If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Reuters)   Lawsuit against Spielberg contends that "Disturbia" was a blatant ripoff of "Rear Window". Not sure how it took a year for someone to notice   (news.yahoo.com) divider line 40
    More: Obvious  
•       •       •

1259 clicks; posted to Entertainment » on 08 Sep 2008 at 8:31 PM   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»



40 Comments   (+0 »)
   

Archived thread
 
2008-09-08 07:25:58 PM
I do think it was a bit much when they had Shia LeBoef wearing Jimmy Stewart's skin like a Halloween costume and talking in a warbly old man voice during the final scenes.
 
2008-09-08 07:32:28 PM
Cagey B: talking in a warbly old man voice during the final scenes.

Oh come on. No one can mimic that voice. It's impossible.
 
2008-09-08 08:34:37 PM
ninjakirby: Cagey B: talking in a warbly old man voice during the final scenes.

Oh come on. No one can mimic that voice. It's impossible.


Kevin Spacey would beg to differ.
 
2008-09-08 08:38:18 PM
i thought it was a remake
 
2008-09-08 08:38:42 PM
FrancoFile: ninjakirby: Cagey B: talking in a warbly old man voice during the final scenes.

Oh come on. No one can mimic that voice. It's impossible.

Kevin Spacey would beg to differ.


See also: Carvey, Dana.
 
2008-09-08 08:45:12 PM
Hah! Yeah the movie's awesome, because it has Shia LaDouche.
 
2008-09-08 08:48:43 PM
Based on the commercials, I always thought Disurbia was just Spielberg's modern remake of Rear Window. It is news to me that it isnt a remake.

Has anyone seen it? And can you speak to similarities and differences.
 
2008-09-08 08:56:04 PM
Good flick.

Bring on the Shia hate.
 
2008-09-08 09:01:15 PM
RedShoes60: FrancoFile: ninjakirby: Cagey B: talking in a warbly old man voice during the final scenes.

Oh come on. No one can mimic that voice. It's impossible.

Kevin Spacey would beg to differ.

See also: Carvey, Dana.


Wasn't Michael J Fox, when he was younger and not so jerky, talked about as portraying Stewart in a biopic? Supposedly he had the voice down pat. Maybe the Parkinsons helped?
 
2008-09-08 09:06:17 PM
Wow, did that one come from the No shiat files or what?
That's almost some Romero-esque news reporting there!
 
2008-09-08 09:09:40 PM
Oh yeah, and need I remind everyone:
Simpsons did it!

animatedtv.about.com

If anyone else remembers, it was the episode where the Simpsons get a pool, Bart tries to jump out of the tree house, falls and breaks his leg. He then has to sit in his room and watch the neighbors through a telescope Lisa gave him....

Oh yeah, and there was a similar Rocko's Modern Life episode where Bev Bighead mysteriously disappears. But I don't watch to much TV!
 
2008-09-08 09:14:17 PM
Jim Carrey does a pretty good Jimmy Stewart too.

/see, I would bring the Shia hate, but it's really not worth getting too angry about the next C. Thomas Howell
 
2008-09-08 09:15:26 PM
XtremeLeeWyte: But I don't watch to much TV!

You should read more.

/I remember that Rocko episode
//Also watch too much tube
 
2008-09-08 09:22:31 PM
I do read whenever I have time, those are actually recalled memories from my childhood. I used to watch ALOT of Nickelodeon back in the day. You know, when it was still good?
 
2008-09-08 09:28:52 PM
I actually don't mind shia lebouf in movies but thought disturbia was pretty awful
 
2008-09-08 09:37:39 PM
ninjakirby: Oh come on. No one can mimic that voice. It's impossible.

David Lindley does it perfectly
 
2008-09-08 09:53:26 PM
You guys aren't fans of Rough LeBeof?
 
2008-09-08 10:00:05 PM
XtremeLeeWyte: Oh yeah, and need I remind everyone:
Simpsons did it!



If anyone else remembers, it was the episode where the Simpsons get a pool, Bart tries to jump out of the tree house, falls and breaks his leg. He then has to sit in his room and watch the neighbors through a telescope Lisa gave him....


When Martin Prince was Queen of Summertime?

/Have watched The Simpsons since The Tracy Ulman Show
 
2008-09-08 10:00:31 PM
greatgodyoshi

Wasn't Michael J Fox, when he was younger and not so jerky, talked about as portraying Stewart in a biopic? Supposedly he had the voice down pat. Maybe the Parkinsons helped?

Nope, originally Michael J Fox was going to star as James Cagney in a biopic about his amazing life. Cagney approved of it and hoped that he would live long enough to be able to help and see the movie.

It was never made.

Gunny Highway: Based on the commercials, I always thought Disurbia was just Spielberg's modern remake of Rear Window. It is news to me that it isnt a remake.

Has anyone seen it? And can you speak to similarities and differences.


I've seen both. I rented this film when I heard he was going to be in Indy 4. They put a few interesting twists on the story.

First Shia character witnessed his dad's death in a fishing accident. A year later, he's an angry young punk slacker, and punches out a teacher who used the old "What would your father think now" on him.

As a result-he gets put on house arrest. He's not allowed to go to school. He's not allowed to leave his yard without setting off the alarms. Despite this he manages to snag the pretty girl next door without coming across like a stalker.

So in his boredom, he starts spying on the neighborhood and listening to the news. He sees his neighbor across the way come home with a damaged mustang....and hears about a possible serial killer who's only link was a damaged mustang.

