Police do not anticipate any charges.

Anticipate any charges? They should throw the guy a banquet.

That guy's earned uber Father's Day presents for the remainder of his existance.

feckingmorons: Police do not anticipate any charges.

Anticipate any charges? They should throw the guy a banquet.

Yeah but in some cities it's illegal to defend yourself or your family. See Washington DC, Chicago, etc.

As the father of a daughter, I'd like to find out that guy's name so I can send him a gift card for his favorite restaurant.

CheddarPants: As the father of a daughter, I'd like to find out that guy's name so I can send him a gift card for his favorite restaurant.

hell yeah. me too.

Police do not anticipate any arrests.

I'm shocked. Pleased, but shocked. And for those wanting to send rewards, a quick zabasearch turns up one Robert McNally in Indianapolis. His birth year matches.

How did the homeowner know this guy was going to hurt anyone? I'm sure they could have reasoned their way out of this with no one getting hurt. The homeowner overreacted and should be locked up, he is violent.

Yeah, I almost wanted to shoot myself for typing that.

That is farking AWESOME!!!


HAHAHAHAHAHA!


MY NEW HERO.

Expect the coroner to find he died of asphyxiation brought on by his heart condition.

The exact reason the 'Castle Doctrine' was put into effect.

"Police responding to a call from the city's northwest side about 3:20 a.m. Sunday found 64-year-old Robert McNally on the hallway floor with his arm around the neck of 52-year-old David T. Meyers"

So he didn't just shoot the guy or bludgeon him with some heavy household object; he actually locked the man in a rear naked choke and squeezed the effing life out of him. That is the most personal, visceral, you-will-not-stand-any-chance-of-living-through-this means of killing someone that I can imagine.

Somebody send this man a blue ribbon.

Dad did what he had to do to protect his daughter. indeed.

Never bring a rape kit to a death match.

Props to the old man for standing up and fighting back. And for choking the no good life out of him.

The more I think about this, the more gut-wrenching it gets. People don't just keel over and die while being choked, even if they're simultaneously having a heart attack. There is kicking and struggling and rolling around and biting involved. And the fact that the police found him on the hallway floor, still choking a corpse.

I'm starting to feel pretty bad for the father.

GWShenlong05: The more I think about this, the more gut-wrenching it gets. People don't just keel over and die while being choked, even if they're simultaneously having a heart attack. There is kicking and struggling and rolling around and biting involved. And the fact that the police found him on the hallway floor, still choking a corpse.

I'm starting to feel pretty bad for the father.

That had to be terrifying for the dad. I imagine the cops probably had to physically remove his arms from around the guys neck. Dad was probably too scared to even let up his grip much less release the guy.

GWShenlong05: The more I think about this, the more gut-wrenching it gets. People don't just keel over and die while being choked, even if they're simultaneously having a heart attack. There is kicking and struggling and rolling around and biting involved. And the fact that the police found him on the hallway floor, still choking a corpse.

I'm starting to feel pretty bad for the father.

I imagine it was quite traumatic for both the father and the daughter. Then again, that's definitely one situation where I could take another person's life and feel no remorse whatsoever.

He said his daughter went to church Sunday after the incident.

Um. Ok. That's an essential detail right there.

Other than that- good on ya, pap!

If he had a mask and gloves on then he wasn't naked, was he? And it was thoughtful to bring condoms.

The father was 64 years old and the naked guy in his 50's. The article says there was a struggle and the guy had a knife. I'm sure that the father was terrified. Not everyone is trained to let go when the person is passed out and you don't know how you will perform in an emergency. At least the family is okay.

Good job dad.

R.A.Danny: How did the homeowner know this guy was going to hurt anyone?

Did you even read the article? What would you do if you found a naked masked man in your daughter's bedroom holding a knife?

I don't think any boyfriend/future husband is ever gonna be able to top Daddy in that little girls eye.

"Daddy choked a naked knife wielding rapist to protect me...what have you done lately?"

Cog: feckingmorons: Police do not anticipate any charges.

Anticipate any charges? They should throw the guy a banquet.

Yeah but in some cities it's illegal to defend yourself or your family. See Washington DC, Chicago, etc.

That's the most insane thing I've ever heard in my life. I can't believe they let crazy people handle emergency response.

madcharlie: Did you even read the article? What would you do if you found a naked masked man in your daughter's bedroom holding a knife?

Did you read the rest of my post? If you can't find the sarcasm there you should probably give up the internet.

Darth_Lukecash: "Daddy choked a naked knife wielding rapist to protect me...what have you done lately?"

There's a Hallmark card there.

GWShenlong05: And the fact that the police found him on the hallway floor, still choking a corpse.

I'm starting to feel pretty bad for the father.

I'd have been found kicking and beating and stabbing the shiat out of his corpse, but that's just me.

I was surprised to read that there was no gunfire involved.

At least the family doesn't have to deal with a bloody mess all over the place.

"Nobody wins," McNally told The Indianapolis Star. "Its a lose-lose situation for everybody. He has family also."

