadil. There never was sequel to Highlander.

I'm confused. . .oh! Movie Plot, not book plot.

yarnothuntin

2009-11-02 07:28:50 AM

I dunno, to me it looks like XKCD found a perfect way to keep track of their virginity.

ragnarqk

2009-11-02 07:31:07 AM

doglover: xkcd sucks

Munroe is terrible.

Sigh. Anyone who runs a "___ Sucks" site is the charred, blackened part on the piece of toast that is humanity.

benlonghair

2009-11-02 07:32:21 AM

mhd: There never was an industrial revolution in the Shire. There's no such person as Tom Bombadil.

I knew there was a reason I liked the books better.

exatron

2009-11-02 07:34:34 AM

doglover: xkcd sucksMunroe is terrible.

Wow, a whole blog dedicated to people who don't understand the jokes.

Hoboclown

2009-11-02 07:35:59 AM

exatron: doglover: xkcd sucksMunroe is terrible.

Wow, a whole blog dedicated to people who don't understand the jokes.

Bonus: Comments along the lines of "Homestar Runner did this joke better"

Pimple

2009-11-02 07:36:31 AM

The LOTR and the Jurrasic park are obviously based on the movie versions, cause Hammond gets it at the end of the book.

benlonghair

2009-11-02 07:39:20 AM

doglover: xkcd sucks

Munroe is terrible.

Also, get a life man.

mhd

2009-11-02 07:39:53 AM

benlonghair: I knew there was a reason I liked the books better.

You actually like ~~Tim Benzedrine~~ Tom Bombadil? How do you feel about Coldplay?

dumbgai

2009-11-02 07:43:23 AM

I sit on the floor and pick my nose
and think of better things
Like dragons who wear rubber clothes
and elves who drub their dings

mamoru

2009-11-02 07:43:47 AM

benlonghair: Except that Sarumon and Wormtongue don't die in the flooding of Isengard, they move to the Shire and take over there which is one of the last scenes of the book.

Except the comic is CLEARLY titled "Movie Narrative Charts" and is therefore not talking about the book.

Thanks for the analysis, though, because I'm sure none of us knew that.

mamoru

2009-11-02 07:44:48 AM

Pimple: The LOTR and the Jurrasic park are obviously based on the movie versions, cause Hammond gets it at the end of the book.

Again, considering the title of the comic, I bet they are all based on the movie versions.

Truthiness

2009-11-02 07:53:11 AM

Yeah, these are all movie versions. The novelization of Primer makes much more sense.

rogue49

2009-11-02 07:53:17 AM

book pattern is irrelevant here.
seems to be tracking movies.

gregfark

2009-11-02 07:58:25 AM

You know, it seems to me these charts are only about the movies. Randall should have indicated that in some way.

YodaBlues

2009-11-02 08:00:10 AM

Wait, is this based on the movies or the books?

Pooter

2009-11-02 08:01:32 AM

I got a good chuckle out of the Primer one. Fantastic movie, but it's a real head-scratcher after even a dozen viewings.

markcant

2009-11-02 08:05:11 AM

A little advice: Learn. To. Draw.

coco ebert

2009-11-02 08:05:36 AM

That's good storytelling. If you're ever in Paris, go to Balzac's house. There's a huge map that covers a whole wall and all it illustrates are the characters of his novels and how they relate with one another.

Oh, and I have no idea what Primer is.

cluelessguru

2009-11-02 08:06:07 AM

I'd love to see this for "Kill Bill 1 & 2", "Pulp Fiction" and "Momento".

Pooter

2009-11-02 08:09:37 AM

coco ebert: Oh, and I have no idea what Primer is.

Primer is about as close to a truly thought-provoking take on a time-travel story as you're likely to see on the big screen. Very low-key and awfully confusing.

mjgrazi23

2009-11-02 08:11:32 AM

What's Lord of the Rings?

gregfark

2009-11-02 08:12:07 AM

markcant: A little advice: Learn. To. Draw.

You really think xkcd is about the drawing?

SteelCityKid

2009-11-02 08:14:08 AM

Where's your website generating revenue while being among the more popular web comics? I like XKCD, every comic he draws doesn't need to be so steeped in obscure references and complicated math jokes to be funny or accepted. People who like to kill other peoples' enjoyment of something are hollow pricks. They can't like something for what it is so you can't either. Wah.

coco ebert

2009-11-02 08:17:06 AM

Pooter: coco ebert: Oh, and I have no idea what Primer is.

Primer is about as close to a truly thought-provoking take on a time-travel story as you're likely to see on the big screen. Very low-key and awfully confusing.

Great. Another movie I would need farking cliff notes to get through. That's not how it should work, folks.

Sword and Shield

2009-11-02 08:17:42 AM

Pimple: The LOTR and the Jurrasic park are obviously based on the movie versions, cause Hammond gets it at the end of the book.

So did Malcolm.

famousp

2009-11-02 08:21:12 AM

Anyone see where he messed up by claiming Boba Fett's death?

Pooter

2009-11-02 08:25:16 AM

coco ebert: Great. Another movie I would need farking cliff notes to get through. That's not how it should work, folks.

Good to know! I love learning new things!

*goes to burn his copy*

dittybopper

2009-11-02 08:25:17 AM

doglover:
Munroe is terrible.

img511.imageshack.us

Magua's village and lodges were burnt. Magua's children were killed by the English. Magua was taken as a slave by the Mohawks who fought for the Grey Hair. Magua's wife believed he was dead and became the wife of another. The Grey Hair was the father of all this.

In time Magua became blood-brother to Mohawk to become free. In his heart he always was Huron. And his heart will be whole again on the day when the Grey Hair and all his seed are dead!

IdBeCrazyIf

2009-11-02 08:25:41 AM

I see no mention of pillow pants

Uncle Wiggly

2009-11-02 08:29:57 AM

Now begins the tale of the XKCD Weekend Screenwriting Seminar: "Rail Switching Screen Writing!"

(Only $755--with box lunch--at the Holiday Inn Express in Des Moines THIS WEEKEND ONLY. SEATING IS LIMITED)

(Patented Rail Switching Layout grid and twelve magic markers available FREE for FIRST 40 RESPONDENTS!)

* Learn how to let momentum help you
* Learn to prevent early collisions
* Learn how to manage multiple trains
* Learn to put the RR into fiction and make frriction!

/formerly the Karma Sutra Screen Writing Seminar

Big Dave

2009-11-02 08:31:00 AM

uhg, no. No no no no. I like XKCD usually but it's not for communicating complicated info like this. Stick to the three-panel format and you have my attention 50% of the time (the other half being devoted to programming languages I've barely heard of).

VictoryCabal

2009-11-02 08:32:55 AM

I lold hard at 12 Angry Men.

telkinsjr

2009-11-02 08:36:28 AM

The Primer chart was spot on. But I already knew that cause I typed this comment three weeks ago when I went back to the future yesterday.

Ender912

2009-11-02 08:36:37 AM

Wicked!

jack21221

2009-11-02 08:36:55 AM

SpinStopper: That was pretty cool. Now I want to watch Primer ;)

Yeah, reminded me a little of the Primer flow charts I've seen.