If you can read this, either the style sheet didn't load or you have an older browser that doesn't support style sheets. Try clearing your browser cache and refreshing the page.

(Christian Science Monitor)   Soldiers upset that media gives such a bleak portrayal of Iraq   (csmonitor.com) divider line 299
    More: Obvious  
•       •       •

9025 clicks; posted to Main » on 28 Nov 2005 at 6:18 PM   |  Favorite    |   share:  Share on Twitter share via Email Share on Facebook   more»



299 Comments   (+0 »)
   

Archived thread

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | » | Last | Show all
 
2005-11-28 05:22:20 PM
YEAH! enough with the facts already.

more pretend stuff, please.
 
2005-11-28 05:30:55 PM
Yeah - and we can get Bruce Willis to do a story about it!
 
2005-11-28 05:32:27 PM
The news is always like that. At best you get a fluff piece every once in a great while about some kids or a dog or some athlete beating cancer. Everything else is politicians fighting, shootings, bad car accidents, natural disasters, missing white women, and weird stuff. That's the news.
 
2005-11-28 05:34:39 PM
If soldiers want cheerier stories in the news, they should stop getting blown up, come home and open a puppy ranch or something.

Too bad if you don't like the tone of the news stories. I thought your job was to be a grunt and not ask questions!
 
2005-11-28 05:35:23 PM
No news is good news.
Conversely, good news is not news.
 
2005-11-28 05:36:05 PM
"Like many soldiers and marines returning from Iraq, Mayer looks at the bleak portrayal of the war at home with perplexity - if not annoyance. It is a perception gap that has put the military and media at odds, as troops complain that the media care only about death tolls, while the media counter that their job is to look at the broader picture, not through the soda straw of troops' individual experiences.

..

In Hit, where marines stayed in force to keep the peace, the progress was obvious, say members of the 3/25. The residents started burning trash and fixing roads - a sign that the city was returning to a sense of normalcy. Several times, "people came up to us [and said]: 'There's a bomb on the side of the road. Don't go there,' " says Pfc. Andrew Howland.

..

Part of the reason that such stories usually aren't told is simply the nature of the war. Kidnappings and unclear battle lines have made war correspondents' jobs almost impossible. Travel around the country is dangerous, and some reporters never venture far from their hotels. "It has to have some effect on what we see: You end up with reporting that waits for the biggest explosion of the day," says Mr. Hart."


... but it's different
when we see from the straw of the Journalist in their hotel room, not the soldier who is warned about the IED from an Iraqi.


This is the point of the article, In my opinion.
 
2005-11-28 05:36:39 PM
Its war, not band camp. Keep up questioning the media and Pat Robertson will redirect a hurricane at you.
 
2005-11-28 05:38:50 PM
Uh, where's the good news coming out of Iraq, submitter?

We can train an American and send him to war in three months. We haven't been able to get Iraqi soldiers trained in three years. The civilians have less water, food, shelter, electricity, and other essentials than they had before we invaded. They have more of some things, such as IEDs, islamic terrorists, potholes from explosions, and god-only-knows how many dead people, but for some reason, they're less than thankful to us for bringing those things to them.

For every soldier coming home calling it a "place of hope," there are ten calling Iraq a deathtrap.
 
2005-11-28 05:38:54 PM
Yes because $200 billion and thousands of lives are totally worth children playing on Army trucks and some guy marvelling at an electric razor. I see his point now. In fact I can only hope that we spend a trillion dollars and sacrifice 100 thousand troops so an Iranian kid can know the joy of blowing bubbles and her mom can marvel at her new electric mixer.

I don't know why we've been so gloomy and negative.
 
2005-11-28 05:40:12 PM
I thought the reason we paid soldiers was to STFU and kill brown people?

Really don't care what they 'think.'
 
2005-11-28 05:40:40 PM
Heh. It's really quite funny to watch people biatch about this article.
 
2005-11-28 05:42:42 PM
the_gospel_of_thomas, if you highlight other parts of your C&P, such as "Kidnappings and unclear battle lines have made war correspondents' jobs almost impossible," it gives it a totally different tone.

/just sayin'
 
2005-11-28 05:44:30 PM
Yeah.

The media SHOULD show the kids flying their kites in downtown Baghdad. That way we'll know it's just as nice a place now as when Michael Moore visited and recorded films of kids flying kites in Baghdad.

Dictatorship by Saddam?
Post Saddam power vacuum?
Civil War?
Unpopular occupation?

None of those exist if you'll only just focus for a moment on the children and their kites. Look! Look at the pretty kites!
 
2005-11-28 05:45:06 PM
What do soldiers know about war anyway?

/probably not as much as me and my BLOG.
 
2005-11-28 05:45:35 PM
I used to get depressed when the market analysts downgraded my old company's stock. But it didn't change the reality that we were tanking it, big time. The truth hurts, but not nearly as much as living in ignorance.
 
2005-11-28 05:45:37 PM
Really don't care what they 'think.'

That's freaking pathetic.
 
