Given the way the 787 program is going, South Carolina will be under water from global warming by the time they get the first line running, let alone the second one.
The plane isn't even in production yet, so Boeing's long history of labor trouble's isn't exactly in play except for being a part of Boeing's history. And South Carolina is merely a right to work state, doesn't mean they won't end up with a unionized shop.
If they went with Everett, where would they put the new lines? The south end of Paine Field is all locked up by Tramco and the Air Guard base. You could shoehorn it into the existing hangers, but that would be a bit of a mess. The area behind Boeing is all developed now, anyways. Intermec and Fluke are in the areas adjacent to the Boeing property. Lots of other light industrial have moved into the other spots.
Then you have transportation issues. I-405 and I-5 are a mess. They basically have to truck parts at night from vendors on the south side of Seattle. That really restricts their schedule.
I recall Boeing talking about Moses Lake as a new assembly locale, but to be honest, I think Boeing is sick of Washington. South Carolina is a right to work state. Washington is a closed shop union state. The IAM is fairly entrenched in Washington, while the guys in South Carolina voted them out. Boeing management and the IAM play about as nicely together as GM and the UAW do.
Charleston is also closer to their Chicago HQ. Makes me wonder if that played any part, too.
WhyteRaven74:Given what they're building, not unreasonable at all.
From what my friends who used to work out on the line have told me, the majority of the work isn't that complicated.
The wiring is fairly complex, and there are some places where fastener tolerances are less than a millimeter, but that's all been validated in the CATIA mock ups, so it is mostly following blue prints.
Dinjiin:the majority of the work isn't that complicated.
I know it's for the most part not complicated work, however you don't want someone doing a slop job because they don't feel they're being paid too poorly to do it right.
WhyteRaven74:Dinjiin: the majority of the work isn't that complicated.
I know it's for the most part not complicated work, however you don't want someone doing a slop job because they don't feel they're being paid too poorly to do it right.
Yes. Most union work results in a slop job.
They are never paid enough. Carpenters should be paid $275k per year and work 30 hours a week, and auto workers should also be paid $450k per year but will work 40 hours a week.
That is how unions act.
Also, don't forget that many union firefighters in Las Vegas make $100-250k per year... while holding second jobs they work during the 2 weeks per month they are off.
WhyteRaven74:Dinjiin: the majority of the work isn't that complicated.
I know it's for the most part not complicated work, however you don't want someone doing a slop job because they don't feel they're being paid too poorly to do it right.
How much they get paid doesnt really make a difference. Theres a reason they call it the Lazy-B around here.
WhyteRaven74:you don't want someone doing a slop job because they don't feel they're being paid too poorly to do it right.
Who do you think is going to be more mindful: somebody who can be fired immediately for doing a slop job, or somebody who has the protection of union reps?
I used to work in a closed shop that was represented by the Teamsters. People who should have been fired were not because they got the union involved. Even after the union drama, they continued to fark off, secure in their knowledge that it would be difficult to remove them.
I have no firsthand knowledge if the IAM is like that, but I've heard that the UAW is, and a lot of people say that the IAM is like the UAW.
If you're not forced to join a union and you get to think about it logically, you don't end up in one. There's no "Seniority" no "I spent years at the bottom now I'm getting mine" mentality.
The UAW nuts flier one of our plants every 6 months. Come stand right off of our property and hand out fliers as everyone drives in. And twice a year the janitors have to work extra hard cleaning them up.
When BMW opened their plant in SC, you HAD to have a college degree to even be considered for factory work. They didn't care what it was in, liberal arts, math, science, teaching, as long as it was a college degree.
Occam's Chainsaw:Funny how the hand that feeds you won't hesitate to jerk that food away at a whim.
IAM's strike last year was both lengthy and unjustified and they've been doing that a LOT over the past decade or so, I don't blame Boeing for getting out of Dodge as soon as the option was available
The IAM guys here have an incredibly entitled attitude, check out some of their quotes in the Seattle Times
mr_a
2009-10-29 12:00:46 AM
Cubansaltyballs
2009-10-29 01:50:38 AM
Unions in CA, and WA need sharp kick in the balls. $40 an hour for laborers... yeah, that sounds reasonable.
WhyteRaven74
2009-10-29 01:51:16 AM
WhyteRaven74
2009-10-29 01:52:34 AM
Given what they're building, not unreasonable at all.
Dinjiin
2009-10-29 01:53:29 AM
Then you have transportation issues. I-405 and I-5 are a mess. They basically have to truck parts at night from vendors on the south side of Seattle. That really restricts their schedule.
I recall Boeing talking about Moses Lake as a new assembly locale, but to be honest, I think Boeing is sick of Washington. South Carolina is a right to work state. Washington is a closed shop union state. The IAM is fairly entrenched in Washington, while the guys in South Carolina voted them out. Boeing management and the IAM play about as nicely together as GM and the UAW do.