Throw in a cop who's assigned his neighborhood, and had to deal with his shenanigans before. The Villain is especially smart and has a pretty cool set up in his house.

There was some nicely done tense scenes a few action bits..and Shia had a few "Harrison Ford" moments (Especially when he got angry at his best friend) that probably made Spielberg go "Hey I found Indy's Son!"

It's worth a rental, at the very least
It's no Alfred Hitchcock film, but better than what it should have been.
 
2008-09-08 10:13:04 PM
It's a homage, not a rip off
 
2008-09-08 10:17:30 PM
Color me no shiat on this one. I think it is well worth a rental especially if you do netflix or some other watch everything rental deal.

My wife and watched it and basically figure out early on that it was rear window. The basic plot points and how the characters act are all the same, just with a modern spin. Not a bad flick, but to deny this is not rear window is just stupidity.

My guess is that Speilberg simply did not know of the original short story they need to pay off OR the studios somehow thought they were covered because they already paid for the original make of Rear Window and don't have to pay again for the remake.
 
2008-09-08 10:31:34 PM
I don't think you can really copyright a concept, and that's basically what Disturbia took from Rear Window.

If being derivitive is against the law, then 90 percent of the movies made every year are probably violating someone's copyright.
 
2008-09-08 10:49:40 PM
wingnut396: Color me no shiat on this one. I think it is well worth a rental especially if you do netflix or some other watch everything rental deal.

My wife and watched it and basically figure out early on that it was rear window. The basic plot points and how the characters act are all the same, just with a modern spin. Not a bad flick, but to deny this is not rear window is just stupidity.

My guess is that Speilberg simply did not know of the original short story they need to pay off OR the studios somehow thought they were covered because they already paid for the original make of Rear Window and don't have to pay again for the remake.


My guess is that Speilberg is a talentless hack who is only famous because the shark was broken in Jaws 1. He decided he was too important have to pay for the rights. Afterall, who are the people going to believe? He is friggin Spielberg.
 
2008-09-08 10:54:17 PM
i291.photobucket.com

Also named on the suit....
 
2008-09-08 10:56:18 PM
robsul82: I would bring the Shia hate, but it's really not worth getting too angry about the next C. Thomas Howell

Don't be dissing Ponyboy!

Disturbia was alright. Yeah it was a rip off, but it wasn't a bad rip off.
 
2008-09-08 10:56:20 PM
falcon176: i thought it was a remake

came here to say this, glad I'm not the only one
 
2008-09-08 11:38:20 PM
Dude, I noticed this in the freakin' trailer. I never even saw the thing.
What took them so long?

And I didn't know Spielberg was involved. For shame, Stevie.
 
2008-09-09 12:07:33 AM
falcon176: i thought it was a remake

i honestly did too, like a modern retelling

OH HOW FAR YOU'VE FALLEN DJ CARUSO

get back to the salton sea and get away from shia lebouf plz
 
2008-09-09 12:10:22 AM
Even the movie posters are similar.

sarahaswell.com
www.allposters.com

Somehow I thought this when Disturbia came out, but I haven't actually seen it, and had no idea what it was about. Maybe it was the posters? I have no idea, and it's kinda weird
 
2008-09-09 12:29:57 AM
even in the poster he looks bored, stiff, and emotionless

please let his career go away as soon as possible
 
2008-09-09 12:59:02 AM
This is the reason I didn't see Disturbia in the theaters -- Rear Window is my favorite film of all time and the trailers made it obvious that Disturbia was a rip-off of the story. And as a film snob it annoyed me that most of the kids going to see it had no idea.

HOWEVER, I rented it later and ended up enjoying it a lot, so I've forgiven them.


Also, Tropic Thunder and Galaxy Quest were rip-offs of Three Amigos, which took a lot of its story from The Seven Samurai, which also influenced The Magnificent Seven...
 
2008-09-09 01:10:39 AM
I kind of like Shia (I won't attempt to spell his last name). Why all the hate?
 
2008-09-09 01:34:43 AM
bi.gazeta.pl

Hottest video on a while, thanks.
 
2008-09-09 03:10:38 AM
Hey, it's Shia's Citizen Kane. Let the kid have his moment.
 
2008-09-09 08:02:06 AM
lolmadillo: even in the poster he looks bored, stiff, and emotionless

So he's the new Keanu? If so, we could be in for a long and painful career.

/not really
//just don't watch them, they will go away
///another simpsons did it
 
2008-09-09 08:20:31 AM
This reminds me of when The Island was coming out. I commented to a friend that it was just a rip of Parts: The Clonus Horror, and we thought it was odd that they'd re-make a movie so bad that MST3k ripped it.

When, months later, the Clonus owners sued, I thought it was hysterical. The fact that they dropped the lawsuit when The Island made no money, that's just comedy gold.ac
 
2008-09-09 10:55:39 AM
Speaking of which, whatever happened to the lawsuit against Michael Bay's The Island, which was an even more rip off of The Clonus Horror?
 
2008-09-09 11:12:12 AM
Mugato: Speaking of which, whatever happened to the lawsuit against Michael Bay's The Island, which was an even more rip off of The Clonus Horror?

Settled, out of court, allegedly for seven figures (but the number is sealed). Basically, they stopped pushing for a full injunction (which was really just extortion for $10 million+) once the movie tanked in theaters.
 
2008-09-09 01:53:51 PM
The same way Tropic Thunder is a rip of Three Amigos
 
2008-09-09 02:09:11 PM
I liked the movie Eragon when it was called Star Wars.
 
Displayed 40 of 40 comments



This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »





Report