2005-11-28 05:46:01 PM
BearToy: and some guy marvelling at an electric razor

I guess if he's reluctant to get rid of his beard and actually has electricity he can still use it as a makeshift stud finder... assuming his walls are still standing.
 
2005-11-28 05:46:17 PM
2005-11-28 05:40:40 PM Dancin_In_Anson [TotalFark]
Heh. It's really quite funny to watch people biatch about this article.

Actually, the article's not bad. It makes a perfectly valid point: The experiences of the soldiers differ from the experiences of the journalists. I have no problem with that.

However, I'm inclined to give more credit to the ongoing reports of violence as indicative of the situation there than to lend the same credence to individual reports of things like Iraqi cooperation. The truth is, the violence hasn't even come close to abating.
 
2005-11-28 05:46:44 PM
"Kidnappings and unclear battle lines have also made Soldiers & Marines' jobs almost impossible," ... but they do it.

And their views from the ground by the soldiers is no less valid than the views of the journalists as they compose their stories on a laptop in the hotel lobby.
 
2005-11-28 05:47:05 PM
I don't blame the press for the bad news out of Iraq any more than I blame the troops for the failure to implement a policy that could never be successfully implemented.
 
2005-11-28 05:47:50 PM
GoodDamon: Actually, the article's not bad.


You certainly wouldn't be able to tell from many of the posts here...
 
2005-11-28 05:49:01 PM
elchip: No news is good news.
Conversely, good news is not news.



You just blew my mind, man...
 
2005-11-28 05:51:43 PM
I'd trust an LT before I trusted a reporter after ad revenue.
 
2005-11-28 05:52:25 PM
2005-11-28 05:40:40 PM Dancin_In_Anson [TotalFark]

Heh. It's really quite funny to watch people biatch about this article.

You must have not RTFM. Libertarians don't like the war in Iraq and don't care for el Presidente too much.

So, are you a Republican or a Constitution Party member in Libertarian's clothing?
 
DAR [TotalFark]
2005-11-28 05:53:25 PM
The war in Iraq is going just the way the Bush administration wanted it too.

The Iraq oil fields are in the hands of Exxon, Shell, and BP.
 
2005-11-28 05:53:40 PM
2005-11-28 05:51:43 PM Chester Fields [TotalFark]

I'd trust an LT before I trusted a reporter after ad revenue.

I'd trust the Christian Science Monitor before I trusted, oh, pretty much any other news source.

CSM for the win!
 
2005-11-28 05:55:41 PM
2005-11-28 05:51:43 PM Chester Fields [TotalFark]
I'd trust an LT before I trusted a reporter after ad revenue.


The problem is the soldier on the ground has, by necessity, a very myopic view of what's going on in-theater.
 
2005-11-28 05:55:52 PM
What's got their panties in a bunch?
 
2005-11-28 05:56:55 PM
2005-11-28 05:46:44 PM the_gospel_of_thomas [TotalFark]
And their views from the ground by the soldiers is no less valid than the views of the journalists as they compose their stories on a laptop in the hotel lobby.

Look at the example from your own comment, tgot. Several times, an Iraqi told a soldier that an IED was hidden on the road. To the soldier, this is helpful - possibly life-saving - and feels that this is a sign of returning normalcy and hope.

Take a look at the bigger picture that soldier doesn't comment on, though; the roads are riddled with IEDs. He wouldn't need to be warned about them unless they were there in the first place.
 
2005-11-28 05:58:48 PM
Thats true they are doing good things over there and I would be bummed out if I was in the sandbox. However if an IED went off in *your town here* and blew up a bus that would be news too so yes it's going to get reported. If you want to see a war with good press look at WWII when the Govt. had the reins of what got put out. So do we want to hear just the bad news or just the Govt's good news?
 
2005-11-28 05:59:10 PM
The problem is the soldier on the ground has, by necessity, a very myopic view of what's going on in-theater.

So, in sports (my analogy), you have a better perspective of the team's moral and attitude than they do? You can also sense a shift in momentum before they can?
 
2005-11-28 06:01:48 PM
elchip: You must have not RTFM. Libertarians don't like the war in Iraq and don't care for el Presidente too much.


Well, I guess that means that I don't march in lockstep with any one party eh? How about you? Oh, and I did read the article...I submitted the one where the CSM was called a propaganda machine or the like...

Like I said, it's pretty funny to watch people biatch about good news.
 
2005-11-28 06:02:01 PM
My unit went to Iraq last year. Iraq isnt as bad as it was when we got there and we made many strides towards their freedom. If you want a good portrayal of life Iraq when my unit was there get the movie Gunner Palace.

If you were there, you would see that it's not as bad as the media makes it out to be.
 
2005-11-28 06:03:16 PM
2005-11-28 05:59:10 PM Civil_War2_Time [TotalFark]

So, in sports (my analogy), you have a better perspective of the team's moral and attitude than they do? You can also sense a shift in momentum before they can?

Your analogy does not scale well from a handful of people on a 100-yard playing field to tens of thousands of people on a California-sized playing field.
 
