Democracy is more than a system of government. It's a system of values. And if a culture doesn't have those values all the guns and bombs in the world can't enforce a democracy.
The Icelander:Democracy is more than a system of government. It's a system of values. And if a culture doesn't have those values all the guns and bombs in the world can't enforce a democracy.
Yeah good luck with all that.
I tried explaining that democracy is more of a cultural concept than a set form of governing when GDubz was starting his "Spread the Freedom" tour of the Middle East.
All you're going to get is some bumper sticker slogans and Toby Keith lyrics in response.
The Icelander:Democracy is more than a system of government. It's a system of values. And if a culture doesn't have those values all the guns and bombs in the world can't enforce a democracy.
Don't be ridiculous. History has proven that if we bomb and shoot enough natives they will finally accept the White Man's Burden.
The Icelander:Democracy is more than a system of government. It's a system of values. And if a culture doesn't have those values all the guns and bombs in the world can't enforce a democracy.
That doesn't speak well for the New Jersey Governors Race.
The argument that certain cultures are incompatible with democracy is absurd, and it's been repeatedly proven false. 30 years ago it was Spain and Portugal which were too conservatively Catholic for democracy. 50 years ago it was South Korea, which was too Confucian for democracy. 60 years ago it was India, which was too poor and too diverse. 90 years ago it was Turkey, which was too Muslim.
It requires a certain mindset from the people, mainly a desire for input in their own government, but it works across cultures.
NobleHam:The argument that certain cultures are incompatible with democracy is absurd, and it's been repeatedly proven false. 30 years ago it was Spain and Portugal which were too conservatively Catholic for democracy. 50 years ago it was South Korea, which was too Confucian for democracy. 60 years ago it was India, which was too poor and too diverse. 90 years ago it was Turkey, which was too Muslim.
It requires a certain mindset from the people, mainly a desire for input in their own government, but it works across cultures.
I wouldn't say that any culture is inherently incompatible with democracy, just that it's a concept they need to arrive at on their own.
NobleHam:It requires a certain mindset from the people, mainly a desire for input in their own government, but it works across cultures.
From what I understand, Afghanistan NEVER really had a central government - at least, one which could effectively govern the far-flung tribal regions (those same places we're having trouble capturing/keeping) from Kabul.
You want to talk about independent, bootstrappy manly rugged individualists, Afghanis in those tribal regions have Mountain West Americans beat by a longshot.
The Icelander:Democracy is more than a system of government. It's a system of values. And if a culture doesn't have those values all the guns and bombs in the world can't enforce a democracy.
wet_dream:The Icelander: Democracy is more than a system of government. It's a system of values. And if a culture doesn't have those values all the guns and bombs in the world can't enforce a democracy.
That doesn't speak well for the New Jersey Governors Race.
Seriously, this is not a troll, but does this strike anyone of history repeating itself. In Vietnam we had an enemy that had safe haven in a neighboring country and we were backing an ineffectual and corrupt government. Now in Afghanistan we are facing the same thing. I seriously think that we should pull out and save the lives that we can.
TheBitterest
2009-11-03 08:48:27 AM
The Icelander
2009-11-03 09:16:04 AM
Diogenes
2009-11-03 09:55:55 AM
redmond24
2009-11-03 10:58:20 AM
A Dark Evil Omen
2009-11-03 10:59:12 AM
colon_pow
2009-11-03 10:59:38 AM
HotWingConspiracy
2009-11-03 10:59:57 AM
Yeah good luck with all that.
I tried explaining that democracy is more of a cultural concept than a set form of governing when GDubz was starting his "Spread the Freedom" tour of the Middle East.
All you're going to get is some bumper sticker slogans and Toby Keith lyrics in response.
illegal.tender
2009-11-03 11:00:36 AM
We should not be supporting this guy.
Diogenes
2009-11-03 11:00:50 AM
Obama would be wise to be cautious with this Afghan. I've heard this breed will turn on you.
Alphax
2009-11-03 11:01:37 AM
I hear the Obama Administration says they need a partner they can trust in Afghanistan. Good luck on finding one.
Therion
2009-11-03 11:01:38 AM
Don't be ridiculous. History has proven that if we bomb and shoot enough natives they will finally accept the White Man's Burden.
A Dark Evil Omen
2009-11-03 11:01:49 AM
Obama would be wise to be cautious with this Afghan. I've heard this breed will turn on you.
So Karzai needs lots of brushing and is highly susceptible to allergies?
wet_dream
2009-11-03 11:03:11 AM
That doesn't speak well for the New Jersey Governors Race.
vernonFL
2009-11-03 11:04:04 AM
I can't think of a more stupid, useless policy than propping up an unpopualr regime there.
A Dark Evil Omen
2009-11-03 11:05:20 AM
If Karzai's government is going to remain corrupt and ineffectual,we should all leave.I can't think of a more stupid, useless policy than propping up an unpopualr regime there.FTFAccuracy
NobleHam
2009-11-03 11:07:31 AM
It requires a certain mindset from the people, mainly a desire for input in their own government, but it works across cultures.
Carth
2009-11-03 11:08:01 AM
I can't think of a more stupid, useless policy than propping up an unpopualr regime there.
The whole war is just a ploy so we can move into Pakistan quickly to secure the nuclear arsenal if Pakistan's government fails.
Diogenes
2009-11-03 11:10:27 AM
Obama would be wise to be cautious with this Afghan. I've heard this breed will turn on you.
So Karzai needs lots of brushing and is highly susceptible to allergies?
And chew toys. They're very high strung and will cause mischief if they get bored.
ilambiquated
2009-11-03 11:11:56 AM
We should not be supporting this guy.
Got another idea?
HotWingConspiracy
2009-11-03 11:12:38 AM
It requires a certain mindset from the people, mainly a desire for input in their own government, but it works across cultures.
I wouldn't say that any culture is inherently incompatible with democracy, just that it's a concept they need to arrive at on their own.
Dr Dreidel
2009-11-03 11:17:00 AM
From what I understand, Afghanistan NEVER really had a central government - at least, one which could effectively govern the far-flung tribal regions (those same places we're having trouble capturing/keeping) from Kabul.
You want to talk about independent, bootstrappy manly rugged individualists, Afghanis in those tribal regions have Mountain West Americans beat by a longshot.
// seriously - when was the last time a band of Mountaineers beat back a Taliban-type attacking force?
Sandelaphon
2009-11-03 11:23:43 AM
Yeah, they should learn from America!
Almet
2009-11-03 11:32:08 AM
That doesn't speak well for the New Jersey Governors Race.
Obvious photoshop is obvious.
End_Of_Line
2009-11-03 11:34:21 AM
boluke01
2009-11-03 11:37:04 AM