Charleston is also closer to their Chicago HQ. Makes me wonder if that played any part, too.
Dinjiin
2009-10-29 02:00:17 AM
From what my friends who used to work out on the line have told me, the majority of the work isn't that complicated.
The wiring is fairly complex, and there are some places where fastener tolerances are less than a millimeter, but that's all been validated in the CATIA mock ups, so it is mostly following blue prints.
Cubansaltyballs
2009-10-29 02:02:12 AM
Given what they're building, not unreasonable at all.
I didn't say machinist. I said laborers. You know, they guys that sweep up, guide the forklifts, drag around wheelbarrows and such.
Laborers the most unskilled on the entire construction site.
I have no idea what Boeing is paying, just giving an example of how out of control the unions have gotten in CA, WA, NJ, and other deep blue states.
WhyteRaven74
2009-10-29 02:10:52 AM
I know it's for the most part not complicated work, however you don't want someone doing a slop job because they don't feel they're being paid too poorly to do it right.
Cubansaltyballs
2009-10-29 02:14:51 AM
I know it's for the most part not complicated work, however you don't want someone doing a slop job because they don't feel they're being paid too poorly to do it right.
Yes. Most union work results in a slop job.
They are never paid enough. Carpenters should be paid $275k per year and work 30 hours a week, and auto workers should also be paid $450k per year but will work 40 hours a week.
That is how unions act.
Also, don't forget that many union firefighters in Las Vegas make $100-250k per year... while holding second jobs they work during the 2 weeks per month they are off.
DrySocket
2009-10-29 02:14:54 AM
I know it's for the most part not complicated work, however you don't want someone doing a slop job because they don't feel they're being paid too poorly to do it right.
How much they get paid doesnt really make a difference. Theres a reason they call it the Lazy-B around here.
Dinjiin
2009-10-29 02:41:46 AM
Who do you think is going to be more mindful: somebody who can be fired immediately for doing a slop job, or somebody who has the protection of union reps?
I used to work in a closed shop that was represented by the Teamsters. People who should have been fired were not because they got the union involved. Even after the union drama, they continued to fark off, secure in their knowledge that it would be difficult to remove them.
I have no firsthand knowledge if the IAM is like that, but I've heard that the UAW is, and a lot of people say that the IAM is like the UAW.
Tourney3p0
2009-10-29 03:02:56 AM
darkscout
2009-10-29 03:17:01 AM
While this is true somehow BMW, Caterpillar, Honda a whole host of other companies are operating in SC with out one.
If you're not forced to join a union and you get to think about it logically, you don't end up in one. There's no "Seniority" no "I spent years at the bottom now I'm getting mine" mentality.
The UAW nuts flier one of our plants every 6 months. Come stand right off of our property and hand out fliers as everyone drives in. And twice a year the janitors have to work extra hard cleaning them up.
When BMW opened their plant in SC, you HAD to have a college degree to even be considered for factory work. They didn't care what it was in, liberal arts, math, science, teaching, as long as it was a college degree.
gave up
2009-10-29 03:46:16 AM
Unobtanium
2009-10-29 06:52:57 AM
BigJake
2009-10-29 07:11:48 AM
Tourney3p0: SEC over Pac10 is really a no-brainer, at least this year. So long as we're not talking about Tennessee.
counterpoint: the Gamecocks
/hoping for a South Carolina/Oregon State game someday
Linux_Yes
2009-10-29 07:21:26 AM
idiot strikers.
Dancin_In_Anson
2009-10-29 07:29:39 AM
Occam's Chainsaw
2009-10-29 07:38:39 AM
Funny how the hand that feeds you won't hesitate to jerk that food away at a whim.
JustFark
2009-10-29 07:39:44 AM
Dancin_In_Anson
2009-10-29 07:50:11 AM
Which is why it's not a good idea to bite said hand, no?
BigJake
2009-10-29 08:05:41 AM
IAM's strike last year was both lengthy and unjustified and they've been doing that a LOT over the past decade or so, I don't blame Boeing for getting out of Dodge as soon as the option was available
The IAM guys here have an incredibly entitled attitude, check out some of their quotes in the Seattle Times
SWOne
2009-10-29 08:38:35 AM
MT4's start @ 11.74 and max out about 32 an hour after 6 plus years of service and continued training... but don't let facts get in your way.
It's only airplanes they are building.
tombotia
2009-10-29 08:57:33 AM
Given what they're building, not unreasonable at all.
Funny, would you pay farm-hands $40 an hour to grow your food for you?
I'd think food is more important than airliners.
tombotia
2009-10-29 08:58:50 AM
idiot strikers.
They have the right to strike, and employers have a right to hire other people. See how that works?