2005-11-28 06:04:53 PM
Civil_War2_Time

So, in sports (my analogy), you have a better perspective of the team's moral and attitude than they do? You can also sense a shift in momentum before they can?


Bad-bad-bad-bad analogy, IMHO. Anyways, no, I'd think it's more like "When your face to face with the opposing linemen, you aren't, and shouldn't be, paying attention to what's going on with every single other team member, the opposing team, your coaches, their coaches, the fans in the stands and the media coverage of the game."
 
2005-11-28 06:05:53 PM
2005-11-28 06:01:48 PM Dancin_In_Anson [TotalFark]

Well, I guess that means that I don't march in lockstep with any one party eh? How about you?

You must have not RTFM. You are required to march in lockstep with a political party.

Okay, in all seriousness, you're right. It's just that a libertarian supporting the war in Iraq is like an anti-death penalty, pro-choice Republican -- a bit of an oddity, but still valid.
 
2005-11-28 06:06:37 PM
Somesoldiers upset that media gives such a bleak portrayal of Iraq.



There, I fixed the headline.
 
2005-11-28 06:07:33 PM
Civil_War2_Time - the 'shift in momentum' is as a result of the us no longer fighting al sadr - instead allowing him and other militias to control the streets. the us tried to take the shia on in najaf and other areas, and now they are ceding control to the same people
 
2005-11-28 06:08:01 PM
Broadcastdave,

what do you do in the army?
 
2005-11-28 06:08:29 PM
Conspiracy Theory #1 - The Pentagon is deliberately relocating troops to areas known to be safer and less hostile to generate "soldiers stories" like these. Discuss.
 
2005-11-28 06:10:23 PM
Why does Broadcastdave hate America?

OBVIOUSLY, Iraq is a quagmire, and no good can come from this.



"Not as bad as the media says," eh, Get him!!! His point of view must not be tolerated here!
 
2005-11-28 06:12:01 PM
the_gospel_of_thomas: Not as bad as the media says



It's funny when I hear that then hear some soldier in Iraq on TV telling the media It's a hellhole over there and he they wouldnt care if it burned to the ground.
 
2005-11-28 06:12:21 PM
2005-11-28 06:10:23 PM the_gospel_of_thomas [TotalFark]

Why does Broadcastdave hate America?

OBVIOUSLY, Iraq is a quagmire, and no good can come from this.

"Not as bad as the media says," eh, Get him!!! His point of view must not be tolerated here!


Stop being funny. You're a conservative, so you're supposed to be constantly ignorant, inflammatory, and evil.
 
2005-11-28 06:14:26 PM
* shuffles out of the thread, head hung low ... mumbling incoherently *

I'll be back ... maybe ...
 
2005-11-28 06:14:43 PM
elchip: It's just that a libertarian supporting the war in Iraq is like an anti-death penalty, pro-choice Republican


Oh, I don't know. I would say that the rabid isolationists in the Libertarian Party are kind of like the far left "whackdoodles" in the "D" column and the far right "wingnuts" in the "R".

Now that we have hat settled, let's sit back and find out why the constant stream of negative news from Iraq is far more accurate and valid than the good news that the fine men and women of the 3rd Battalion, 25th Marines and other units would like to have braodcast.

Or will the conversation veer away from that to a "Bush lied" thing while completely ignoring the words of men like Cpl. Jeff Schuller?
 
2005-11-28 06:15:31 PM
it's actually a lot worse than the media paints, tgot. you've got a couple of career-minded soldiers blowing their own trumpets, but i can point to any number of official (conservative) reports that detail the failures in infrastructure reconstruction, security, spending, iraqi moral, employment, the iraqi government - just about anything that you want

but no, a couple of grunts toe the line, and you're back out of the woodwork, talking out of your ass, yet again
 
2005-11-28 06:16:20 PM
You_mean_Im_gonna_stay_this_color: It's funny when I hear that then hear some soldier in Iraq on TV telling the media It's a hellhole over there and he they wouldnt care if it burned to the ground.


What's funnier* is that he'll get more airplay than will the men in this article...

*but I'm not laughing.
 
2005-11-28 06:16:24 PM
Chester Fields-

I am a 74D (Chemical Operations) that belonged to a medical unit (E Co, 27th MSB) during the time we were in Iraq. Now I am in a new unit (A Co, 15th BSTB)which consists of mostly 88M (truck drivers).
 
2005-11-28 06:18:19 PM
you are joking aren't you dancin'? are you seriously suggesting that in a democracy in wartime, that reporting should be controlled by grunts in the army? jesus christ! even for you that is desperate. would you give lynndie england an anchoring role too? how about jessica lynch?
 
2005-11-28 06:18:28 PM
You_mean_Im_gonna_stay_this_color: It's funny when I hear that then hear some soldier in Iraq on TV telling the media It's a hellhole over there and he they wouldnt care if it burned to the ground.

Where and when did you hear a soldier say this? I haven't heard any soldiers saying anything like this.
 
Displayed 50 of 299 comments

First | « | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | » | Last | Show all



This thread is closed to new comments.

Continue Farking
Submit a Link »






Report