That's an interesting thing for the father to say. Sounds like he needs Internet Toughguy Lessons. He walks the walk but doesn't talk the talk.

To the father:



From TFA: "If a person breaks into your home, you are justified in using deadly force in defending your family," said Mount.

rescue11cpt: The exact reason the 'Castle Doctrine' was put into effect.

THIS.

I only hope this pervert suffered a slow, excruciating death. Quick and painless is too good for him.

WaltzingMathilda: Cog: feckingmorons: Police do not anticipate any charges.

Anticipate any charges? They should throw the guy a banquet.

Yeah but in some cities it's illegal to defend yourself or your family. See Washington DC, Chicago, etc.

That's the most insane thing I've ever heard in my life. I can't believe they let crazy people handle emergency response.

LOLWUT?

Cog:
Yeah but in some cities it's illegal to defend yourself or your family. See Washington DC, Chicago, etc.

STFU

R.A.Danny: Did you read the rest of my post? If you can't find the sarcasm there you should probably give up the internet.

I'm trying to quit. My brain no longer recognizes sarcasm, and when I'm having sex and the girl isn't any good I find myself wanting to scroll to the cumshot to just get it over with.

Is someone a "hero" when they do exactly what they should do? And should be expected to do?

Fk the philosophical debate...good for dad and daughter, and good for sick-fk rapist. Buh-bye!

SCENE: Daughter's wedding night

DAUGHTER: "So, you wanna...y'know?"

GROOM: "Depends. Is your Dad staying in this hotel, too?"

Lionel Mandrake: Is someone a "hero" when they do exactly what they should do?

When a father kills the previously-convicted sexual predator attempted rapist of his daughter, yeah -- the Hero tag fits.

When he kills him with his bare farking hands doubly so.

propasaurus: Cog:
Yeah but in some cities it's illegal to defend yourself or your family. See Washington DC, Chicago, etc.

STFU

EABOD

I find it odd that a 64-year-old has a 17-year-old daughter.

Obama would prosecute this guy.

BGates: Obama would prosecute this guy.

Intriguing. Please support your claim...

Cog: WaltzingMathilda: Cog: feckingmorons: Police do not anticipate any charges.

Anticipate any charges? They should throw the guy a banquet.

Yeah but in some cities it's illegal to defend yourself or your family. See Washington DC, Chicago, etc.

That's the most insane thing I've ever heard in my life. I can't believe they let crazy people handle emergency response.

LOLWUT?

Your profile says you're a 911 operator/police dispatch. You said it's illegal to defend yourself and your family in chicago, d.c., which is farking insane. I can't believe insane people are allowed to do your high stress job. The fact that you answer "lolwut" as though you couldn't put that logic together makes me even more scared for people under your watch.

It would have been easier to shoot the guy, but then you have to deal with the mess. So I guess good on him for applying a good choke.

well, did he come, or what?

Kome: I find it odd that a 64-year-old has a 17-year-old daughter.

I came here to say exactly that!

GWShenlong05: "Police responding to a call from the city's northwest side about 3:20 a.m. Sunday found 64-year-old Robert McNally on the hallway floor with his arm around the neck of 52-year-old David T. Meyers"

So he didn't just shoot the guy or bludgeon him with some heavy household object; he actually locked the man in a rear naked choke and squeezed the effing life out of him. That is the most personal, visceral, you-will-not-stand-any-chance-of-living-through-this means of killing someone that I can imagine.

Somebody send this man a blue ribbon.

THIS x 2,000,000

You should be able to blow away/waste anybody who breaks into your home, regardless of their "intent."

Yeah, yeah, sanctity of life, blah, blah. Whatever...

WaltzingMathilda: Cog: WaltzingMathilda: Cog: feckingmorons: Police do not anticipate any charges.

Anticipate any charges? They should throw the guy a banquet.

Yeah but in some cities it's illegal to defend yourself or your family. See Washington DC, Chicago, etc.

That's the most insane thing I've ever heard in my life. I can't believe they let crazy people handle emergency response.

LOLWUT?

Your profile says you're a 911 operator/police dispatch. You said it's illegal to defend yourself and your family in chicago, d.c., which is farking insane. I can't believe insane people are allowed to do your high stress job. The fact that you answer "lolwut" as though you couldn't put that logic together makes me even more scared for people under your watch.

How is it insane? You seen to be quite crazy or perhaps intoxicated. Whatever your problem is - get some help.

"Nobody wins," McNally told The Indianapolis Star. "It's a lose-lose situation for everybody. He has family also."
No, society wins, by not having this monster in it anymore.

Any cop or prosecutor who would charge the father should be fired. One dead scumbag, he got what he deserved, no loss here.

Lionel Mandrake: BGates: Obama would prosecute this guy.

Intriguing. Please support your claim...

Based upon the guy he tried to prosecute in Chicago who killed an intruder. I can't remember all the facts off the top of my head. I'll have to find it on the tubes.